What's new
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

The 100 Greatest Songs of 1973 #1. Karn Evil 9, 1st Impression, Part 2 (1 Viewer)

85. Led Zeppelin “Dancing Days” (from Houses of the Holy)


At the time this album was released, a reviewer from Rolling Stone referred to this song as “filler”. Well, it’s pretty damn good filler. In fact it’s been consistently on my playlist for years.
 
86. Mott the Hoople “Honaloochie Boogie” (from Mott)


Following the success of All the Young Dudes the band released an even better album filled with glam goodness, of which A few highlights are musts for this list, this one is a classic with Ian Hunter and Mick Ralphs at the top of their games.
@squistion I’m curious: why are you sad about the selection of “Honaloochie Boogie”??
 
86. Mott the Hoople “Honaloochie Boogie” (from Mott)


Following the success of All the Young Dudes the band released an even better album filled with glam goodness, of which A few highlights are musts for this list, this one is a classic with Ian Hunter and Mick Ralphs at the top of their games.
@squistion I’m curious: why are you sad about the selection of “Honaloochie Boogie”??

Since you asked, I wouldn't include it in the 1000 greatest songs of 1973. Speaking only for myself, I am rather unimpressed with this music list so far. Admittedly it wasn't that great a year and maybe you will salvage this with the 85 picks remaining, but after this start I have my doubts.

I will refrain from using emojis with future selections.
 
86. Mott the Hoople “Honaloochie Boogie” (from Mott)


Following the success of All the Young Dudes the band released an even better album filled with glam goodness, of which A few highlights are musts for this list, this one is a classic with Ian Hunter and Mick Ralphs at the top of their games.
@squistion I’m curious: why are you sad about the selection of “Honaloochie Boogie”??
Tim:

I am going through a particularly rough patch in my marriage right now and just wanted to say that your ongoing commitment to these music lists and your ability and willingness to engage other FBGs on issues like this oddly provides a nice diversion.

Keep on keepin’ on, man!
 
86. Mott the Hoople “Honaloochie Boogie” (from Mott)


Following the success of All the Young Dudes the band released an even better album filled with glam goodness, of which A few highlights are musts for this list, this one is a classic with Ian Hunter and Mick Ralphs at the top of their games.
@squistion I’m curious: why are you sad about the selection of “Honaloochie Boogie”??
Tim:

I am going through a particularly rough patch in my marriage right now and just wanted to say that your ongoing commitment to these music lists and your ability and willingness to engage other FBGs on issues like this oddly provides a nice diversion.

Keep on keepin’ on, man!
Wow. Thanks and I hope things come out OK for you.
 
86. Mott the Hoople “Honaloochie Boogie” (from Mott)


Following the success of All the Young Dudes the band released an even better album filled with glam goodness, of which A few highlights are musts for this list, this one is a classic with Ian Hunter and Mick Ralphs at the top of their games.
@squistion I’m curious: why are you sad about the selection of “Honaloochie Boogie”??

Since you asked, I wouldn't include it in the 1000 greatest songs of 1973. Speaking only for myself, I am rather unimpressed with this music list so far. Admittedly it wasn't that great a year and maybe you will salvage this with the 85 picks remaining, but after this start I have my doubts.

I will refrain from using emojis with future selections.
No respect for the glam rock kings, eh? I’m sad for you that you don’t appreciate Mott the Hoople. One of the best rock bands of the 1970s.
 
86. Mott the Hoople “Honaloochie Boogie” (from Mott)


Following the success of All the Young Dudes the band released an even better album filled with glam goodness, of which A few highlights are musts for this list, this one is a classic with Ian Hunter and Mick Ralphs at the top of their games.
@squistion I’m curious: why are you sad about the selection of “Honaloochie Boogie”??

Since you asked, I wouldn't include it in the 1000 greatest songs of 1973. Speaking only for myself, I am rather unimpressed with this music list so far. Admittedly it wasn't that great a year and maybe you will salvage this with the 85 picks remaining, but after this start I have my doubts.

I will refrain from using emojis with future selections.
No respect for the glam rock kings, eh? I’m sad for you that you don’t appreciate Mott the Hoople. One of the best rock bands of the 1970s.

