He jumped the gun. They have moved Qb6 officially now.White
Why did Kutta make that Qb6 move then? He and I have the dual games together. Mistake?
Seconded. This should be a quick thing, as we need to capture back material.Black,
They've moved. Rxd3.
This is a no-brainer, bxc6. All in favor?
Opposed?
Yup - no brainer.Black,
They've moved. Rxd3.
This is a no-brainer, bxc6. All in favor?
Opposed?
doneYup - no brainer.Black,
They've moved. Rxd3.
This is a no-brainer, bxc6. All in favor?
Opposed?
yep, do itBlack,
They've moved. Rxd3.
This is a no-brainer, bxc6. All in favor?
Opposed?
Edited - sometimes I get screwed up on my orientations and completely mismarked all this. Continue reading down.Be7 as you liked before, Sand.
Then we castle. We can then consider f5 at some point to either trade off more pieces or shut down any threats.
Be7Sand,
Be7
O-O O-O
Bh5 f5 I don't see anything wrong here.
If the take the pawn en passant we just exchange pieces.
What are you worried about?
I'd say Rac1. Let's get control of the c file.In our white game O has moved Rc8. Not much of a surprise there.
I have looked over it several times and I can't find the line that Be7 doesn't work. Joe, nsfl?Sand,
Black
Be7
Rf1 O-O (no need to move the B again)
We'd have to go Kd8, as Ke8 is still under attack. Doesn't look great overall.I think you mean Nc5
Nf6+ Ke7
Rc3 Ke8?
Not bad but they certainly have momentum.
Devil's advocate:I'd say Rac1. Let's get control of the c file.In our white game O has moved Rc8. Not much of a surprise there.
Any thoughts here?I'd say Rac1. Let's get control of the c file.In our white game O has moved Rc8. Not much of a surprise there.
That's what I meant. DurrrrrrWe'd have to go Kd8, as Ke8 is still under attack. Doesn't look great overall.I think you mean Nc5
Nf6+ Ke7
Rc3 Ke8?
Not bad but they certainly have momentum.
Be7Sand,
Be7
O-O O-O
Bh5 f5 I don't see anything wrong here.
If the take the pawn en passant we just exchange pieces.
What are you worried about?
O-O O-O
Bh5 f5
exf6 Nxf6
NxN BxN
Rf3 Bd4+ (savior)
Kh1 RxR
That looks ok. Taking with the N is a big thing as we need to be able to escape with check to avoid losing a big piece of material. Anyone see variants that don't work here? I think after Bd4+, they go Bf2
Bxf2 Rxf2
Rxf3 Rxf3
then, we've got to stop him from Rf6 and taking our h6 pawn.
Does:
Be7
O-O O-O
Rd3f3 this work better for them? I don't see it, but I want to take some time here.
I assume you mean f5?
exf6 Nxf6
Nxf6 Bxf6
Rxf6 Rxf6
Rxf6
seems to leave us a bishop behind. This looks baddish.
They moved quickly here in the midgame, so they obviously see a line they really like. This is a critical move, so I'd like to torture it a while before being convinced that it works.
Let's also work on this line:
Be7
Rf1 This gives them more protection from Bc4+ - we would then have to go Bb5+ and they have a c pawn to protect.
Great thought. It does seem to keep them off the c column to a large extent. And it starts moving the pass pawn, which has to be a huge concern for them.Black
Haven't gone through Be7 yet, but looks solid on the surface.
A completely alternate plan would be a5:
I thought I deleted that post. Host of errors in there.nysfl2 said:Sand said:Be7pizzatyme said:Sand,
Be7
O-O O-O
Bh5 f5 I don't see anything wrong here.
If the take the pawn en passant we just exchange pieces.
What are you worried about?
O-O O-O
Bh5 f5
exf6 Nxf6
NxN BxN
Rf3 Bd4+ (savior)
Kh1 RxR
That looks ok. Taking with the N is a big thing as we need to be able to escape with check to avoid losing a big piece of material. Anyone see variants that don't work here? I think after Bd4+, they go Bf2
Bxf2 Rxf2
Rxf3 Rxf3
then, we've got to stop him from Rf6 and taking our h6 pawn.
Does:
Be7
O-O O-O
Rd3f3 this work better for them? I don't see it, but I want to take some time here.
I assume you mean f5?
exf6 Nxf6
Nxf6 Bxf6
Rxf6 Rxf6
Rxf6
seems to leave us a bishop behind. This looks baddish.
They moved quickly here in the midgame, so they obviously see a line they really like. This is a critical move, so I'd like to torture it a while before being convinced that it works.
Let's also work on this line:
Be7
Rf1 This gives them more protection from Bc4+ - we would then have to go Bb5+ and they have a c pawn to protect.
