Otis said:
Noom has been pretty solid in getting me out of this rut. I even have been having a glass or two of wine at night, and a few Hershey kisses or crackers etc. Making it all work.
I can smell sub-220 like a warm fresh-baked brownie.
I signed up for Noom last week too, I like it so far. It's nothing groundbreaking/that different than MyFitnessPal but I like the red/yellow/green way of looking at things. For the weekend I basically planned out my days based on those categories to enable to me stay within them but also do what I want to do. I always eat very well and exercise during the week but come Friday through Sunday afternoon, it's a blizzard of beer and overeating. I'm at a similar weight to you Otis, at 227 at present - been as high as 240 and ideal is probably around 200, though 210-215 is my short term target.
I also like how Noom considers exercise in terms of the calorie budget - it basically gives you back half of what you earn, so if I go for a run that in theory burns 600 calories, it gives 300 extra. I think this is helpful in letting you reward yourself for the exercise but also not go off the rails with the health halo effect of "oh I ran 3K, I can eat that whole pizza".
The big thing for me is beer, I won't give it up, I don't want to give it up - but by logging the calories from it honestly, I have switched to lighter beers and probably a couple less than I'd normally have
If anyone's interested, my weekend looked like this:
Friday - 2050 calorie allowance (ran 5K and walked 9.5K - walked to the pub and back to pick up some curbside beer for weekend), 1763 calories used
- Green 405 calories - lentil soup, banana, grapes, coffee
- Yellow 910 calories - 4 slices thin crust pizza, one 4% beer
- Red 448 calories - 2 x IPA beer
Saturday - 1780 calorie allowance (did 40 mins circuit training), 1757 calories used
- Green 346 calories - spaghetti squash, homemade marinara sauce, apple, whole wheat english muffin
- Yellow 948 calories - 2 eggs, bahn mi sandwich, plant based chicken breast, helles lager
- Red 463 calories - margarine, 2x IPA beer
Sunday - 1790 calorie allowance (ran 5.5 km), 1724 calories used
- Green 782 calories - whole wheat english muffin, lentil soup, roasted potatoes, black bean burger patty
- Yellow 787 calories - plant based sausage patty, one egg, 1/2 cup pasta salad, 2x pilsner, 2x light beer
- Red 155 calories - burger bun, margarine
So, the obvious takeaway is maybe don't have ten beers over the weekend but for me, it's the fact that I was able to still have those beers, still have pizza Friday, still have chicken parm Saturday (though on Spag squash), still have a mothers day BBQ Sunday and keep it within a moderate range. Usually I weigh in about 4 lbs heavier on Monday than I was Friday morning, today I was about the same (within a pound) and now during the week when I won't have ten beers, I can get some losses going.