What's new
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

What is the worst dynasty trade you have been offered? (3 Viewers)

JohnnyU said:
Counter for a 1st.  After all, that is a SF, where QBs cost you an arm and a leg.
Click to expand...
The other owner places very low values on QBs and is surprised that he can't get trades done. He posted in the league chat during the season that he offered a 2nd for Lawrence and a 4th for Wentz and couldn't believe that neither were accepted and then that he was glad that his "offer" for Lawrence wasn't accepted.

He made a bad offer to me for Trey Lance, initially a 3rd, then a 2nd max because "that's all a rookie QB is worth". I turned this around on him and offered him a 2nd (ended up being 2.03) for Zach WIlson. He accepted.

I countered with 4.01 for Garoppolo. He messaged back that he didn't understand the offer because he is trying to add QBs and that he's not going to be taking any in the rookie draft. I replied that I want to add QBs too at his valuation, like I did with Wilson, and that I was offering a better pick for a lower ranked QB. Then wished him good luck adding QBs at his price point. I'm not holding my breath that he will ever get it (it being realistic QB value in a SF) 😆

 
JohnnyU said:
I got what ended up being the 2.01 for Sutton and I’m ecstatic.
Click to expand...
That's cool if you are, but I wouldn't be.  As someone who acquired the 2.01 in 2 leagues this past year, I landed Michael Carter and Terrace Marshall.  I wouldn't trade Sutton for either at this point.

 
New MFL league year brings this doozy in a TE Premium PPR:

I give: 1.01, Renfro, St Brown and Freiermuth

I get: CEH, 1.10 and 2023 2nd

 
DexterDew said:
New MFL league year brings this doozy in a TE Premium PPR:

I give: 1.01, Renfro, St Brown and Freiermuth

I get: CEH, 1.10 and 2023 2nd
Click to expand...
That’s…less than a good offer. 
 

ETA Obviously imbalanced, but I ran it though a calc for giggles. 

you give: 417.65

you get: 260.30

:lol:  

 
Last edited by a moderator:
ghostguy123 said:
You guys gotta stop using these calculators.

I am seeing far too many horrible trades where people say it's close on their calculator.
Click to expand...
Uh, wut?

I said it wasn’t remotely close on calculator.

417-260 is close?  :unsure:

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Here’s the thing about trade calcs: if you have league-mates who use them religiously, you can take advantage in trades.

When dealing away my aging assets for my current rebuild, I got WAY better value than I expected because my trade partners used trade calcs. 

They’re not completely accurate, no. But that’s a 2-way street that sometimes works to your favor. 

ETA: I actually asked each of them which calc they used. I paid $10 for Dynasty Dominator. Was worth every penny to maximize those deals in my favor. 

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Hot Sauce Guy said:
Here’s the thing about trade calcs: if you have league-mates who use them religiously, you can take advantage in trades.

When dealing away my aging assets for my current rebuild, I got WAY better value than I expected because my trade partners used trade calcs. 

They’re not completely accurate, no. But that’s a 2-way street that sometimes works to your favor. 

ETA: I actually asked each of them which calc they used. I paid $10 for Dynasty Dominator. Was worth every penny to maximize those deals in my favor. 
Click to expand...


Well yeah, calcs are for nothing more than taking advantage of bad owners who actually use them

 
ghostguy123 said:
You guys gotta stop using these calculators.

I am seeing far too many horrible trades where people say it's close on their calculator.
Click to expand...
I love when someone sends and offer of five average players for one stud and uses the trade calculator numbers to justify how I'm getting more "points".

 
Not the worst ever but keeping the thread going...

I give up:

Harris, Najee PIT RB

Waddle, Jaylen MIA WR

Year 2022 Draft Pick 2.03

Year 2022 Draft Pick 3.03

I receive:

Akers, Cam LAR RB

Edwards-Helaire, Clyde KCC RB

Brown, Marquise BAL WR

 
Lehigh98 said:
Not the worst ever but keeping the thread going...

I give up:

Harris, Najee PIT RB

Waddle, Jaylen MIA WR

Year 2022 Draft Pick 2.03

Year 2022 Draft Pick 3.03

I receive:

Akers, Cam LAR RB

Edwards-Helaire, Clyde KCC RB

Brown, Marquise BAL WR
Click to expand...
OUCH

Cam recovering from Achilles, CEH recovering from Core Surgery/Gall Bladder & Hollywood Brown looking at a career as a Gamer!  (yes I know this is false rumor stuff)... 

 
14 team SF 1.5 TEP start 11
Give: 1.01, 1.06
Get: 1.13, 2023 1st, 2024 2nd

From the same manager who has previously offered me 4.14 for DeShaun Watson and a 3rd for Trey Lance that was upgraded to a 2nd (because that's all a rookie QB is worth).

 
Lehigh98 said:
Not the worst ever but keeping the thread going...

I give up:

Harris, Najee PIT RB

Waddle, Jaylen MIA WR

Year 2022 Draft Pick 2.03

Year 2022 Draft Pick 3.03

I receive:

Akers, Cam LAR RB

Edwards-Helaire, Clyde KCC RB

Brown, Marquise BAL WR
Click to expand...
Classic case of let me give you my problem guys for your good guys.

 
barackdhouse said:
New candidate:

FFPC SuperFlex

I give 1.02, Mitchell, 2023 2nd
I get Brady

Yes he holds some value now but get real.
Click to expand...
WOW...  that is amazing!  They could even consider that equitable?  Did you counter asking if you needed to include your 1st Born in case they missed that part?  

