Vick dynasty value? (1 Viewer)

[Tornacl]

For those of us that play in dynasty leagues, what is your opinion of Michael Vick's value? If you're buying what would you be willing to give up, and if you're selling what would it take to part with him?

I'm selling, because I don't think that he can keep it up and because if there's a contending team that needs a QB, Vick will be near the top of the list. At this point, I would only part with him for a 1st round pick + a QB2. If the pick were to be likely a high 1st rounder, I would take that, but a team in that situation isn't likely to want him.

 

[Tornacl]

shameless bump.

 

[SSOG]

It really depends on what the offers are, to be honest. I'll sell anyone for the right price. As a Vick dynasty owner (took him in the last round of a startup this year ), I'm in no hurry to sell him. I think he's a legit top QB this year and for a couple more years to come.

 

[thatguy]

This should really be broken up into two polls. A buyer can't very well hold him, can he?

One poll for owners--hold or sell--and one for non-owners--buy or avoid.

 

[thatguy]

As to the question, as a Vick dynasty owner, I am holding. However, I am really in no position to sell, as I came into the season with Ryan as my starting QB, and Carson, Freeman, and Bradford backing him up. While I like Ryan, this is a 10 team league, so he's a below average starter. Vick, assuming he continues to play well, will push my already stacked team to new levels.

So, in dynasty, for teams in win now mode, I probably wouldn't sell him unless I had Peyton, Brees or Rodgers. If I had that luxury, I would consider dealing him, but the offer would have to be very enticing.

If I had not been lucky enough to snag Vick off of waivers after week 1 in this league, I would absolutely be buying.