What's new
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

The Top 300 Greatest TV Shows of All Time: FBG Consensus: 50 Lists received. 2: Seinfeld 1: Breaking Bad (9 Viewers)

194 - Orange Is the New Black​

Comedy
Score: 156
Average Rank: 48.7

The story of Piper Chapman, a woman in her thirties who is sentenced to fifteen months in prison after being convicted of a decade-old crime of transporting money for her drug-dealing girlfriend.

List Breakdown

Pip's Invitation 27
UncleZen 40
Bottomfeeder Sports 49
John Madden's Lunchbox 50
Tick 55
timschochet 59
Don Quixote 61
When this came out, there was nothing like it. It was funny and heart-wrenching and thought-provoking. The first four seasons were some of the most invested I have ever been in a show.

They made a poor decision to kill off one of the best characters and flanderized some of the others, so the final seasons were somewhat of a struggle and I never finished the last one.
I didn’t like when they got rid of P0rnstache.
 

194 - Orange Is the New Black​

Comedy
Score: 156
Average Rank: 48.7

The story of Piper Chapman, a woman in her thirties who is sentenced to fifteen months in prison after being convicted of a decade-old crime of transporting money for her drug-dealing girlfriend.

List Breakdown

Pip's Invitation 27
UncleZen 40
Bottomfeeder Sports 49
John Madden's Lunchbox 50
Tick 55
timschochet 59
Don Quixote 61
When this came out, there was nothing like it. It was funny and heart-wrenching and thought-provoking. The first four seasons were some of the most invested I have ever been in a show.

They made a poor decision to kill off one of the best characters and flanderized some of the others, so the final seasons were somewhat of a struggle and I never finished the last one.
I didn’t like when they got rid of P0rnstache.
Master Chief P0rnstache, the dockworker.
 

194 - Orange Is the New Black​

Comedy
Score: 156
Average Rank: 48.7

The story of Piper Chapman, a woman in her thirties who is sentenced to fifteen months in prison after being convicted of a decade-old crime of transporting money for her drug-dealing girlfriend.

List Breakdown

Pip's Invitation 27
UncleZen 40
Bottomfeeder Sports 49
John Madden's Lunchbox 50
Tick 55
timschochet 59
Don Quixote 61
When this came out, there was nothing like it. It was funny and heart-wrenching and thought-provoking. The first four seasons were some of the most invested I have ever been in a show.

They made a poor decision to kill off one of the best characters and flanderized some of the others, so the final seasons were somewhat of a struggle and I never finished the last one.
Pretty accurate - I tried to make myself rate shows for their best seasons rather than their worst, though it's hard to stay consistent there. Well, I'll amend that... I tried not to punish shows for not getting cancelled. If they were good from the start through 4 seasons, I try to remember that. I give less credit for a show that takes a season or 2 to get going (like Parks and Rec, which I often hear gets good after season 1, but that I've never gone back to after season 1 didn't grab me).
Don’t recall but maybe there was a long lapse between seasons. I find that happening with a lot of shows that go a year or two (sometimes more) between seasons - lose interest after moving on to another show(s). Far cry from the old days when the season would end with May sweeps and pick up again in Sep
The original intent of the show was to have the focus on Piper Chapman, as the story was based on a true character, and their “adventures”
But a) the actress was awful and b) the other characters were so much more interesting. By the end Piper was just a bit player. Still series lead, but her storylines were boring and less and less time was spent on them.

Yes they killed Poussay, but it directly led to the series events that followed.
Ultimately it showed that some people are just screwed by life and the system they are put into doesnt exactly help their rehabilitation.

Enjoyed the series, but went on for one season too many.
If the focus wasnt on Piper for much of the run time, this would have ranked higher than the #50 I had it at.
 

194 - Orange Is the New Black​

Comedy
Score: 156
Average Rank: 48.7

The story of Piper Chapman, a woman in her thirties who is sentenced to fifteen months in prison after being convicted of a decade-old crime of transporting money for her drug-dealing girlfriend.

