What's new
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Where does ROETHLISBERGER get DEALT ? (1 Viewer)

Where does BigBen get DEALT ?

  • San Francisco

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Seattle

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Oakland

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Cleveland

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Jacksonville

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Not Dealt

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Total voters
    0
What about Buffalo? Carolina? He could go to Carolina and be reunited with Cowher when he becomes the new head coach for the Panthers next year. :unsure:
Pittsburgh called Buffalo and were rebuffed.Carolina doesn't own a 1st round pick this yr.It's been reported that Pitt wants a top 10 pick for Ben.
 
What about Buffalo? Carolina? He could go to Carolina and be reunited with Cowher when he becomes the new head coach for the Panthers next year. :unsure:
Would be hard for Carolina to give them the picks they would need in trade as they are without their 1st rounder this year.
 
I would think if a team were to deal for him, it would have to be one with a solid fan base and doesn't care all that much about reputation. One not too far from contending and needs a QB. Jacksonville makes sense except the solid fan base.San Fran seems to meet the criteria.Oakland isn't close to contending although Ben would push that along. Davis probably doesn't care to build a team properly and maybe just maybe the rest of the team is solid if they had a good QB. I'll vote "not traded", but Oakland would be my guess if he is.
Jacksonville has a solid fan base of about 10 people.
It's funny how Jacksonville's fan base is called into question and no mention is made of Oakland's fan base. 2010 average home attendance:Jacksonville: 49.651Oakland: 44,282Both numbers are embarrassing, but might as well try and keep the playing field level.
I go to Oakland to see the A's play; went there last Saturday. The facility is a dump IMO, but I digress. Seeing the Raiders in that place, for those prices, with the lousy product, the continual stupid draft picks... no way am I spending big bucks to go there. Maybe when Al goes to that big Super Bowl in the sky things will improve, but after being 5-11 or worse for 5 straight seasons it doesn't surprise me at all that people don't go.
 
At first I thought San Francisco, but they've already had one fiasco with a guy and his pants on the ground so...
Besides, if Ben takes someone wearing a skirt into the bathroom in SF he may be surprised to discover 'more' than he bargained for.
 
This just posted at Rotoworld:

Ben Roethlisberger-QB- Steelers Apr. 21 - 3:30 pm et According to NFL Network's Jason La Canfora, the Raiders are in contact with the Steelers about a trade for Ben Roethlisberger.La Canfora says Oakland "might be (the) only real option" for Pittsburgh if the Steelers are truly prepared to wash their hands of the 28-year-old QB. The Raiders, smartly (for once), appear to have realized that JaMarcus Russell is a bust, and very arguably the biggest in NFL history. The Steelers might ask for Nnamdi Asomugha in addition to Oakland's No. 8 overall pick.
Schilens, Murphy, HeyBey, ZMiller owners may be about to get a boost.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
At first I thought San Francisco, but they've already had one fiasco with a guy and his pants on the ground so...
Besides, if Ben takes someone wearing a skirt into the bathroom in SF he may be surprised to discover 'more' than he bargained for.
:lmao:Reminds me of that old joke... why do cheerleaders in SF wear pants instead of skirts?P.S. San Francisco is probably my favorite city in the US, so please San Franciscans, don't take any of this the wrong way.
 
This just posted at Rotoworld:

Ben Roethlisberger-QB- Steelers Apr. 21 - 3:30 pm et According to NFL Network's Jason La Canfora, the Raiders are in contact with the Steelers about a trade for Ben Roethlisberger.La Canfora says Oakland "might be (the) only real option" for Pittsburgh if the Steelers are truly prepared to wash their hands of the 28-year-old QB. The Raiders, smartly (for once), appear to have realized that JaMarcus Russell is a bust, and very arguably the biggest in NFL history. The Steelers might ask for Nnamdi Asomugha in addition to Oakland's No. 8 overall pick.
I would gladly take that.
 
I would think if a team were to deal for him, it would have to be one with a solid fan base and doesn't care all that much about reputation. One not too far from contending and needs a QB.

Jacksonville makes sense except the solid fan base.

San Fran seems to meet the criteria.

Oakland isn't close to contending although Ben would push that along. Davis probably doesn't care to build a team properly and maybe just maybe the rest of the team is solid if they had a good QB.

