What's new
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

The Top 300 Greatest TV Shows of All Time: FBG Consensus: 50 Lists received. 2: Seinfeld 1: Breaking Bad (15 Viewers)

Babylon 5 48th on my list. May not have aged as well effects-wise, but this was one of the first great serial stories on TV.
It was in my list of close misses. I watched it for the first time just a few years ago, and obviously it now suffers in comparison to many shows that have come after, which it probably partially inspired/influenced. I think, had I watched it when released, I'd probably have ranked it higher. It's tough to get past the production quality of the effects, prosthetics, etc. 30 years later.
 
Of the ones posted so far, I had World at War and Late Night with Conan O’Brien on mine. My list is pretty doc heavy, and World at War was one of the finest. Love just about everything that Conan has done. My favorite of the Tonight Show/Late Night/Late Show network shows. I’m still angry about Jay Leno taking The Tonight Show back from Conan.
 
I considered "I Think You Should Leave" but didn't ultimately put it on my list. I'm surprised Mork & Mindy isn't higher. I didn't consider it, but thought it was beloved.
Something I find funny about that show is how little content there is. It's like 3 episodes of SNL worth of runtime. I thought it was hilarious, there just wasn't much of it.
 

290-281​


289Dopesick3

I only had Dopesick out of this group. So far all three shows I have had on my lists were nominated by exactly three people. I wonder if they are the same three people..haha
  • Dopesick (#26): I was pleasantly surprised by this series so it may be higher than it should be on my list out of sheer expectations and exceeding them. Very well done on a difficult subject. "Based on a true story" but seemed to be very plausible in that it didn't take many liberties (or at least it didn't seem like it did). Well worth the watch if you like true story type of stuff.
would have probably had dope sick as well, but probably chose too many shows because of nostalgia and not what i would actually watch first today.
 
I considered "I Think You Should Leave" but didn't ultimately put it on my list. I'm surprised Mork & Mindy isn't higher. I didn't consider it, but thought it was beloved.
Something I find funny about that show is how little content there is. It's like 3 episodes of SNL worth of runtime. I thought it was hilarious, there just wasn't much of it.

I actually had typed out something very similar but then deleted it. The reason it didn't make my list is because there isn't enough of it.
 
I liked NCIS:LA. I'm not a big fan of procedural but I did watch the first 2 seasons of The Rookie and I liked Cold Case. Can't believe that I didn't even think about Castle.
I liked NCIS: LA too but figured I would just go with one of the franchise for this. Big fan of The Rookie but not on long enough to place in the top 70. Cold Case was fine and an interesting concept but it wasn't quite up to par with some of the other ones of that type. Big fan of Castle. It's on my list.
 

290-281​


281Carnivale3
t-282Rick and Morty3
t-282Malcolm in the Middle3
t-282Chuck3
t-285The Great British Bake Off3
t-285What We Do in the Shadows3
t-285Late Night With Conan O'Brien3
288Babylon 52
289Dopesick3
290Loki2

I cant believe I'm one of only 3 people with British baking show. That kinda blows my mind.

I liked Chuck and Loki but neither made my final list.
The very concept of the show pissed off some people earlier. I enjoy watching it with my wife.
 
LFG! Remember, 300-201 are being posted in groups. 200 on individually.

300-291!!​


RankTitle# of Lists
291I Think You Should Leave2
292The Challenge2
293The World at War2
294NCIS3
295Magnum, P.I.5
296Supernatural3
297Billions4
298Just Shoot Me3
299The Wonderful World of Disney2
300Mork & Mindy3

So, who's my other 10% crew who put Magnum in?
 
and lasted 15 seasons
I probably eliminated a lot of shows from my list BECAUSE they lasted 10 or 15 or 20 seasons instead of keeping it at a tight 5 or 6. I'm looking at you, Walking Dead, Sons of Anarchy (ok, only 7 seasons but should have been 3) and pretty much every American sitcom ever created.
How dare you. Which season was Sons of Ireland again?
That was season 3, and I'm not sure if I included that season as my cutoff because it was good or because I'm a sucker for Irish stuff.
 