The threat of Ba3 really doesn't leave him with much choice but to move that rook.Black
Actually, if he moves Rf3 before Bh5, he doesn't have enough attackers on the f pawn to worry about. We wouldn't need to move it at all.
I think the response to Nc6 would be Nf6+, which doesn't seem good . I'd still prefer Ba6 after a5.Sand said:Great thought. It does seem to keep them off the c column to a large extent. And it starts moving the pass pawn, which has to be a huge concern for them.nysfl2 said:Black
Haven't gone through Be7 yet, but looks solid on the surface.
A completely alternate plan would be a5:
a5
Rf3 Nc6
NxN BxN
Rf1 O-O
Looks very good to me.
Too many things going on. Distracted by those ####ers from Connecticut winning the championship. Hate them. Anyway, I should have posted:I think the response to Nc6 would be Nf6+, which doesn't seem good . I'd still prefer Ba6 after a5.Sand said:Great thought. It does seem to keep them off the c column to a large extent. And it starts moving the pass pawn, which has to be a huge concern for them.nysfl2 said:Black
Haven't gone through Be7 yet, but looks solid on the surface.
A completely alternate plan would be a5:
a5
Rf3 Nc6
NxN BxN
Rf1 O-O
Looks very good to me.
a5Nd6+ Bxd6?nysfl2 said:Black
Haven't gone through Be7 yet, but looks solid on the surface.
A completely alternate plan would be a5:
a5 O-O
Ba6 if (Rd2, Bxe2) If (Re3, Bc5, pinning the rook and forcing Nxc5, trading the bishop for the knight)
Someone take a look and tell me the flaws. If we can trade our trapped pieces for his attacking pieces, I think it's a win for us.
If they follow this line, we can always diffuse the double rook by going f5 to force the en passant or set up our pawn defense nicely. f5 works much better when they've got one fewer rook involved.a5Nd6+ Bxd6?nysfl2 said:Black
Haven't gone through Be7 yet, but looks solid on the surface.
A completely alternate plan would be a5:
a5 O-O
Ba6 if (Rd2, Bxe2) If (Re3, Bc5, pinning the rook and forcing Nxc5, trading the bishop for the knight)
Someone take a look and tell me the flaws. If we can trade our trapped pieces for his attacking pieces, I think it's a win for us.
Rxd6 (attacking c pawn)
Not bad but there's still concerns there once they castle and double their Rooks.
Agreed. I like this line best.If they follow this line, we can always diffuse the double rook by going f5 to force the en passant or set up our pawn defense nicely. f5 works much better when they've got one fewer rook involved.a5Nd6+ Bxd6?nysfl2 said:Black
Haven't gone through Be7 yet, but looks solid on the surface.
A completely alternate plan would be a5:
a5 O-O
Ba6 if (Rd2, Bxe2) If (Re3, Bc5, pinning the rook and forcing Nxc5, trading the bishop for the knight)
Someone take a look and tell me the flaws. If we can trade our trapped pieces for his attacking pieces, I think it's a win for us.
Rxd6 (attacking c pawn)
Not bad but there's still concerns there once they castle and double their Rooks.
a5 Bh5One other possibility following a5:
a5 Bh5
Be7? Rf3
O-O O-O
and we're outnumbered on the f pawn
What's our counter if they go Bh5? Bg7, setting up Ne5 if they still go Rf3?
Someone else look down this line.
I don't see this as too badBe7 now doesn't look as exciting to me once they go Nd6+ as we either have to take the N or move Kf8
The more I look the more I like Be7. I'm going to put in an official vote for Be7 here. It is the most flexible move to diffuse the f column attack.Even worse is after Be7 they go Nd6+ and easily win the pawn with the B or N.
I'm back to Be7 as our best move here.
Be7
Bh5? O-O and we eliminate the pressure on the f pawn as we can go f6 or f5 now without concern.
Mistake - the pawn is much more of a threat there. Then we move c5 and diffuse. We may end up losing the c pawn at the expense of them losing a rook and us a knight. I'll take that trade.Instead of exd6 they'd go Rxd6.
I haven't really seen much to move besides that - our options are limited. But it does keep up pressure. I'd be happy with a draw in this one.Seconded Be7.
I also like Rac1 for white. Thoughts here??
2 votes for Rac1.White
Screw the draw!
I have a master plan there. We want to trade off some pieces and get our N to c4. This will put pressure at their weak pawn structure.
I'd also like to get in f4 to open up the f file.
We own them in piece flexibility. Let's do this!
I was looking at trying to get the N over to c4, too. Unfortunately, it takes a lot of moves.White
Screw the draw!
I have a master plan there. We want to trade off some pieces and get our N to c4. This will put pressure at their weak pawn structure.
I'd also like to get in f4 to open up the f file.
We own them in piece flexibility. Let's do this!