What's new
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Willaimson or Cotchery (1 Viewer)

jurrassic

Footballguy
Who do you think will have the better year between this two? Williamson is the clear #1 but the Jets have been passing a ton and Cotchery already has 2 td's.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
I like Cotchery but then again I'm a Jets homer.

Williamson is in what appears to be a better and more consistent offence. But Cotch will be behind alot and clearly Pennington loves him and Coles will keep defenses looking his direction as well.

 
The Jets have been throwing a ton. The Vikes have been dedicated to the run, and Williamson has a 100+ yard game, and what could have been a 100+ game with a TD had he not had a case of the drops. I like the chances of Williamson continuing to do what he's done within the Vikes so for conservative game plan, than I do like the chances of the Jets continuing to light it up in the passing game.

 
Evans is headed to my bench and I'm deciding between these two guys. I like Williamson better but Cotchery is going to get a lot of chances.

 
Excuse me for going off topic, but at what point does this question belong in the ACF? Where do you draw the line? How much different is this question from "Advice Needed: Pick up Williamson or Cotchery?"

Seriously.

 
Excuse me for going off topic, but at what point does this question belong in the ACF? Where do you draw the line? How much different is this question from "Advice Needed: Pick up Williamson or Cotchery?"Seriously.
Williamson is on waivers?
 
Excuse me for going off topic, but at what point does this question belong in the ACF? Where do you draw the line? How much different is this question from "Advice Needed: Pick up Williamson or Cotchery?"Seriously.
Williamson is on waivers?
Well, I just searched on Jurrassic's posts & it looks like he started one thread in the ACF titled "Drop Henry for Cotchery?" and another one titled "Droughns and Housh for C. Taylor and Williamson?" So, I take it, in his league, Cotchery is on the wire & Williamson is on another team.I hope that answers your question. Next time I guess Jurassic should post his whole roster.
 
i don't get it:

crotchery plays for pass happy team with no running game and. coles is there to draw coverages. crotchery is looking to get more targets. he's already put up 12-186-2

while, williamson plays for a ball control running team who has other options in the red zone (mrob, chester) he's put up 10-179-0. also has a favorable schedule

i just feel that williamson may end up with more yards maybe, but crotchery will have more TDs.

 
Sigmund Bloom said:
Williamson, and it's not close.
Bloom,Why so emphatic? This reminds me a lot of when Anquan Boldin had such a strong start his rookie season and everyone kept calling it a fluke. Cotchery is a talented guy and I think the latest in a long line of NFL receivers to prove that straight line speed is one of the most overrated measurements scouts use on receivers. Williamson, who certainly doesn't lack straight line speed, also appears to have a bright future but the Vikings have a ton of weapons and I can't see why they won't continue to spread the ball around.
 
Sigmund Bloom said:
Williamson, and it's not close.
Bloom,Why so emphatic? This reminds me a lot of when Anquan Boldin had such a strong start his rookie season and everyone kept calling it a fluke. Cotchery is a talented guy and I think the latest in a long line of NFL receivers to prove that straight line speed is one of the most overrated measurements scouts use on receivers. Williamson, who certainly doesn't lack straight line speed, also appears to have a bright future but the Vikings have a ton of weapons and I can't see why they won't continue to spread the ball around.
I see Cotchery as more of a possession WR - his stats have benefitted greatly from facing Tennessee and a fluky long TD. Williamson looks electric every time he gets the ball in his hands, and is a threat to score at anytime. Cotchery is good, but his stats are somewhat connected to how much the Jets pass. Williamson has the ability to post a good week on one or two plays, even when the offense is not pass heavy. He can post 150+ if the Vikes do have to air it out. I wouldn't call Marcus Robinson, Jermaine Wiggins, and Travis Taylor "weapons". They are decent role players, but Williamson is the featured target in that offense.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Who do you think will have the better year between this two? Williamson is the clear #1 but the Jets have been passing a ton and Cotchery already has 2 td's.
Who are you going to pick up off your leagues waiver wire?
I think its Cotchery. He would have had 3 TD's but one was called back. This is his third season and Coles takes the double coverage not him.He has the opportunity more so in my opinion than Williamson.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top