wannabee Strategy Thread (3 Viewers)

[grtwhtsk]

Hi Jeff,

12 team PPR (IDP) Dynasty League with the following offensive scoring: Rushing and Rec YDS 1 pt. every 10, Rushing and Rec TDs are 6 pts, 2pt conversions are 2 pts, Receptions 1 pt for each, Fumbles -3, PR & KR Yds are 1 every 30 yds, PR & KR Tds are 6 pts. We start 2 RB, 3 WR.

Of my current roster, here are my RBs: A. Peterson (MN), S. Slaton, D. Ware, R. Mendenhall. My WR are: Desean Jackson, K. Burton, E. Bennett, Josh Morgan, Devin Thomas, and Malcom Kelly. My TE is Z. Miller.

I was offered the following deal, and would appreciate your input:

I give pick 1.01 and get picks 1.06 and 2.06. I currently have picks 1.01, 1.03, 1.05, and 1.11 in the first, and 2.01 and 2.12 in the second.

Thanks,

Steve

 

[Jeff Tefertiller]

Hi Jeff,12 team PPR (IDP) Dynasty League with the following offensive scoring: Rushing and Rec YDS 1 pt. every 10, Rushing and Rec TDs are 6 pts, 2pt conversions are 2 pts, Receptions 1 pt for each, Fumbles -3, PR & KR Yds are 1 every 30 yds, PR & KR Tds are 6 pts. We start 2 RB, 3 WR.Of my current roster, here are my RBs: A. Peterson (MN), S. Slaton, D. Ware, R. Mendenhall. My WR are: Desean Jackson, K. Burton, E. Bennett, Josh Morgan, Devin Thomas, and Malcom Kelly. My TE is Z. Miller.I was offered the following deal, and would appreciate your input:I give pick 1.01 and get picks 1.06 and 2.06. I currently have picks 1.01, 1.03, 1.05, and 1.11 in the first, and 2.01 and 2.12 in the second.Thanks,Steve

The 1.01 is worth a lot more than 1.06 and 2.06. I really do not think it is remotely close.

 

[Packers4ever]

8 player keeper league( next year we will be able to keep 10 players) Stardard scoring no PPR Starters 1QB, 2RB's, 3WR's, 1TE, 1 Flex(RB, WR, TE)

My Team

QB’s J. Culter

RB's S. Jackson, J. Addai, R. Brown, J. Stewart,

WR's R. Moss, G. Jennings, B. Marshall,

TE's C. Cooley,

1.05 & 3.05

Would you trade Addai for 1.10. This team also has the 1.2 & 1.4 and said he would not trade either one since he wants to draft 2 of Wells, Brown or Greene.

Or do I just keep Addai and draft whichever one is leftover or maybe Crabtree will fall to me.

 

[Jeff Tefertiller]

8 player keeper league( next year we will be able to keep 10 players) Stardard scoring no PPR Starters 1QB, 2RB's, 3WR's, 1TE, 1 Flex(RB, WR, TE)My TeamQB’s J. CulterRB's S. Jackson, J. Addai, R. Brown, J. Stewart, WR's R. Moss, G. Jennings, B. Marshall, TE's C. Cooley, 1.05 & 3.05Would you trade Addai for 1.10. This team also has the 1.2 & 1.4 and said he would not trade either one since he wants to draft 2 of Wells, Brown or Greene.Or do I just keep Addai and draft whichever one is leftover or maybe Crabtree will fall to me.

Addai is worth more than the 1.10, imo, quite a bit more.

 

[Packers4ever]

8 player keeper league( next year we will be able to keep 10 players) Stardard scoring no PPR Starters 1QB, 2RB's, 3WR's, 1TE, 1 Flex(RB, WR, TE)My TeamQB’s J. CulterRB's S. Jackson, J. Addai, R. Brown, J. Stewart, WR's R. Moss, G. Jennings, B. Marshall, TE's C. Cooley, 1.05 & 3.05Would you trade Addai for 1.10. This team also has the 1.2 & 1.4 and said he would not trade either one since he wants to draft 2 of Wells, Brown or Greene.Or do I just keep Addai and draft whichever one is leftover or maybe Crabtree will fall to me.

Addai is worth more than the 1.10, imo, quite a bit more.

So who would you pick at 1.05 of these players.Hicks, McCoy, Greene, or Harvin.

 

[Jeff Tefertiller]

8 player keeper league( next year we will be able to keep 10 players) Stardard scoring no PPR Starters 1QB, 2RB's, 3WR's, 1TE, 1 Flex(RB, WR, TE)My TeamQB’s J. CulterRB's S. Jackson, J. Addai, R. Brown, J. Stewart, WR's R. Moss, G. Jennings, B. Marshall, TE's C. Cooley, 1.05 & 3.05Would you trade Addai for 1.10. This team also has the 1.2 & 1.4 and said he would not trade either one since he wants to draft 2 of Wells, Brown or Greene.Or do I just keep Addai and draft whichever one is leftover or maybe Crabtree will fall to me.

Addai is worth more than the 1.10, imo, quite a bit more.

So who would you pick at 1.05 of these players.Hicks, McCoy, Greene, or Harvin.

Greene or McCoy ... I LOVE Nicks' future, but RBs are harder to come by in non-PPR.

 

[Packers4ever]

8 player keeper league( next year we will be able to keep 10 players) Stardard scoring no PPR Starters 1QB, 2RB's, 3WR's, 1TE, 1 Flex(RB, WR, TE)My TeamQB’s J. CulterRB's S. Jackson, J. Addai, R. Brown, J. Stewart, WR's R. Moss, G. Jennings, B. Marshall, TE's C. Cooley, 1.05 & 3.05Would you trade Addai for 1.10. This team also has the 1.2 & 1.4 and said he would not trade either one since he wants to draft 2 of Wells, Brown or Greene.Or do I just keep Addai and draft whichever one is leftover or maybe Crabtree will fall to me.

Addai is worth more than the 1.10, imo, quite a bit more.

So who would you pick at 1.05 of these players.Hicks, McCoy, Greene, or Harvin.

Greene or McCoy ... I LOVE Nicks' future, but RBs are harder to come by in non-PPR.

If Crabtree is still there would you take him over either Greene or McCoy. Looking over the other 2 teams ahead of me in the draft it looks like they would be drafting RB's & I know the other owner with the 1.2 & 1.4 is going to pick 2 of either Wells, Brown or Greene so Crabtree might be there at 1.5.

 

[Jeff Tefertiller]

Yes, I would consider Crabtree. He should be a very good receiver. I think I would take him over McCoy and Greene.

 

[Jeff Tefertiller]

Hey everyone, I am on twitter in case uses it. I primarily use it for NFL news and remarking on news stories that come out. Also, feel free to "steal" those I am following. I keep adjusting who I follow to get all of the NFL news/updates with the fewest duplicates.

http://twitter.com/JeffTefertiller

 

[Packers4ever]

I am currently drafting in a league and I have already drafted M. Turner & R. White would you draft M. Ryan and T. Gonzalez if you already had these 2 players from Atl. I also have K. Moreno as my other back.

Starters are 1 QB, 1 RB, 1 WR, 1 TE, 2 Flex(WR or RB), 1 K, 1 Def

14 teams standard scoring with no PPR and QB's get 6 points/TD

If you would not draft these two players what 2 player would you draft between the players below.

Chris Wells

B. Edwards

W. Welker

D. Clark

TJ

LJ

C. Benson

Big Ben

DeSean Jackson

L. White

 

[Jeff Tefertiller]

I am currently drafting in a league and I have already drafted M. Turner & R. White would you draft M. Ryan and T. Gonzalez if you already had these 2 players from Atl. I also have K. Moreno as my other back.Starters are 1 QB, 1 RB, 1 WR, 1 TE, 2 Flex(WR or RB), 1 K, 1 Def14 teams standard scoring with no PPR and QB's get 6 points/TDIf you would not draft these two players what 2 player would you draft between the players below.Chris WellsB. EdwardsW. WelkerD. ClarkTJLJC. BensonBig BenDeSean JacksonL. White

Is this a keeper or dynasty? I would look at QB and take the one you have the highest. On the other pick, I think I might go RB. The ability to start three RBs in a 14 teamer is huge. I would take the RB you think will score the best. I would say Wells or Jones. But, I would try to get a handcuff.