List Breakdown

Pip's Invitation 27
UncleZen 40
Bottomfeeder Sports 49
John Madden's Lunchbox 50
Tick 55
timschochet 59
Don Quixote 61
When this came out, there was nothing like it. It was funny and heart-wrenching and thought-provoking. The first four seasons were some of the most invested I have ever been in a show.

They made a poor decision to kill off one of the best characters and flanderized some of the others, so the final seasons were somewhat of a struggle and I never finished the last one.
Pretty accurate - I tried to make myself rate shows for their best seasons rather than their worst, though it's hard to stay consistent there. Well, I'll amend that... I tried not to punish shows for not getting cancelled. If they were good from the start through 4 seasons, I try to remember that. I give less credit for a show that takes a season or 2 to get going (like Parks and Rec, which I often hear gets good after season 1, but that I've never gone back to after season 1 didn't grab me).
Don’t recall but maybe there was a long lapse between seasons. I find that happening with a lot of shows that go a year or two (sometimes more) between seasons - lose interest after moving on to another show(s). Far cry from the old days when the season would end with May sweeps and pick up again in Sep
The original intent of the show was to have the focus on Piper Chapman, as the story was based on a true character, and their “adventures”
But a) the actress was awful and b) the other characters were so much more interesting. By the end Piper was just a bit player. Still series lead, but her storylines were boring and less and less time was spent on them.

Yes they killed Poussay, but it directly led to the series events that followed.
Ultimately it showed that some people are just screwed by life and the system they are put into doesnt exactly help their rehabilitation.

Enjoyed the series, but went on for one season too many.
If the focus wasnt on Piper for much of the run time, this would have ranked higher than the #50 I had it at.
My blurb written a few weeks ago-

Orange is the New Black

This ran out of steam as characters left, but the first few seasons were addicting
 

194 - Orange Is the New Black​

Comedy
Score: 156
Average Rank: 48.7

The story of Piper Chapman, a woman in her thirties who is sentenced to fifteen months in prison after being convicted of a decade-old crime of transporting money for her drug-dealing girlfriend.

List Breakdown

Pip's Invitation 27
UncleZen 40
Bottomfeeder Sports 49
John Madden's Lunchbox 50
Tick 55
timschochet 59
Don Quixote 61
When this came out, there was nothing like it. It was funny and heart-wrenching and thought-provoking. The first four seasons were some of the most invested I have ever been in a show.

They made a poor decision to kill off one of the best characters and flanderized some of the others, so the final seasons were somewhat of a struggle and I never finished the last one.
Pretty accurate - I tried to make myself rate shows for their best seasons rather than their worst, though it's hard to stay consistent there. Well, I'll amend that... I tried not to punish shows for not getting cancelled. If they were good from the start through 4 seasons, I try to remember that. I give less credit for a show that takes a season or 2 to get going (like Parks and Rec, which I often hear gets good after season 1, but that I've never gone back to after season 1 didn't grab me).
Don’t recall but maybe there was a long lapse between seasons. I find that happening with a lot of shows that go a year or two (sometimes more) between seasons - lose interest after moving on to another show(s). Far cry from the old days when the season would end with May sweeps and pick up again in Sep
The original intent of the show was to have the focus on Piper Chapman, as the story was based on a true character, and their “adventures”
But a) the actress was awful and b) the other characters were so much more interesting. By the end Piper was just a bit player. Still series lead, but her storylines were boring and less and less time was spent on them.

Yes they killed Poussay, but it directly led to the series events that followed.
Ultimately it showed that some people are just screwed by life and the system they are put into doesnt exactly help their rehabilitation.

Enjoyed the series, but went on for one season too many.
If the focus wasnt on Piper for much of the run time, this would have ranked higher than the #50 I had it at.
My blurb written a few weeks ago-

Orange is the New Black

This ran out of steam as characters left, but the first few seasons were addicting
That doesn't link to a review for me, just the general show IMDB page.
 

194 - Orange Is the New Black​

Comedy
Score: 156
Average Rank: 48.7

The story of Piper Chapman, a woman in her thirties who is sentenced to fifteen months in prison after being convicted of a decade-old crime of transporting money for her drug-dealing girlfriend.

