What's new
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

What are you doing with Nicks on Monday? (1 Viewer)

Ariakis

Footballguy
All signs point to him playing. However, I think this is further complicated because he was not productive last week and many of his owners took losses for his poor outing. Do you risk starting your stud or play a less appealing option?

What is everyone else doing with him and what are your situations? I don't mean this to be a WDIS but I'm curious what everyone else's strategy is going to be in relation to my three decisions below. This is of course subject to change if we get a better report by Noon Sunday.

For myself in one league I have Dez Bryant in reserve in a milestone heavy scoring system so I will let Nicks ride until Monday as none of my other Sunday options are as appealing with Calvin on a bye. For now sticking with Nicks knowing Dez is less likely to hit 100 yards but is viable if needed. The other benefit here is knowing whether the 4-40-1 outing likely for Dez will be enough if both play although Dez is not 100% healthy either but it's a 14 teamer and the ww is thin (and we pay for transactions).

In another league, a PPR/milestone format, I'd be starting a guy like Denario Alexander or similar from the ww with Wayne on a bye but don't have a MNF option although I could cut DA for Manningham but for now will not. For now sticking with Nicks because while I like DA to get something like 4-70-1 I think a healthy Nicks is likely to pull down a 7-100-1 score for a huge day. That said, I really can't take a 0 so I'm waivering because DA plays early. My only other play is to find a 3 PM or SNF WR with some viability to atleast see how the 1 PM games shape up to decide if I can risk nothing from Nicks.

For the 3rd league, a yardage heavy format with no bonuses, I have Collie out leaving me with Mike Wallace, Nicks, and Mike Williams (TB) for 2 spots. I was definitely going Wallace. It's a shallow bench league and just can't afford a cut (Collie) to pick up a later afternoon starting WR. I am very tempted to plug in Williams who unfortunately plays at Noon. I project to win easily even with the lesser projection of Williams but a 0 would be deadly ... after losing last week by 1 point with Scobee going last Monday night and getting me only 3 points.

I actually own him in 4 of 8 leagues. This is a basic 10 team dynasty and I project to win even with a 0 so I'm just letting Nicks ride with Alexander (unknown), Ocho (stinks), and DJax (hurt) as my other options. Subject to change on Sunday by Noon of course.

 
I'm keeping him in my lineup until I hear he is out. If he doesn't play Monday, hopefully I don't need the points. If I'm down a few points Monday and he is out, I'll drop one of my players that's on a bye week (can't drop anyone that has already played Sunday) and pick up Sam Hurd (only Cowboy or Giant on the WW that I can hope to get any points from). If he's not playing and I've either already won my game or I'm down big, then I'll just leave him in my lineup and take the 0.

ETA: If anyone is is planning to follow this same strategy, and have guys like Barber, Jacobs, Manningham, or Roy Williams on their WW, I'd put Nicks at FLEX instead of WR to give yourself some flexibility if you have to make a change Monday night.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
This is of course subject to change if we get a better report by Noon Sunday.
That's what I'm waiting for. With D. Jackson and M. Floyd out this weekend, I picked up J. Avant off waivers. It's actually not a horrible matchup with Avant lining up opposite Maclin, but I'd rather plug in Nicks.The problem is needing to know by noon tomorrow.
 
I'm keeping him in my lineup until I hear he is out. If he doesn't play Monday, hopefully I don't need the points. If I'm down a few points Monday and he is out, I'll drop one of my players that's on a bye week (can't drop anyone that has already played Sunday) and pick up Sam Hurd (only Cowboy or Giant on the WW that I can hope to get any points from). If he's not playing and I've either already won my game or I'm down big, then I'll just leave him in my lineup and take the 0.ETA: If anyone is is planning to follow this same strategy, and have guys like Barber, Jacobs, Manningham, or Roy Williams on their WW, I'd put Nicks at FLEX instead of WR to give yourself some flexibility if you have to make a change Monday night.
once the games start on Sunday, we can't pick up any more players off waivers. I had the same issue, and waived one of my scrubs for Kevin Boss (TE counts as WR in my league). It was between Hurd and Boss, and I figured Boss might do something if Nicks is out, while Hurd remains, at best, the 5th option in the Cowboys passing game behind Austin, Roy, Dez and Witten. Sure as hell hoping that Nicks plays, but at least I have a warm body to put into my line-up Monday night if he doesn't.
 
Got Nicks in 3 leagues. Definitely starting him in 2 over the likes of Meachem, Britt, & Murphy.

One league I'm still debating between Nicks and Hines Ward. Might start Ward as a way to hedge my bets

 
hamstring injuries scare me....it doesn't take much to reaggravate them.......even if he is a go, one little move could have him on the bench...I am sitting him and if I miss out on a big night, so be it......

 
hamstring injuries scare me....it doesn't take much to reaggravate them.......even if he is a go, one little move could have him on the bench...I am sitting him and if I miss out on a big night, so be it......
You just described everything in football. If hes playing im playing him, If hes out im not.
 
I just went and double checked the FBG's summary of day 6 and don't really see injury as a reason mentioned for the horrible fantasy outing but it makes you wonder. If this week's game was against a less important AFC game would he sit knowing week 8 is their bye to get healthy? The more I think about this the more nervous I get about sticking with him despite him being so productive most of the season.

Again, that gets back to my main point in making this strategy topic ... my gut says decoy if he plays and I'm leaning towards other options as mentioned above.

 
Remember when people sat calvin last week when he questionable? Reports were he couldn't left his arm past his shoulder and he ended with 147-1 . Don't bench your studs.

Eli throws to him if nothing else from the 10 in the redzone. Week one he had minimal yards but 3 tds. Dumb to sit him unless you're stacked.