 

[Packers4ever]

I am currently drafting in a league and I have already drafted M. Turner & R. White would you draft M. Ryan and T. Gonzalez if you already had these 2 players from Atl. I also have K. Moreno as my other back.Starters are 1 QB, 1 RB, 1 WR, 1 TE, 2 Flex(WR or RB), 1 K, 1 Def14 teams standard scoring with no PPR and QB's get 6 points/TDIf you would not draft these two players what 2 player would you draft between the players below.Chris WellsB. EdwardsW. WelkerD. ClarkTJLJC. BensonBig BenDeSean JacksonL. White

Is this a keeper or dynasty? I would look at QB and take the one you have the highest. On the other pick, I think I might go RB. The ability to start three RBs in a 14 teamer is huge. I would take the RB you think will score the best. I would say Wells or Jones. But, I would try to get a handcuff.

Sorry forgot what type league it is a Redraft.

 

[Jeff Tefertiller]

I am currently drafting in a league and I have already drafted M. Turner & R. White would you draft M. Ryan and T. Gonzalez if you already had these 2 players from Atl. I also have K. Moreno as my other back.Starters are 1 QB, 1 RB, 1 WR, 1 TE, 2 Flex(WR or RB), 1 K, 1 Def14 teams standard scoring with no PPR and QB's get 6 points/TDIf you would not draft these two players what 2 player would you draft between the players below.Chris WellsB. EdwardsW. WelkerD. ClarkTJLJC. BensonBig BenDeSean JacksonL. White

Is this a keeper or dynasty? I would look at QB and take the one you have the highest. On the other pick, I think I might go RB. The ability to start three RBs in a 14 teamer is huge. I would take the RB you think will score the best. I would say Wells or Jones. But, I would try to get a handcuff.

Sorry forgot what type league it is a Redraft.

no problem ... I think Ryan is overrated for 09. What QBs are gone? To be honest, I would be tempted to go RB/RB if no QBs I liked.

 

[Packers4ever]

I am currently drafting in a league and I have already drafted M. Turner & R. White would you draft M. Ryan and T. Gonzalez if you already had these 2 players from Atl. I also have K. Moreno as my other back.Starters are 1 QB, 1 RB, 1 WR, 1 TE, 2 Flex(WR or RB), 1 K, 1 Def14 teams standard scoring with no PPR and QB's get 6 points/TDIf you would not draft these two players what 2 player would you draft between the players below.Chris WellsB. EdwardsW. WelkerD. ClarkTJLJC. BensonBig BenDeSean JacksonL. White

Is this a keeper or dynasty? I would look at QB and take the one you have the highest. On the other pick, I think I might go RB. The ability to start three RBs in a 14 teamer is huge. I would take the RB you think will score the best. I would say Wells or Jones. But, I would try to get a handcuff.

Sorry forgot what type league it is a Redraft.

no problem ... I think Ryan is overrated for 09. What QBs are gone? To be honest, I would be tempted to go RB/RB if no QBs I liked.

Here are the current QB's.Palmer, Ryan, Schaub, Big Ben, E. Manning, Garrard, & Cassel.I think I will just go Wells and Jones and then the next 2 picks go for either WR/QB or QB/QB since there are already 9 teams with QB's 1 or 2 of these should still be there with my next picks unless you think one is to good to pass up at this point.

 

[Jeff Tefertiller]

I am currently drafting in a league and I have already drafted M. Turner & R. White would you draft M. Ryan and T. Gonzalez if you already had these 2 players from Atl. I also have K. Moreno as my other back.Starters are 1 QB, 1 RB, 1 WR, 1 TE, 2 Flex(WR or RB), 1 K, 1 Def14 teams standard scoring with no PPR and QB's get 6 points/TDIf you would not draft these two players what 2 player would you draft between the players below.Chris WellsB. EdwardsW. WelkerD. ClarkTJLJC. BensonBig BenDeSean JacksonL. White

Is this a keeper or dynasty? I would look at QB and take the one you have the highest. On the other pick, I think I might go RB. The ability to start three RBs in a 14 teamer is huge. I would take the RB you think will score the best. I would say Wells or Jones. But, I would try to get a handcuff.

Sorry forgot what type league it is a Redraft.

no problem ... I think Ryan is overrated for 09. What QBs are gone? To be honest, I would be tempted to go RB/RB if no QBs I liked.

Here are the current QB's.Palmer, Ryan, Schaub, Big Ben, E. Manning, Garrard, & Cassel.I think I will just go Wells and Jones and then the next 2 picks go for either WR/QB or QB/QB since there are already 9 teams with QB's 1 or 2 of these should still be there with my next picks unless you think one is to good to pass up at this point.

I would go RB/RB with Palmer or Schaub next time around

 

[Packers4ever]

10 team dynasty league standard Scoring and no PPR starter 1 QB, 2RB's, 3 WR's, 1TE

My team

QB’s D. McNabb, C. Pennington, C. Henne,

RB’s M. Barber, M. Forte, A. Foster, A. Bradshaw, L. White, J. Norwood, C. Brown,

WR’s B. Edwards, R. Wayne, J. Cotchery, P. Burress, D. Branch, N. Washington, J. Galloway, D. Thomas, Mike Thomas

TE’s T. Heap, D. Lee, LJ. Smith, S. Nelson

K’s D. Akers,

DEF Baltimore, San Diego

Just turned down McNabb, R. Wayne for P. Rivers, L. Evans, T. Ginn & 2010 2nd round pick.

What do you think of this counter McNabb, R. Wayne for P. Rivers, G. Jennings, T. Ginn and 2010 2 round pick would that be too much if so would it be better if I drop off Ginn or the 2nd round pick

 

[Jeff Tefertiller]

10 team dynasty league standard Scoring and no PPR starter 1 QB, 2RB's, 3 WR's, 1TEMy teamQB’s D. McNabb, C. Pennington, C. Henne,RB’s M. Barber, M. Forte, A. Foster, A. Bradshaw, L. White, J. Norwood, C. Brown, WR’s B. Edwards, R. Wayne, J. Cotchery, P. Burress, D. Branch, N. Washington, J. Galloway, D. Thomas, Mike ThomasTE’s T. Heap, D. Lee, LJ. Smith, S. NelsonK’s D. Akers, DEF Baltimore, San DiegoJust turned down McNabb, R. Wayne for P. Rivers, L. Evans, T. Ginn & 2010 2nd round pick.What do you think of this counter McNabb, R. Wayne for P. Rivers, G. Jennings, T. Ginn and 2010 2 round pick would that be too much if so would it be better if I drop off Ginn or the 2nd round pick

I do not like the offer to you at all. But, I think you are asking too much on the flip side. Most have both QBs and both WRs (Wayne and Jennings) very close. I would not move either McNabb or Wayne unless I got a stud at the position back. Evans, Ginn, and a 2nd do not qualify.

 

[Packers4ever]

8 player keeper league( next year we will be able to keep 10 players) Stardard scoring no PPR Starters 1QB, 2RB's, 3WR's, 1TE, 1 Flex(RB, WR, TE)

My Team

QB’s J. Culter

RB's S. Jackson, J. Addai, R. Brown, J. Stewart,

WR's R. Moss, G. Jennings, B. Marshall,

TE's C. Cooley,

1.05 & 3.05

Would you trade R. Brown for K. Smith the team that has him has been offering me many trades for Brown but has never put K. Smith in the deal do not even know if I would do it for K. Smith. What do you think.

