The Z Machine
Footballguy
I put the odds of a foreign coach getting this gig at near zero. Klinsmann was not a success and I think USSF has a bad taste from that still.
I put the odds of a foreign coach getting this gig at near zero. Klinsmann was not a success and I think USSF has a bad taste from that still.
1. JK, while abrasive and obstinate, did get the program moving in the right direction. Looking at it now, I think he also accidentally illustrated to us all a subtle obstacle American players will have to overcome...I put the odds of a foreign coach getting this gig at near zero. Klinsmann was not a success and I think USSF has a bad taste from that still.
The JK era ended badly but it is hard to say the 2014 cycle was a failure.
FWIW, no one who will be making the coaching decision now was involved in US Soccer during the Klinsmann era.
I put the odds of a foreign coach getting this gig at near zero. Klinsmann was not a success and I think USSF has a bad taste from that still.
The JK era ended badly but it is hard to say the 2014 cycle was a failure.
FWIW, no one who will be making the coaching decision now was involved in US Soccer during the Klinsmann era.
If they go with someone 'domestic', it will mean that MLS players, regardless of merit, will always have a place on the roster.
If they go with someone 'domestic', it will mean that MLS players, regardless of merit, will always have a place on the roster.
I agree with most of your comments but don’t understand this assumption. Fans often think coaches play favorites and maybe there’s some of that going on but I refuse to believe a coach at this level would make any decision based on anything other than putting out the best team possible.


I think the lack of playing with anything resembling a goal scoring striker has probably kept assists lower than they should be
================================
Tutul Rahman
@tutulismyname
USMNT Players with 30+ Goals & Assists (g+a/cap)
1) Donovan - 115 (0.73)
2) Dempsey - 78 (0.55)
3) Jozy - 56 (0.49)
4) Wynalda - 50 (0.47)
5) McBride - 40 (0.42)
6) Bradley - 40 (0.26)
7) JMM - 38 (0.38)
8) Cobi - 37 (0.23)
9) Pulisic - 34 (0.61)
10) Beasley - 30 (0.24)
Just opinion on my part, which is woefully incomplete at times. This time around, though, Jordan Morris is the player I was thinking of. He was brought for his physicality and familiarity to the program. Granted we're just a bunch of armchair coaches, but the points about his lack of foot speed and doubts about his current skillset working well against international players were obvious beforehand and on display when he did get on the field.If they go with someone 'domestic', it will mean that MLS players, regardless of merit, will always have a place on the roster.
I agree with most of your comments but don’t understand this assumption. Fans often think coaches play favorites and maybe there’s some of that going on but I refuse to believe a coach at this level would make any decision based on anything other than putting out the best team possible.
Just opinion on my part, which is woefully incomplete at times. This time around, though, Jordan Morris is the player I was thinking of. He was brought for his physicality and familiarity to the program. Granted we're just a bunch of armchair coaches, but the points about his lack of foot speed and doubts about his current skillset working well against international players were obvious beforehand and on display when he did get on the field.If they go with someone 'domestic', it will mean that MLS players, regardless of merit, will always have a place on the roster.
I agree with most of your comments but don’t understand this assumption. Fans often think coaches play favorites and maybe there’s some of that going on but I refuse to believe a coach at this level would make any decision based on anything other than putting out the best team possible.
Fair enough and you're probably right.
I don't agree with either the Morris or the Haji selection but I also don't think that playing in MLS or Turkey had anything to do with the selections.
I believe he played with England in this Football Federations Cup last month after being in the US camp.I believe he is a dual nat, English and Yank
==============================
https://twitter.com/NYCFCSOURCE
nycfc.source
@NYCFCSOURCE
#ManCity are ready to sign New York City FC left back Christian McFarlane (15).
How does the guy not want to come play with us?For what little it is worth, the twitter stalkers say Balogun has spent a good part of the WC posting pro US team stuff on his social media.
Man, I haven't even been following lately since he made his move to Ligue 1. For Stade Reims, he's their leading goal scorer and he already has 8 goals and 2 assists in 15 appearances, including scores in 5 of his last 6 games.For what little it is worth, the twitter stalkers say Balogun has spent a good part of the WC posting pro US team stuff on his social media.