No respect for the glam rock kings, eh? I’m sad for you that you don’t appreciate Mott the Hoople. One of the best rock bands of the 1970s.

I really liked All The Young Dudes, All The Way To Memphis and even bought Roll Away The Stone on 45, so I appreciated Mott, it is just I didn't care for that particular song.

And as far as glam is concerned, I was a big T-Rex, Marc Bolan fan and recently saw a 1973 video from German TV where he is wearing a white feather boa (and you can't get much more glam than that).
 
92. Styx “Lady” (from Styx II)


This is thought by some music critics to be the first ever “power ballad”. Released by the band some 5 years prior to “Come Sail Away”, it’s a diamond among the dregs of their early albums, when they were trying to be the American version of Yes. And unlike some of Dennis De Young’s later efforts, “Lady” isn’t sappy or schlocky; even Tommy Shaw can’t really complain.
Top 2 Styx for me.
I presume the other one is NOT Mr. Roboto?

I once had the misfortune of hearing all of Kilroy Was Here (my ex-wife's father was really into it), and aside from Don't Let It End, the other songs are even WORSE than Mr. Roboto.
I have seriously never listened to more than 10 seconds of that song. Can't stand it.

Actually have a Styx Top 3. Not sure of the order. Add Suite Madame Blue and Lorelei.
but when she's with me I'm smiling.
 
86. Mott the Hoople “Honaloochie Boogie” (from Mott)


Following the success of All the Young Dudes the band released an even better album filled with glam goodness, of which A few highlights are musts for this list, this one is a classic with Ian Hunter and Mick Ralphs at the top of their games.
@squistion I’m curious: why are you sad about the selection of “Honaloochie Boogie”??

Since you asked, I wouldn't include it in the 1000 greatest songs of 1973. Speaking only for myself, I am rather unimpressed with this music list so far. Admittedly it wasn't that great a year and maybe you will salvage this with the 85 picks remaining, but after this start I have my doubts.

I will refrain from using emojis with future selections.

yikes.
 
86. Mott the Hoople “Honaloochie Boogie” (from Mott)


Following the success of All the Young Dudes the band released an even better album filled with glam goodness, of which A few highlights are musts for this list, this one is a classic with Ian Hunter and Mick Ralphs at the top of their games.
@squistion I’m curious: why are you sad about the selection of “Honaloochie Boogie”??

Since you asked, I wouldn't include it in the 1000 greatest songs of 1973. Speaking only for myself, I am rather unimpressed with this music list so far. Admittedly it wasn't that great a year and maybe you will salvage this with the 85 picks remaining, but after this start I have my doubts.

I will refrain from using emojis with future selections.
I'm not looking to argue. But, Tim does a lot of work for these threads and accepts the criticism that goes along with sharing his musical tastes.
Maybe you should do the same? Others have contributed the "next 100 songs of 19xx" threads in response to Tim's top 100, so why don't you do the same? Or if you think the year Tim chose isn't a particularly strong year for music, share your top 100 from another year.
 
89. Eagles “Tequila Sunrise” (from Desperado)


Pleasant little tune from Fry and Henley; always reminded me (lyrically) of a Jimmy Buffett song. This would never make a list of my very favorite Eagles songs, but I don’t turn it off when I hear it played, either.
Hippling Warning!

This is a fine song. I bash Eagles a lot here, but they knew how to construct/play/sing a good record. I don't get the Buffett vibe Tim does, because - like most Eagles records Joe Walsh didn't have something to do with - there's not one hint of humor in it.
 
85. Led Zeppelin “Dancing Days” (from Houses of the Holy)


At the time this album was released, a reviewer from Rolling Stone referred to this song as “filler”. Well, it’s pretty damn good filler. In fact it’s been consistently on my playlist for years.
You could easily have 6 of the 8 songs from the album on here and few would probably argue.
 
86. Mott the Hoople “Honaloochie Boogie” (from Mott)


Following the success of All the Young Dudes the band released an even better album filled with glam goodness, of which A few highlights are musts for this list, this one is a classic with Ian Hunter and Mick Ralphs at the top of their games.
@squistion I’m curious: why are you sad about the selection of “Honaloochie Boogie”??