 

[Jeff Tefertiller]

8 player keeper league( next year we will be able to keep 10 players) Stardard scoring no PPR Starters 1QB, 2RB's, 3WR's, 1TE, 1 Flex(RB, WR, TE)My TeamQB’s J. CulterRB's S. Jackson, J. Addai, R. Brown, J. Stewart, WR's R. Moss, G. Jennings, B. Marshall, TE's C. Cooley, 1.05 & 3.05Would you trade R. Brown for K. Smith the team that has him has been offering me many trades for Brown but has never put K. Smith in the deal do not even know if I would do it for K. Smith. What do you think.

Brown is worth a lot more. I like Smith a lot, but many LOVE Brown. I see him getting a ton of buzz.

 

[Packers4ever]

Alright I went Wells and Edwards so this is my current lineup.

Turner, Moreno, Wells, R. White, B. Edwards.

4 picks before i draft and if no one drafts Winslow in those picks that is my pick.

But for my next pick I need to get a QB since everyone else has one but me.

Who would you pick out of these QB's Garrard, Hasselbeck, E. Manning, Edwards, Cassel, Flacco or would I be better off picking Cotchery, S. Moss, E. Royal, T. Holt or A. Gonzalez.

I know if I do not pick a QB that a few of the ones I have listed will be gone by my next picks that is why I am thinking I need to pick a QB with one of these picks.

Also there is no trading in this league so I could not trade for a QB later what I draft is what I get which is why I think I might be screwed in this league.

Thanks for all your help.

 

[Jeff Tefertiller]

Alright I went Wells and Edwards so this is my current lineup.Turner, Moreno, Wells, R. White, B. Edwards.4 picks before i draft and if no one drafts Winslow in those picks that is my pick. But for my next pick I need to get a QB since everyone else has one but me.Who would you pick out of these QB's Garrard, Hasselbeck, E. Manning, Edwards, Cassel, Flacco or would I be better off picking Cotchery, S. Moss, E. Royal, T. Holt or A. Gonzalez.I know if I do not pick a QB that a few of the ones I have listed will be gone by my next picks that is why I am thinking I need to pick a QB with one of these picks.Also there is no trading in this league so I could not trade for a QB later what I draft is what I get which is why I think I might be screwed in this league.Thanks for all your help.

I would order them:RoyalGarrardCasselCotcheryOrton if thereEliDelhommeI would just try to get Garrard or Cassel, with one of the others listed or Favre, and Leinart late. I like Leinart as a sleeper because I doubt Warner makes it through the season healthy.

 

[Packers4ever]

14 team Dynasty league, Scoring is standard with no PPR starters 1 QB, 1 RB, 1 WR 1 TE 3 Flex(RB, WR, or TE)

My Team

QB's McNabb, J. Garcia, T. Edwards, K Collins

RB's S. Jackson, LJ, C. Benson, Portis, C. Perry, J. Norwood

WR's R. Wayne, D. Bowe, E. Royal, S. Moss, Nate Washington

TE's Jason Witten, T. Heap

Def TEN

Draft picks 1.08, 2.07, 3.07, & 4.07.

I have been offered two different trades from the same team here they are.

1.08 and Royal for 1.06 & 1.10.

J. Morgan or M Austin & 1.10 for 1.08. I don't like this one.

This team has 4 picks out of the first six picks.

I am thinking Crabtree will be there at #1.06 since he is telling me he is drafting Moreno at 1.1, McCoy at 1.3 & Green at 1.04 with the team drafting 1.02 taking either Brown or Wells and the team at 1.05 will take whichever RB is left on the Board since he only has 2 good RB's but has Edwards, R. Moss, Jennings, & R. White as his WR's.

He said that he would be taking Harvin at 1.08 so that would leave me with either taking 1 of the 2 QB's (Stafford, Sanchez) or 1 of either Maclin or Nicks.

So would you take the offer and if you would who would you draft at the 1.10 pick.

 

[Jeff Tefertiller]

14 team Dynasty league, Scoring is standard with no PPR starters 1 QB, 1 RB, 1 WR 1 TE 3 Flex(RB, WR, or TE)My TeamQB's McNabb, J. Garcia, T. Edwards, K CollinsRB's S. Jackson, LJ, C. Benson, Portis, C. Perry, J. NorwoodWR's R. Wayne, D. Bowe, E. Royal, S. Moss, Nate Washington TE's Jason Witten, T. HeapDef TEN Draft picks 1.08, 2.07, 3.07, & 4.07.I have been offered two different trades from the same team here they are.1.08 and Royal for 1.06 & 1.10. J. Morgan or M Austin & 1.10 for 1.08. I don't like this one. This team has 4 picks out of the first six picks.I am thinking Crabtree will be there at #1.06 since he is telling me he is drafting Moreno at 1.1, McCoy at 1.3 & Green at 1.04 with the team drafting 1.02 taking either Brown or Wells and the team at 1.05 will take whichever RB is left on the Board since he only has 2 good RB's but has Edwards, R. Moss, Jennings, & R. White as his WR's.He said that he would be taking Harvin at 1.08 so that would leave me with either taking 1 of the 2 QB's (Stafford, Sanchez) or 1 of either Maclin or Nicks.So would you take the offer and if you would who would you draft at the 1.10 pick.

I would take Royal over Crabtree so there is no way I give up him and a pick. We know that Royal can play. He is worth more than the picks.

 

[Unwrittenlaw]

What do you think I should do with my upcoming draft rookie draft picks?

16 team league

This is what I've done so far:

1.10: Stafford

2.06: DHB

3.10: ??

4.06: ??

5.10:

6.10:

starting lineups:

1 qb

2 rb

3 wr

1 te

2 rb/wr/te

dt

de

dt/de

3 LB

cb

s

cb/s

Leinart, Matt ARI QB - 4

Smith, Troy BAL QB - 7

Warner, Kurt ARI QB - 4

Woodson, Andre' NYG QB - 10

Young, Vince TEN QB - 7

Stafford (1.10)

Maroney, Laurence NEP RB - 8

Peterson, Adrian MIN RB - 9

Thomas, Pierre NOS RB - 5

Williams, DeAngelo CAR RB - 4

Avery, Donnie STL WR - 9

Burress, Plaxico FA WR - -

Burton, Keenan STL WR - 9

Chambers, Chris SDC WR - 5

Holmes, Santonio PIT WR - 8

Morgan, Josh SFO WR - 6

Nelson, Jordy GBP WR - 5

Obomanu, Ben SEA WR - 7

Royal, Eddie DEN WR - 7

DHB (2.06)

Cottam, Brad KCC TE - 8

Daniels, Owen HOU TE - 10

Lewis, Marcedes JAC TE - 7

Brock, Raheem IND DT - 6

Hovan, Chris TBB DT - 8

Robbins, Fred NYG DT (P) - 10

Abiamiri, Victor PHI DE - 4

Anderson, Jamaal ATL DE - 4

Anderson, Mark CHI DE - 5

McCray, Bobby NOS DE - 5

Parker, Juqua PHI DE - 4

Vanden Bosch, Kyle TEN DE - 7

Boley, Michael NYG LB - 10

Dansby, Karlos ARI LB - 4

Durant, Justin JAC LB - 7

Hayes, Geno TBB LB - 8

McIntosh, Roger WAS LB - 8

Nicholas, Stephen ATL LB - 4

Waters, Anthony NOS LB - 5

Hayden, Kelvin IND CB - 6

Lowery, Dwight NYJ CB - 9

Lucas, Ken SEA CB - 7

Springs, Shawn NEP CB - 8

Atogwe, Oshiomogho STL S - 9

Griffin, Michael TEN S - 7

Hope, Chris TEN S - 7

Smith, Eric NYJ S - 9

These are the best rookies available that I am strongly considering for 3.10. We're at 3.08 right now.