List Breakdown

Pip's Invitation 27
UncleZen 40
Bottomfeeder Sports 49
John Madden's Lunchbox 50
Tick 55
timschochet 59
Don Quixote 61
Watched the first two seasons of this and really liked it. Lost interest after that but don’t recall why - very good cast.
This was my experience too. Not sure why I stopped. I wasn't watching it live so a stop in seasons wasn't a factor. I just lost interest.
 

194 - Orange Is the New Black​

Comedy
Score: 156
Average Rank: 48.7

The story of Piper Chapman, a woman in her thirties who is sentenced to fifteen months in prison after being convicted of a decade-old crime of transporting money for her drug-dealing girlfriend.

List Breakdown

Pip's Invitation 27
UncleZen 40
Bottomfeeder Sports 49
John Madden's Lunchbox 50
Tick 55
timschochet 59
Don Quixote 61
When this came out, there was nothing like it. It was funny and heart-wrenching and thought-provoking. The first four seasons were some of the most invested I have ever been in a show.

They made a poor decision to kill off one of the best characters and flanderized some of the others, so the final seasons were somewhat of a struggle and I never finished the last one.
I didn’t like when they got rid of P0rnstache.
Master Chief P0rnstache, the dockworker.
And bank robber.
 
I liked the first 2 seasons of OITNB, maybe it was good for a little longer, it all runs together, but it got way too “girl power” for me. Sorry, don’t mean that to sound misogynistic, but I just had a hard time connecting with it after awhile
Not even sure I finished it, I think the wife started watching on her own
 
I really liked OITNB but like others, it didn’t keep my interest and never made my list. Another one of this genre from Australia was equally as good, if not better.
 
This Week In Baseball

Forgot about this and probably would have included it. Another nostalgia-related sports show I considered was
George Michael's Sports Machine

Shocked TWIB ended up so low with this group. I was one of the rankers and had it fairly high - I think somewhere around 30.
Guessing many overlooked it or didn’t think it was eligible.

How about that?
I loved it, just didn’t consider those type of shows
 

194 - Orange Is the New Black​

Comedy
Score: 156
Average Rank: 48.7

The story of Piper Chapman, a woman in her thirties who is sentenced to fifteen months in prison after being convicted of a decade-old crime of transporting money for her drug-dealing girlfriend.

List Breakdown

Pip's Invitation 27
UncleZen 40
Bottomfeeder Sports 49
John Madden's Lunchbox 50
Tick 55
timschochet 59
Don Quixote 61
RT: 90/82
 
Slow Horses - my #56 - one of only a handful of current shows on my list. Gary Oldman is fantastic in it and the rest of the cast is great. To me it does a really good job of staying true to the book series. Definitely check this out if you haven’t already.

#63 for me and agree with everything you said. I can't get over how good Gary Oldman is. An acting master class.

ETA: I watched this specifically to see if I should put it on this list, so I could have some recency bias in there.

I was one of the other rankers - love Oldman in this.
 

196 - Bloodline​

Drama
Score: 153
Average Rank: 40.4

A family of adult siblings find that their past secrets and scars are revealed when their black sheep of a brother returns home.

List Breakdown

:pickle: steelerfan1 6
Frostillicus 33
simey 38
Dr Octopus 57
AAABatteries 68
The last two episodes nearly destroyed what was an excellent series with amazing acting and an interesting storyline.

If not for a weak and weird ending I would have it even higher.

I ranked it but barely due to the ending. Was excellent before that and as you will see later in the countdown, I’ll not totally hate on a show with a bad ending.
 
IMDB ratings

Dukes of Hazzard: 7.1
Penguin: 8.6
Quantum Leap: 8.2
Bosch: 8.5
I would like to make a request of @Scoresman

Maybe too much to ask, but would you be open to including IMDB rating along with score and average rank?
I’m a big proponent of IMDB ratings for movies, I think they’re the best ratings out there. I ignore them for TV, though - every show is an 8.0. People who make it through the show liked it enough to stick with it and give it a 9. People who didn’t like it dipped out after 3 episodes and don’t feel like they saw enough to give it a rating. At least that’s my guess at why the show scores are all so high.
I'm thinking you're right.

