Jump to content
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums

Dynasty Value Discussion Thread

spider321

By spider321,
in The Shark Pool (NFL Talk)

 Share Followers 15

Recommended Posts

Concept Coop

Concept Coop 1,764

Posted
Posted
3 minutes ago, FF Ninja said:

If I could legitimately get those prices, I would sell most of those players at that dynasty value you listed. 

I think those are about the prices you'd have to pay to acquire these guys right now. Top 15 sounds really high for the WRs, but take a look at the names in that range - Diggs, Thielen, Cooks, Hilton, Golladay, Lockett - I'd take Chark and Sutton over some of those guys. (I haven't done my homework yet on McLaurin.)

To answer my own question, I'd buy Godwin, Sutton, all 3 TEs, Jackson, and Jacobs at those prices.

Link to post
Share on other sites
  • Replies 11.5k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Popular Days

Top Posters In This Topic

Popular Days

Popular Posts

EBF

Tentative rookie RB/WR tiers after diving into clips and stats this weekend:   RB Josh Jacobs, Raiders - No major weaknesses and walks into a starting role. Power, hands, elusiveness, and e

onionsack

That is interesting. As a Gordon owner here and there, I think I'd have jumped on that offer in any league I have him, without even looking at my own roster or that of the owner sending me the pick.

FreeBaGeL

Wow I think people really need to go back and look at the last 10 years of 1st/2nd round NFL WR picks.  These guys hit at what, a 20% rate?  15%?  It's a miserable number.  I'd be pretty surprised if

FF Ninja

FF Ninja 2,842

Posted
Posted
10 minutes ago, Concept Coop said:

I think those are about the prices you'd have to pay to acquire these guys right now. Top 15 sounds really high for the WRs, but take a look at the names in that range - Diggs, Thielen, Cooks, Hilton, Golladay, Lockett - I'd take Chark and Sutton over some of those guys. (I haven't done my homework yet on McLaurin.)

To answer my own question, I'd buy Godwin, Sutton, all 3 TEs, Jackson, and Jacobs at those prices.

As always, in a seller's market you'll have to pay a premium if you're trying to pry a player away from a team that wasn't shopping him, but if you were to be selling RBs to a team with extra WRs in need of RBs, I don't think you'd have to pay a top 15 WR price for Chark, McLaurin, or Sutton. But most importantly, if you were to do a startup right now, I would not expect to see those guys be taken in the top 15 of their position. 

Link to post
Share on other sites
Concept Coop

Concept Coop 1,764

Posted
Posted (edited)
22 minutes ago, FF Ninja said:

As always, in a seller's market you'll have to pay a premium if you're trying to pry a player away from a team that wasn't shopping him, but if you were to be selling RBs to a team with extra WRs in need of RBs, I don't think you'd have to pay a top 15 WR price for Chark, McLaurin, or Sutton. But most importantly, if you were to do a startup right now, I would not expect to see those guys be taken in the top 15 of their position. 

Chark and Sutton will be going well before WR15 in off-season startup drafts if their current production holds. It's certainly reasonable to bet against that happening, but that startups aren't taking place right now is kind of the point of the exercise. In general, if you're buying these guys right now it's because you're sold and are paying accordingly.

Edited by Concept Coop
  • Like 1
Link to post
Share on other sites
Gally

Gally 4,831

Posted
Posted
1 hour ago, wgoldsph said:

Who do you consider a top 10wr if not Godwin?

These are all guys I would want over Godwin (in no particular order)

Hopkins, Thomas, OBJ, Adams, Thielen, Hill, Julio, Cooper, Allen, JuJu, Evans, Kupp……..

 

I am not saying Godwin can't beat out any of those guys but I would rather have those other guys over him....It's a toss up for me between Godwin, JuJu, Evans, Allen, Kupp, Thielen, Cooper, Julio……...so I guess I have them all kind of in the same tier so to speak.  The other guys would be a tier above. 