Forgot about Cold Case. Would have made my list.

My list had Chuck. It was campy, but I watched the whole thing and enjoyed it all.
 

290-281​


281Carnivale3
t-282Rick and Morty3
t-282Malcolm in the Middle3
t-282Chuck3
t-285The Great British Bake Off3
t-285What We Do in the Shadows3
t-285Late Night With Conan O'Brien3
288Babylon 52
289Dopesick3
290Loki2

Nothing in this group is on my list, but I did watch Malcolm in the Middle pretty regularly and probably should have considered it. We all know about Bryan Cranston's dramatic chops, but this series showed he is a brilliant comedic actor as well. In fact, AMC was reluctant to let Vince Gilligan cast him for Breaking Bad because their execs thought of him as a sitcom guy.

Conan's heyday came during a time when I rarely watched late-night TV, so I didn't catch him that much.
 
I only had Dopesick out of this group. So far all three shows I have had on my lists were nominated by exactly three people. I wonder if they are the same three people..haha
  • Dopesick (#26): I was pleasantly surprised by this series so it may be higher than it should be on my list out of sheer expectations and exceeding them. Very well done on a difficult subject. "Based on a true story" but seemed to be very plausible in that it didn't take many liberties (or at least it didn't seem like it did). Well worth the watch if you like true story type of stuff.
I'm one of the three that has this on my list. One of my best friends was "dopesick" for 8 years. It all started when he broke his ankle delivering mail. Thankfully, he survived his oxy addiction.
 
LFG! Remember, 300-201 are being posted in groups. 200 on individually.

300-291!!​


RankTitle# of Lists
291I Think You Should Leave2
292The Challenge2
293The World at War2
294NCIS3
295Magnum, P.I.5
296Supernatural3
297Billions4
298Just Shoot Me3
299The Wonderful World of Disney2
300Mork & Mindy3

So, who's my other 10% crew who put Magnum in?

Raising my hand here. So, I went back and re-watched it from the beginning (several times now actually) and I think it's funny that they changed the original theme song, I totally forgot about that. The theme song they used from episode 1 to 12, is actually really good but I think the 12 year old version of me would have hated it compared to the iconic theme song from episode 13 on.
 
LFG! Remember, 300-201 are being posted in groups. 200 on individually.

300-291!!​


RankTitle# of Lists
291I Think You Should Leave2
292The Challenge2
293The World at War2
294NCIS3
295Magnum, P.I.5
296Supernatural3
297Billions4
298Just Shoot Me3
299The Wonderful World of Disney2
300Mork & Mindy3


One of the two votes for "I Think You Should Leave" was mine. If you haven't watched this yet, do yourself a favor and do so immediately.
 
Is the NCIS the original or all 700 of them combined?
If it the original, I don't know how it is not listed higher

These were the only ones that had "NCIS" in the title, so I assume the original.

I've never watched these network crime procedurals.
It would have to be. The spinoffs have different titles (NCIS: Los Angeles, NCIS: New Orleans, etc.) and different casts but they share the same universe. You wouldn't count Star Trek, Star Trek: The Next Generation and Star Trek: Deep Space Nine as the same series. Same idea here.
 
I was going to do a list but ran out of time. Womp-womp.

I wonder if anyone besides me would have had Impractical Jokers on their list?
 
LFG! Remember, 300-201 are being posted in groups. 200 on individually.

300-291!!​


RankTitle# of Lists
291I Think You Should Leave2
292The Challenge2
293The World at War2
294NCIS3
295Magnum, P.I.5
296Supernatural3
297Billions4
298Just Shoot Me3
299The Wonderful World of Disney2
300Mork & Mindy3

So, who's my other 10% crew who put Magnum in?

