What is the worst dynasty trade you have been offered? (1 Viewer)

[Raging weasel]

Woke up to this offer
D Hopkins, 26 2nd and 3rd
for
My 26 1st

 

[smbkrypt24]

Thought I was missing something:

Give up: Odunze
For: Justice Hill

 

[JohnnyU]

Thought I was missing something:

Give up: Odunze
For: Justice Hill

This would call for mailiing someone rotten fish wrapped in newspaper.

 

[smbkrypt24]

Thought I was missing something:

Give up: Odunze
For: Justice Hill

This would call for mailiing someone rotten fish wrapped in newspaper.

I just responded that I didn't see anything of value coming my way.

 

[phandango]

I'm doing an FFPC Triflex startup (superflex and TE premium). I have the 1.01. The guy with the 1.04 sent me an offer to trade up. Here it was:

Give: 1.01, 9.01
Get: 1.04, 10.09

Yes, the offer was for me to trade down twice. I rejected with the comment, "Not sure if you meant to send it like this." He never corrected it, and even though we've messaged and sent offers back and forth, he's never mentioned whether that was a mix-up. And all his offers have been indicative of someone who isn't interested in making anything close to a fair deal, only one that massively benefits him. So I went from "maybe he just fat-fingered that offer and sent it by mistake" to "maybe he sent it on purpose and hoped I wouldn't notice." I've done a ton of FFPC startups and have gotten offers sent by mistake, but they've always been corrected or withdrawn. Not with this guy. Weird.

 

[JohnnyU]

I'm doing an FFPC Triflex startup (superflex and TE premium). I have the 1.01. The guy with the 1.04 sent me an offer to trade up. Here it was:

Give: 1.01, 9.01
Get: 1.04, 10.09

Yes, the offer was for me to trade down twice. I rejected with the comment, "Not sure if you meant to send it like this." He never corrected it, and even though we've messaged and sent offers back and forth, he's never mentioned whether that was a mix-up. And all his offers have been indicative of someone who isn't interested in making anything close to a fair deal, only one that massively benefits him. So I went from "maybe he just fat-fingered that offer and sent it by mistake" to "maybe he sent it on purpose and hoped I wouldn't notice." I've done a ton of FFPC startups and have gotten offers sent by mistake, but they've always been corrected or withdrawn. Not with this guy. Weird.

I’ve killed for less

 

[Gatorade]

I was offered this trade yesterday.
16 team 1 QB IDP dynasty
I give up:
Rookie picks 3.5 and 3.10
I get :
2nd round rookie pick in 2026
This guy was the runner up on the league last year.

I replied back that he could maybe have one but not both. No response.
He already has two third round picks in this years draft, so I countered with those two picks for my 2nd rounder next year. No response.

 

[Western_77]

1 QB 12 Team Dynasty
I was offered this:

I get:
Rondale Moore WR Min
4th pick in 2026 Rookie Draft

I give:
Roschon Johnson RB Chic

No thanks, Johnson situation is interesting this year considering that Chicago only added a 7th round rookie to their mix at RB. I'd need more than a late rookie draft pick and a depth WR coming off of a significant knee injury.

 

[greenmountaingoat]

I was offered this trade yesterday.
16 team 1 QB IDP dynasty
I give up:
Rookie picks 3.5 and 3.10
I get :
2nd round rookie pick in 2026
This guy was the runner up on the league last year.

I replied back that he could maybe have one but not both. No response.
He already has two third round picks in this years draft, so I countered with those two picks for my 2nd rounder next year. No response.

I don't hate that deal. Would have countered with 3.5 and 4.-- for his 26 2nd. Consolidating value is usually a good move.

 

[greenmountaingoat]

1 QB 12 Team Dynasty
I was offered this:

I get:
Rondale Moore WR Min
4th pick in 2026 Rookie Draft

I give:
Roschon Johnson RB Chic

No thanks, Johnson situation is interesting this year considering that Chicago only added a 7th round rookie to their mix at RB. I'd need more than a late rookie draft pick and a depth WR coming off of a significant knee injury.