I'll vote "not traded", but Oakland would be my guess if he is.
Jacksonville has a solid fan base of about 10 people.
It's funny how Jacksonville's fan base is called into question and no mention is made of Oakland's fan base. 2010 average home attendance:

Jacksonville: 49.651

Oakland: 44,282

Both numbers are embarrassing, but might as well try and keep the playing field level.
I know 49.651 is, like, almost 5 times the alleged number of 10. But, let's not act like it is 44,000.I'd also like to commend you on getting ahold of Marty McFly's Sports Almanac, can I get numbers from you?
Good one. :lmao: I'll edit the "2010" to "2009".

 
i imagine the "not dealt" option will be very popular with "wishful thinking steeler fan".
Why do you say that when by reading the Big Ben threads, one can easily see that the Steeler fans are just as mad at Ben than any other fans. Big talk around town the past week have been about getting rid of Ben. :shrug:Or are you just :lmao:
no :thumbup: at all.I'll go out on a limb and say that I believe a majority of Steeler fans will not be cool with them dealing BR for a top 10 pick, which is reportedly the asking price.
If a single top 10 pick is indeed the entire asking price, he's as good as gone.
 
That La Canfora guy has been spouting that for, like, three days now. Sounds like a Raider fan to me.

I don't see any logical explaination that would have the Steelers taking that poison contract of Nnamdi's off of the Raiders' books, no matter how much Al & Co. wish they would.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
This just posted at Rotoworld:

Ben Roethlisberger-QB- Steelers Apr. 21 - 3:30 pm et According to NFL Network's Jason La Canfora, the Raiders are in contact with the Steelers about a trade for Ben Roethlisberger.La Canfora says Oakland "might be (the) only real option" for Pittsburgh if the Steelers are truly prepared to wash their hands of the 28-year-old QB. The Raiders, smartly (for once), appear to have realized that JaMarcus Russell is a bust, and very arguably the biggest in NFL history. The Steelers might ask for Nnamdi Asomugha in addition to Oakland's No. 8 overall pick.
Schilens, Murphy, HeyBey, ZMiller owners may be about to get a boost.
geez. who would have thought of that one.
 
This just posted at Rotoworld:

Ben Roethlisberger-QB- Steelers Apr. 21 - 3:30 pm et According to NFL Network's Jason La Canfora, the Raiders are in contact with the Steelers about a trade for Ben Roethlisberger.La Canfora says Oakland "might be (the) only real option" for Pittsburgh if the Steelers are truly prepared to wash their hands of the 28-year-old QB. The Raiders, smartly (for once), appear to have realized that JaMarcus Russell is a bust, and very arguably the biggest in NFL history. The Steelers might ask for Nnamdi Asomugha in addition to Oakland's No. 8 overall pick.
I would gladly take that.
Asomugha would have to agree to re-do his contract if the Steelers were going to take him on. His deal is ridiculous.
 
That La Canfora guy has been spouting that for, like, three days now. Sounds like a Raider fan to me.I don't see any logical explaination that would have the Steelers taking that poison contract of Nnamdi's off of the Raiders' books, no matter how much Al & Co. wish they would.
They've got a day to figure out contract issues.
 
This just posted at Rotoworld:

Ben Roethlisberger-QB- Steelers Apr. 21 - 3:30 pm et According to NFL Network's Jason La Canfora, the Raiders are in contact with the Steelers about a trade for Ben Roethlisberger.La Canfora says Oakland "might be (the) only real option" for Pittsburgh if the Steelers are truly prepared to wash their hands of the 28-year-old QB. The Raiders, smartly (for once), appear to have realized that JaMarcus Russell is a bust, and very arguably the biggest in NFL history. The Steelers might ask for Nnamdi Asomugha in addition to Oakland's No. 8 overall pick.
Schilens, Murphy, HeyBey, ZMiller owners may be about to get a boost.
geez. who would have thought of that one.
:lmao: OK, sorry I posted something so obvious. I'll try harder next time.
 