RT seems like a better gauge (tomatometer/popcorn):

Dukes: N/A
Penguin: 95%/89%
Quantum Leap: 58%/73%
Bosch: 97%/94%
Bloodline: 62%/74%

Even though I ranked it, I’m shocked Bosch does that well on RT.
 

192 - Veronica Mars​

Crime
Score: 158
Average Rank: 31.5

After her best friend is murdered and her father is removed as county sheriff, Veronica Mars dedicates her life to cracking the toughest mysteries in the affluent town of Neptune.

List Breakdown

UncleZen 16
Barry2 24
whoknew 39
KarmaPolice 47
I need to watch this show. Kristen Bell is one of my favorite comedic actresses. Her work on The Good Place is brilliant and she gives me the jumpy&quo.
 

192 - Veronica Mars​

Crime
Score: 158
Average Rank: 31.5

After her best friend is murdered and her father is removed as county sheriff, Veronica Mars dedicates her life to cracking the toughest mysteries in the affluent town of Neptune.

List Breakdown

UncleZen 16
Barry2 24
whoknew 39
KarmaPolice 47
Never watched this but after a cursory review, I'm interested!

Mr. Rogers - never even crossed my mind. Of course I watched it as a kid. I can't really seem to remember if I was extremely into it or not, but it was on. I think my age might have something to do with it - Nickelodeon garnered most of attention back then even though PBS stuff was on in the house, too.
 

192 - Veronica Mars​

Crime
Score: 158
Average Rank: 31.5

After her best friend is murdered and her father is removed as county sheriff, Veronica Mars dedicates her life to cracking the toughest mysteries in the affluent town of Neptune.

List Breakdown

UncleZen 16
Barry2 24
whoknew 39
KarmaPolice 47
i havent watched any of the last 4 shows i don't think, but this one sounds interesting.
 
Hadn't thought of the Dukes of Hazard in a long time. Surprised to read season 1 started in 1979. As a youth it was just a fun show. Great characters. Those silly Duke boys. Ha ha
 
IMDB ratings

Dukes of Hazzard: 7.1
Penguin: 8.6
Quantum Leap: 8.2
Bosch: 8.5
I would like to make a request of @Scoresman

Maybe too much to ask, but would you be open to including IMDB rating along with score and average rank?
I’m a big proponent of IMDB ratings for movies, I think they’re the best ratings out there. I ignore them for TV, though - every show is an 8.0. People who make it through the show liked it enough to stick with it and give it a 9. People who didn’t like it dipped out after 3 episodes and don’t feel like they saw enough to give it a rating. At least that’s my guess at why the show scores are all so high.
I'm thinking you're right.

RT seems like a better gauge (tomatometer/popcorn):

Dukes: N/A
Penguin: 95%/89%
Quantum Leap: 58%/73%
Bosch: 97%/94%
Bloodline: 62%/74%

Even though I ranked it, I’m shocked Bosch does that well on RT.

Makes perfect sense to me. Of course, I ranked it #4…
 

193 - Mr. Rogers’ Neighborhood​

Childrens
Score: 157
Average Rank: 39.6

Fred Rogers explores various topics for young viewers through presentations and music, both in his world and in the Neighborhood of Make-Believe.

List Breakdown

krista4 20
Yo Mama 30
Psychopav 40
Runkle 52
Eephus 56
Since it was a competition and I was trying to win, I’m sure I probably stated this more eloquently in the TV Draft when I selected this show, but this is up there with Sesame Street as far as public impact and importance.

Where Sesame Street taught us how to count and to read, Mr. Rogers taught us how to treat others, how to love ourselves, how it’s ok to have feelings, and how it’s ok to be different.

I still remember how I learned things watching Sesame Street (more on that later I’m sure). I still remember how Mr. Rogers Neighborhood made me feel.
 

191 - Whose Line Is It Anyway?​

Comedy
Score: 158
Average Rank: 48.4

Improvisational comedy game show in which four players act out various comic games and sketches.