I put the odds of a foreign coach getting this gig at near zero. Klinsmann was not a success and I think USSF has a bad taste from that still.
The JK era ended badly but it is hard to say the 2014 cycle was a failure.
FWIW, no one who will be making the coaching decision now was involved in US Soccer during the Klinsmann era.
English media acting as if he’s all but a Liverpool player already.Jesus, Dortmund is going to do it again. Bellingham is going to be sold for a crap ton.
Dortmund has to hold some sort of transfer record after Dembele, Pulisic, Auba, Haaland and Sancho.
I watched some more pieces of games this weekend and I’m convinced the wingers realized at some point that they needed to get inside more and be more direct which made that 9 role even more invisible. I made allusion to it earlier, but that match in particular was screaming for a 3-5-2 as at least then the man marking becomes more difficult (their back three then has an extra wasted man) and you’ve created width to combat the cutback. I’m convinced they knew they could suck in Dest and Jedi, force them to sprint back 70 yards and wait for the eventual slack defensive play which we already know they have the propensity for. Great coaches exploit your weaknesses and that’s exactly what LvG did. He also correctly guessed MMA hadn’t seen man marking as a group and how to free each other up. They’re good at direct passes and using their athleticism to create the space individually, but not proficient at creating that space with their movement as a unit.I'm probably the biggest Haji fanboy in here- as I've mentioned from the u15s and even watching some of his Turkey games. really thought he provided the right combo of things- not exactly hold up play typical target 9 guy, but good at running the channels, showing and winning balls with his long frame (not holding the ball) to find combinations with runners, and most importantly- scoring goals of all kinds: headed crosses, hitting goals with both feet from crosses, hitting goals from outside the box on shots. what I've seen is what I've want to see from a 9 for hte US.
But wow- he was abjectly terrible in Qatar. and did even worse than none of those things... felt like he clogged space and was a black hole on the ball, and then couldn't make the right decision ever- and lacked touch (to put it nicely). from the outside, looked like he played scared of the moment.
.
I’m sort of over it, but it’s also evident that even the best MLS coach (save prime -Arena) isn’t truly up to second order tactics. us.
Every coach, like every player is an individual. The league they play or coach in will never define whether they are good or bad as a broad stroke imo.
Every coach, like every player is an individual. The league they play or coach in will never define whether they are good or bad as a broad stroke imo.
although I think it's safe to say that GGG's propensity to favor MLS players over international players in more highly regarded leagues was a noticeable detriment to the team this past cycle.
I saw your post on this before and I think it would have been an interesting idea.but that match in particular was screaming for a 3-5-2 as at least then the man marking becomes more difficult (their back three then has an extra wasted man) and you’ve created width to combat the cutback.
Oh come on. He got this team to a World Cup and advanced with a mixed team of MLS and international, with a team that was never fully healthy and together through qualifying and made it through.Every coach, like every player is an individual. The league they play or coach in will never define whether they are good or bad as a broad stroke imo.
although I think it's safe to say that GGG's propensity to favor MLS players over international players in more highly regarded leagues was a noticeable detriment to the team this past cycle.
I'm probably the biggest Haji fanboy in here- as I've mentioned from the u15s and even watching some of his Turkey games. really thought he provided the right combo of things- not exactly hold up play typical target 9 guy, but good at running the channels, showing and winning balls with his long frame (not holding the ball) to find combinations with runners, and most importantly- scoring goals of all kinds: headed crosses, hitting goals with both feet from crosses, hitting goals from outside the box on shots. what I've seen is what I've want to see from a 9 for hte US.
But wow- he was abjectly terrible in Qatar. and did even worse than none of those things... felt like he clogged space and was a black hole on the ball, and then couldn't make the right decision ever- and lacked touch (to put it nicely). from the outside, looked like he played scared of the moment.
both can be trueEvery coach, like every player is an individual. The league they play or coach in will never define whether they are good or bad as a broad stroke imo.
although I think it's safe to say that GGG's propensity to favor MLS players over international players in more highly regarded leagues was a noticeable detriment to the team this past cycle.
