What's new
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

What Is a 'Livable Wage'? A Poll. (1 Viewer)

Should the Living Wage definition, in your opinion, include saving for college?

  • Yes

    Votes: 37 22.4%
  • No

    Votes: 128 77.6%

  • Total voters
    165
Depends on healthcare, but before that you can probably get by in Cleveland at 30k with a family of four.
Anyone know what the going rate for healthcare in that scenario is? That's a huge factor.
i gambled on catastrophic only when I was single, I'm sure I could have made due at 20k, maybe less. Not rolling those dice with family though. Health care has to range between very little and...600? Per month? Just throwing a number out there, but more than 5k per year for many I'm sure.
 
IMO, a livable wage for a single person should assume roommates and either public transportation or a cheap ### bike. People can and do survive in this country for far less than most here think. Is is pleasant? Not really but livable <> comfortable.

Teachers should be making far more than what I consider "livable".

 
IMO, a livable wage for a single person should assume roommates and either public transportation or a cheap ### bike. People can and do survive in this country for far less than most here think. Is is pleasant? Not really but livable <> comfortable.

Teachers should be making far more than what I consider "livable".
A roommate does seem like a reasonable compromise. The transport is a catch 22 b/c in order for your suggestion to be practical, that rules out suburbia which is where I find rentals to be more affordable.

 
Depends on healthcare, but before that you can probably get by in Cleveland at 30k with a family of four.
Anyone know what the going rate for healthcare in that scenario is? That's a huge factor.
i gambled on catastrophic only when I was single, I'm sure I could have made due at 20k, maybe less. Not rolling those dice with family though. Health care has to range between very little and...600? Per month? Just throwing a number out there, but more than 5k per year for many I'm sure.
I'd think way more than 5K for a family of four unless you're talking employee subsidized which I wouldn't think at that pay scale.

 
Here in Charlotte the living wage for a single person is 9.00 an hour allegedly. Not sure how that can be right when the average rental is 850.00 a month though.
Dude, you can buy a whole damn 2 BR house in Rock Hill for less than $50k.
http://www.zillow.com/homes/for_sale/Rock-Hill-SC/pmf,pf_pt/2109409894_zpid/13554_rid/priced_sort/37.675125,-74.783936,32.509762,-84.836426_rect/6_zm/9_p/
Charlotte the nearest city for good employment? 27 mile commute to there is very reasonable.

 
IMO, a livable wage for a single person should assume roommates and either public transportation or a cheap ### bike. People can and do survive in this country for far less than most here think. Is is pleasant? Not really but livable <> comfortable.

Teachers should be making far more than what I consider "livable".
A roommate does seem like a reasonable compromise. The transport is a catch 22 b/c in order for your suggestion to be practical, that rules out suburbia which is where I find rentals to be more affordable.
i got a house with three others in a good young neighborhood in Cleveland before I met my wife for $1400. I'm sure it's a little more now, but $350 per month with roommates is cheaper than a rental in the burbs. More likely to get to work cheaply too, obviously depending on where,you work. I think I could have gotten by at $15k now that I think more about it. Definitely not optimal though, bare bones living.
 
IMO, a livable wage for a single person should assume roommates and either public transportation or a cheap ### bike. People can and do survive in this country for far less than most here think. Is is pleasant? Not really but livable <> comfortable.

Teachers should be making far more than what I consider "livable".
A roommate does seem like a reasonable compromise. The transport is a catch 22 b/c in order for your suggestion to be practical, that rules out suburbia which is where I find rentals to be more affordable.
Yeah you cannot discount transportation. That's part of livable, though it is regionally dependent.

Nobody needs a car in Manhatten. But a bike probably doesnt work if they are in the Rocky Mountains.

Still has to be included in a basic "livable" scenario.