He's trying to unclog his roster on you. But if that's the worst deal you've been offered, you've otherwise been getting some pretty sweet offers.

 

[JohnnyU]

1 QB 12 Team Dynasty
I was offered this:

I get:
Rondale Moore WR Min
4th pick in 2026 Rookie Draft

I give:
Roschon Johnson RB Chic

No thanks, Johnson situation is interesting this year considering that Chicago only added a 7th round rookie to their mix at RB. I'd need more than a late rookie draft pick and a depth WR coming off of a significant knee injury.

None of those players look that good. Not sure I would put in worst trade thread. Perhaps we need a all bums thread for trades.

 

[Western_77]

1 QB 12 Team Dynasty
I was offered this:

I get:
Rondale Moore WR Min
4th pick in 2026 Rookie Draft

I give:
Roschon Johnson RB Chic

No thanks, Johnson situation is interesting this year considering that Chicago only added a 7th round rookie to their mix at RB. I'd need more than a late rookie draft pick and a depth WR coming off of a significant knee injury.

None of those players look that good. Not sure I would put in worst trade thread. Perhaps we need a all bums thread for trades.

Maybe, but at least Roschon is worth a "wait and see", with the new offense and second on the depth chart.

The owner making the offer said that he only made the offer to see how I felt about Johnson because he'd read reports that he'd fallen down the depth chart.

 

[The Future Champs]

I was offered this trade yesterday.
16 team 1 QB IDP dynasty
I give up:
Rookie picks 3.5 and 3.10
I get :
2nd round rookie pick in 2026
This guy was the runner up on the league last year.

I replied back that he could maybe have one but not both. No response.
He already has two third round picks in this years draft, so I countered with those two picks for my 2nd rounder next year. No response.

There’s a couple of unknowns in this trade; is the draft a snake draft, and does his team look equally strong this year? If the answer to both questions is yes, let’s assume that he’s projected for a similar finish this year, in which case it’s rookie pick #17~19 next year for this years #37 &#42. That’s not horrible. Low IDP value would make it more reasonable, high IDP value makes it worse.

ETA: ok, just ran it through KTC, which likes it for you, but KTC doesn’t take into account possible late pick inflated value due to IDPs.

 

[JohnnyU]

I was offered this trade yesterday.
16 team 1 QB IDP dynasty
I give up:
Rookie picks 3.5 and 3.10
I get :
2nd round rookie pick in 2026
This guy was the runner up on the league last year.

I replied back that he could maybe have one but not both. No response.
He already has two third round picks in this years draft, so I countered with those two picks for my 2nd rounder next year. No response.

There’s a couple of unknowns in this trade; is the draft a snake draft, and does his team look equally strong this year? If the answer to both questions is yes, let’s assume that he’s projected for a similar finish this year, in which case it’s rookie pick #17~19 next year for this years #37 &#42. That’s not horrible. Low IDP value would make it more reasonable, high IDP value makes it worse.

That’s what I thought but was afraid to say anything in case there was something I missed.

 

[msudaisy26]

I was offered this trade yesterday.
16 team 1 QB IDP dynasty
I give up:
Rookie picks 3.5 and 3.10
I get :
2nd round rookie pick in 2026
This guy was the runner up on the league last year.

I replied back that he could maybe have one but not both. No response.
He already has two third round picks in this years draft, so I countered with those two picks for my 2nd rounder next year. No response.

Doesn't seem like a bad offer at all. Pretty standard starting off point.

 

[mjb03003]

I was offered this trade yesterday.
16 team 1 QB IDP dynasty
I give up:
Rookie picks 3.5 and 3.10
I get :
2nd round rookie pick in 2026
This guy was the runner up on the league last year.