 
14 team PPR SF 1.5 TEP start 11
Was offered: DJ Chark + 2023 2nd for E Moore
Countered with: Mooney + 2023 2nd for E Moore
Received counter of: DJ Chark + 2023 2nd for E Moore

I believe countering with the initial offer that was rejected belongs in this thread. 🙄 C'mon man!

Maybe I should counter with my counter. 😇

 
zaner75 said:
14 team PPR SF 1.5 TEP start 11
Was offered: DJ Chark + 2023 2nd for E Moore
Countered with: Mooney + 2023 2nd for E Moore
Received counter of: DJ Chark + 2023 2nd for E Moore

I believe countering with the initial offer that was rejected belongs in this thread. 🙄 C'mon man!

Maybe I should counter with my counter. 😇
Click to expand...
Your should up your counter.   Clearly you meant Mooney and the 2023 1st.

 
zaner75 said:
14 team PPR SF 1.5 TEP start 11
Was offered: DJ Chark + 2023 2nd for E Moore
Countered with: Mooney + 2023 2nd for E Moore
Received counter of: DJ Chark + 2023 2nd for E Moore

I believe countering with the initial offer that was rejected belongs in this thread. 🙄 C'mon man!

Maybe I should counter with my counter. 😇
Click to expand...
You should absolutely counter with your same original counter. :lol:  

 
new owner took over a team and trying to make it his "own"

he sent offer of Cooks MIN RB for Williams DEN RB and my 1.05

i explained that i don't want to get older and all the Dynasty FF sites have Williams > Cooks

next offer is 2.08 for Higgins (who I put on the Trading Block to see what I might get)

his email explanation: I just thought if you wanted to move Higgins like you said that you might be willing to control the rookie you select🤦‍♂️

 
DexterDew said:
next offer is 2.08 for Higgins (who I put on the Trading Block to see what I might get)

his email explanation: I just thought if you wanted to move Higgins like you said that you might be willing to control the rookie you select🤦‍♂️
Click to expand...
Wut

 
I'm new to dynasty this year, which my new league mates knew going in. They're a by-and-large very open and friendly group and it's been really fun. But there's this one guy with the offers over the past 2 months..

14 team, 1QB league/ no IDP.

  • I get his 2.07+ 23 late 2nd for Javonte Williams
  • I get 1.02 for my (2) early 23 firsts
  • I get his late 23 first and his late 23 2nd for 1.01..  not in the same tier as the other two but not very close for me.
I declined all with no counter but emailed after the last one and and asked how far off we were if we did:

I get -1.02+Metcalf, he gets 1.01+ 23 first that projects to be in the 8-10 range. Figured he'd need a little more to get it done but it was closer to value than the other offers he'd send me. Declined politely.

 
Was offered Brady for Adams straight up.  Logic in the comments was "Top QB for a top WR"

I resisted the urge to point out the flaws of the comment for dynasty 

 
Hot Sauce Guy said:
Ran it through Dynasty Dominator & they gave the Brady side a 15% advantage.

Dynasty 101 heavily favors the Adams side. 
Click to expand...
Note to self:  Never consult Dynasty Dominator lol

Only way I see doing that trade is a superflex and you want to win this year.  Maybe if you have a terminal disease and know it will be your last season, then go for it. 

But, I never use trade calculators so maybe I am off in some of my dynasty opinions.  For me, the fun of FF is calculating value and trades myself.  Have a friend who runs EVERYTHING through a trade calculator and accepts or declines based on that.  Constantly complains FF isn't fun anymore.  

 
efactor said:
Note to self:  Never consult Dynasty Dominator lol

Only way I see doing that trade is a superflex and you want to win this year.  Maybe if you have a terminal disease and know it will be your last season, then go for it. 

But, I never use trade calculators so maybe I am off in some of my dynasty opinions.  For me, the fun of FF is calculating value and trades myself.  Have a friend who runs EVERYTHING through a trade calculator and accepts or declines based on that.  Constantly complains FF isn't fun anymore.  
Click to expand...
I just did it for lol’s.

i use calcs because a few league-mates do, and I’m able to occasionally get better deals as a result.

I could see doing the deal for Brady for a win-now team in either SF or 1-QB league. He’s old but he’s valuable so long as he’s a top QB. 

At some point the wheels will fall off the bus, but I’m not sure the offer is bad enough for this topic either way. 

 
Hot Sauce Guy said:
I just did it for lol’s.

i use calcs because a few league-mates do, and I’m able to occasionally get better deals as a result.

I could see doing the deal for Brady for a win-now team in either SF or 1-QB league. He’s old but he’s valuable so long as he’s a top QB. 

At some point the wheels will fall off the bus, but I’m not sure the offer is bad enough for this topic either way. 
Click to expand...
Adams is 3rd round startup pick right now.  Brady is like 11th.

It's horrific

 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

Ministry of Pain
New Dynasty League and we've had our first trade where people are asking questions
2
Replies
79
Views
795
JohnnyU
JohnnyU
ignatiusjreilly
Have I been starting the wrong BRobinson?
Replies
4
Views
518
ignatiusjreilly
ignatiusjreilly
Terpman22
Do you play fantasy football with your spouse?
Replies
27
Views
584
Saint
Saint

Users who are viewing this thread

Total: 2 (members: 0, guests: 2)
Back
Top