 
Depends on healthcare, but before that you can probably get by in Cleveland at 30k with a family of four.
Anyone know what the going rate for healthcare in that scenario is? That's a huge factor.
i gambled on catastrophic only when I was single, I'm sure I could have made due at 20k, maybe less. Not rolling those dice with family though. Health care has to range between very little and...600? Per month? Just throwing a number out there, but more than 5k per year for many I'm sure.
I'd think way more than 5K for a family of four unless you're talking employee subsidized which I wouldn't think at that pay scale.
probably, I really don't know. My wife is a teacher and we have always had good affordable healthcare. Don't know exact numbers but $300 something for full coverage. Definitely helps off set the low pay she takes home.
 
Teachers really don't know how much it costs. When my wife quit teaching she was shell shocked at how expensive ins was (esp the Cadillac plans many teachers have).

 
IMO, a livable wage for a single person should assume roommates and either public transportation or a cheap ### bike. People can and do survive in this country for far less than most here think. Is is pleasant? Not really but livable <> comfortable.

Teachers should be making far more than what I consider "livable".
A roommate does seem like a reasonable compromise. The transport is a catch 22 b/c in order for your suggestion to be practical, that rules out suburbia which is where I find rentals to be more affordable.
i got a house with three others in a good young neighborhood in Cleveland before I met my wife for $1400. I'm sure it's a little more now, but $350 per month with roommates is cheaper than a rental in the burbs. More likely to get to work cheaply too, obviously depending on where,you work. I think I could have gotten by at $15k now that I think more about it. Definitely not optimal though, bare bones living.
You can certainly get that price is a safe neighborhood in NJ. I'd be surprised if you can say the same thing for an urban area around here.

 
Here in Charlotte the living wage for a single person is 9.00 an hour allegedly. Not sure how that can be right when the average rental is 850.00 a month though.
Dude, you can buy a whole damn 2 BR house in Rock Hill for less than $50k.
http://www.zillow.com/homes/for_sale/Rock-Hill-SC/pmf,pf_pt/2109409894_zpid/13554_rid/priced_sort/37.675125,-74.783936,32.509762,-84.836426_rect/6_zm/9_p/
Charlotte the nearest city for good employment? 27 mile commute to there is very reasonable.
sure, if the only place you can get a job is Bank of America corporate office.Pretty sure there are employment opportunities in Rock Hill. Not good ones, but jobs that can keep you off the street.

 
Here in Charlotte the living wage for a single person is 9.00 an hour allegedly. Not sure how that can be right when the average rental is 850.00 a month though.
Dude, you can buy a whole damn 2 BR house in Rock Hill for less than $50k.
http://www.zillow.com/homes/for_sale/Rock-Hill-SC/pmf,pf_pt/2109409894_zpid/13554_rid/priced_sort/37.675125,-74.783936,32.509762,-84.836426_rect/6_zm/9_p/
Charlotte the nearest city for good employment? 27 mile commute to there is very reasonable.
sure, if the only place you can get a job is Bank of America corporate office.Pretty sure there are employment opportunities in Rock Hill. Not good ones, but jobs that can keep you off the street.
But are they "livable wage" paying jobs?

 
Here in Charlotte the living wage for a single person is 9.00 an hour allegedly. Not sure how that can be right when the average rental is 850.00 a month though.
Dude, you can buy a whole damn 2 BR house in Rock Hill for less than $50k.
http://www.zillow.com/homes/for_sale/Rock-Hill-SC/pmf,pf_pt/2109409894_zpid/13554_rid/priced_sort/37.675125,-74.783936,32.509762,-84.836426_rect/6_zm/9_p/
Charlotte the nearest city for good employment? 27 mile commute to there is very reasonable.
sure, if the only place you can get a job is Bank of America corporate office.Pretty sure there are employment opportunities in Rock Hill. Not good ones, but jobs that can keep you off the street.
But are they "livable wage" paying jobs?
i think the scenario is that the jobs are indeed all liveable wage jobs.