Since you asked, I wouldn't include it in the 1000 greatest songs of 1973. Speaking only for myself, I am rather unimpressed with this music list so far. Admittedly it wasn't that great a year and maybe you will salvage this with the 85 picks remaining, but after this start I have my doubts.

I will refrain from using emojis with future selections.
I'm not looking to argue. But, Tim does a lot of work for these threads and accepts the criticism that goes along with sharing his musical tastes.
Maybe you should do the same? Others have contributed the "next 100 songs of 19xx" threads in response to Tim's top 100, so why don't you do the same? Or if you think the year Tim chose isn't a particularly strong year for music, share your top 100 from another year.

For someone who doesn't want to argue you do a pretty good job.

Rather than hijack this thread responding to your specific questions and expressing further criticism of Tim and his greatest songs list, I will just stop here and leave your above comments as the last word on the matter.
 
88. Jim Croce “I’ll Have To say I Love You In A Song” (from I Got A Name)


Croce died in a plane crash in September of 1973, and this was one of several songs that was released posthumously.
It’s interesting (and sad) to speculate on what might have been if there had been no crash. Would Croce have become a superstar with great songs year after year? Or would he have become like Cat Stevens or James Taylor, endlessly performing the tunes from the early 70s that made him famous? Like Richie Valens and Buddy Holly, we’ll never know…
If you read any orthodox rock histories, you'd think Croce didn't exist. He wasn't an ethereal Laurel Canyon Woodstock God(ess). He was vaguely "ethnic" and wrote some funny songs, which automatically excluded him from the pantheon Jann Wenner had set up as "singer-songwriters" (same with Bill Withers). But he was a better songwriter than almost all of them and this record proves it - because it ain't about cutting someone up in a pool hall. It's direct and says want it needs to in as few words as possible - plus, it sounds great to this day.

In other words, he was the anti-Paul Simon - which is a plus in my book.
 
87. Elton John “Harmony” (from Goodbye Yellow Brick Road)


There really are a lot of great songs on this album, and it’s not even the only record that Elton John released in 1973. He’s one of a couple of artists that are all over this list from start to finish.
Fantastic song. Unlike Styx, there's not one hit of his that I don't at least love a lot. This album is a masterpiece.
 
85. Led Zeppelin “Dancing Days” (from Houses of the Holy)


At the time this album was released, a reviewer from Rolling Stone referred to this song as “filler”. Well, it’s pretty damn good filler. In fact it’s been consistently on my playlist for years.
Best song on the LP, in my opinion.
 
86. Mott the Hoople “Honaloochie Boogie” (from Mott)


Following the success of All the Young Dudes the band released an even better album filled with glam goodness, of which A few highlights are musts for this list, this one is a classic with Ian Hunter and Mick Ralphs at the top of their games.
I'm still trying to navigate backspacing on this board and think I may have missed this one.

I think second-tier artists like Mott did/do more to prop up the music than they are given credit for. Mott was basically Foghat or Bad Company (the offensive linemen), while Bowie/Zep/Stones/Grand Funk were guys like Tom Brady or Jerry Rice.
 
85. Led Zeppelin “Dancing Days” (from Houses of the Holy)


At the time this album was released, a reviewer from Rolling Stone referred to this song as “filler”. Well, it’s pretty damn good filler. In fact it’s been consistently on my playlist for years.
There are few things less accurate than contemporary Rolling Stone reviews of Led Zeppelin albums.
 
88. Jim Croce “I’ll Have To say I Love You In A Song” (from I Got A Name)


Croce died in a plane crash in September of 1973, and this was one of several songs that was released posthumously.
It’s interesting (and sad) to speculate on what might have been if there had been no crash. Would Croce have become a superstar with great songs year after year? Or would he have become like Cat Stevens or James Taylor, endlessly performing the tunes from the early 70s that made him famous? Like Richie Valens and Buddy Holly, we’ll never know…
If you read any orthodox rock histories, you'd think Croce didn't exist. He wasn't an ethereal Laurel Canyon Woodstock God(ess). He was vaguely "ethnic" and wrote some funny songs, which automatically excluded him from the pantheon Jann Wenner had set up as "singer-songwriters" (same with Bill Withers). But he was a better songwriter than almost all of them and this record proves it - because it ain't about cutting someone up in a pool hall. It's direct and says want it needs to in as few words as possible - plus, it sounds great to this day.