Collie

Massaquoi

Coffman

Beckum

Maybin

Sintim

Chung

Moore

Delmas

 

[Packers4ever]

14 team Dynasty league, Scoring is standard with no PPR starters 1 QB, 1 RB, 1 WR 1 TE 3 Flex(RB, WR, or TE)My TeamQB's McNabb, J. Garcia, T. Edwards, K CollinsRB's S. Jackson, LJ, C. Benson, Portis, C. Perry, J. NorwoodWR's R. Wayne, D. Bowe, E. Royal, S. Moss, Nate Washington TE's Jason Witten, T. HeapDef TEN Draft picks 1.08, 2.07, 3.07, & 4.07.I have been offered two different trades from the same team here they are.1.08 and Royal for 1.06 & 1.10. J. Morgan or M Austin & 1.10 for 1.08. I don't like this one. This team has 4 picks out of the first six picks.I am thinking Crabtree will be there at #1.06 since he is telling me he is drafting Moreno at 1.1, McCoy at 1.3 & Green at 1.04 with the team drafting 1.02 taking either Brown or Wells and the team at 1.05 will take whichever RB is left on the Board since he only has 2 good RB's but has Edwards, R. Moss, Jennings, & R. White as his WR's.He said that he would be taking Harvin at 1.08 so that would leave me with either taking 1 of the 2 QB's (Stafford, Sanchez) or 1 of either Maclin or Nicks.So would you take the offer and if you would who would you draft at the 1.10 pick.

I would take Royal over Crabtree so there is no way I give up him and a pick. We know that Royal can play. He is worth more than the picks.

He just sent me another that would be his 1.06 and his 2rd pick next year this should be somewhere in the 6-9 range for my 1.08 and my first next year would you do that. I really do not like giving up picks for the next year since I do not know where I am going to finish I would bet that I would be in the 9-12 pick.

 

[Jeff Tefertiller]

14 team Dynasty league, Scoring is standard with no PPR starters 1 QB, 1 RB, 1 WR 1 TE 3 Flex(RB, WR, or TE)My TeamQB's McNabb, J. Garcia, T. Edwards, K CollinsRB's S. Jackson, LJ, C. Benson, Portis, C. Perry, J. NorwoodWR's R. Wayne, D. Bowe, E. Royal, S. Moss, Nate Washington TE's Jason Witten, T. HeapDef TEN Draft picks 1.08, 2.07, 3.07, & 4.07.I have been offered two different trades from the same team here they are.1.08 and Royal for 1.06 & 1.10. J. Morgan or M Austin & 1.10 for 1.08. I don't like this one. This team has 4 picks out of the first six picks.I am thinking Crabtree will be there at #1.06 since he is telling me he is drafting Moreno at 1.1, McCoy at 1.3 & Green at 1.04 with the team drafting 1.02 taking either Brown or Wells and the team at 1.05 will take whichever RB is left on the Board since he only has 2 good RB's but has Edwards, R. Moss, Jennings, & R. White as his WR's.He said that he would be taking Harvin at 1.08 so that would leave me with either taking 1 of the 2 QB's (Stafford, Sanchez) or 1 of either Maclin or Nicks.So would you take the offer and if you would who would you draft at the 1.10 pick.

I would take Royal over Crabtree so there is no way I give up him and a pick. We know that Royal can play. He is worth more than the picks.

He just sent me another that would be his 1.06 and his 2rd pick next year this should be somewhere in the 6-9 range for my 1.08 and my first next year would you do that. I really do not like giving up picks for the next year since I do not know where I am going to finish I would bet that I would be in the 9-12 pick.

I would pass. That is not worth it

 

[ex-ghost]

Hi Jeff. I've had a few comments on this already, all saying that I should not consider this trade. Curious to see if you agree:

Dynasty: 20 players, non-ppr, 6 pts per TD, 1 per 10 rush/rec, 1 per 25 passing, 12 teams

I am looking to unload J Russell. Don't want him, think he will be a waste of space. The offer, from the other team, on the table, is this:

He gives me:

C Palmer

Barber

2009 2.11

2011 2nd

I give:

J Russell

Leftwich

W Parker

Chambers

2009 1.12

2011 1st

I don't care for Leftwich and Chambers, I view them as throw-ins. He will not budge on the 1st round picks, we have gone round and round and this is where we are. I declined this deal a week ago, but am rethinking it.

My roster:

QB:

Russell

Leftwich

Rothlisberger

A Rodgers

RB:

Parker

D Williams

M Turner

Rice

Bradshaw, A

Duckett, T

Jackson, F

Jones, K

Ware, D

WR:

Arrington, A

Austin, M

Chambers, C

Evans, L

Fitzgerald, L

Hill, J

Holmes, S

Jackson, D

TE:

Gates

 

[Jeff Tefertiller]

With your QBs, I do not see why you need Palmer at this time, especially with only 20 player rosters. I think I would try either Parker and 1.12 for MB3 or Russell and 1.12 for Schaub (if you thought you needed/wanted another QB). The other options would be to package 1.12 and FJax to Lynch owner. I think I would pass. I just do not feel as though the assets you are getting would help you week to week. Have you considered giving Big Ben instead of the pick swaps? It would leave you with Rodgers and Palmer. And, you could get a rookie WR at 1.12.Good luck and have a good one.

Hi Jeff. I've had a few comments on this already, all saying that I should not consider this trade. Curious to see if you agreeynasty: 20 players, non-ppr, 6 pts per TD, 1 per 10 rush/rec, 1 per 25 passing, 12 teamsI am looking to unload J Russell. Don't want him, think he will be a waste of space. The offer, from the other team, on the table, is this:He gives me:C PalmerBarber2009 2.112011 2ndI give:J RussellLeftwichW ParkerChambers2009 1.122011 1stI don't care for Leftwich and Chambers, I view them as throw-ins. He will not budge on the 1st round picks, we have gone round and round and this is where we are. I declined this deal a week ago, but am rethinking it.My roster:QB:RussellLeftwichRothlisbergerA RodgersRBarkerD WilliamsM TurnerRiceBradshaw, ADuckett, TJackson, FJones, KWare, DWR:Arrington, AAustin, MChambers, CEvans, LFitzgerald, LHill, JHolmes, SJackson, DTE:Gates

 

[Packers4ever]

8 player keeper(will change to 10 keepers in 2010) league Stardard scoring no PPR Starters 1QB, 2RB's, 3WR's, 1TE, 1 Flex(RB, WR, TE)

My Team

QB’s J. Culter

RB's S. Jackson, J. Addai, R. Brown, J. Stewart,

WR's R. Moss, G. Jennings, B. Marshall,

TE's C. Cooley,

1.05 & 3.05

His team

QB's D. Brees

RB's C. Portis, K. Smith, S. Slaton

WR's D. Avery, A. Bryant, A. Bryant, T. Owens,

TE's J. Witten

His top picks 1.06, 1.08, & 2.01

Do you see any trade here with this team that I would include R. Brown. I would say that I would need Slaton in any deal for Brown. Can be multiple players if you see anything here.

 

[Childress]

Thanks for answering some of my questions in the past, this is another one of the many great features here at FBG's.

Anyway, I just completed a dynasty draft and I'm having a little bit of drafters remorse.

The league is a 12 team PPR with 4 pts per passing TD (everything else is standard scoring). Start QB/WR/WR/RB/RB/Flex/Flex/TE/K/DEF so you can start up to 4 RB's or WR's.

QB

Jay Cutler

Matt Cassel

Matt Stafford

WR

Greg Jennings

Brandon Marshall

Marques Colston

Michael Crabtree

Jeremy Maclin

Jordy Nelson

Brandon Tate

Pierre Garcon

Isaac Bruce

Chansi Stuckey

RB

Steven Jackson

Cedric Benson

LeSean McCoy!!

Fred Taylor

James Davis

TE

Visanthe Shiancoe

Brandon Pettigrew

Randy Mcmichael

K

Kris Brown

DEF

Baltimore

Miami

When I took Greg Jennings over Randy Moss in the 2nd I made the decision to go young to build a good team for the future. I ended up picking Crabtree, McCoy, Maclin when my leaguemates were drafting productive veterans so my team for THIS year is not looking terribly competitively. I know I made the choice to go young and I have to live with it but my impatient FF soul is trying to get me to make a move for a productive RB for this year so I can make a push for the playoffs. I could be ok starting Crabtree as my 4th WR THIS year and maybe have a competitive year but looking at my RBs it's tough to have Benson as my 2nd RB who I have to start every week.