I replied back that he could maybe have one but not both. No response.
He already has two third round picks in this years draft, so I countered with those two picks for my 2nd rounder next year. No response.

There’s a couple of unknowns in this trade; is the draft a snake draft, and does his team look equally strong this year? If the answer to both questions is yes, let’s assume that he’s projected for a similar finish this year, in which case it’s rookie pick #17~19 next year for this years #37 &#42. That’s not horrible. Low IDP value would make it more reasonable, high IDP value makes it worse.

That’s what I thought but was afraid to say anything in case there was something I missed.

But isn’t a late 2nd in a 16 teamer actually pick 29-32? No one does snaking rookie drafts do they?

 

[Hot Sauce Guy]

Woke up to this offer
D Hopkins, 26 2nd and 3rd
for
My 26 1st

That’s… not good.

 

[Riffraff]

I was offered this trade yesterday.
16 team 1 QB IDP dynasty
I give up:
Rookie picks 3.5 and 3.10
I get :
2nd round rookie pick in 2026
This guy was the runner up on the league last year.

I replied back that he could maybe have one but not both. No response.
He already has two third round picks in this years draft, so I countered with those two picks for my 2nd rounder next year. No response.

Doesn't really belong in the thread. Most people enjoy getting the best player in a 2for1 trade.

 

[Gatorade]

I was offered this trade yesterday.
16 team 1 QB IDP dynasty
I give up:
Rookie picks 3.5 and 3.10
I get :
2nd round rookie pick in 2026
This guy was the runner up on the league last year.

I replied back that he could maybe have one but not both. No response.
He already has two third round picks in this years draft, so I countered with those two picks for my 2nd rounder next year. No response.

There’s a couple of unknowns in this trade; is the draft a snake draft, and does his team look equally strong this year? If the answer to both questions is yes, let’s assume that he’s projected for a similar finish this year, in which case it’s rookie pick #17~19 next year for this years #37 &#42. That’s not horrible. Low IDP value would make it more reasonable, high IDP value makes it worse.

That’s what I thought but was afraid to say anything in case there was something I missed.

Not a snake draft, so pick would be around #30. I would be okay with it if it was a 2025 pick, but to wait a year for that pick I would need more.

 

[Gatorade]

I was offered this trade yesterday.
16 team 1 QB IDP dynasty
I give up:
Rookie picks 3.5 and 3.10
I get :
2nd round rookie pick in 2026
This guy was the runner up on the league last year.

I replied back that he could maybe have one but not both. No response.
He already has two third round picks in this years draft, so I countered with those two picks for my 2nd rounder next year. No response.

Doesn't really belong in the thread. Most people enjoy getting the best player in a 2for1 trade.

Not sure that pick #30 next year will be better than either picks #37 or #42 this year. I was not even looking to trade. Someone else offered a 2026 second(probably late) for that #37. To me that is a reasonable offer

 

[phandango]

I'm doing an FFPC Triflex startup (superflex and TE premium). I have the 1.01. The guy with the 1.04 sent me an offer to trade up. Here it was:

Give: 1.01, 9.01
Get: 1.04, 10.09

Yes, the offer was for me to trade down twice. I rejected with the comment, "Not sure if you meant to send it like this." He never corrected it, and even though we've messaged and sent offers back and forth, he's never mentioned whether that was a mix-up. And all his offers have been indicative of someone who isn't interested in making anything close to a fair deal, only one that massively benefits him. So I went from "maybe he just fat-fingered that offer and sent it by mistake" to "maybe he sent it on purpose and hoped I wouldn't notice." I've done a ton of FFPC startups and have gotten offers sent by mistake, but they've always been corrected or withdrawn. Not with this guy. Weird.

Before the draft started, the same guy above was able to get someone to give him the startup 3.07 for a rookie 1st and 2nd. (For context, a rookie 1st is roughly worth a startup 7th; the guy's pick at 3.07 was Saquon Barkley.)

