Playing Tiger Woods 12 now (Xbox 360). Not all that far into it, but here are some first impressions:
- They nail Augusta - it looks great. But they also nail the attitude of it, for better or worse (see further below)
- The caddy is cool, but over 18 holes, a little time consuming. A round is about 30% longer. You can turn him off, but his recommendations are still there, etc. Personally, I don't mind the caddy, and think it's a great addition, despite taking more time to play a round.
- Gameplay is prettymuch unchanged. I'm two years removed from a Tiger Woods game, and I jumped right in without any issue.
- They took out a lot of the "sillier" stuff. Bunny suits, crowds shouting out your nickname, and baseball swing celebrations? Errr no... not at Augusta, thank you very much. They (seemingly) even got rid of the "big swing" animations. It's pretty clear the club had some say in this aspect of the game. Even the somewhat cool electronica-lite music of past versions is replaced with a very staid choice of tunes, all of which would fit a real Masters telecast going to commercial break. Basically, if older versions had a loose "Pro-am" vibe, this one is all button down and corporate. I'm kind of surprised they even allowed jeans, flip-flops, and basketball-style shorts in wardrobe choices (but that's about as subversive as it gets.)
I like the game so far, but I do wish they kept a few of the sillier aspects, even if just custom celebrations and the nickname. It just adds a little life to the game. But if anyone didn't like the silly stuff and wanted more of a sim in terms of personality, this is your game.