Link to post
Share on other sites
Hankmoody

Hankmoody 3,775

Posted
Posted
6 hours ago, Concept Coop said:

Are you buying or selling the sustainability of these breakouts? Proposed dynasty value in (). 

Chark (top 15 WR) Want to sell but can't argue with the eyes.  Grudgingly buy expecting the floor to cave in.

Sutton (top 15 WR) Buy all in

Godwin (top 3 WR) Sell

Kupp (top 10 WR) Buy

McLaurin (top 15 WR) Torn and probably can't be unbiased with my Scarlet and Gray goggles on

Andrews (top 5 TE) Buy buy buy

Hooper (top 5 TE) Sell but not discounting him

Waller (top 5 TE) Buy

Jackson (top 3 QB) Buy all in

Jacobs (top 10 RB) Buy, situation is too good and his talent is sufficient.  I'd comp him at Curtis Martin, talented compiler that just keeps getting opportunities to compile.

 

 

  • Like 1
  • Thanks 1
Link to post
Share on other sites
Just Win Baby

Just Win Baby 2,611

Posted
Posted (edited)
On 10/23/2019 at 6:00 PM, Concept Coop said:

Chark and Sutton will be going well before WR15 in off-season startup drafts if their current production holds

Intuitively I did not agree with this, so I took a look. First, here are the current top 15 WRs in total points (1 PPR):

  1. Thomas
  2. Godwin
  3. Diggs
  4. Kupp
  5. Cooper
  6. Chark
  7. Julio
  8. Hopkins
  9. Allen
  10. Lockett
  11. Edelman
  12. Sutton
  13. Thielen
  14. Robinson
  15. McLaurin

Here is the current top 15 in PPG (1 PPR):

  1. Godwin
  2. Thomas
  3. Kupp
  4. Cooper
  5. Hilton
  6. Jackson
  7. Chark
  8. Robinson
  9. Julio
  10. Hopkins
  11. Allen
  12. Ross
  13. Diggs
  14. Evans
  15. Lockett

Chark shows up on both of those lists, but Sutton is #20 in PPG.

That is 19 total names in those lists above. That group does not include these notable WRs, all of whom were top 15 in ADP as of 9/4/19:

  1. Adams - ADP 2
  2. Beckham - ADP 5
  3. Juju - ADP 6
  4. Hill - ADP 7
  5. Antonio Brown - ADP 8
  6. Thielen - ADP 10
  7. Cooks - ADP 15

So we have at least 26 candidates for next year's top 15 startup WRs, along with any rookies who warrant top 15 consideration. I'm not familiar with that rookie class yet, so will ignore them for now.

As of today, I expect these guys are locks for top 15 startup value next year, barring catastrophic injury and/or off field events (in no particular order):

  1. Thomas - top 2 on both lists despite Brees injury; 26 years old
  2. Godwin - top 2 on both lists despite presence of Evans and subpar QB play; 23 years old
  3. Kupp - top 4 on both lists despite presence of Cooks and Woods; 26 years old
  4. Cooper - top 5 on both lists; 25 years old
  5. Julio - top 10 on both lists; on pace for 6th straight season over 1400 receiving yards; 30 years old
  6. Hopkins - top 10 on both lists; finished top 4 in 3 of previous 4 seasons; expect he will finish 2019 higher than his current ranking; 27 years old
  7. Adams - numbers currently down due to transition to new offense and injury that will not linger into future seasons; 26 years old
  8. Beckham - numbers currently down due to transition to new offense; expect he will finish 2019 higher than his current ranking; expect Kitchens will be gone, creating optimism for improved offense; 26 years old
  9. Juju - only 6 games in and has played 4.5 games with QB2 Rudolph and QB3 Hodges; expect he will finish 2019 higher than his current ranking; expect Roethlisberger will return, creating optimism for improved offense; 22 (!) years old
  10. Hill - left game 1 early due to injury, skewing his numbers; his PPG in the 2 full games he has played rank him #3 right now, and that is despite Mahomes playing at less than 100% in those games and QB2 Moore playing most of 1 of them; 25 years old

I suspect that could be next year's top 10 right there. In order for Chark and Sutton to be drafted "well before" top 15, they would pretty much have to be the next 2 choices. Meaning they would have to be drafted ahead of all of these guys (in no particular order):

  1. Evans
  2. Diggs
  3. Allen
  4. Lockett
  5. Thelien
  6. Hilton
  7. Robinson
  8. All rookies
  9. All older veterans (e.g., Edelman, Green, Brown)
  10. Any other young WR who has a strong performance the rest of 2019 (e.g., Marquise Brown)

I suppose it could happen, but I'm surprised at the confidence of your claim.