That La Canfora guy has been spouting that for, like, three days now. Sounds like a Raider fan to me.I don't see any logical explaination that would have the Steelers taking that poison contract of Nnamdi's off of the Raiders' books, no matter how much Al & Co. wish they would.
They've got a day to figure out contract issues.
Why would Nnamdi want to re-negotiate his contract? Raiders deal ain't happening if they expect the Steelers to take Asomugha.
 
That La Canfora guy has been spouting that for, like, three days now. Sounds like a Raider fan to me.

I don't see any logical explaination that would have the Steelers taking that poison contract of Nnamdi's off of the Raiders' books, no matter how much Al & Co. wish they would.
They've got a day to figure out contract issues.
Why would Nnamdi want to re-negotiate his contract?

Raiders deal ain't happening if they expect the Steelers to take Asomugha.
And therein lies the rub. IB, I know you keep saying that they could re-structure his deal, but what possible motive does Asomugha have to facilitate this? He has the sweetheart deal of the century, he'd have to be nuts to tear that up unless they gave him a whopping amount of guaranteed money over a long-term deal. Otherwise, he collects either 15 million this year and becomes a free agent in 2011 or collects $32 million over the next two years and is a UFA in 2012.
 
I think he does get traded and I think it's to Oakland. It's to ideal. Al loves strong armed QB's and it's the one team that could care less about any bad PR Ben would bring. All Al see's is the great value he'll be getting acquiring aruably a top 5 NFL QB in the prime of his career.As a Steeler fan if Ben is dealt this will be the worst off season in the 32 years I've followed this team. Holmes gone for nothing and Ben for a first round draft pick. Now the team is stressing this zero strike policy which also means more than usual they will target character guys in the draft which means no chance of getting a guy like Dez Bryant. I'll say if Ben is traded it's the most pissed I'll ever have been at the Steelers FO. If I want to see choir boys on Sunday I'll go to church. Holmes and Ben were key in winning a SB which is what it's supposed to be about and not putting trying to win the solid citizen roster award.
Not sure why so many are angry with the Steelers FO. Ben has issues. He didn't get his act together after the motorcycle accident. Didn't wise up after the Reno allegation. And here we are ... one more strike and he gets cut and most likely a 1 yr suspension. He's a ####.
So what. Add all that up and all he's done so far is cost himself what looks like a 4 game suspension. If my choice is missing Ben for a 4 game timeout or just removing a franchise QB and possibly the most important player to the Steeler team in the last 30 years I think I'll just live with the 4 game time out.
 
That La Canfora guy has been spouting that for, like, three days now. Sounds like a Raider fan to me.

I don't see any logical explaination that would have the Steelers taking that poison contract of Nnamdi's off of the Raiders' books, no matter how much Al & Co. wish they would.
They've got a day to figure out contract issues.
Why would Nnamdi want to re-negotiate his contract?

Raiders deal ain't happening if they expect the Steelers to take Asomugha.
And therein lies the rub. IB, I know you keep saying that they could re-structure his deal, but what possible motive does Asomugha have to facilitate this? He has the sweetheart deal of the century, he'd have to be nuts to tear that up unless they gave him a whopping amount of guaranteed money over a long-term deal. Otherwise, he collects either 15 million this year and becomes a free agent in 2011 or collects $32 million over the next two years and is a UFA in 2012.
:lol:

 
This just posted at Rotoworld:

Ben Roethlisberger-QB- Steelers Apr. 21 - 3:30 pm et According to NFL Network's Jason La Canfora, the Raiders are in contact with the Steelers about a trade for Ben Roethlisberger.La Canfora says Oakland "might be (the) only real option" for Pittsburgh if the Steelers are truly prepared to wash their hands of the 28-year-old QB. The Raiders, smartly (for once), appear to have realized that JaMarcus Russell is a bust, and very arguably the biggest in NFL history. The Steelers might ask for Nnamdi Asomugha in addition to Oakland's No. 8 overall pick.
Schilens, Murphy, HeyBey, ZMiller owners may be about to get a boost.
geez. who would have thought of that one.
:lol: OK, sorry I posted something so obvious. I'll try harder next time.
no, no CP...not you. I was talking about the Oakland deal with Asomugha. I've been talking about that deal potentially for days.
 
Not sure how anyone could say Cleveland or Seattle. I just don't see Ben being effective in a WCO where timing is so important. His strength is down the field, which is why I think Oakland makes the most sense.

