Hi folks, just wanted to chime in on something. I have tried my hand at day-trading, mid-range holding periods, and buy & hold over long time periods. In addition, I have traded everything from stocks to ETFs to emini futures, etc.
I just want to share what I believe is one of the most important things I have learned.
While it is okay to run ideas off of people and it is great to learn from others' successes and failures - I think it is really important NOT to do something, simply because it is getting pimped or hyped up by others.
Just because someone else writes an article about it, or because CNBC is talking about it, or someone blogs or tweets about it, etc - doesn't mean they are right. (I know this seems obvious, but I think people get caught up in others' ideas more easily than they care to admit. Many of us have made this mistake; and I am definitely no exception.)
Even beyond articles, tv, blogs, twitter, etc - just look at these stock threads over the years. I have not gone through every recommendation. But my guess is, if someone actually tried doing the OPPOSITE of the ideas posted in here - they'd be up big.
I don't mean to offend anyone. I am literally just picking at the ones I remember offhand. (And yeah, maybe I just remember the bad ones and not the good ones - but I doubt it.)
Consider this...
EXK was being discussed to death in the 2012 version of this thread. Again I am not looking back, so this is off the top of my head (so please note my actual numbers may be off, but you will get the idea). But last year as it was breaking through $10 - there were people here that said they could easily see it ending the year at $17 (again sorry if it was really $16 or $18 ~ just going for overall point, not exact numbers).
Now EXK is at $3.00.
Ditto that on QCOM from early Feb. $67 then. $62 now.
Ditto that on silver from April. Using SLV - early April it was $26/27; mid-April it was $23. Now it is $18.
Ditto that on IGR. Someone was touting that at around $9.50. Yes, it went up and through $10 (not even $10.50). Now it is at $8.50.
Someone recently was talking about long MUX. Although that may have been one of you guys on twitter and not this thread. I think at the time it was breaking above $2.50/$2.60 (just a few weeks ago). Today it is at $1.67.
And definitely ditto that sentiment on how much some loved the sexy ipos of recent years (FB, ZNGA, GRPN).
FB ipo'd 1 year ago at around $38 or $40. Shot up that day to $45. It is now at $24.
ZNGA ipo'd less than 2 yrs ago between $9 and $11. It is now under $3.
GRPN ipo'd less than 2 yrs ago at about $28. It is now a little above $8.
I am not saying this to jump on anyone. Again I have made bad calls as well over the years. And again, I have gotten caught up in what others touted as well. What I am saying is: I wish I hadn't. And that is the suggestion I am making today. It is obviously okay to learn from others' successes (as you would your own). Ditto that on learning from others' failures (as you would your own). But don't make a trade and enter a position just because someone else is.
If we had done the opposite of the ideas/trades in these threads over the years that had gotten the most hype and the most attention - we'd probably be up a lot.