SCOUTING COMBINE PARTICIPANTS
link
ART CARMODY
Height: 5'9"
Weight: 168
College: Louisville
Overview: Called "Art-o-matic" by his teammates, Carmody ended his career in perfect fashion, nailing a 33-yard field goal with 20 seconds remaining to defeat Rutgers in the last game of the season and finishing as the NCAA career record holder with 433 points. While smaller and possessing a weaker leg than scouts would like, Carmody's consistency is tounding -- he made 67 of 79 career field-goal attempts and owns the NCAA record for most consecutive made extra points in one season (77 in 2004).
Positives: Rare accuracy. Made 67 of 79 career field goals and 253 of 255 extra-point attempts (both misses were blocked). ... Gets to the kicking point quickly and has good rise. ... Calm under pressure. ... Characterized as a normal guy who happens to be a kicker.
Negatives: Lacks prototypical size and leg strength. ... Only had one career attempt from beyond 50 yards (51) and missed it. ... Has only two kickoffs over the past two years. ... Attempted only one game-winning kick under 1:00 minute in his career (33-yarder to beat Rutgers in 2007).
SHANE LONGEST
Height: 5'11"
Weight: 176
College: St Xavier
Overview: The only NAIA prospect invited to the Combine, Longest was a one-man special teams crew for the Cougars, serving as the team's primary punter, place-kicker and kickoff specialist. Scouts have reservations about Longest's leg strength, but his improvement in accuracy over the past two seasons is enough to warrant a closer look.
Positives: Made significant gains in accuracy over the past two seasons, successfully making 42 of 55 field-goal attempts over the past two years after making only 50 percent (12 of 24) his first two seasons. ... Flashes the leg strength required, posting a career long 55-yard field goal in 2007. ... Recorded 20 touchbacks among his 87 kickoffs in 2007. ... Good initial rise on his kicks. ... Added punting to his resume in 2007, finishing third in the NAIA with a 43.2-yard average.
Negatives: Significant improvement in accuracy and depth of his kicks warrants a stronger look - especially as to what he could do with NFL caliber coaching. Still, Longest is viewed by some as a jack-of-all-trades, master of none type. ... Leg strength for kickoffs, directional accuracy and ability to handle pressure have earned moderate grades from scouts.
TAYLOR MEHLHAFF
Height: 5'10"
Weight: 185
College: Wisconsin
Overview: Taylor Mehlhaff teamed with punter Ken DeBauche to form what many experts felt was the best kicking tandem in college football in recent years. Mehlhaff finished his career as Wisconsin's second-leading scorer in school history (295 points) and tied for second all-time in field goals (50). He also holds the Badgers' all-time record by making 145-of-148 extra point attempts. The 2007 Lou Groza Award semifinalist, given to the nation's premier place-kicker, Mehlhaff also garnered All-American first-team honors as a senior. A three-year starter who handled all field goals and extra-point attempts, Mehlhaff was a major reason the opposition consistently had poor field position. In handling kickoff chores, 123 of his attempts were touchbacks and 160 of those kicks were returned for a 19.75-yard average, none for touchdowns.
Positives: Has a small frame, but shows good muscle tone, firm midsection and good thigh and calf development...Very poised under pressure, showing great confidence in his ability to kick for distance and in poor weather conditions...Has tunnel vision on the field, blocking out all distractions...Durable athlete with no health issues...Has the quickness, balance, agility and leg flexibility to put full force behind his kicks from either hash...Hits the ball with a quick stride, showing steady acceleration and trajectory on his attempts...Drives the ball deep on kickoffs, even when making attempts into the wind...Shows very good strength on contact with the ball, driving it deep and with very good hang time...Consistently gets the ball into the end zone on kickoffs and has the range to make field goals from the 50-yard area...Has adapted well to the swirling winds at Wisconsin's Camp Randall stadium and should not have any problems kicking into the wind...Makes proper adjustments in his approach to the ball based on field and weather conditions...Poised and in control in pressure situations, showing confidence and concentration coming through in the clutch...Lacks size, but is a tough open-field tackler who will square up, wrap and secure with good pop on contact...Has the athletic ability to break down and tackle in space (former defensive back in high school).
Negatives: Did not always get great height on his kickoffs, but as a senior, his hang time greatly improved from the previous season (4.54-second average in 2007, compared to 3.84 in 2005)...Needs to show a bit more quickness on his approach on field goals and conversions (bit deliberate in the past), but is much quicker when he uses a 2 1/2-step approach (note-he has never had a field goal or extra point blocked. The missed PAT in the 2007 UNLV was due to a muffed snap)...Might need some time to work with his holder and snapper at the next level, as he is a left-footed, soccer style kicker and the trio need to get comfortable with the kicker's approach and timing.
ALEXIS SERNA
Height: 5'7"
Weight: 168
College: Oregon State
Overview: The 2005 Lou Groza Award winner as the nation's best kicker, Serna leaves Oregon State as the Pac-10's second-leading all-time scorer with 383 points and has proven to be effective in poor weather situations. As impressive as Serna's career numbers are, he faces an uphill battle in getting drafted as his accuracy dropped each year of his career.
Positives: Good leg strength for a smaller kicker. ... Has demonstrated the ability to drive the ball on kickoffs and has a long field goal of 58 yards. ... Gets the ball up quickly. ... Best attribute might be a history of success in poor weather situations. ... Emerged as OSU's primary punter in 2007.
Negatives: Accuracy has dropped each year of his career after winning the 2005 Lou Groza Award. ... Serna may have bottomed out to end his senior season, missing five of his final seven kicks. ... While his leg strength is considered good for a smaller kicker, Serna only recorded two touchbacks out of 68 kickoff attempts as a senior.