Not sure why anyone is worried about Pittsburgh's QB of the future. Could easily be Dixon. I thought he showed some legitimate skills and probably would have been drafted much higher if not for the injuries.

 
This just posted at Rotoworld:

Ben Roethlisberger-QB- Steelers Apr. 21 - 3:30 pm et According to NFL Network's Jason La Canfora, the Raiders are in contact with the Steelers about a trade for Ben Roethlisberger.La Canfora says Oakland "might be (the) only real option" for Pittsburgh if the Steelers are truly prepared to wash their hands of the 28-year-old QB. The Raiders, smartly (for once), appear to have realized that JaMarcus Russell is a bust, and very arguably the biggest in NFL history. The Steelers might ask for Nnamdi Asomugha in addition to Oakland's No. 8 overall pick.
Schilens, Murphy, HeyBey, ZMiller owners may be about to get a boost.
geez. who would have thought of that one.
:confused: OK, sorry I posted something so obvious. I'll try harder next time.
no, no CP...not you. I was talking about the Oakland deal with Asomugha. I've been talking about that deal potentially for days.
Ooooohhhhhhh.... sorry. My comment was a pretty obvious thing so I thought you were needling me for it. Gotcha.
 
Given how much the Seahawk population vilified Roethlisberger/Pittsburgh after Superbowl XL, I think it would be worth watching him get traded to Seattle just to watch all those fans have to eat their own kidneys over it. :confused:
I don't want to speak for the whole city of Seattle, but I think it's safe to say we hate the refs from that game, and most Steelers fans...not BB.
 
Not sure how anyone could say Cleveland or Seattle. I just don't see Ben being effective in a WCO where timing is so important. His strength is down the field, which is why I think Oakland makes the most sense.Not sure why anyone is worried about Pittsburgh's QB of the future. Could easily be Dixon. I thought he showed some legitimate skills and probably would have been drafted much higher if not for the injuries.
Kordell II, right down to the pick he threw when they desperately needed a play in a sure passing situation. Granted, I'm basing this on one whopping start, but Dixon will never be Roethlisberger, not in a million years.
 
Given how much the Seahawk population vilified Roethlisberger/Pittsburgh after Superbowl XL, I think it would be worth watching him get traded to Seattle just to watch all those fans have to eat their own kidneys over it. :confused:
I don't want to speak for the whole city of Seattle, but I think it's safe to say we hate the refs from that game, and most Steelers fans...not BB.
That makes sense.
 
That La Canfora guy has been spouting that for, like, three days now. Sounds like a Raider fan to me.I don't see any logical explaination that would have the Steelers taking that poison contract of Nnamdi's off of the Raiders' books, no matter how much Al & Co. wish they would.
They've got a day to figure out contract issues.
Why would Nnamdi want to re-negotiate his contract?
To get the hell outta Oakland?
 
Not sure how anyone could say Cleveland or Seattle. I just don't see Ben being effective in a WCO where timing is so important. His strength is down the field, which is why I think Oakland makes the most sense.Not sure why anyone is worried about Pittsburgh's QB of the future. Could easily be Dixon. I thought he showed some legitimate skills and probably would have been drafted much higher if not for the injuries.
Kordell II, right down to the pick he threw when they desperately needed a play in a sure passing situation. Granted, I'm basing this on one whopping start, but Dixon will never be Roethlisberger, not in a million years.
EG, if Ben is traded... Dixon/Leftwich, who do you see getting the starts at the beginning of the year if they don't draft Clausen? If they do draft Clausen? If they draft Clausen and he doesn't start right away, how long would you guess before he starts? Ben started after just one game his rookie year IIRC. Finally, if Ben stays in PIT do you see the Dixon/Leftwich starter being different for the suspension period than if he's dealt? I could see Leftwich having a better chance in this situation since it wouldn't be as important to develop the a young guy during that period if Ben is returning.
 
Seattle fan here, if we get Big Ben as our quarterback, I guess I will have to find a new team to root for. Count me out as a "shmuck". The only "shmuck" I see here is that rapist in Pittsburg.