We likely don't even qualify with out Turner, Zimm, Pepi, Miles and others.
Oh come on. He got this team to a World Cup and advanced with a mixed team of MLS and international, with a team that was never fully healthy and together through qualifying and made it through.Every coach, like every player is an individual. The league they play or coach in will never define whether they are good or bad as a broad stroke imo.
although I think it's safe to say that GGG's propensity to favor MLS players over international players in more highly regarded leagues was a noticeable detriment to the team this past cycle.
He took a fractured program and brought them together and made huge strides for our team. To me any grief he is getting is undeserved at this point. He did everything that was asked of him and more.
Is he going to match up tactically with more experienced managers? Of course not. But he has gotten them to a place where he is definitely leaving the program better than what he inherited. If he indeed moves on.
Yes, agree.Oh come on. He got this team to a World Cup and advanced with a mixed team of MLS and international, with a team that was never fully healthy and together through qualifying and made it through.Every coach, like every player is an individual. The league they play or coach in will never define whether they are good or bad as a broad stroke imo.
although I think it's safe to say that GGG's propensity to favor MLS players over international players in more highly regarded leagues was a noticeable detriment to the team this past cycle.
He took a fractured program and brought them together and made huge strides for our team. To me any grief he is getting is undeserved at this point. He did everything that was asked of him and more.
Is he going to match up tactically with more experienced managers? Of course not. But he has gotten them to a place where he is definitely leaving the program better than what he inherited. If he indeed moves on.
I agree. My larger point is we can do better. Thanks for your service Greg, but it's time we upgrade.
I think that's right as Reyna was showing for the ball on both the right and left sides. So I do think that was GGG's intent (and also the reason Reyna wasn't playing as it breaks the defensive setup), and I think it was somewhat effective change since he's the best guy on our team playing to and creating space (off topic: there was this comment in the England match that Henderson is so popular with his teammates because he recognizes what's happening and will make 30 yard runs to simply get out of the way) and it seemed to open some space around the box.I saw your post on this before and I think it would have been an interesting idea.but that match in particular was screaming for a 3-5-2 as at least then the man marking becomes more difficult (their back three then has an extra wasted man) and you’ve created width to combat the cutback.
I really wanted Gio to come in and play as a 10 as one area that MMA struggles is showing for the ball and they were allowing themselves to be marked out of the game. Gio excels at finding the ball when given free reign and his movement eliminates the man-marking problem. But I noticed with as high as he was playing, VVD was marking him a lot.
That's not ideal but that opens up Reyna coming deep and pulling VVD out, freeing space for Pulisic or Weah (or Aaronson if we'd have put him out wide) who should then push higher allowing them to attack the wide centerbacks without cover. Well executed we'd be pinging balls into Gio who could then either turn or lay it off to McKennie/Musah driving forward with a wide forward to unleash. That's not really MM's forte but I think it would have worked.
This may have been what Berhalter intended but it looked like a confusing mess with players on top of each other and Gio really didn't find himself until we took out Weah. I think that may come down to a lack of prep for that sort of tactical shift as we've never really played in between the lines like that. Our patterns of play tend to all be to focused on getting around the sides (which is why we cross so much).
It was that I haven't seen anyone (save maybe Schmetzer) that seems really tactically flexible. Even someone like Cushing is a big step down tactically from Delia. I'm on the West Coast now so see mostly west coast MLS and the NYCFC matches, so maybe that isn't true of some of the Midwest/Southern teams who I don't see a lot of, but I sort of doubt it..
I’m sort of over it, but it’s also evident that even the best MLS coach (save prime -Arena) isn’t truly up to second order tactics. us.
GGG being bad tactically really should not cause all MLS coaches to be painted with the same brush just as JK's, often severe, limitations should in no way cause us to think all foreign coaches are like that.
Every coach, like every player is an individual. The league they play or coach in will never define whether they are good or bad as a broad stroke imo.
Strange...He doesn't have to make a decision soon. Will be plenty of time before WCQ to see if he can push his way into competition for the england side or not.