I tried moving Marshall for a RB but my leaguemates consider his value so low with all of his uncertainty that I have been turned down for every offer I present involving Marshall.

I have one owner who would possibly consider McCoy/Maclin for Chris Wells which makes be happy because I don't lose any starters and potentially gain one who is still a rookie.

Anyway, I was wondering if you had any advice on how to proceed. Who to target? Who to try and move? Whether or not I should just be patient and wait for my team's youth to hopefully come of age? Thanks in advance.

 

[Jeff Tefertiller]

8 player keeper(will change to 10 keepers in 2010) league Stardard scoring no PPR Starters 1QB, 2RB's, 3WR's, 1TE, 1 Flex(RB, WR, TE)My TeamQB’s J. CulterRB's S. Jackson, J. Addai, R. Brown, J. Stewart, WR's R. Moss, G. Jennings, B. Marshall, TE's C. Cooley, 1.05 & 3.05His team QB's D. Brees RB's C. Portis, K. Smith, S. SlatonWR's D. Avery, A. Bryant, A. Bryant, T. Owens, TE's J. WittenHis top picks 1.06, 1.08, & 2.01Do you see any trade here with this team that I would include R. Brown. I would say that I would need Slaton in any deal for Brown. Can be multiple players if you see anything here.

Since I am not an Addai fan, I could see Addai/Brown for Slaton/KSmithWould give you an extra RB starter. All depends whether you feel comfortable with Slaton.

 

[Jeff Tefertiller]

I like your team. At this point, I would keep your young WRs. Their values will only go up. The one thing I might do is nose around Muhammad, Driver, Hines Ward, etc to see if you can get a proven bench/flex player. You have a strong team. The only spot I see you could use is one or two veteran WRs to hold you for a year while your youngsters develop. You are in great shape. As the season progresses, I would hit the waiver wire for players with upside. With such a young team, I would evaluate all trades/waiver pickups on what you think the 2010 value will be. This is with the exception of the one or two vet WRs.

Other things to think about. I might look to see if I could get Josh Morgan or James Jones cheaply to pair with Crabtree and Jordy Nelson. Would be nice to hold the pair of young WRs.I would hold Garcon with the press he is getting.

You did a good job on the draft so now I would just try to build young depth. The team will be much better in 2010 than 2009.

Have a good one.

Jeff

Thanks for answering some of my questions in the past, this is another one of the many great features here at FBG's.

Anyway, I just completed a dynasty draft and I'm having a little bit of drafters remorse.

The league is a 12 team PPR with 4 pts per passing TD (everything else is standard scoring). Start QB/WR/WR/RB/RB/Flex/Flex/TE/K/DEF so you can start up to 4 RB's or WR's.

QB

Jay Cutler

Matt Cassel

Matt Stafford

WR

Greg Jennings

Brandon Marshall

Marques Colston

Michael Crabtree

Jeremy Maclin

Jordy Nelson

Brandon Tate

Pierre Garcon

Isaac Bruce

Chansi Stuckey

RB

Steven Jackson

Cedric Benson

LeSean McCoy!!

Fred Taylor

James Davis

TE

Visanthe Shiancoe

Brandon Pettigrew

Randy Mcmichael

K

Kris Brown

DEF

Baltimore

Miami

When I took Greg Jennings over Randy Moss in the 2nd I made the decision to go young to build a good team for the future. I ended up picking Crabtree, McCoy, Maclin when my leaguemates were drafting productive veterans so my team for THIS year is not looking terribly competitively. I know I made the choice to go young and I have to live with it but my impatient FF soul is trying to get me to make a move for a productive RB for this year so I can make a push for the playoffs. I could be ok starting Crabtree as my 4th WR THIS year and maybe have a competitive year but looking at my RBs it's tough to have Benson as my 2nd RB who I have to start every week.

I tried moving Marshall for a RB but my leaguemates consider his value so low with all of his uncertainty that I have been turned down for every offer I present involving Marshall.

I have one owner who would possibly consider McCoy/Maclin for Chris Wells which makes be happy because I don't lose any starters and potentially gain one who is still a rookie.

Anyway, I was wondering if you had any advice on how to proceed. Who to target? Who to try and move? Whether or not I should just be patient and wait for my team's youth to hopefully come of age? Thanks in advance.

 

[Packers4ever]

8 player keeper(will change to 10 keepers in 2010) league Stardard scoring no PPR Starters 1QB, 2RB's, 3WR's, 1TE, 1 Flex(RB, WR, TE)My TeamQB’s J. CulterRB's S. Jackson, J. Addai, R. Brown, J. Stewart, WR's R. Moss, G. Jennings, B. Marshall, TE's C. Cooley, 1.05 & 3.05His team QB's D. Brees RB's C. Portis, K. Smith, S. SlatonWR's D. Avery, A. Bryant, A. Bryant, T. Owens, TE's J. WittenHis top picks 1.06, 1.08, & 2.01Do you see any trade here with this team that I would include R. Brown. I would say that I would need Slaton in any deal for Brown. Can be multiple players if you see anything here.

Since I am not an Addai fan, I could see Addai/Brown for Slaton/KSmithWould give you an extra RB starter. All depends whether you feel comfortable with Slaton.

I offered him the Addai/Brown for Slaton/K. Smith but don't think he will go for it.I am also thinking Brees & K. Smith or Portis for Culter and Brown. What do you think of this trade I don't think he would go for K. Smith but probably Portis since he has been shopping him but don't know how much he has left.

 

[Jeff Tefertiller]

8 player keeper(will change to 10 keepers in 2010) league Stardard scoring no PPR Starters 1QB, 2RB's, 3WR's, 1TE, 1 Flex(RB, WR, TE)My TeamQB’s J. CulterRB's S. Jackson, J. Addai, R. Brown, J. Stewart, WR's R. Moss, G. Jennings, B. Marshall, TE's C. Cooley, 1.05 & 3.05His team QB's D. Brees RB's C. Portis, K. Smith, S. SlatonWR's D. Avery, A. Bryant, A. Bryant, T. Owens, TE's J. WittenHis top picks 1.06, 1.08, & 2.01Do you see any trade here with this team that I would include R. Brown. I would say that I would need Slaton in any deal for Brown. Can be multiple players if you see anything here.

Since I am not an Addai fan, I could see Addai/Brown for Slaton/KSmithWould give you an extra RB starter. All depends whether you feel comfortable with Slaton.

I offered him the Addai/Brown for Slaton/K. Smith but don't think he will go for it.I am also thinking Brees & K. Smith or Portis for Culter and Brown. What do you think of this trade I don't think he would go for K. Smith but probably Portis since he has been shopping him but don't know how much he has left.

I would not do that for Portis. I am high on K Smith this season. He could be a surprise this season. If he does not go for it, you might ask what else is needed.

 

[Packers4ever]

10 team 9 keepers or you can keep your whole team standard scoring no PPR 1QB, 2 RB's, 3 WR's, 1TE, 1 K, 1 Def

My Team

QB's J. Cutler, M. Ryan

RB's F. Gore, S. Slaton, M. Turner. J. Stewart, W. McGahee

WR's A. Boldin, Cotchery, Jennings, S. Smith (Car), Ginn Jr

TE's K. Winslow, Z. Miller (Oak)

K's Akers, Crosby

Def Philadelphia

His Team

QB's T. Brady, D. Brees, J. Campbell

RB's C. Portis, B. Westbrook, M. Moore

WR's A. Gonzalez, J. Gage, D. Henderson, S. Holmes, T. Holt

TE's J. Witton, D. Lee

K's N. Kaeding, J. Reed

DEF Giants

This team wants to trade one his QB's for Wr's or RB's since I have so extra of both was thinking of offering him something but don't really know were to start since I like all of them except maybe for McGahee. Would Brady or Brees be that much of a upgrade to try to trade for one of them or should I just stay with what I have and keep my whole team.

