Finally got the lineup with that roll: Total Slash for these guys: .284avg .379obp .471slg
1 C 1977 Gene Tenace R 0.233 0.415 0.41 29.1 C/A-/A+
2 OF 1981 Chet Lemon R 0.302 0.384 0.491 36.4 B/A-
3 OF 1978 Reggie Smith S 0.295 0.382 0.559 15.4 D/D+
4 OF 1977 Oscar Gamble L 0.297 0.386 0.588 13.2 B+-/D-
5 1B 1978 Willie Stargell L 0.295 0.382 0.567 13.9 B/D-
6 3B 1988 Bobby Bonilla S 0.274 0.366 0.476 24.3 C-/A+
7 2B 1992 Robby Thompson R 0.26 0.333 0.415 31.6 C+/A+
8 SS 1988 Scott Fletcher R 0.276 0.364 0.328 0 A/B
2 OF 1984 Dan Gladden R 0.351 0.41 0.447 85.5 B+/A-
Ok, Lineup is in. Looking middling, but as usual I tried to build according to batting order (not a believer in the order doesn't matter philosophy

)
Gladden might be the only best season offensively, though Fletcher's season is tops including defense. Got Thompsons weaker defensive season, but one of the best ranges from any second baseman, so I'll take that and the C+.
Gladden will be #2 hitter (maybe #1) against Lefties in addition to coming in for Gamble for defense and taking center for Lemon's 50-100 needed PAs. -2 HR park so other than the three thumpers in the middle, wasn't looking for HR punch, but it's there if needed.
Considering I started with 3 pitchers, not terrible.
ETA: Slash line isn't as ugly as I'd have thought. Not sure how its over .470 slugging considering some of the lightweights I have in there (either great D or really good OBP).