Raising my hand here. So, I went back and re-watched it from the beginning (several times now actually) and I think it's funny that they changed the original theme song, I totally forgot about that. The theme song they used from episode 1 to 12, is actually really good but I think the 12 year old version of me would have hated it compared to the iconic theme song from episode 13 on.
I never noticed that, but one of my other older shows, I did notice the change in the opening music theme i think in season 2 or mid through season 1.
 
LFG! Remember, 300-201 are being posted in groups. 200 on individually.

300-291!!​


RankTitle# of Lists
291I Think You Should Leave2
292The Challenge2
293The World at War2
294NCIS3
295Magnum, P.I.5
296Supernatural3
297Billions4
298Just Shoot Me3
299The Wonderful World of Disney2
300Mork & Mindy3

So, who's my other 10% crew who put Magnum in?

Raising my hand here. So, I went back and re-watched it from the beginning (several times now actually) and I think it's funny that they changed the original theme song, I totally forgot about that. The theme song they used from episode 1 to 12, is actually really good but I think the 12 year old version of me would have hated it compared to the iconic theme song from episode 13 on.
I never noticed that, but one of my other older shows, I did notice the change in the opening music theme i think in season 2 or mid through season 1.
A show on my list had a different theme song in its first 2 seasons than in subsequent ones. Perhaps we are talking about the same thing.
 
Is the NCIS the original or all 700 of them combined?
If it the original, I don't know how it is not listed higher
Well, apparently if a show went over 6 seasons it was banned from certain peoples list on principle. Doesn't matter how good they were. Over 6 seasons......must be bad.
That's not quite what I mean and it isn't a firm rule. There's a tendency for shows to get worse and worse the more they drag on, like the creators may have had an original arc in mind but the show was successful so they just keep on cranking out shows and seasons and they get progressively worse. Those types of shows often ended up getting bumped from my list. I definitely have some that lasted a while and made it to my list, though.

That wasn't the case with NCIS. NCIS didn't make it to my list because I'm not a 64 year-old woman named Midge. :scared:
 
Is the NCIS the original or all 700 of them combined?
If it the original, I don't know how it is not listed higher
Well, apparently if a show went over 6 seasons it was banned from certain peoples list on principle. Doesn't matter how good they were. Over 6 seasons......must be bad.

I'll admit to having a bias against most regular network TV shows these days, especially the never ending list of crime ones. I think the last network show I watched was Lost. I just feel the quality is so much better on the cable networks and streaming. I also much prefer serial shows than procedurals.

Nothing to do with length though. So long as the quality holds, the longer a show is the better. More to binge on!
 
That's not quite what I mean and it isn't a firm rule. There's a tendency for shows to get worse and worse the more they drag on, like the creators may have had an original arc in mind but the show was successful so they just keep on cranking out shows and seasons and they get progressively worse. Those types of shows often ended up getting bumped from my list. I definitely have some that lasted a while and made it to my list, though.
I know what you meant. Just couldn't resist jabbing the comment....hahaha I think there are shows that definitely have an arc and a course but I think there are shows that are fine going that long. The procedurals that have basically stand alone episodes can withstand the test of time longer than one that kind of have an expiration based on the overarching story. Criminal Minds is one that comes to mind. It is still going and in general I don't think it has lost that much.
That wasn't the case with NCIS. NCIS didn't make it to my list because I'm not a 64 year-old woman named Midge. :scared:
I am not embarrassed to say that I had NCIS on my list..................and I am not a 64 yr old woman named Midge. My friends call me Gladys
 
my money is on the swan
So I just did some super scientific research and it seems I'd easily have the upper hand on a swan. I am actually disappointed at how little a challenge they actually posted in the videos I watched. Not sure why I thought more of their attacking capabilities but I've believed for years that an aggressive swan would be dangerous. I'm little disappointed if I'm being honest.