I wonder how many shmucks here who have always had nothing but hatred for the Steelers/Big Ben are quietly hoping Ben goes to their team? :confused:
 
Not sure how anyone could say Cleveland or Seattle. I just don't see Ben being effective in a WCO where timing is so important. His strength is down the field, which is why I think Oakland makes the most sense.Not sure why anyone is worried about Pittsburgh's QB of the future. Could easily be Dixon. I thought he showed some legitimate skills and probably would have been drafted much higher if not for the injuries.
Kordell II, right down to the pick he threw when they desperately needed a play in a sure passing situation. Granted, I'm basing this on one whopping start, but Dixon will never be Roethlisberger, not in a million years.
EG, if Ben is traded... Dixon/Leftwich, who do you see getting the starts at the beginning of the year if they don't draft Clausen? If they do draft Clausen? If they draft Clausen and he doesn't start right away, how long would you guess before he starts? Ben started after just one game his rookie year IIRC. Finally, if Ben stays in PIT do you see the Dixon/Leftwich starter being different for the suspension period than if he's dealt? I could see Leftwich having a better chance in this situation since it wouldn't be as important to develop the a young guy during that period if Ben is returning.
Tough to say what would happen if they draft Clausen. I think ideally they'd be looking for him to be the starter in 2011, but if he proved to be the best chance to win out of camp, I don't think they'd balk at starting him day 1.If they don't trade Ben, I think you're dead on, Leftwich starts the first 4 games and turns it back over to Ben. If Ben is dealt and not for a QB, I think they give Dixon every chance to win the #1 job out of camp, but would not hesitate to make Lefty the season-long starter if he clearly outclasses Dixon in camp/pre-season.
 
That La Canfora guy has been spouting that for, like, three days now. Sounds like a Raider fan to me.I don't see any logical explaination that would have the Steelers taking that poison contract of Nnamdi's off of the Raiders' books, no matter how much Al & Co. wish they would.
They've got a day to figure out contract issues.
Why would Nnamdi want to re-negotiate his contract?
To get the hell outta Oakland?
I'd wager a 32 million dollar nut makes Oakland a lot more palatable and not something a guy is going to want to throw out the window.I re-iterate.....I seriously doubt Nnamdi is going any place, no matter how much the Raiders wished otherwise. The Raiders signed him to a retaaahded deal. They would need to find an equally retahhhded organization to divest themselves of that albatross. Maybe I'm wrong. I'm guessing I'm not.If the Steelers DO make a deal that involves Nnamdi, and he DOESN'T agree to re-negotiate, then Kevin Colbert should be immediately fired.
 
That La Canfora guy has been spouting that for, like, three days now. Sounds like a Raider fan to me.I don't see any logical explaination that would have the Steelers taking that poison contract of Nnamdi's off of the Raiders' books, no matter how much Al & Co. wish they would.
They've got a day to figure out contract issues.
Why would Nnamdi want to re-negotiate his contract?
To get the hell outta Oakland?
I'd wager a 32 million dollar nut makes Oakland a lot more palatable and not something a guy is going to want to throw out the window.I re-iterate.....I seriously doubt Nnamdi is going any place, no matter how much the Raiders wished otherwise. The Raiders signed him to a retaaahded deal. They would need to find an equally retahhhded organization to divest themselves of that albatross. Maybe I'm wrong. I'm guessing I'm not.If the Steelers DO make a deal that involves Nnamdi, and he DOESN'T agree to re-negotiate, then Kevin Colbert should be immediately fired.
Yeah, I was being a bit tongue-in-cheek.
 
That La Canfora guy has been spouting that for, like, three days now. Sounds like a Raider fan to me.
LaCanfora's background is as Redskin beat reporter for the Washington Post, and he was quite good at it. As far as I know he's had no connection to the Raiders.
 
Just adding Schefter's tweets:

Adam_Schefter Here are the known no's on interest in Roethlisberger right now: Rams, Bills. Others might not be, just not known yet.18 minutes ago via UberTwitter Adam_Schefter Here are teams that Steelers have called about Roethlisberger: Rams, 49ers, Raiders, Bills, Jaguars, Seahawks and Browns.
Following this story, we tried reaching out to the quarterbacks of each of these teams, but the phone number for the quarterback in St. Louis has been temporarily disconnected. Alex Smith kept asking if we were really looking for him. Jamarcus Russell seemed unconcerned until we asked to speak with Gradkowski. Trent Edwards told us we had the wrong number and hung up. Matt Hasselbeck confidently said "I'm going to be a quarterback, and I'm going to win!" , and Jake Delhomme seemed confused that Pittsburgh would trade away a quarterback to get picks, after Cleveland had traded for him in spite of all the picks, and finally, told of Shefter's tweet, David Garrard just said, "What the hell? Who else was on that list?"
 