In other words, he was the anti-Paul Simon - which is a plus in my book.
I like what you wrote except for the Paul Simon diss. We will be discussing Mr. Simon more at length since 1973 was a good year for him.
 
85. Led Zeppelin “Dancing Days” (from Houses of the Holy)


At the time this album was released, a reviewer from Rolling Stone referred to this song as “filler”. Well, it’s pretty damn good filler. In fact it’s been consistently on my playlist for years.
I approve of this song. :thumbup:
 
84. Joni Mitchell “Raised on Robbery” (released as a single)


So this fine tune was released in November of 1973 in advance of her 1974 brilliant album Court and Spark. The live video is from several years later, but it’s worth watching because the great Jaco Pastorius is on bass. Jaco wasn’t part of the original recording but toured with Joni when she began a jazz exploration on several albums. Interestingly enough, the original version features Robbie Robertson of The Band on lead guitar.
 
84. Joni Mitchell “Raised on Robbery” (released as a single)


So this fine tune was released in November of 1973 in advance of her 1974 brilliant album Court and Spark. The live video is from several years later, but it’s worth watching because the great Jaco Pastorius is on bass. Jaco wasn’t part of the original recording but toured with Joni when she began a jazz exploration on several albums. Interestingly enough, the original version features Robbie Robertson of The Band on lead guitar.
Also in 1973, Joni dropped by Neil Young's sessions for what became the Tonight's the Night album, and they played this. Finally saw the light of day when Neil's Archives Vol. 2 came out last year. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dEHcNf68lUA
 
86. Mott the Hoople “Honaloochie Boogie” (from Mott)


Following the success of All the Young Dudes the band released an even better album filled with glam goodness, of which A few highlights are musts for this list, this one is a classic with Ian Hunter and Mick Ralphs at the top of their games.
@squistion I’m curious: why are you sad about the selection of “Honaloochie Boogie”??

Since you asked, I wouldn't include it in the 1000 greatest songs of 1973. Speaking only for myself, I am rather unimpressed with this music list so far. Admittedly it wasn't that great a year and maybe you will salvage this with the 85 picks remaining, but after this start I have my doubts.

I will refrain from using emojis with future selections.
No respect for the glam rock kings, eh? I’m sad for you that you don’t appreciate Mott the Hoople. One of the best rock bands of the 1970s.
I know a lot of people who like MTH. Like Squistion, I never got into them at all.
 
86. Mott the Hoople “Honaloochie Boogie” (from Mott)


Following the success of All the Young Dudes the band released an even better album filled with glam goodness, of which A few highlights are musts for this list, this one is a classic with Ian Hunter and Mick Ralphs at the top of their games.
@squistion I’m curious: why are you sad about the selection of “Honaloochie Boogie”??

Since you asked, I wouldn't include it in the 1000 greatest songs of 1973. Speaking only for myself, I am rather unimpressed with this music list so far. Admittedly it wasn't that great a year and maybe you will salvage this with the 85 picks remaining, but after this start I have my doubts.

I will refrain from using emojis with future selections.
No respect for the glam rock kings, eh? I’m sad for you that you don’t appreciate Mott the Hoople. One of the best rock bands of the 1970s.
I know a lot of people who like MTH. Like Squistion, I never got into them at all.

I know a lot of people who like MTH. Like Squistion, I never got into them at all.

I kinda got into MTH and I bought Ian Hunter's first solo LP but to rank “Honaloochie Boogie” in the greatest 100 of 1973 only makes sense to me if you were like 7 years old at the time and your older brother was a big Mott fan and constantly played the LP.
 
86. Mott the Hoople “Honaloochie Boogie” (from Mott)


Following the success of All the Young Dudes the band released an even better album filled with glam goodness, of which A few highlights are musts for this list, this one is a classic with Ian Hunter and Mick Ralphs at the top of their games.
@squistion I’m curious: why are you sad about the selection of “Honaloochie Boogie”??