Edited by Just Win Baby
  • Like 1
Link to post
Share on other sites
Interseptopus

Interseptopus 5,722

Posted
Posted
On 10/23/2019 at 5:00 PM, Concept Coop said:

Chark and Sutton will be going well before WR15 in off-season startup drafts if their current production holds. It's certainly reasonable to bet against that happening, but that startups aren't taking place right now is kind of the point of the exercise. In general, if you're buying these guys right now it's because you're sold and are paying accordingly.

agree. two under rated guys for 2020

Link to post
Share on other sites
ConnSKINS26

ConnSKINS26 5,718

Posted
Posted
2 hours ago, Concept Coop said:

If Chark finishes with the 1,300/11 that he’s on pace for, he’ll go ahead of Kupp, Julio, and Adams, too. Or should. Sutton might need to pick it up just a bit.

 

Adams seems like the type of guy who will hang onto a high ranking despite the injury plagued year, unless the Packers do something drastic

Link to post
Share on other sites
Concept Coop

Concept Coop 1,764

Posted
Posted (edited)
2 hours ago, ConnSKINS26 said:

Adams seems like the type of guy who will hang onto a high ranking despite the injury plagued year, unless the Packers do something drastic

I don’t disagree. But those numbers at 23, coupled with the athletic profile and solid draft capital - Chark is going to be a high end dynasty asset if he can keep it up. I think plenty of owners will take Chark and the 3.5 years. I could certainly be wrong, and I do agree that Adams’ value will hold relatively steady.

Edited by Concept Coop
  • Like 1
Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 2 weeks later...
Birdie048

Birdie048 316

Posted
Posted
9 hours ago, Ashem said:

Price check on Chris Carson? Start 2 RB, 1 PPR league. Took over a team that looks like it's 2 years away from being 2 years away.

I made an offer 3 weeks ago on Carson... 12 Team Dynasty PPR 1/2/2/1 & 2 Flex   

Note:  Offer was made when Kamara was out and Freeman was healthy... and they needed RB2 help (their RB depth = Ballage & Hines)

Offered ATL RB D Freeman & NOS RB L Murray and a 3rd (late) for Carson  ...  rejected and no counter or feedback.  They have since lost 3 in a row.  

Link to post
Share on other sites
DAG

DAG 261

Posted
Posted
38 minutes ago, bicycle_seat_sniffer said:

what do we think about juju vs sutton/chark types rest of season? are we sure ben comes back? long term is juju a slam dunk over those types?....

Good question. All 3 arguably have long term QB questions. Even if Ben comes back next year we have to ask what life after his career is like for JuJu. I still have JuJu above Chark and Sutton but I’m guessing his value will vary widely based on how individuals in our leagues view his talent. Recency probably means you’d have to offer JuJu almost straight up for guys in the Chark/Sutton tier; at least that’s what I’d expect in my leagues. I don’t  feel comfortable selling at that price. 

Link to post
Share on other sites
bicycle_seat_sniffer

bicycle_seat_sniffer 5,109

Posted
Posted
10 minutes ago, DAG said:

Good question. All 3 arguably have long term QB questions. Even if Ben comes back next year we have to ask what life after his career is like for JuJu. I still have JuJu above Chark and Sutton but I’m guessing his value will vary widely based on how individuals in our leagues view his talent. Recency probably means you’d have to offer JuJu almost straight up for guys in the Chark/Sutton tier; at least that’s what I’d expect in my leagues. I don’t  feel comfortable selling at that price. 

thanks for the response....im debating an offer in a league... seems like a no brainer.....but yet i hesitate to pull the trigger 

Link to post
Share on other sites
Concept Coop

Concept Coop 1,764

Posted
Posted
2 hours ago, bicycle_seat_sniffer said:

what do we think about juju vs sutton/chark types rest of season? are we sure ben comes back? long term is juju a slam dunk over those types?....