 

[Jeff Tefertiller]

10 team 9 keepers or you can keep your whole team standard scoring no PPR 1QB, 2 RB's, 3 WR's, 1TE, 1 K, 1 Def My TeamQB's J. Cutler, M. RyanRB's F. Gore, S. Slaton, M. Turner. J. Stewart, W. McGahee WR's A. Boldin, Cotchery, Jennings, S. Smith (Car), Ginn Jr TE's K. Winslow, Z. Miller (Oak)K's Akers, CrosbyDef Philadelphia His TeamQB's T. Brady, D. Brees, J. CampbellRB's C. Portis, B. Westbrook, M. MooreWR's A. Gonzalez, J. Gage, D. Henderson, S. Holmes, T. Holt TE's J. Witton, D. LeeK's N. Kaeding, J. ReedDEF GiantsThis team wants to trade one his QB's for Wr's or RB's since I have so extra of both was thinking of offering him something but don't really know were to start since I like all of them except maybe for McGahee. Would Brady or Brees be that much of a upgrade to try to trade for one of them or should I just stay with what I have and keep my whole team.

There are a few ways to go with this. You could start with Cotch and Cutler for one of the QBs. If he wants a RB, I owuld think you would be good with Cutler/Gore for QB/Portis or Westbrook. You are very strong at RB and WR so a 2 for 2 deal makes sense if he does not like the Cotch/Cutler deal. You may even think of making it Cutler/Cotch/Willis for a QB. This would not impact your team at all, but would upgrade starters. If the other owner is good with this deal, I would try to "choose" who you get back as throw ins. Gage and Mewelde are who I would want. No one likes either much, but could be decent.

 

[Packers4ever]

8 player keeper league( next year we will be able to keep 10 players) Stardard scoring no PPR Starters 1QB, 2RB's, 3WR's, 1TE, 1 Flex(RB, WR, TE)

My Team

QB’s J. Culter

RB's S. Jackson, J. Addai, R. Brown, J. Stewart,

WR's R. Moss, G. Jennings, B. Marshall,

Ok keepers are all in and the draft will be starting tomorrow and I have the 1.05. I know Moreno, Wells, & Brown will be gone by my pick so who would you pick out of these players I think the team at 1.04 is taking Greene.

Crabtree

R. Rice

Mendenhall

McCoy

W. Parker

H. Nicks

Maclin

Harvin

Cotchery

McNabb

I am leaning towards Crabtree but when I seen someone drop Rice & Mandenhall I was thinking maybe one of them.

Another question with all these players out there would you offer a 1st round pick next for a high 2nd round pick this year?

 

[Jeff Tefertiller]

8 player keeper league( next year we will be able to keep 10 players) Stardard scoring no PPR Starters 1QB, 2RB's, 3WR's, 1TE, 1 Flex(RB, WR, TE)My TeamQB’s J. CulterRB's S. Jackson, J. Addai, R. Brown, J. Stewart, WR's R. Moss, G. Jennings, B. Marshall,Ok keepers are all in and the draft will be starting tomorrow and I have the 1.05. I know Moreno, Wells, & Brown will be gone by my pick so who would you pick out of these players I think the team at 1.04 is taking Greene.CrabtreeR. RiceMendenhallMcCoyW. ParkerH. NicksMaclinHarvin CotcheryMcNabbI am leaning towards Crabtree but when I seen someone drop Rice & Mandenhall I was thinking maybe one of them.Another question with all these players out there would you offer a 1st round pick next for a high 2nd round pick this year?

Crabtree or Rice or Mendenhall is a close one for me. None should have a huge impact this season, imo. Add in McCoy and Nicks and I think I would offer a next year's first for a pick to get one of these five. Since you have such good starters, I would look at who might be worth most in a year. I am thinking these players plus Harvin or McNabb (in case you can sell high mid-season) would be decent choices for your 2nd rounder. Back to the first round pick, I would even consider trading back a couple of spots if you got a good offer. If not, I might go with one of the RBs. The upside is much higher in non-ppr. I do think Crabtree will be good. Just see him as having Plaxico upside, not Calvin Johnson. If you are good with that upside, then take Crabtree. He should be good for a long time.

 

[Packers4ever]

8 player keeper league( next year we will be able to keep 10 players) Stardard scoring no PPR Starters 1QB, 2RB's, 3WR's, 1TE, 1 Flex(RB, WR, TE)My TeamQB’s J. CulterRB's S. Jackson, J. Addai, R. Brown, J. Stewart, WR's R. Moss, G. Jennings, B. Marshall,Ok keepers are all in and the draft will be starting tomorrow and I have the 1.05. I know Moreno, Wells, & Brown will be gone by my pick so who would you pick out of these players I think the team at 1.04 is taking Greene.CrabtreeR. RiceMendenhallMcCoyW. ParkerH. NicksMaclinHarvin CotcheryMcNabbI am leaning towards Crabtree but when I seen someone drop Rice & Mandenhall I was thinking maybe one of them.Another question with all these players out there would you offer a 1st round pick next for a high 2nd round pick this year?

Crabtree or Rice or Mendenhall is a close one for me. None should have a huge impact this season, imo. Add in McCoy and Nicks and I think I would offer a next year's first for a pick to get one of these five. Since you have such good starters, I would look at who might be worth most in a year. I am thinking these players plus Harvin or McNabb (in case you can sell high mid-season) would be decent choices for your 2nd rounder. Back to the first round pick, I would even consider trading back a couple of spots if you got a good offer. If not, I might go with one of the RBs. The upside is much higher in non-ppr. I do think Crabtree will be good. Just see him as having Plaxico upside, not Calvin Johnson. If you are good with that upside, then take Crabtree. He should be good for a long time.

I have offer the team with the 1.02 pick my 1.05 and my 2nd round pick in 2010 just waiting to hear back the only thing is it could be a high pick since we do a snake draft do you think Wells or Brown is worth that.

 

[Jeff Tefertiller]

8 player keeper league( next year we will be able to keep 10 players) Stardard scoring no PPR Starters 1QB, 2RB's, 3WR's, 1TE, 1 Flex(RB, WR, TE)My TeamQB’s J. CulterRB's S. Jackson, J. Addai, R. Brown, J. Stewart, WR's R. Moss, G. Jennings, B. Marshall,Ok keepers are all in and the draft will be starting tomorrow and I have the 1.05. I know Moreno, Wells, & Brown will be gone by my pick so who would you pick out of these players I think the team at 1.04 is taking Greene.CrabtreeR. RiceMendenhallMcCoyW. ParkerH. NicksMaclinHarvin CotcheryMcNabbI am leaning towards Crabtree but when I seen someone drop Rice & Mandenhall I was thinking maybe one of them.Another question with all these players out there would you offer a 1st round pick next for a high 2nd round pick this year?

Crabtree or Rice or Mendenhall is a close one for me. None should have a huge impact this season, imo. Add in McCoy and Nicks and I think I would offer a next year's first for a pick to get one of these five. Since you have such good starters, I would look at who might be worth most in a year. I am thinking these players plus Harvin or McNabb (in case you can sell high mid-season) would be decent choices for your 2nd rounder. Back to the first round pick, I would even consider trading back a couple of spots if you got a good offer. If not, I might go with one of the RBs. The upside is much higher in non-ppr. I do think Crabtree will be good. Just see him as having Plaxico upside, not Calvin Johnson. If you are good with that upside, then take Crabtree. He should be good for a long time.

I have offer the team with the 1.02 pick my 1.05 and my 2nd round pick in 2010 just waiting to hear back the only thing is it could be a high pick since we do a snake draft do you think Wells or Brown is worth that.

Oh, yeah. I think both are worth that deal, esp with 10 keepers next yr

 

[MoraccoMole]

Dynasty format. Standard scoring. Starting line up 1 qb, 2 rb, 2wr, 1 te.

Couple weeks before the rookie draft. I hold pick 1.02 and 2.01.

My team:

Manning

T Edwards

Forte

McGahee

Rice

Mendenhall

Sproles

Calvin Johnson

S Holmes

Cotchery

A Gates

I have been offered Colston, 1.07, and 3.01 for Mendenhall, Holmes, and Edwards. Your thoughts appreciated.

