The people who think Young is a good QB because his TEAM won 2/3rds of those games are probably the same people who thought Trent Dilfer was a good QB.
Dont' flip-flop the argument. People have said that he 'stinks' and that is merely one of the many pieces of evidence that he doesn't along with the 98.6 passer rating, 10/3 TD/INT ratio, 60% completion percentage, 8.0 yards per attempt, and the 5.0 yards per rush. The Titans were 4-12 before he got there and they went 8-8 the subsequent year, they were 0-6 last year with Collins and 8-2 with Young. He stunk his 2nd year, but the last couple of year's he's been quite solid and repeatedly gets benched for it. Anyway, there isn't much in the way of free agent QBs this year, Fisher will get his wish of relying on Kerry Collins unchallenged for 2011.
What is this, fun with numbers? He's has a lifetime QB rating of 75, 54 TD to 54 Turnovers, and a career completion percentage of 57%. 'HE' didn't win but a handful of games himself, his 'TEAM' won 2/3rds of the games he played with a great RB, nice offensive line, and a solid defense. He has been mediocre at best. You don't get paid the money he is getting paid for mediocre and then throw in his lack of work ethic, off field issues, and possible coaching issues. He might not be the worst QB in the league, but they could certainly do better for that amount of money and off field headaches. Bud Adams loves him because Adams is a middle finger waving lunatic who thinks he is sticking it to the state of Texas by having Young in Tennessee. The problem is everyone outside of Austin doesn't care about Young anymore. Vodka Collins and some scrub rookie aren't the answer obviously, but if Young did the things they said he did(and I'm not saying he did), then the coach not doing something about it will lose his team. Fisher made the right decision. Young isn't Favre, and Chilly kissing Favre's ### is costing him his job.