Since you asked, I wouldn't include it in the 1000 greatest songs of 1973. Speaking only for myself, I am rather unimpressed with this music list so far. Admittedly it wasn't that great a year and maybe you will salvage this with the 85 picks remaining, but after this start I have my doubts.

I will refrain from using emojis with future selections.
No respect for the glam rock kings, eh? I’m sad for you that you don’t appreciate Mott the Hoople. One of the best rock bands of the 1970s.
I know a lot of people who like MTH. Like Squistion, I never got into them at all.

it's well known around these parts that you have the ABSOLUTE WORST taste in music.

so no surprise there.
 
86. Mott the Hoople “Honaloochie Boogie” (from Mott)


Following the success of All the Young Dudes the band released an even better album filled with glam goodness, of which A few highlights are musts for this list, this one is a classic with Ian Hunter and Mick Ralphs at the top of their games.
@squistion I’m curious: why are you sad about the selection of “Honaloochie Boogie”??

Since you asked, I wouldn't include it in the 1000 greatest songs of 1973. Speaking only for myself, I am rather unimpressed with this music list so far. Admittedly it wasn't that great a year and maybe you will salvage this with the 85 picks remaining, but after this start I have my doubts.

I will refrain from using emojis with future selections.
No respect for the glam rock kings, eh? I’m sad for you that you don’t appreciate Mott the Hoople. One of the best rock bands of the 1970s.
I know a lot of people who like MTH. Like Squistion, I never got into them at all.

it's well known around these parts that you have the ABSOLUTE WORST taste in music.

so no surprise there.
I know, right?
 
86. Mott the Hoople “Honaloochie Boogie” (from Mott)


Following the success of All the Young Dudes the band released an even better album filled with glam goodness, of which A few highlights are musts for this list, this one is a classic with Ian Hunter and Mick Ralphs at the top of their games.
@squistion I’m curious: why are you sad about the selection of “Honaloochie Boogie”??

Since you asked, I wouldn't include it in the 1000 greatest songs of 1973. Speaking only for myself, I am rather unimpressed with this music list so far. Admittedly it wasn't that great a year and maybe you will salvage this with the 85 picks remaining, but after this start I have my doubts.

I will refrain from using emojis with future selections.
No respect for the glam rock kings, eh? I’m sad for you that you don’t appreciate Mott the Hoople. One of the best rock bands of the 1970s.
I know a lot of people who like MTH. Like Squistion, I never got into them at all.

it's well known around these parts that you have the ABSOLUTE WORST taste in music.

so no surprise there.

If truth be told, although FairWarning and I don't agree politically, we do occasionally share the same rock music tastes. :yes:
 
Funny how nobody at Steve Hoffman forums (where they know their ****) ever refers to Television as "New Wave." They just don't.

Because they weren't. They're referred to as either punk progenitors or no wave.

They're not new wave no matter how many twenty year-old critics say it. And you still don't get that distinction, either.
 
Funny how nobody at Steve Hoffman forums (where they know their ****) ever refers to Television as "New Wave." They just don't.

Because they weren't. They're referred to as either punk progenitors or no wave.

And you still have no ****ing clue about anything. They're not new wave no matter how many twenty year-old critics say it. And you still don't get that distinction, either. Everywhere you, go there you are. Smugly satisfied, stupidly smiling, friendless.
I don’t think we will be discussing Television or New Wave much in a thread about the music of 1973. But there ARE some progenitors….
 
Funny how nobody at Steve Hoffman forums (where they know their ****) ever refers to Television as "New Wave." They just don't.

Because they weren't. They're referred to as either punk progenitors or no wave.

They're not new wave no matter how many twenty year-old critics say it. And you still don't get that distinction, either.