Rest of season I think Chark and Sutton are clear upgrades over Juju. In terms of dynasty value, I don’t think it’s a slam dunk, but still prefer Juju. He’s younger, has proven more, and has more trade value, should I decide to move him in the near future.

I expect Ben to come back, and the Steelers to put more around Rudolph if not. I think Juju’s situation is likely to improve next season.

Link to post
Share on other sites
The Captain

The Captain 529

Posted
Posted (edited)

Thoughts on Guice value right now in non-ppr dynasty?  Value could either jump or decline once he starts getting touches so if you wanted to sell before he hits the field what would it take? 

Edited by The Captain
Link to post
Share on other sites
kutta

kutta 5,526

Posted
Posted

I own Barkley and pretty much vowed to never trade him.

But, the Kamara owner is sniffing around and he owns 4 first round picks next year, three of them will be mid-late and one will be early-mid.

What's the consensus on Barkley's value at this point. I cant believe that I would find myself turning down Kamara and two 2020 firsts, but I'm not sure I could pull the trigger there.

Link to post
Share on other sites
Birdie048

Birdie048 316

Posted
Posted
2 hours ago, The Captain said:

Thoughts on Guice value right now in non-ppr dynasty?  Value could either jump or decline once he starts getting touches so if you wanted to sell before he hits the field what would it take? 

Guice (IMO) short term is not going to help any competitive team this year... Wash Offense is not firing on the right cylinders.... 

Long Term - I think they can repair things to for him to be a valuable RB2 but the Off/OL limitations cap his value.  

Link to post
Share on other sites
tkrull

tkrull 405

Posted
Posted
1 hour ago, kutta said:

I own Barkley and pretty much vowed to never trade him.

But, the Kamara owner is sniffing around and he owns 4 first round picks next year, three of them will be mid-late and one will be early-mid.

What's the consensus on Barkley's value at this point. I cant believe that I would find myself turning down Kamara and two 2020 firsts, but I'm not sure I could pull the trigger there.

Ask for another 1st, but I'd have no problem accepting Kamara and 2 2020 1sts.

Link to post
Share on other sites
kutta

kutta 5,526

Posted
Posted
7 minutes ago, tkrull said:

Ask for another 1st, but I'd have no problem accepting Kamara and 2 2020 1sts.

There's been no offer yet, just some chatting back and forth. I'm really struggling with this one.

Thanks for your thoughts.

Link to post
Share on other sites
Arodin

Arodin 3,083

Posted
Posted

Kamara and the early first or Kamara and two late ones would be enough to tempt me.  Early plus two late would be more of an offseason move when I no longer needed an RB in a lineup this week.

That said, it is situational.  My current home league team has Barkley and is a perennial contender.  It doesn’t need more depth so I’d rather consolidate into star players than break them up into multiple lesser assets.  I wouldn’t do the deal there.

Another league, where my dynasty is crumbling thsnks to Antonio going nuts and Rivers falling off a cliff, the idea of 2-4 talents in this rich upcoming draft class that could outlast Barkley by years once the rebuild is over, and I’d be happy to move on.

  • Like 2
Link to post
Share on other sites
RC94

RC94 2,032

Posted
Posted
6 hours ago, hispeedthinmint said:

Who has more value, long term, in PPR; Malcolm Brown or Josh Reynolds?

IMO Reynolds, but he will probably have to leave the crowded LAR WRs until he gets a consistent chance to play a significant role.

  • Like 1
Link to post
Share on other sites
kutta

kutta 5,526

Posted
Posted
4 minutes ago, JoeJoe88 said:

How would you guys rank these five WR's in terms of dynasty value?  I had a pretty difficult time with this:

DJ Moore

Chris Godwin

Christian Kirk

Kenny Golladay

DJ Chark

Damn. That’s tough. 
 

