wouldnt this makes sense if you were the browns and the dolphins (1 Viewer)

[Chaser1439]

If you are the dolphins you make this move to save face. If you are the browns you already have a every day starter in Derek Anderson. The Dolphins are going to have a top 4 pick in next years draft. Why wouldnt they make this move?

 

[doughboydeluxe]

Anyone who gets taken with the Dolphins 2008 1st rounder >>>>>>>>>> Brady Quinn

 

[Doctor Detroit]

They also used a 2nd round pick 40th overall on a QB (Beck) this past year. Why on earth would they want Quinn especially for what may be the #1 overall pick? Did you think all this through?

 

[Tom Baker]

How about the Quinn for the Ginn family, straight up?

 

[Chaser1439]

just a thought. I am a dolphins fan and I feel that would give life to the team. Trade Beck. You are now in full rebuild mode so why not start rebuilding with a franchise QB

 

[Ace Matherton]

If you are the dolphins you make this move to save face. If you are the browns you already have a every day starter in Derek Anderson. The Dolphins are going to have a top 4 pick in next years draft. Why wouldnt they make this move?

Why would Miami give up their first round pick for a QB when they drafted what they feel will be the QB of the future in the second round this year? they would not, it makes no sense for them to even entertain a trade like this. Beyond the fact no one in theri right mind could be confident in anderson as an every day starter. Fantasy wise he's done very well, reality wise he's very mistake prone.

 

[Iwannabeacowboybaby!]

If you are the dolphins you make this move to save face. If you are the browns you already have a every day starter in Derek Anderson. The Dolphins are going to have a top 4 pick in next years draft. Why wouldnt they make this move?

You just answered your own question. The Dolphins are going to have a top 4 pick and Quinn was selected like 22nd. How is that a fair trade for Miami?

 

[TME]

If they thought Quinn was any good they would have taken him in April.

 

[duaneok66]

If they thought Quinn was any good they would have taken him in April.

and the above post should end this thread . . .

 

[moondawg]

If they thought Quinn was any good they would have taken him in April.

Nobody in that organization has a clue on how to evaulate players---- signed a far over the hill Joey Porter and Trent Green, trade Welker away, etc and then pass on Quinn for a WR, give me a break.

 

[stanmarino13]

Browns would take the sb cap hit? Fins give up on Beck, and give up a top 5 pick? Sounds like one of those trades u might do in ur Madden game

 

[ooofffaaa]

Anyone who gets taken with the Dolphins 2008 1st rounder >>>>>>>>>> Brady Quinn

Contrary to what everybody else thinks the Dolphins are really high on John Beck.It will be interesting if they get the 1st pick who they will take.They'll have no use for Brohm or McFadden.

 

[-OZ-]

Contrary to what everybody else thinks the Dolphins are really high on John Beck.It will be interesting if they get the 1st pick who they will take.They'll have no use for Brohm or McFadden.

3 points!Fins should trade Jason Taylor, Zach Thomas, etc. NOT a pick for Quinn, who frankly, probably won't be better than Beck anyway.I've lost track, when is the trade deadline?

 

[Steeler07]

Not happening. And considering how lame ND is right now Quinn certainly carried that team. Rusell will be the huge bust.

 

[burd]

Quinn, at this point in his career is no more a "savior" than Beck. Why give up on Beck before he's been given a chance to succeed? Being familiar w/ a pro-style offense doesn't guarantee Quinn will play well in games. Beck, from what ive seen in college has just as good a chance at being the real deal ... and anyone who's semi-familiar w/ pro football knows that college pedigrees don't mean jack in the NFL ... just ask all the great former QBs that were overlooked.

If I were Miami, i'd hold onto that top-5 pick. If they must feel the need to address the QB position, players like Losman and yet-to-be-named disgruntled franchise QB are more of a sure-thing than Quinn. First and foremost, Miami must address the area at which they're most in need ... GM. Even Matt Millen is laughing at the Fins.

 

[bigfeet_88]

Why wouldnt they make this move?

I've lost track, when is the trade deadline?

Win.

 

[David Yudkin]

I've lost track, when is the trade deadline?

The trade dealine was 4 PM Tuesday 10/16.