What are your early thoughts on McNair? (1 Viewer)

[bigreese82]

Looks like he has some weapons. The rooks from last year will be a year older...Calico will be 2 years away from knee surgery...secondary should still be suspect...so potential for shootouts. Norm Chow's second year

I see McNair as a top 15 qb

What do you think?

Givens deal will be signed this morning

 

[bigreese82]

Deal done with Givens

 

[helix]

Looks like he has some weapons. The rooks from last year will be a year older...Calico will be 2 years away from knee surgery...secondary should still be suspect...so potential for shootouts. Norm Chow's second year

I see McNair as a top 15 qb

What do you think?

Givens deal will be signed this morning

Problem with McNair is injury risk. He is going to miss at least a couple games and not finish a few as well. I doubt he will be top 15, maybe 18-22. Maybe.

 

[fruity pebbles]

He still doesn't have that #1 WR that Mason afforded him.

 

[gman8343]

Is Givens that great?

 

[fruity pebbles]

Is Givens that great?

About the same as Bennett. Good not great. Better football player than fantasy player.

 

[cstu]

He still doesn't have that #1 WR that Mason afforded him.

He doesn't need it - they'll spread the ball around and the numbers will pile up.The only problem I have with McNair is the headache he'll cause since he's always on the injury report and you will have to carry Volek on your roster.

 

[Ozymandias]

I suspect McNair will be questionable every week. As will about 25% of the Titans. You just can't read anything into Fisher's injury report.