EBF
QB Ben Roethlisberger Steelers (PIT) - $15
QB Philip Rivers Chargers (SDG) - $8
RB Clinton Portis Redskins (WAS) - $45
RB Willie Parker Steelers (PIT) - $15
RB Rashard Mendenhall Steelers (PIT) - $8
RB Julius Jones Seahawks (SEA) - $12
RB Jonathan Stewart Panthers (CAR) - $10
WR Chris Chambers Chargers (SDG) - $14
WR Santana Moss Redskins (WAS) - $14
WR Isaac Bruce 49ers (SFO) - $9
WR Sidney Rice Vikings (MIN) - $9
WR Laurent Robinson Falcons (ATL) - $5
WR Ted Ginn Jr. Dolphins (MIA) - $5
WR Brandon Stokley Broncos (DEN) - $4
WR Mark Clayton Ravens (BAL) - $3
TE Tony Scheffler Broncos (DEN) - $4
TE Marcedes Lewis Jaguars (JAC) - $4
TE Zach Miller Raiders (OAK) - $2
K Jeff Reed Steelers (PIT) - $1
K Rian Lindell Bills (BUF) - $2
DEF Houston Texans Texans (HOU) - $2
DEF San Francisco 49ers 49ers (SFO) - $1
I've played a few of these best ball auctions by now, so I think I have a pretty good feel for how to build a team in this format. My basic strategy is to get elite players at positions where elite scorers are scarce and to save money at positions where elite scorers are common. That usually translates to spending a lot at RB/TE and saving a lot at WR. This time around things went a little differently. I didn't like the price people were paying for players and I wanted to wait for good values. I'm cautiously optimistic about the results. QB - I don't believe in paying top dollar for Manning or Brady in a best buy auction. Those guys are great, but lots of QBs are capable of big games. My strategy is usually to get one solid top 6-8 QB and one respectable backup with good job security. I think I accomplished that here. Roethlisberger is a steady scorer with big game potential. Rivers is a solid backup FF QB.
RB - I had a long list of RBs I would have been happy with. Most of those guys went for more than I wanted to spend. At some point you have to spend some cash to get a player though, so I stepped up and got Portis for $45. I'm not wild about it considering that someone like Reggie Bush went for $43, but Portis is a relatively safe bet to give me middle of the road RB1 production. I would've like to have paired him with another top back like Westbrook or Lynch, but I decided I didn't want to spend another $45-55 for my second back. Depth is hugely important in best ball leagues. You need to give yourself several viable scoring options to cover your starting positions in case one of your top dogs has a bad week. So rather than spend $45 on Marshawn Lynch, I took that same amount of money and bought Willie Parker, Rashard Mendenhall, Julius Jones, and Jonathan Stewart. I wouldn't be comfortable with any of these guys as my RB2 in a league where you're required to name a starter each week, but I think they make a pretty competitive group in a best ball format. I've guaranteed myself the starting Steelers RB between Parker and Mendenhall. I think Jones is probably the best back in Seattle and I think Stewart is capable of producing immediately. Between my five backs I think I'll get two solid scores more often than not.
WR - I don't buy top 20 WRs in best ball auctions. Period. There's no reason to pay $30-35 for a WR when there are 65+ WRs capable of posting 80 yards and a score every week. What I do in a league like this is build a deep core of cheap guys who should catch a few passes every week. Moss, Chambers, and Bruce are the best WRs on their teams. Clayton, Rice, and Robinson are underrated starters with breakout potential. Even if none of them improve on last year's numbers, they all should be useful for a game or two. Ginn is a big play threat with big game potential. Stokley is a boring veteran who should catch a few passes each week. The basic theme here is quantity over quality. I did very well in this league last year without spending more than $7 for most of my WRs.
TE - I wanted to get someone like Todd Heap or Chris Cooley, but they went off the board a bit early and I wasn't ready to spend the big cash for a TE just yet. Scheffler for $4 was a decent consolation prize. Lewis and Miller are good backup options. I would've liked Crumpler as my backup, but he surprisingly generated a minor bidding war when he was nominated late in the going.
PK - Two veteran kickers with good job security.
DEF - Two defenses.
OVERALL - Not my best work, but it could be competitive. I like a lot of the players I got and I did well to avoid reckless spending. Depth is hugely important in this format, so I like the fact that every player on my team has a realistic chance of contributing in a given week. My only real concern is a lack of true star power. Portis is a solid RB1, but he's not a difference maker in PPR. Roethlisberger is probably the only other player on my roster who might qualify as a stud. Everyone else is sort of ho-hum. I might need someone like Stewart, Rice, Robinson, or Ginn to go bonkers if I'm going to rise above mediocrity. If I could go back and do things over then I might consider paying the necessary premium to pair Portis with Westbrook and then buying two cheap backups like F. Taylor and L. White. I would also have paid the $8-10 needed to get Heap since I finished with $8 extra at the end of the auction.
It will take some lucky breaks to win, but I think I have a fair shot to finish in the top 4 and advance to the next round. I haven't looked at the other rosters yet, so I don't have anything to compare my squad to.