Chark last. Golladay first. Godwin a close second. Moore and Kirk a close third and fourth.

I think...

  • Thanks 1
Link to post
Share on other sites
barackdhouse

barackdhouse 2,182

Posted
Posted
7 minutes ago, JoeJoe88 said:

How would you guys rank these five WR's in terms of dynasty value?  I had a pretty difficult time with this:

DJ Moore

Chris Godwin

Christian Kirk

Kenny Golladay

DJ Chark

Godwin, Golladay, Chark, Kirk, Moore (somebody had to be last)

I think Kirk is the biggest x-factor out of these for me

  • Thanks 1
Link to post
Share on other sites
King of the Jungle

King of the Jungle 1,390

Posted
Posted (edited)
1 hour ago, JoeJoe88 said:

How would you guys rank these five WR's in terms of dynasty value?  I had a pretty difficult time with this:

DJ Moore

Chris Godwin

Christian Kirk

Kenny Golladay

DJ Chark

Good list. I could see valid points for any order. Many of their QBs are up in the air and Kirk may be on the most solid ground there. If gun to head:

Kenny Golladay. Seems like the one most capable of being a WR1. This is assuming Stafford continues to QB the Lions.

Chris Godwin. Great player but gets the benefit of having Big Mike take the top corners. QB a concern going forward but is a good security blanket for a young signal caller.

DJ Moore. Love him as a player, just not sure he will ever get fed WR1 target amounts. (Edit...he has 10 and 11 targets last two games). Also unsure what the QB situation is going forward.

Christian Kirk. Love the pairing with Murray and showed his upside last week. I just don’t have a good feel for what he is yet. Doesn’t feel like a WR1 but definitely has his place.

DJ Chark. Has had some great weeks and some quiet weeks. New to the production scene so may have caught some defenses by surprise. Least confident based on his short resume.

Edited by King of the Jungle
  • Like 3
Link to post
Share on other sites
Just Win Baby

Just Win Baby 2,611

Posted
Posted (edited)

This last series of posts reminded me of this post from @Concept Coop 

On 10/23/2019 at 6:00 PM, Concept Coop said:

Chark and Sutton will be going well before WR15 in off-season startup drafts if their current production holds. It's certainly reasonable to bet against that happening, but that startups aren't taking place right now is kind of the point of the exercise. In general, if you're buying these guys right now it's because you're sold and are paying accordingly.

I commented then that I thought it was an overstatement. Looks like there isn't really a consensus on Chark's value yet. Will be interesting to watch the rest of the way.

Edited by Just Win Baby
Link to post
Share on other sites
wgoldsph

wgoldsph 961

Posted
Posted
4 hours ago, JoeJoe88 said:

How would you guys rank these five WR's in terms of dynasty value?  I had a pretty difficult time with this:

DJ Moore

Chris Godwin

Christian Kirk

Kenny Golladay

DJ Chark

Like everyone else I had a hard time with this.  Assuming ppr

1a Godwin - expect him to be a yearly 100+ catch 1000+ yard player no matter who's at qb, plus is great yac

1b Golladay - behind Godwin due to the fact that his game is based more on the big play.

3 Kirk - someone needs to be the alpha in the air raid.  I'm not quite sure it won't be issabella in 2 years. But for now it's looking like Kirk

4 Chark - will have to see how he works with Foles

5 Moore - this offense runs on CMC.  As noted above he's getting a big target share, but when it comes to rz or important downs you know where the ball is going.

  • Like 1
Link to post
Share on other sites
Biabreakable

Biabreakable 5,140

Posted
Posted (edited)
5 hours ago, JoeJoe88 said:

How would you guys rank these five WR's in terms of dynasty value?  I had a pretty difficult time with this:

DJ Moore

Chris Godwin

Christian Kirk

Kenny Golladay

DJ Chark

This is a great question and not one that is easy to answer because I think all of these players are similarly talented and young. I think these players are for the most part in the same tier although some are more proven than others.