I'm not questioning the worth of Ben but given the crazy trades this year, a single 1st seems like a good deal for both teams and then move on. Maybe a first and a 5th given 5th is the new?

Steelers have had good teams with out much at QB BUT they use to have a top 5 OL and would pound you into next week. That hasn't really happened since the Bus left town and FWP became well WP.

Would really change the draft if a sane person was picking at #8.

 
That La Canfora guy has been spouting that for, like, three days now. Sounds like a Raider fan to me.I don't see any logical explaination that would have the Steelers taking that poison contract of Nnamdi's off of the Raiders' books, no matter how much Al & Co. wish they would.
They've got a day to figure out contract issues.
Why would Nnamdi want to re-negotiate his contract?
To get the hell outta Oakland?
I'd wager a 32 million dollar nut makes Oakland a lot more palatable and not something a guy is going to want to throw out the window.I re-iterate.....I seriously doubt Nnamdi is going any place, no matter how much the Raiders wished otherwise. The Raiders signed him to a retaaahded deal. They would need to find an equally retahhhded organization to divest themselves of that albatross. Maybe I'm wrong. I'm guessing I'm not.If the Steelers DO make a deal that involves Nnamdi, and he DOESN'T agree to re-negotiate, then Kevin Colbert should be immediately fired.
Not saying it's likely, but restructuring is certainly more likely than it otherwise would be with this year being uncapped. Is it that unlikely that Pitt would offer him a Haynesworth-style contract where the big payday is for the first year or two but then the contract is very managable against the cap for the remaining 2-4 years?
 
I think Oakland is the only potential trading partner because they are the only organization screwed up enough to take Ben. That and the fact that there fans are desperate enough to win to accept him. The fact is Ben is a serious albatross over any organization he goes to. His reputation has pretty much been destroyed. He ruins jersey sales and merchandise sales for teams outside their own fan base. Kills the "role model" aspect for local kids. Puts a huge community spotlight on the franchise. Creates a major distraction for the team all season with constant dicussion in the locker room and in visiting team cities. Possible financial ramifications if he makes any other "questionable" decisions. There isn't going to be single football fan rooting for this guy or his team outside of the city he plays for, and even then there may be issues. The NFL is a business and when the face of your franchise is presumed to be a rapist in the court of public opinion you have a serious problem.

 
Can you imagine if a potential Oakland deal had J. Russell thrown in to seal the deal and he comes to Steeler Country and the change of scenery, some real coaching and supporting cast gets his attention. Maybe a strong coach like Tomlin causes him to change his work ethic and his ways and finally lives up to the hype and becomes an All-Pro?

That would be awesome!

 
Can you imagine if a potential Oakland deal had J. Russell thrown in to seal the deal and he comes to Steeler Country and the change of scenery, some real coaching and supporting cast gets his attention. Maybe a strong coach like Tomlin causes him to change his work ethic and his ways and finally lives up to the hype and becomes an All-Pro?That would be awesome!
It would also be awesome if the Tooth Bunny and Easter Fairy and Sandy Claws and Loch Ness Monster and Bigfoot were real, and I was young and rich and good looking...but... ;)
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Can you imagine if a potential Oakland deal had J. Russell thrown in to seal the deal and he comes to Steeler Country and the change of scenery, some real coaching and supporting cast gets his attention. Maybe a strong coach like Tomlin causes him to change his work ethic and his ways and finally lives up to the hype and becomes an All-Pro?That would be awesome!
Ch'yeah. And maybe monkeys will fly out of my butt!/waynecampbell
 