now picture Larry with a golf club
 

280-271​


RankTitle# of Lists
271Tom & Jerry3
272Loudermilk2
273Sex and the City2
274The Mentalist5
275Boy Meets World4
276The Amazing Race3
277Chopped3
278Boston Legal3
279Your Honor2
280Party Down3

None of these on my list. I wanted to like Loudermilk but it just didn't grab me. I'll probably try again. Love Chopped but eventually got bored with it. I tried Party Down but never finished - I liked what I saw though. Of course I watched Tom and Jerry but Top 70, no way. Sex and the City was my ex's jam. I never really watched the rest - but young McB remembers Topanga.
 
Many many of you guys here are familiar with "Connections"? I am thinking it would be a hit with this critical thinking crowd. It was originally on PBS. Such a great combination of history, technology and social studies and how they intertwined to bring us to where we are.

here's one about the NYC black out of the 60s

Connections is a science education television series created, written, and presented by British science historian James Burke. The series was produced and directed by Mick Jackson of the BBC Science and Features Department and first aired in 1978 (UK) and 1979 (US). It took an interdisciplinary approach to the history of science and invention, and demonstrated how various discoveries, scientific achievements, and historical world events were built from one another successively in an interconnected way to bring about particular aspects of modern technology. The series was noted for Burke's crisp and enthusiastic presentation (and dry humour), historical re-enactments, and intricate working models.

Connections explores an "Alternative View of Change" (the subtitle of the series) that rejects the conventional linear and teleological view of historical progress. Burke contends that one cannot consider the development of any particular piece of the modern world in isolation. Rather, the entire gestalt of the modern world is the result of a web of interconnected events, each one consisting of a person or group acting for reasons of their own motivations (e.g., profit, curiosity, religion) with no concept of the final, modern result to which the actions of either them or their contemporaries would lead.
 
LFG! Remember, 300-201 are being posted in groups. 200 on individually.

300-291!!​


RankTitle# of Lists
291I Think You Should Leave2
292The Challenge2
293The World at War2
294NCIS3
295Magnum, P.I.5
296Supernatural3
297Billions4
298Just Shoot Me3
299The Wonderful World of Disney2
300Mork & Mindy3

So, who's my other 10% crew who put Magnum in?

Raising my hand here. So, I went back and re-watched it from the beginning (several times now actually) and I think it's funny that they changed the original theme song, I totally forgot about that. The theme song they used from episode 1 to 12, is actually really good but I think the 12 year old version of me would have hated it compared to the iconic theme song from episode 13 on.
I never noticed that, but one of my other older shows, I did notice the change in the opening music theme i think in season 2 or mid through season 1.
A show on my list had a different theme song in its first 2 seasons than in subsequent ones. Perhaps we are talking about the same thing.
I don't think so, as these were just minor changes, not complete ones.
 

280-271​


RankTitle# of Lists
271Tom & Jerry3
272Loudermilk2
273Sex and the City2
274The Mentalist5
275Boy Meets World4
276The Amazing Race3
277Chopped3
278Boston Legal3
279Your Honor2
280Party Down3

Alright three more of mine here with Mentalist, Chopped, and Boston Legal

Boston Legal is criminally low. That show was hilarious and stayed pretty good for it's entire run. Incredible cast too, Shatner, Spader, the mom from Modern Family and a bunch of other great and famous ones I lack the names of right now.

Chopped is the second (after British baking) of MANY competition shows on my 70. Like I said, some variation of "do challenges, cut a person, do challenges, cut a person, declare a winner" is my absolute favorite type of show by far.
 

280-271​


RankTitle# of Lists
271Tom & Jerry3
272Loudermilk2
273Sex and the City2
274The Mentalist5
275Boy Meets World4
276The Amazing Race3
277Chopped3
278Boston Legal3
279Your Honor2
280Party Down3

2 more of mine go down and it looks like only 1 other person and i liked them.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top