Dude, I quoted in another thread, a NYT review of their concert at CBGBs in the mid 70s that called them "New Wave" but what did he know. :lol:
 
New wave is a loosely defined[21][22][23] music genre that encompasses pop-oriented styles from the late 1970s and the 1980s.[2] It was originally used as a catch-all for the various styles of music that emerged after punk rock,[24] including punk itself.[23] Later, critical consensus favored "new wave" as an umbrella term involving many popular music styles of the era, including power pop, synth-pop, ska revival, and more specific forms of punk rock that were less abrasive.[8] It may also be viewed as a more accessible counterpart of post-punk.[23]

Common characteristics of new wave music include a humorous or quirky pop approach, the use of electronic sounds, and a distinctive visual style in music videos and fashion.[23][5] In the early 1980s, virtually every new pop/rock act – and particularly those that employed synthesizers – were tagged as "new wave".[23] Although new wave shares punk's do-it-yourself philosophy, the artists were more influenced by the lighter strains of 1960s pop and were opposed to the generally abrasive, political bents of punk rock, as well as what was considered to be creatively stagnant "corporate rock".[5]

New wave commercially peaked in the late 1970s and the early 1980s with numerous major artists and an abundance of one-hit wonders. MTV, which was launched in 1981, heavily promoted new-wave acts, boosting the genre's popularity.[23] In the mid-1980s, new wave declined with the emergence of the New Romantic, New Pop, and New Music genres.[25] Since the 1990s, new wave resurged several times with the growing nostalgia for several new-wave-influenced artists.[26][27][28]
 
Marquee Moon came out in '77, before "New Wave" was a term of art. Blondie, The Talking Heads, other CBGB bands are on the New Wave page for Wikipedia. Television is nowhere to be found. Sure, anybody can dig up one article calling something "New Wave" a year or two after the fact, but the fact is nobody thinks Television is a new wave band that is worth their salt. The term came too late for them and captured the spirit of a different kind of music than they were performing.

They're just not in the genre.

I hope this helped you out.
 
Marquee Moon also proved to be a foundational record of alternative rock, as Television's innovative post-punk instrumentation for the album strongly influenced the new wave and indie rock movements of the 1980s and rock guitar playing in general. - Wikipedia, Marquee Moon entry

Still not new wave.
Whatever genre it is, I love this album. My favorite song is “Guiding Light”, but The whole album is a good listen.
 
83. Elton John “Crocodile Rock” (from Don’t Shoot Me, I’m Only the Piano Player)


So this was Elton John’s other album of 1973 which preceded GBYBR. The song is a throwback to 50s style doowop, which always caused me to consider it somewhat as one of his lesser efforts. But it’s grown on me over the years.
 
83. Elton John “Crocodile Rock” (from Don’t Shoot Me, I’m Only the Piano Player)


So this was Elton John’s other album of 1973 which preceded GBYBR. The song is a throwback to 50s style doowop, which always caused me to consider it somewhat as one of his lesser efforts. But it’s grown on me over the years.
It’s hard to fathom that he released another album in the same year as his double-album magnum opus.

I presume that energy was fueled by cocaine.
 
83. Elton John “Crocodile Rock” (from Don’t Shoot Me, I’m Only the Piano Player)


So this was Elton John’s other album of 1973 which preceded GBYBR. The song is a throwback to 50s style doowop, which always caused me to consider it somewhat as one of his lesser efforts. But it’s grown on me over the years.
Don't shoot me is one of my favorite EJ albums. Have seen him about 15 times. First time was at Dodger Stadium
 
83. Elton John “Crocodile Rock” (from Don’t Shoot Me, I’m Only the Piano Player)


So this was Elton John’s other album of 1973 which preceded GBYBR. The song is a throwback to 50s style doowop, which always caused me to consider it somewhat as one of his lesser efforts. But it’s grown on me over the years.
I've seen a million crocodiles and I've rocked them all.
 
Why are we devoting so much energy to an album released in 1977 in a thread for songs from 1973?

Ask Rockaction. He started it all with his obligatory gratuitous swipe at me.
The excuse favored by 8 year old children since the dawn of time.

Sorry, but anytime someone takes a shot at me in a thread I am going to respond to it. This is one of the usual suspects that are always trying to antagonize me.

Now...let's return to our regularly scheduled programing of Tim's 100 Greatest Songs of 1973 :popcorn:
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top