Can you imagine if a potential Oakland deal had J. Russell thrown in to seal the deal and he comes to Steeler Country and the change of scenery, some real coaching and supporting cast gets his attention. Maybe a strong coach like Tomlin causes him to change his work ethic and his ways and finally lives up to the hype and becomes an All-Pro?That would be awesome!
It would also be awesome if the Tooth Bunny and Easter Fairy and Sandy Claws and Loch Ness Monster and Bigfoot were real, and I was young and rich and good looking...but... :shrug:
The Tooth Bunny isn't real ? :rant: :cry:
 
Can you imagine if a potential Oakland deal had J. Russell thrown in to seal the deal and he comes to Steeler Country and the change of scenery, some real coaching and supporting cast gets his attention. Maybe a strong coach like Tomlin causes him to change his work ethic and his ways and finally lives up to the hype and becomes an All-Pro?That would be awesome!
Dont know about QB, but he could definitely help sure up the o-line...
 
If he lands in oakland, he'll be jumping in the black hole every chance he gets.

.....seriously, for an organization to go after him, when another strike dooms him, or hell, something resurfaces from the past(5th victim), it would set the team back years

 
I realize the Russell situation is far-fetched, but if you had to pick an organization to draft a QB early, pay him the big money while not giving him any real weapons (DMAC is an incomplete in my book) or protection and then cut him a few year later only to have him blow up on another team...who would you think that organization would be?

My point is...that is exactly the kind of thing Al Davis would do and especially when it would be part of a deal when they take the risk on a guy with baggage.

 
Given how much the Seahawk population vilified Roethlisberger/Pittsburgh after Superbowl XL, I think it would be worth watching him get traded to Seattle just to watch all those fans have to eat their own kidneys over it. :ph34r:
I don't want to speak for the whole city of Seattle, but I think it's safe to say we hate the refs from that game, and most Steelers fans...not BB.
I think/hope you're the very small minority. I hate BB (the Steelers QB, not a personal hate) more than probably any player in the league (as far as fandom likes/hates go, nothing to do with Bb the person, understand?). And I didn't want him at any cost or for any future potential before all this came out. I don't see how he could ever be accepted as a Seahawk.
 
i imagine the "not dealt" option will be very popular with "wishful thinking steeler fan".
Why do you say that when by reading the Big Ben threads, one can easily see that the Steeler fans are just as mad at Ben than any other fans. Big talk around town the past week have been about getting rid of Ben. :shrug: Or are you just :ph34r:
The only Steeler fans I see that are mad at BR are ACP and Crosseyed.
The vast majority of Steeler fans are mad at Ben. I am not opposed to a trade for a reasonable value -- the question is what is reasonable value?
They certainly won't get that. They are trying to sell one of the 10 most important players in the league for 10 cents on the dollar.

They've got as much chance of getting fair value for BR as they do of drafting another Santonio Holmes in the 5th round.

Steelers appear to be pawning off assets when their values have plummeted. Smart move.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Okies, so how about this question. How long is he gone for if he gets "excited" again and tries to get himself another un-willing partner? He just got 6 games with a possibility of it being reduced to 4. Is the next infraction a year? If so, do you really want to give up a high first round pick for him, make him your franchise QB and then possibly lose him because he can't keep his pants zipped?

 
Okies, so how about this question. How long is he gone for if he gets "excited" again and tries to get himself another un-willing partner? He just got 6 games with a possibility of it being reduced to 4. Is the next infraction a year? If so, do you really want to give up a high first round pick for him, make him your franchise QB and then possibly lose him because he can't keep his pants zipped?
That would mean the team only gets 5 years of Roethlisberger (assuming Ben is worthless after age 34 and won't re-sign).Will Jimmy Claussen, or any other 1st rounder not named Bradford (STL reportedly declined), be worth 5 years of one of the 5 best NFL QBs (keeping in mind that the draft pick will probably sign a 4-5 year contract, with alot of guaranteed money)? What are the chances that the team would've been lucky enough to actually predict and draft one of the very few players in this draft that might close to being worth 5 years of Roethlisberger?
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I don't think he'll be dealt. I'm going to go with what I just heard Schefter suggest: that the Steelers could be trying to put a scare in hm. And I don't see how another team could take him. It is not like with Vick, where time passed and the PR case could be made that he paid his dues, has done a lot of work to reform, yada yada. New team is left with "Well, the Steelers think he's trash, but we like that here in (new city).

 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top