I mention all this because I messaged the league to say I'd be interested in trading into the 5th round and that my 2026 rookie picks were available. I got an offer of the 6.05 for my 2026 1st and 2nd -- from the same guy who previously traded his own 1st and 2nd for the 3.07.

 

[Gatorade]

I was offered this trade yesterday.
16 team 1 QB IDP dynasty
I give up:
Rookie picks 3.5 and 3.10
I get :
2nd round rookie pick in 2026
This guy was the runner up on the league last year.

I replied back that he could maybe have one but not both. No response.
He already has two third round picks in this years draft, so I countered with those two picks for my 2nd rounder next year. No response.

Doesn't really belong in the thread. Most people enjoy getting the best player in a 2for1 trade.

Not sure that pick #30 next year will be better than either picks #37 or #42 this year. I was not even looking to trade. Someone else offered a 2026 second(probably late) for that #37. To me that is a reasonable offer

That 2026 second (probably around #30) was eventually traded for 2025 picks #42 and #48.

 

[ffmail4me]

Just offered this steaming pile of crap

Give: Nabers, Hunter Henry
Get: Jayden Higgins, Sinnott, 2nd in 2026 (late 2nd most likely)

 

[Hot Sauce Guy]

Well it’s been a minute, so here’s the offer I rec’d today. Was it the worst ever? No. Was it a good or even decent offer? Also no.

12 team SF PPR TEP

we just finished the start-up 2 weeks ago.

The offer:
I give: Braelon Allen (13.11)
I receive: Rachaad White (17.09)

I-

I asked him why I wouldn’t have just taken White in the 13th, or any round between there & 17.09. He said “oh I didn’t check the draft picks.”

Huh

 

[Streetduck]

Same guy has offered me everyone of his DB's in individual trades for Rashee Rice. When I asked him to stop sending me streamable DB's for Rice he replied. Just counter offer.

 

[Gatorade]

Same guy has offered me everyone of his DB's in individual trades for Rashee Rice. When I asked him to stop sending me streamable DB's for Rice he replied. Just counter offer.

Counter offer Rice for his stud RB

 

[Buckna]

So I have a SF/TEP startup this coming weekend... I've gotten a few that were pretty far off, but this can only be a misclick or something:

I give the 3.12 startup pick
I get a 2026 3rd rounder & 5th rounder

 

[eighsse2]

So I have a SF/TEP startup this coming weekend... I've gotten a few that were pretty far off, but this can only be a misclick or something:

I give the 3.12 startup pick
I get a 2026 3rd rounder & 5th rounder

He's hoping you have no concept of the difference between startup and rookie drafts. "wElL it'S a 3rD fOR a 3Rd, pLuS I geT A fiFtH BacK?? aCcEPt!!!"

 

[Hot Sauce Guy]

So I have a SF/TEP startup this coming weekend... I've gotten a few that were pretty far off, but this can only be a misclick or something:

I give the 3.12 startup pick
I get a 2026 3rd rounder & 5th rounder

Startup >> rookie

It’s a concept that eludes many.

 

[eighsse2]

So I have a SF/TEP startup this coming weekend... I've gotten a few that were pretty far off, but this can only be a misclick or something:

I give the 3.12 startup pick
I get a 2026 3rd rounder & 5th rounder

Startup >> rookie

It’s a concept that eludes many.

And the farther down the list, the more extreme, I think is an accurate thing to say. The 1.01 rookie some years can be not crazy far behind the 1.01 overall. But, say, the 6.12 overall is the #72 player, which has pretty decent value, while the 6.12 rookie pick might be literally worthless in most leagues.

ETA: I guess there would be a "most extreme difference" at some point as you lower the draft slot more and more, and then it would start to become less of a difference, until the point where they are both worthless.

 

[Raging weasel]

Was offered this
I give- Tet and Mark Andrews
I get- Hunter and D Schultz

 

[msudaisy26]

Was offered this
I give- Tet and Mark Andrews
I get- Hunter and D Schultz

I don't think that is that bad.