 
Here in Charlotte the living wage for a single person is 9.00 an hour allegedly. Not sure how that can be right when the average rental is 850.00 a month though.
Dude, you can buy a whole damn 2 BR house in Rock Hill for less than $50k.
http://www.zillow.com/homes/for_sale/Rock-Hill-SC/pmf,pf_pt/2109409894_zpid/13554_rid/priced_sort/37.675125,-74.783936,32.509762,-84.836426_rect/6_zm/9_p/
Charlotte the nearest city for good employment? 27 mile commute to there is very reasonable.
sure, if the only place you can get a job is Bank of America corporate office.Pretty sure there are employment opportunities in Rock Hill. Not good ones, but jobs that can keep you off the street.
But are they "livable wage" paying jobs?
I know quite a few people struggling to make ends meet in the 'Rock'. 'Livable' means something different to my 23 yr old bachelor buddy than it might for others- all he really wants is some cash for beer and to be able to pay for MMA classes (~$100/mo). He works full time at lowes and has roommates.I have two other buddies sharing a 2 bedroom house, both 30 yrs old bachelors, ex-marines, one is not making crap as a pro MMA fighter and the other has been bouncing around lately - most recent gig was selling cars, but prior to that he wad a cameraman for a religious TV station.

Again, its not easy but these guys are not on the streets. There is some hustle to make things work. I don't believe there is any 401 (k) savings happening, nor saving for college.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
I think some people have an absolutely assssinine definition of "liveable wage" if their number for a single person is 30K+. A person can easily live on 12-15K in most areas, albeit without a car payment and possibly some amenities like cable TV and top end cell phone data packages.

 
I guess I can't honestly answer this. Thankfully never in debt and didn't have college loans to pay off. I've made a life where a lot of my expenditures go towards things I don't really need like cable tv, streaming services, carry out, etc. However I don't know how easy it would be to cut a lot of that out. I guess that's why my livable wage is higher. Hmmmm this thread has put a lot of stuff in perspective.

 
I think some people have an absolutely assssinine definition of "liveable wage" if their number for a single person is 30K+. A person can easily live on 12-15K in most areas, albeit without a car payment and possibly some amenities like cable TV and top end cell phone data packages.
Healthcare options?

 
I don't see how a family can make it on much less than $100k a year with 2-3 kids if they own a home, drive 2 cars less than 5 years old, enjoy cable, it cost money.

 
:lmao: People, LIVABLE WAGE. Not 'middle class wage.' Shop at Goodwill for clothes, fix things instead of buy new, cook your own food etc. Not 'average house and a smidge left over for entertainment'. THAT actually used to be the definition of middle class. Now that's considered, what, bottom of 'acceptable'?
Try surviving in NYC on $45k a year without government assistance with a family of four... It'll be pure hell. You'll also be living in a very dangerous neighborhood.
"pure hell" :lmao: What a joke
You can't be serious.
More serious than the dude claiming half of New York is living in pure hell and suicidal misery.
According to Wikipedia the median HHI in NYC is almost $76k :shrug:

 
fantasycurse42 said:
:lmao: People, LIVABLE WAGE. Not 'middle class wage.' Shop at Goodwill for clothes, fix things instead of buy new, cook your own food etc. Not 'average house and a smidge left over for entertainment'. THAT actually used to be the definition of middle class. Now that's considered, what, bottom of 'acceptable'?
Try surviving in NYC on $45k a year without government assistance with a family of four... It'll be pure hell. You'll also be living in a very dangerous neighborhood.
"pure hell" :lmao: What a joke
You can't be serious.
More serious than the dude claiming half of New York is living in pure hell and suicidal misery.
According to Wikipedia the median HHI in NYC is almost $76k :shrug:
No, that is the mean figure.

 
Ministry of Pain said:
I don't see how a family can make it on much less than $100k a year with 2-3 kids if they own a home, drive 2 cars less than 5 years old, enjoy cable, it cost money.
you need to get out more.

 
Could probably manage on about $5K a year living in the country and living off the land. A few chickens and lots of hunting year round. Would just need money for basic necessities, ammo and the upkeep of a small "house" (no power or water).

 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top