List Breakdown

:pickle: Shaft41 3
BLOCKED PUNT 37
Hastur 46
Instinctive 49
ilov80s 64
Those of us in the music theme draft know how much I love this show. My theme is basically a skit from Scenes From a Hat. Couldn’t make it into my top 70, but it was close.
 

191 - Whose Line Is It Anyway?​

Comedy
Score: 158
Average Rank: 48.4

Improvisational comedy game show in which four players act out various comic games and sketches.

List Breakdown

:pickle: Shaft41 3
BLOCKED PUNT 37
Hastur 46
Instinctive 49
ilov80s 64
Show is funny - didn't consider it and not sure it would have made my list, but it's always a fun watch.

The future Mrs. McBokonon, Aisha Tylor, once said I was "hilarious" and "on fire" during an online fundraiser. :bowtie:
 

191 - Whose Line Is It Anyway?​

Comedy
Score: 158
Average Rank: 48.4

Improvisational comedy game show in which four players act out various comic games and sketches.

List Breakdown

:pickle: Shaft41 3
BLOCKED PUNT 37
Hastur 46
Instinctive 49
ilov80s 64
Colin Mochrie and Ryan Stiles are my generation's version of Tim Conway and Harvey Korman.

The way they played off each other was top notch, Laurel and Hardy level stuff.
 
Whose Line was brilliant when Drew Carey was host. The banter between performers was great. I should check out some of the recent episodes, it looks like the 2nd run just ended.
 

190 - Beverly Hills, 90210​

Drama
Score: 158
Average Rank: 39.8

The lives of teens in Beverly Hills.

List Breakdown

KarmaPolice 25
Dan Lambskin 29
zamboni 36
simey 55
Todem 62
Scoresman 63
Tau37 69
I considered this one, but left it off my top 70.

I was slightly too young to fully appreciate it when it was on and never went back to watch it later on.
 
I checked with @Scoresman before posting ...this one didn't make the top 300.

I made sure a quirky 2 "season" mockumentary from Netflix called "American Vandal" made my list at #68. It's a spin on the true crime docs and both seasons are set within high school situations.

The first season 2 HS "investigators" take on who really spray-painted the "phallic" symbols on almost 30 teacher's cars in the HS parking lot.

The 2nd season these two try and solve who in the school put a powerful laxative in the lemonade in the cafeteria causing a massive "brown out" across the entire school. The culprit calls themselves the "Turd Burglar"

Highly recommend for those who are fans of mockumentaries - didn't want to let this one slip by.

Season 1 promo

Season 2 promo
 
90210 was surely a thing when it came out. The show came out and peaked during my high school years, and it was fascinating how everyone was watching it. The jocks, nerds, rockers, EVERYONE seemed to watch this.
Yep. I'm finally confident in myself to admit that it was one of the first shows I recorded on our VCR to watch. Smh. For those kids, you can Google VCR. Ha ha
 
This Week In Baseball

Forgot about this and probably would have included it. Another nostalgia-related sports show I considered was
George Michael's Sports Machine

Shocked TWIB ended up so low with this group. I was one of the rankers and had it fairly high - I think somewhere around 30.
Guessing many overlooked it or didn’t think it was eligible.

How about that?
I loved it, just didn’t consider those type of shows
Same….was a staple for me but never even considered shows like that.
 
if i would have submitted a list , it wouldve been skewed with alot of Canadian shows
From 300-201, I watched 19 of those shows regularly and another dozen or so , i have never heard of
 
Whose Line was brilliant when Drew Carey was host. The banter between performers was great. I should check out some of the recent episodes, it looks like the 2nd run just ended.
You should check out the British version. I thought that was better and how I first stumbled upon it. Had many of the same players but the host didn't try as hard as Drew Carey and I thought he was better (not that Drew was bad).

I assume that the show in this ranking was the US version.
 
Whose Line was brilliant when Drew Carey was host. The banter between performers was great. I should check out some of the recent episodes, it looks like the 2nd run just ended.
You should check out the British version. I thought that was better and how I first stumbled upon it. Had many of the same players but the host didn't try as hard as Drew Carey and I thought he was better (not that Drew was bad).

I assume that the show in this ranking was the US version.

It is. One person voted for the British version. It did not make the list.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top