 

[Raging weasel]

Was offered this
I give- Tet and Mark Andrews
I get- Hunter and D Schultz

I don't think that is that bad.

Not horrible but I was asking a 2nd for Andrews. Schultz would be a roster cut as I would still have Kittle and Mason Taylor at TE

 

[msudaisy26]

Was offered this
I give- Tet and Mark Andrews
I get- Hunter and D Schultz

I don't think that is that bad.

Not horrible but I was asking a 2nd for Andrews. Schultz would be a roster cut as I would still have Kittle and Mason Taylor at TE

I am on your side because I like Tet more than Hunter, but a lot of people like Hunter quite a bit more than Tet.

 

[Hot Sauce Guy]

Was offered this
I give- Tet and Mark Andrews
I get- Hunter and D Schultz

I don't think that is that bad.

Yeah, that’s a fairly decent offer. I’d rather have Tet/Andrews, but Hunter is theoretically more valuable than Tet. Right now. On paper.


Definitely not a “worst ever” candidate IMO.

 

[Raging weasel]

Was offered this
I give- Tet and Mark Andrews
I get- Hunter and D Schultz

I don't think that is that bad.

Yeah, that’s a fairly decent offer. I’d rather have Tet/Andrews, but Hunter is theoretically more valuable than Tet. Right now. On paper.


Definitely not a “worst ever” candidate IMO.

Yeah, probably should've posted it in the FFPC thread instead but this one was on main page.

 

[BearsFan4Life]

Was offered this morning:

Get: Kendre Miller
Give: AJ Brown

Am I missing news out of New Orleans?

 

[Hot Sauce Guy]

Am I missing news out of New Orleans?

nope, that’s just awful.

 

[greenmountaingoat]

In one of my leagues the dominant team has WRs:

Chase - Nabers - London - AJB - Jeudy- Pickens etc.

and Gibbs/ KW3/Conner/Charbs

My team needs to kick back for another year or two so I thought he would like the idea of Something centered around Chase Brown (he had AJB in his trade bait) and started off with trying to get Drake London. I was prepared to chip in a bit more but wasn't expecting this reply:

My Chase Brown for his Jerry Jeudy.

No such luck for me I guess. I have London in one of my other leagues. Think he could be one of the big breakout guys this year.

 

[msudaisy26]

Woke up to this one.

ARSB and Olave

for

Charbonnet and Garrett Wilson.

After 20 minutes of frantic Google searches to make sure ARSB's leg didn't fall off I accepted.

 

[DexterDew]

had to mention in the notes i was posting this, format doesn't matter but it's super flex

i give
Chase

i get
waddle
tuten
geno smith

 

[Hot Sauce Guy]

had to mention in the notes i was posting this, format doesn't matter but it's super flex

i give
Chase

i get
waddle
tuten
geno smith

 

[smbkrypt24]

the village idiot just offered me:

D. Adams for my Justin Jefferson

He wants me to get 6 years older for a worse WR in a worse spot (QB, team)?

Follow up. 12 team 1 QB. PPR.
This guy asks me what players I like on his team to work a deal out for nabers and/or Harrison.
I decided to play nice and named the players of interest for his team. I list Barkley, Mason, Mahommes, and Bowers.

He sends out an offer of his Mahommes and Mason for my Nabers and the throw in of Odunze.

Same owner strikes again. Yesterday, THE GUY reaches out and tells me his Stevenson and Mason are for sale. I ask what he is looking for and he proceeds to tell me how they are starting RBs and wants equal value WRs. I just ignore due to the education piece he added about starting RBs I figured he was overvaluing them. Fast forward to today I get the offer:

Send: M. Harrison, Odunze

Receive: Mason, Stevenson, 2026 1st, 2026 2nd (mid/late picks)

 

[Raging weasel]

the village idiot just offered me:

D. Adams for my Justin Jefferson

He wants me to get 6 years older for a worse WR in a worse spot (QB, team)?