 

[Packers4ever]

8 player keeper league( next year we will be able to keep 10 players) Stardard scoring no PPR Starters 1QB, 2RB's, 3WR's, 1TE, 1 Flex(RB, WR, TE)My TeamQB’s J. CulterRB's S. Jackson, J. Addai, R. Brown, J. Stewart, WR's R. Moss, G. Jennings, B. Marshall,Ok keepers are all in and the draft will be starting tomorrow and I have the 1.05. I know Moreno, Wells, & Brown will be gone by my pick so who would you pick out of these players I think the team at 1.04 is taking Greene.CrabtreeR. RiceMendenhallMcCoyW. ParkerH. NicksMaclinHarvin CotcheryMcNabbI am leaning towards Crabtree but when I seen someone drop Rice & Mandenhall I was thinking maybe one of them.Another question with all these players out there would you offer a 1st round pick next for a high 2nd round pick this year?

Crabtree or Rice or Mendenhall is a close one for me. None should have a huge impact this season, imo. Add in McCoy and Nicks and I think I would offer a next year's first for a pick to get one of these five. Since you have such good starters, I would look at who might be worth most in a year. I am thinking these players plus Harvin or McNabb (in case you can sell high mid-season) would be decent choices for your 2nd rounder. Back to the first round pick, I would even consider trading back a couple of spots if you got a good offer. If not, I might go with one of the RBs. The upside is much higher in non-ppr. I do think Crabtree will be good. Just see him as having Plaxico upside, not Calvin Johnson. If you are good with that upside, then take Crabtree. He should be good for a long time.

Draft has just started and have been offered D. Brown for J. Stewart. Is this something that you would do since I have addai.

 

[Jeff Tefertiller]

8 player keeper league( next year we will be able to keep 10 players) Stardard scoring no PPR Starters 1QB, 2RB's, 3WR's, 1TE, 1 Flex(RB, WR, TE)My TeamQB’s J. CulterRB's S. Jackson, J. Addai, R. Brown, J. Stewart, WR's R. Moss, G. Jennings, B. Marshall,Ok keepers are all in and the draft will be starting tomorrow and I have the 1.05. I know Moreno, Wells, & Brown will be gone by my pick so who would you pick out of these players I think the team at 1.04 is taking Greene.CrabtreeR. RiceMendenhallMcCoyW. ParkerH. NicksMaclinHarvin CotcheryMcNabbI am leaning towards Crabtree but when I seen someone drop Rice & Mandenhall I was thinking maybe one of them.Another question with all these players out there would you offer a 1st round pick next for a high 2nd round pick this year?

Crabtree or Rice or Mendenhall is a close one for me. None should have a huge impact this season, imo. Add in McCoy and Nicks and I think I would offer a next year's first for a pick to get one of these five. Since you have such good starters, I would look at who might be worth most in a year. I am thinking these players plus Harvin or McNabb (in case you can sell high mid-season) would be decent choices for your 2nd rounder. Back to the first round pick, I would even consider trading back a couple of spots if you got a good offer. If not, I might go with one of the RBs. The upside is much higher in non-ppr. I do think Crabtree will be good. Just see him as having Plaxico upside, not Calvin Johnson. If you are good with that upside, then take Crabtree. He should be good for a long time.

Draft has just started and have been offered D. Brown for J. Stewart. Is this something that you would do since I have addai.

no, that is not worth considering unless you get considerably more. Stewart is viewed by many as a Top 12-15 dynasty RB

 

[Jeff Tefertiller]

Dynasty format. Standard scoring. Starting line up 1 qb, 2 rb, 2wr, 1 te.Couple weeks before the rookie draft. I hold pick 1.02 and 2.01.My team:ManningT EdwardsForteMcGaheeRiceMendenhallSprolesCalvin JohnsonS HolmesCotcheryA GatesI have been offered Colston, 1.07, and 3.01 for Mendenhall, Holmes, and Edwards. Your thoughts appreciated.

In a non-PPR, I would not do this. I like Colston a lot, but not worth giving up Mendenhall and crew.

 

[Packers4ever]

8 player keeper league( next year we will be able to keep 10 players) Stardard scoring no PPR Starters 1QB, 2RB's, 3WR's, 1TE, 1 Flex(RB, WR, TE)My TeamQB’s J. CulterRB's S. Jackson, J. Addai, R. Brown, J. Stewart, WR's R. Moss, G. Jennings, B. Marshall, M. CrabtreeOk keepers are all in and the draft will be starting tomorrow and I have the 1.05. I know Moreno, Wells, & Brown will be gone by my pick so who would you pick out of these players I think the team at 1.04 is taking Greene.CrabtreeR. RiceMendenhallMcCoyW. ParkerH. NicksMaclinHarvin CotcheryMcNabbI am leaning towards Crabtree but when I seen someone drop Rice & Mandenhall I was thinking maybe one of them.Another question with all these players out there would you offer a 1st round pick next for a high 2nd round pick this year?

Crabtree or Rice or Mendenhall is a close one for me. None should have a huge impact this season, imo. Add in McCoy and Nicks and I think I would offer a next year's first for a pick to get one of these five. Since you have such good starters, I would look at who might be worth most in a year. I am thinking these players plus Harvin or McNabb (in case you can sell high mid-season) would be decent choices for your 2nd rounder. Back to the first round pick, I would even consider trading back a couple of spots if you got a good offer. If not, I might go with one of the RBs. The upside is much higher in non-ppr. I do think Crabtree will be good. Just see him as having Plaxico upside, not Calvin Johnson. If you are good with that upside, then take Crabtree. He should be good for a long time.

Draft has just started and have been offered D. Brown for J. Stewart. Is this something that you would do since I have addai.

no, that is not worth considering unless you get considerably more. Stewart is viewed by many as a Top 12-15 dynasty RB

Here is his roster.RB's R. Bush, S. Greene, D. McFadden, D Williams, D. Brown WR's D. Avery, D. Bowe, V. Jackson, A. Johnson I did draft Crabtree so I don't think I would need a WR in the trade if I offered him something else. What do you think about offering him R. Brown, J. Addai & my 3.05 for D. Williams I keep thinking that this is not enough for Williams but I do not really what to give up one of my WR's but I know that is what he is going to want in return is atleast one of my WR's.Just received a email from him and he is not interested in trading D. Williams throught since he had Brown and Williams ANd I had Stewart and Addai that I would make a trade since he knew I would be drafting Brown. I don't really see to much else that I would want other than maybe McFadden but with him in Oakland don't really know about him. If you see anything in a trade that could get me Brown and I give him Stewart give me some ideas because I don't see much there fro a trade.

 

[Jeff Tefertiller]

8 player keeper league( next year we will be able to keep 10 players) Stardard scoring no PPR Starters 1QB, 2RB's, 3WR's, 1TE, 1 Flex(RB, WR, TE)My TeamQB’s J. CulterRB's S. Jackson, J. Addai, R. Brown, J. Stewart, WR's R. Moss, G. Jennings, B. Marshall, M. CrabtreeOk keepers are all in and the draft will be starting tomorrow and I have the 1.05. I know Moreno, Wells, & Brown will be gone by my pick so who would you pick out of these players I think the team at 1.04 is taking Greene.CrabtreeR. RiceMendenhallMcCoyW. ParkerH. NicksMaclinHarvin CotcheryMcNabbI am leaning towards Crabtree but when I seen someone drop Rice & Mandenhall I was thinking maybe one of them.Another question with all these players out there would you offer a 1st round pick next for a high 2nd round pick this year?

Crabtree or Rice or Mendenhall is a close one for me. None should have a huge impact this season, imo. Add in McCoy and Nicks and I think I would offer a next year's first for a pick to get one of these five. Since you have such good starters, I would look at who might be worth most in a year. I am thinking these players plus Harvin or McNabb (in case you can sell high mid-season) would be decent choices for your 2nd rounder. Back to the first round pick, I would even consider trading back a couple of spots if you got a good offer. If not, I might go with one of the RBs. The upside is much higher in non-ppr. I do think Crabtree will be good. Just see him as having Plaxico upside, not Calvin Johnson. If you are good with that upside, then take Crabtree. He should be good for a long time.