 
I am trying to arrange my lineup so that I play Nicks in my Flex spot and can then replace him with Barber if he can't go

Nicks despite being questionable is supposed to play....but I would like to have a fallback position IF I can play a WR3 for him that doesn't weaken my lineup too much........

 
Remember when people sat calvin last week when he questionable? Reports were he couldn't left his arm past his shoulder and he ended with 147-1 . Don't bench your studs.Eli throws to him if nothing else from the 10 in the redzone. Week one he had minimal yards but 3 tds. Dumb to sit him unless you're stacked.
:goodposting: Came here to post exactly this because, well, I was one of those people (sat Calvin for Tampa Mike). He has said he is playing. Unless I hear he is out, he's in my lineup.
 
Have already flipped back and forth between Nicks and Crabtree on two different teams. May change my mind again tomorrow AM, though i don't expect any true new info between now and then.

VERY tough situation.

In one league, could swap Crabtree for Mario Manningham, giving me option of Nicks or Manningham Monday night. Though, looking forward, much prefer Crabtree to Manningham...

 
Remember when people sat calvin last week when he questionable? Reports were he couldn't left his arm past his shoulder and he ended with 147-1 . Don't bench your studs.Eli throws to him if nothing else from the 10 in the redzone. Week one he had minimal yards but 3 tds. Dumb to sit him unless you're stacked.
Is it really that black and white? If you think you can win with 6-10 points from an average guy do you really take the risk at this point? Do you find a late game alternative so that if it appears a 6-10 point game is enough you'll put in a safer alternative who plays later on Sunday or Monday? Are you really OK losing by 6 and taking a 0 from Nicks when you could have started a middling choice?
 
VERY tough situation. In one league, could swap Crabtree for Mario Manningham, giving me option of Nicks or Manningham Monday night. Though, looking forward, much prefer Crabtree to Manningham...
Agreed................I just grabbed Manningham so I have him as my MNF backup, but hopefully Nicks playsOn my other "Nicks team" I have to decide before the early games whether to keep him in the lineup or replace him with Lance Moore
 
"*** Friday Update *** WR Hakeem Nicks (NYG) did not practice on Friday. He said he's playing Monday night though.

"Nothing serious. Probably more fatigue," Nicks said, "just a lot of running, a lot of reps, that's all. ... I've dealt with this before so I know how to approach it now. I just want to make the right decisions."

"Oh I'm definitely playing. There's no question about that," Nicks said. "It's Monday Night Football."

 
If Nicks is out would you rather have R. Williams (have him now, dropped M. Williams (Sea) to get him) or M. Manningham (he is on waivers currently) for this weeks game, in a .5 ppr league?

 
If Nicks is out then Manningham is the obvious play. If Nicks plays that's the bigger decision ... do you play him or go with a lesser option?

 
This is tough, I want to start Nicks but might just end up putting M Williams TB in to avoid being stuck with Nicks suddenly not playing and no other options. Anyone that can grab Manningham should have already. Definitely the best move to make and wait until Monday to swap them if needed.

 
bill bates hits hard said:
Remember when people sat calvin last week when he questionable? Reports were he couldn't left his arm past his shoulder and he ended with 147-1 . Don't bench your studs.Eli throws to him if nothing else from the 10 in the redzone. Week one he had minimal yards but 3 tds. Dumb to sit him unless you're stacked.
I think you're missing the pointCalvin Johnson game was early Sunday last week, Nicks game is next Monday....so if he doesn't play you're fracked because it'll be the last game of the weekend
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Just read that he was a limited participant in Saturday's practice. As much as I don't want to possibly miss one of his break-out performances, I think I'll opt to sit him this week just in case he can't go or is just ineffective on that ankle. I'll be starting T. Owens over him in one league and Jeremy Maclin over him in another.

 
I'm rolling with Nicks over Tampa Bay Mike. Last week, Addai was questionable in the Sunday night game and I played it 'safe' rather than starting him. Addai has a great game on Sunday and I lose. Won't be making that mistake again. If a players says he is definitely playing, I'm going with it.

 
With Collie and Finley out in a short roster league. Ocho and Smyff pretty much have to play. Danario or Nicks. WW is closed. Going Nicks unless I hear something worse on Nicks before I'd have to start Alexander. But I'll go with Cutler 9against WAS) over Eli and reduce the double whammy potential by at least that small bit.

 
I'm going to play him unless some negative news comes out Monday prior to the game, and if that happens I will switch in Roy Williams for him.

 
Nicks will play and (unless he reinjures himself, which he seems to be taking precaution against) I expect he will try to be a monster.

However,

Steve Smith has been targeted 26 times against the Giants the last two times they have played. And he has produced in those situations. I think he has the match-up advantage against the Cowboys corner on short patterns if the Cowboys play the Giants the same way they have the past two times they have met.

But,

Teams watch the news. They see that Nicks is hurting (or at least suspect it). Steve Smith has killed them the past 2 times they have played. This is a must win division game. I think the Cowboys change it up, roll to Smith and see how much gas Nicks has against their best corner. At least to start.

And,

Nicks had practically no production last game. Very few pros will want to string multiple bad outings together, especially not one with Nicks ego and talent. I expect he will come out ready to make redemption on MNF. And I expect Eli to give him a chance to.

Therefore,

I think it is more likely than not that the stars have aligned for Nicks to have a big game IF he is right.

Im playing him over Satana Moss.

 
My only other option is Percy Harvin and he hasnt exactly been a picture of good health lately himself. I guess I'll listen to the reports today before making up my mind. Leaning to Nicks though.

 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top