There she is! I sorta half-apologized to JML when I sent in my rankings, knowing many people hate this one. And
@bigbottom, way back then I commented that you and I had
such similar tastes, with one big exception. You worried it was New Year's Day (which is in my top 10 and I think your #1?), but it was this one. I
love this song, and it is my highest-rated loss so far, having had it at #21 on my list (and even higher in some earlier iterations).
I can't give a good explanation at all. In the years when I wasn't paying attention to U2, I knew this song and loved it. I love the cadence, I love the mood, I love how weird it is. My absolute favorite part is each time that off-kilter organ that sounds circus-y yet slightly menacing comes in. Bono sounds off-kilter, too, in his falsetto. It's so bizarre and just a hugely fun song to me.
ETA: Also, don't ever think you can't criticize a song others love. I love to read all the comments, good and bad. It's nothing personal! It's nice to have a diversity of opinions.