Speaking of odometers, Tesla is being sued in California for inflating odometer mileage on vehicles in order to get the vehicles to pass out of warranty more quickly.
Tesla is facing a proposed class action lawsuit in California accusing the company of deliberately inflating odometer readings in its vehicles. The lawsuit claims Tesla manipulated vehicle mileage data to shorten warranty periods and reduce […]
driveteslacanada.ca
The lawsuit, brought forward by law firm
Singleton Schreiber,
alleges the vehicle began logging an average of over 72 miles per day — nearly quadruple the 20 miles Hinton expected based on his driving habits. This sudden surge in mileage pushed the vehicle past the 50,000-mile limit of Tesla’s Basic Vehicle Limited Warranty, which covers repairs for four years or 50,000 miles, whichever comes first. When Hinton returned to Tesla for continued service, the automaker informed him the warranty had expired and refused to cover further repairs.
Then, Hinton alleges the mileage readings returned to expected levels after the warranty lapsed.
According to the claims in the lawsuit, Tesla’s odometer system estimates mileage using predictive algorithms that factor in energy consumption and driver behavior, unlike traditional odometers that rely on physical distance measurement. The lawsuit argues that Tesla assigns lower efficiency values to aggressive driving — such as rapid acceleration — causing the system to report inflated distances. These discrepancies, the complaint alleges, can artificially accelerate depreciation, force early warranty expiration, and pressure owners into purchasing extended warranties.
The lawsuit claims that Tesla’s algorithmic approach can inflate mileage readings, and that “Tesla knowingly overstates the distances traveled in Tesla vehicles,” calling the practice a calculated effort to reduce warranty-related costs and increase profit margins.
Tesla has not publicly commented on the lawsuit, and none of the claims have been verified in court.
Interesting. Presumably this also inflates their mile per charge rate.
This had to be unintentional. Don't they lease vehicles and don't those leases come with annual mileage limits? I'm surprised this hasn't come up before now. Surely leasees pay attention to mileage.
Pay attention to mileage how? I look at my odometer. I don't have a separate instrument to keep track of my mileage. If my car was doing this (intentional or unintentional), there's about 99.999% I wouldn't notice. This person only noticed because they knew how far they were supposed to be traveling. I doubt most of us know that outside of using our car's odometer.
Do you lease?
Yes.
Then we are different. I lease and I am quite conscious of the mileage because the cost of going over is very high. The story talks about how the owner drives the same commute every day and the odometer increase was noticeable. I would be in the same situation and I'm sure I would notice it.
This is a very strange conversation.
Of course I'm conscious of my mileage. You know how I watch my mileage? My odometer in my car.
I don't bring a separate odometer. I don't pull up Google maps for every trip and then compare it to my odometer.
That's my whole point. Unless you have something consistent to validate it against (this guy apparently traveled the same distance and knew exactly what it should be and then noticed there was a discrepancy), then this would be something very difficult for most to pick up.
You would? Fantastic. I would wager a SIGNIFICANT amount that you are in the vast minority.
If this turns out to be true, the fact this is the first we are hearing of it goes along with that.
Kind of the same way I'd have no idea if my speedometer was slightly off. Why? Because I use that speedometer for my speed and don't bring my own. Even though speeding can be costly.
Unless I am not in the vast minority, and this is just a glitch.
You are all over the place with your responses. I'm not even sure what you're trying to say at this point. The initial conversation we were having wasn't about whether or not this was a glitch. You made a statement that "surely leasees pay attention to mileage".
I countered that statement saying that yeah, I pay attention to the mileage by using the odometer in the car. If that odometer was faulty, I wouldn't really know. You then asked if I lease and stated you are conscious of mileage because cost of going over is high. That doesn't have much to do with my original statement, but I explained that yes, I pay attention to the mileage, but again, I pay attention using the odometer in the car. If that odometer is faulty, it would be very unlikely I would notice. I also stated that I think it's unlikely that most people would notice.
What does this being a "glitch" have anything to do with that position? I'm not arguing whether it happened or didn't happen, whether it's intentional or it's not intentional. I'm simply stating that IF it were happening in my car, it's highly unlikely I would have any idea because I don't compare my odometer to any anything else and I doubt most people do. Same way I don't check the temperature of my engine to compare to the temperature gauge, or the speedometer to my speed with a laser gun, or any other piece of equipment that is supposed to be accurate and calibrated. ESPECIALLY an odometer that is heavily regulated and shouldn't be tampered with due to laws and consequences of doing so.
The statement "if it turns out to be true, the fact this is the first we are hearing of it goes along with that" means exactly that. If these odometers have been not reading correctly (glitch, no glitch, intentional, not intentional, don't care), and it hasn't been brought up until recently, and assuming it's been happening a while, means most people didn't notice it was incorrect either.
Now, as for whether or not it's a "glitch", this is actually a class action suit. That means there's got to be at least a few drivers that this is happening to. And, whether intentional or not, glitch or not, that's illegal and it would be a major problem.
And this seems to be something that has been brought up before as well.
And, I'll state again, given that over 7 million Teslas have been sold and have been out for about a decade, and this lawsuit is just now being filed by someone noticing this in 2023 tells me this is not something that was obvious to most owners because MOST PEOPLE PAY ATTENTION TO MILEAGE USING THEIR CAR'S ODOMETER.