If you were to rank them based on career VBD produced so far

Golladay 66

Godwin 62

Chark 36

Sutton 23

Moore 4

Kirk 0

Because these are such young players though, we are more interested in what they will produce in years ahead.

It is hard to project what these players will do in years ahead. Those projections would for me still be based on what they have produced so far. So similar to VBD to date order.

Based on pre NFL draft evaluations I had Moore and Kirk ranked a lot higher than Sutton and I wouldn't change that yet (the players are still too young and unproven at this point) 

Chark is a guy I didn't really evaluate as a college prospect. He has been a surprise to me. I do have some fog of war when it comes to the Jaguars who I rarely read about or get to see play.

Based on the VBD Godwin should be in a tier by himself above the other WR.

Considering the situation around the player, I think Kirk gets the biggest bump here because of Murray being the best QB of these teams.

There are a lot of other things I could consider as well, but based on the above factors I would rank them like this:

Tier one

Golladay

Godwin

 

Tier two

Moore

Kirk

Sutton

Chark

Kind of a coin flip for me between Golladay and Godwin. I think I like Golladays situation better. I could see going either way though and might just depend on what I had for lunch that day.

Edited by Biabreakable
I missed Golladay
  • Like 1
Link to post
Share on other sites
Biabreakable

Biabreakable 5,140

Posted
Posted

I think I should point out that those tiers are only in vacuum.

If you evaluate the players by VBD and use data for more than just this season, there are WR with much higher career VBD who would be ranked ahead of these guys by a high enough margin to drop them into tier two if we are talking about the WR value overall.

These players are still so young that they haven't had enough time to compete with that. For the older WR with more seasons of data to work with, then you have to look at it more from a VBD per season type basis instead of overall. Thats another step to this as far as overall rankings I didn't do here.

  • Thanks 1
Link to post
Share on other sites
Zyphros

Zyphros 1,979

Posted
Posted
On 11/13/2019 at 10:11 AM, kutta said:

I own Barkley and pretty much vowed to never trade him.

But, the Kamara owner is sniffing around and he owns 4 first round picks next year, three of them will be mid-late and one will be early-mid.

What's the consensus on Barkley's value at this point. I cant believe that I would find myself turning down Kamara and two 2020 firsts, but I'm not sure I could pull the trigger there.

I was offered Kerryon, Aaron Jones and a 2nd for Barkley today actually.  Told him no chance at that price.  I didn't counter because I was unsure of what I actually wanted, but my first thought was Kittle, Nuk, and Miles Sanders in TE premium.  Didn't send it though cause I'm not sure if I'd even do that.  

  • Like 1
Link to post
Share on other sites
Zyphros

Zyphros 1,979

Posted
Posted
7 hours ago, JoeJoe88 said:

How would you guys rank these five WR's in terms of dynasty value?  I had a pretty difficult time with this:

DJ Moore

Chris Godwin

Christian Kirk

Kenny Golladay

DJ Chark

Easy

Godwin, Golladay, Moore, BIG GAP, Chark, Kirk

  • Like 2
Link to post
Share on other sites
Just Win Baby

Just Win Baby 2,611

Posted
Posted

What are people thinking about David Johnson right now? AFAIK he is healthy but played just 7 snaps and had 0 touches yesterday. He has seemingly been surpassed by Drake, who has only been with the team for a few weeks.

While I have long felt that Johnson is overrated, I did not see that coming. 

Link to post
Share on other sites
Just Win Baby

Just Win Baby 2,611

Posted
Posted
2 minutes ago, Concept Coop said:

Micheal Gallup is out-scoring Golladay, Kirk, and Moore PPG. Is he in the same tier as these guys?

To really do justice to some of the WR discussion (which is good), we really should talk about top 25 or 30 WRs. 

(He says, hoping others will post rankings.)

  • Like 1
Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Restore formatting

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

×
 Share
Followers 15
Go to topic listing

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

×
×
  • Create New...