In my case, I remember the best songs, but quite often forget the worst, probably listening to the track just once, maybe not even all the way through if it is awful.
An example would be a daily Twitter thread I follow where people post the song that is in their head right now, and someone posted
No Time This Time by The Police from 2003 and I realized I didn't remember the song, which surprised me because I was a big early fan and had bought all their LPs. After listening I knew the reason why, it is terrible, as Sting is singing off key for much of the song.
https://youtu.be/hKz6d4kRvy0