A commish question. Here is our tiebreaker criteria for playoff entry. 1. W/L record 2. HTH record 3. Overall points Here is the scenario, let's say 3 teams with same w/l records contend for just one playoff spot. Every team has played each other twice during the season. Team A lost to team B twice and split with team C. Leads in overall points over team B and team C. Team B beat team A twice and split with team C. Remains behind Team A and Team C in overall points. Team C split with team A and split with team B. Remains behind Team A and is ahead of team C in overall points. What team should make the playoff based on this criteria?
Given what you posted above and taking nothing else into account (i.e., what you really should do, current rules notwithstanding), you look at HTH among the group first. Within the group;A is 1-3B is 3-1C is 2-2Therefore, your order of finish is B, C, A. Points do not get factored in. It's pretty clear that unless you have omitted something, this is the only way the issue can be decided per your current rules.