Draft has just started and have been offered D. Brown for J. Stewart. Is this something that you would do since I have addai.

no, that is not worth considering unless you get considerably more. Stewart is viewed by many as a Top 12-15 dynasty RB

Here is his roster.RB's R. Bush, S. Greene, D. McFadden, D Williams, D. Brown WR's D. Avery, D. Bowe, V. Jackson, A. Johnson I did draft Crabtree so I don't think I would need a WR in the trade if I offered him something else. What do you think about offering him R. Brown, J. Addai & my 3.05 for D. Williams I keep thinking that this is not enough for Williams but I do not really what to give up one of my WR's but I know that is what he is going to want in return is atleast one of my WR's.Just received a email from him and he is not interested in trading D. Williams throught since he had Brown and Williams ANd I had Stewart and Addai that I would make a trade since he knew I would be drafting Brown. I don't really see to much else that I would want other than maybe McFadden but with him in Oakland don't really know about him. If you see anything in a trade that could get me Brown and I give him Stewart give me some ideas because I don't see much there fro a trade.

I do not see anything off hand. Is the other owner interested in Addai to pair with DBrown? Wonder if Crabtree and Addai would get close to Andre Johnson ....The only other thing I see is maybe you could get McFadden for Addai. If you are to move Stewart in a deal for Brown, I would ask for Green or Avery in addition to Brown.

 

[Trent]

Hey Jeff,

I'm in a 16 team keeper league where we can keep 10 and have an additional 2 players on what we call a practice squad.

Last year we implemented a new kind of free agent feature that we call "player movement". I wanted your opinion on it to see if there was anything we can tweak or add to this to make it any better. Last year people were kind of gun shy to participate but i think more owners will give it a go this time around. Here is how it works:

August 15th we announce our 10 keepers. These keepers get split into two categories called Restricted and Unrestricted based on scoring. Top 5 scorers Restricted bottom 5 scorers Unrestricted.

The compensation to acquire a restricted player is a 1st round rookie pick and a 1st round regular pick.

The compensation for an Unrestricted player is a 2nd round rookie pick and a 2nd round regular pick.

Owners have the right to refuse giving up a Restricted player by giving the requesting owner their 1st round regular pick.

A week later we declare 3 players. Owners must have at least one of each category. Before our annual rookie draft we start the "player movement".

Starting with the owner with the worst record from the previous year each owner will be given the opportunity to acquire a single player from another teams designated players. Owners that did not finish in the money the previous year get two chances to acquire players while owners finishing in the money get one.

Do you see any tweaks we should consider making to this? Thanks for your time.

 

[Jeff Tefertiller]

Hey Jeff, I'm in a 16 team keeper league where we can keep 10 and have an additional 2 players on what we call a practice squad. Last year we implemented a new kind of free agent feature that we call "player movement". I wanted your opinion on it to see if there was anything we can tweak or add to this to make it any better. Last year people were kind of gun shy to participate but i think more owners will give it a go this time around. Here is how it works: August 15th we announce our 10 keepers. These keepers get split into two categories called Restricted and Unrestricted based on scoring. Top 5 scorers Restricted bottom 5 scorers Unrestricted. The compensation to acquire a restricted player is a 1st round rookie pick and a 1st round regular pick.The compensation for an Unrestricted player is a 2nd round rookie pick and a 2nd round regular pick.Owners have the right to refuse giving up a Restricted player by giving the requesting owner their 1st round regular pick. A week later we declare 3 players. Owners must have at least one of each category. Before our annual rookie draft we start the "player movement". Starting with the owner with the worst record from the previous year each owner will be given the opportunity to acquire a single player from another teams designated players. Owners that did not finish in the money the previous year get two chances to acquire players while owners finishing in the money get one.Do you see any tweaks we should consider making to this? Thanks for your time.

I am trying to think through this .... please let me know if I have this right ...Each team keeps ten players. Teams can "steal" each others' players. If a team steals your player, you get a 1st round rookie and veteran pick if it is a player not in the top five players kept for your team? Why do you get more reimbursement if it is one of five worst keepers than five best? Just trying to understand ...On the player movement, are the players allowed to be "taken" limited to the three you choose? If so, do the teams' losing a player get another in return? If nothing, I would think maybe you could make it where the bad teams get to swap keepers .. this at least gives the teams losing players something. I apologize if I have not understood this correctly.

 

[Trent]

In the player movement the players allowed to be "taken" are limited to the three we choose. The teams' losing a player only get compensated with picks in return. If the owner lost one of their top 5 keepers they would get a 1st round rookie pick and a 1st round veteran pick. If the owner lost one of their bottom 5 keepers they would get a 2nd round rookie and 2nd round veteran pick in return.

Also an owner has the right to refuse giving up a restricted player by doing so they forfeit their 1st round veteran pick to the owner requesting the player.

In addition if you exposed 2 restricted players and 1 unrestricted player and an owner takes one of your restricted players you can pull back the other restricted player and vice versa with 2 unrestricted players and 1 restricted player exposed.

In the weeks leading up to the player movement there were several trades between teams so that owners could move a player or two up or down each clasification depending on who they wanted to keep so they were more likeley or less likely to lose certain players.

Last year we expanded from 14 teams to 16 teams so in the player movement we only exposed 1 of each classification. Here is how it went:

Team 1 pass

Tean 2 pass

Team 3 Roddy White

Team 4 pass

Team 5 pass

Team 6 pass

Team 7 Santana Moss

Team 8 Deuce Mcallister

Team 9 pass

Team 10 Lavernues Coles

Team 11 Jamarcus Russell

Team 12 pass

Team 13 Todd Heap

Team 14 pass

Team 15 Donald Driver

Team 16 pass

The 2nd pass through was only the teams not finishing in the money and they all passed.

I think a few owners last year were gunshy about making moves, I feel this year will be different. I will be exposing Donald Driver and Tom Coughlin as my restricted players and either Leon Washington or Brent Celek as my unrestricted players.

Thanks again.

 

[Jeff Tefertiller]

In the player movement the players allowed to be "taken" are limited to the three we choose. The teams' losing a player only get compensated with picks in return. If the owner lost one of their top 5 keepers they would get a 1st round rookie pick and a 1st round veteran pick. If the owner lost one of their bottom 5 keepers they would get a 2nd round rookie and 2nd round veteran pick in return.Also an owner has the right to refuse giving up a restricted player by doing so they forfeit their 1st round veteran pick to the owner requesting the player. In addition if you exposed 2 restricted players and 1 unrestricted player and an owner takes one of your restricted players you can pull back the other restricted player and vice versa with 2 unrestricted players and 1 restricted player exposed.In the weeks leading up to the player movement there were several trades between teams so that owners could move a player or two up or down each clasification depending on who they wanted to keep so they were more likeley or less likely to lose certain players.Last year we expanded from 14 teams to 16 teams so in the player movement we only exposed 1 of each classification. Here is how it went:Team 1 passTean 2 passTeam 3 Roddy WhiteTeam 4 passTeam 5 passTeam 6 passTeam 7 Santana MossTeam 8 Deuce McallisterTeam 9 passTeam 10 Lavernues ColesTeam 11 Jamarcus RussellTeam 12 passTeam 13 Todd HeapTeam 14 passTeam 15 Donald DriverTeam 16 passThe 2nd pass through was only the teams not finishing in the money and they all passed.I think a few owners last year were gunshy about making moves, I feel this year will be different. I will be exposing Donald Driver and Tom Coughlin as my restricted players and either Leon Washington or Brent Celek as my unrestricted players.Thanks again.

Thinking about the trades, it seems few players "exposed" would be worth the 1st round picks. I could see several worth the 2nd rounders. But, if you choose who could be taken, you would choose those overvalued or last on the list. To me, the easiest ways to increase trades would be either to lower compensation or allow more players to be exposed. The more players available, the more worth the price needed to acquire. Also,