Follow up. 12 team 1 QB. PPR.
This guy asks me what players I like on his team to work a deal out for nabers and/or Harrison.
I decided to play nice and named the players of interest for his team. I list Barkley, Mason, Mahommes, and Bowers.

He sends out an offer of his Mahommes and Mason for my Nabers and the throw in of Odunze.

Same owner strikes again. Yesterday, THE GUY reaches out and tells me his Stevenson and Mason are for sale. I ask what he is looking for and he proceeds to tell me how they are starting RBs and wants equal value WRs. I just ignore due to the education piece he added about starting RBs I figured he was overvaluing them. Fast forward to today I get the offer:

Send: M. Harrison, Odunze

Receive: Mason, Stevenson, 2026 1st, 2026 2nd (mid/late picks)

If I was a contender but starving at RB I would take that for just Harrison.

 

[smbkrypt24]

the village idiot just offered me:

D. Adams for my Justin Jefferson

He wants me to get 6 years older for a worse WR in a worse spot (QB, team)?

Follow up. 12 team 1 QB. PPR.
This guy asks me what players I like on his team to work a deal out for nabers and/or Harrison.
I decided to play nice and named the players of interest for his team. I list Barkley, Mason, Mahommes, and Bowers.

He sends out an offer of his Mahommes and Mason for my Nabers and the throw in of Odunze.

Same owner strikes again. Yesterday, THE GUY reaches out and tells me his Stevenson and Mason are for sale. I ask what he is looking for and he proceeds to tell me how they are starting RBs and wants equal value WRs. I just ignore due to the education piece he added about starting RBs I figured he was overvaluing them. Fast forward to today I get the offer:

Send: M. Harrison, Odunze

Receive: Mason, Stevenson, 2026 1st, 2026 2nd (mid/late picks)

If I was a contender but starving at RB I would take that for just Harrison.

To me even that is short sighted.

The Patriots drafted Henderson, who will likely replace Stevenson.
Mason I view as replaceable.
So I wouldn't want to sell Harrison for a short tern fix at RB and a mid/late first and second. If I was selling Harrison for RB help I would want someone more like Henderson and a Stevenson perhaps as starting points.

 

[BearsFan4Life]

14 team - 0.5 PPR - Yes I did inquire about Achane and said I would overpay a little for him if he were available. So I received this offer:

Get: Achane
Give: Njigba, Flowers and either Bill or Fannin

Njigba may be more valuable alone than Achane.

 

[Birdie048]

OK... So, I opened 0-3 and current points have me #11 of 12 so I sent out a few "feelers" for rebuild ideas...

Got this offer:

I get Jax WR T Hunter
I give Min RB J Mason, Mia RB D Achane, Chi WR R Odunze

HARD PASS. I am a big Rome fan. I prefer Rome over THunter even.

 

[eighsse2]

OK... So, I opened 0-3 and current points have me #11 of 12 so I sent out a few "feelers" for rebuild ideas...

Got this offer:

I get Jax WR T Hunter
I give Min RB J Mason, Mia RB D Achane, Chi WR R Odunze

HARD PASS. I am a big Rome fan. I prefer Rome over THunter even.

You give up the two biggest pieces in the deal, and chip in a backup RB who currently is in the starting role, for a "very good prospect" who's been okay out of the gate. But those roster spots, man! Never underestimate those. You could maybe pick up Xavier Legette and Jaydon Blue!

 

[Raging weasel]

Got offered Deebo and a 4th( mid to late) for my D London.
Countered with London and a 3rd for St Brown which was rejected in minutes.

 

[JohnnyU]

Got offered Deebo and a 4th( mid to late) for my D London.
Countered with London and a 3rd for St Brown which was rejected in minutes.

Rough offer.