Trade Offer - Ertz / Gallup for Thielen Need outside opinion (1 Viewer)

[jmble]

12 team Superflex PPR League.

Start QB / RB / WR / WR / TE / Flex / Flex / Superflex / K / Def

My roster:                                                                                                                      His roster:

QB - Watson, Brady, Dalton                                                                                         QB - Stafford, Mariota, Bridgewater, Tannehill, Falk

RB - A Jones, K Johnson, White, Drake, Peterson                                                   RB - McCaffrey, Barkley, R Jones II, Barber

WR - Golladay, Hilton, Gallup, M Jones, Valdes-Scantling, C Davis                      WR - Cooper, Chark, Thielen, Jeffery, Sanu, D Jackson

TE - Ertz, Andrews                                                                                                        TE - Oshaughnessy

K - Zuerlein                                                                                                                    K - Elliott

Def - Jags                                                                                                                       DEF - Bills

I was offered Adam Thielen for Ertz and Gallup.  

He is desperate for a tight end.  Thielen is a personal favorite of mine so I know I probably overvalue him.  Would you make this trade?  Is there a different offer you might make back for one of my tight ends?

Thanks for the opinions.  As always will answer yours.

 

[Gally]

I don't Gallup will be much less (if at all) to Thielen ROS.  I do not make this trade to get Thielen.  I much prefer Ertz & Gallup.  I would counter with Andrews for Thielen straight or if we wants more give him his choice of Jones, MVS or Davis in addition to Andrews. 

 

[jmble]

I don't Gallup will be much less (if at all) to Thielen ROS.  I do not make this trade to get Thielen.  I much prefer Ertz & Gallup.  I would counter with Andrews for Thielen straight or if we wants more give him his choice of Jones, MVS or Davis in addition to Andrews. 

Thanks Gally, I can always count on you to talk me out of bad decisions that my head knows are probably bad but I want to make anyway.