Welcome to Our Forums. Once you've registered and logged in, you're primed to talk football, among other topics, with the sharpest and most experienced fantasy players on the internet.
I haven't offered him for draft picks in the one league where I own him, but I have received offers for him where I would receive a player in return. The latest offer I received was Sony Michel for Hunt and my 2020 1st round pick.
Sold him in a PPR/PPC league a few weeks ago for a 2020 1st. Was happy to get it and some people in group chat thought I could have gotten more.
Everyone always says you could get more in the group chat after you pull the trigger on a deal but for some reason when you are shopping a guy they never offer more. It's easy to say I would have paid more when the player is no longer on the block.
About the same. In the games that Odell has missed he has only increased his production by 2 PPR fantasy points a game. Odell got a lot of targets but he opened up things for everyone else. Now you got Tate who in his Lions 4 full seasons averaged 8.25 targets a game, just 2.25 less then Odell per game, and he may not sustain that but he's a higher volume target guy who unlike Odell does not open up the field. So all in all about the same.Pwingles said:
I offered 1.9 for him before he signed with the Browns but also when we had no idea who he would be playing for and when he'd be allowed to play. I got shot down and was told I needed to include my 2020#1 AND a player. I don't have that 1.9 pick anymore, if I did I would not offer it because I think the owner is not reasonable to work with on a trade for Hunt but a pick in the second round is a steal. I'd for sure still give a late first for him.
Seems like this is the way of it - if you want to sell him you need to take less but if you're actively looking to buy him you have to overpay.
There's a really wide spread on hunt's value and a really wide spread on the value of picks in this year's draft. If someone loves this year's draft and everyone in their league hates hunt it wouldn't shock me to see them trade hunt for a second. In other leagues a late first in a supposedly weak class isn't much of an offer.
Been trying to get an opinion on this hunt trade everywhere. I'm in full rebuild, Team Name
Well, it should go in the AC form but...
I agree with Andy. Seems too cheap for Hunt. Better to hold him and hope he lands safely somewhere.
Didn't get any replies in AC...
Good trade for the guy getting 1.01 if Barkley was a rookie. There isn't one player right now that is worthy of the 1.01. After the draft that will change, but this WR class seems a tad overrated.
I dealt him for Kittle and Duke Johnson in FFPC right after the arthritis report came out. I took some flack for it, but the market is cold.
I would take that in a heartbeat. I own him and he has nowhere that value in my league. I dare say that is a landslide trade in your favor.
He'd be the one getting DJ.
Yeah even if I did think DJ put me over the top, I'd try a whole bunch of other options first. And I say that as a guy who think Davis is one of the most overrated players in dynasty.
I'd recommend reading the entire long article making the rounds today about Rodgers and McCarty's bad relationship. Found a few fantasy nuggets of info in that article and one of them was that MVS reportedly told at least one source that Rodgers hates him and would not throw the ball to him because MVS ran the routes that McCarthy wanted and did not deviate his routes like Rodgers wanted. Anyway I'd read the article if when you have time, Green Bay is going to be interesting next year.
Kyler Murray is going to open everything up for DJ. DJ is a League winner this year barring injury.
https://www.revengeofthebirds.com/2018/12/5/18128028/arizona-cardinals-original-starting-offensive-line-is-gone-for-the-season
A little worried about Kyler Murray stealing GL carries.....so maybe league winner ceiling is a stretch. Top 5 RB is in play though....
RNC = Reject, no counter-offer? What do you consider to be a "moderate hit" in a return for Gurley?
I've posted it a few times now, so apologize if I'm being redundant, but I sold Gurley for Kittle and Duke Johnson. I kinda wanted to puke immediately after but I'm feeling better and better about it by the day.
I did in the trade thread when I made them and did not want to keep making people read my trades but since you asked. These trades were made in February I think, for sure before FA.
Yes, reject no counter. I offered him for the 1.02 and a 2020 1st. I offered him for $FAAB (we also do RFA process with this, the amount I requested would be enough to get say Amari Cooper) plus a 2020 1st. Those are laughable offers 5 months ago yet today it's flipped.
I'm thinking you must be in a contract league to have RFA. How many years does Gurley have, out of curiosity.
We are, and this is a couple of different leagues. One has a lead-pipe lock Franchise Tag rule, so the contract is kind of irrelevant, but the other is a 4 year contract. These aren't the only ones I have thrown out, but they are representative of the "hit" I am willing to take.
I’m trying to figure out if Gurley is a hold, sell now, or wait for his value to go back up and sell then.
It's like the 2016 draft without Elliott. The top receivers - doctson, treadwell, Coleman - all had warts but that draft also had Michael thomas, tyreek hill, Tyler boyd, Derrick Henry, Jordan Howard, Kenyan drake. hunter henry, and some ok producers like fuller and shepherd. Everyone talked about how terrible that draft was but it produced 3 elite guys and a bunch of starters.
* I have a draft starting this week, so some of my thinking is “at this point.” 40 man offseason rosters, cut to 30 before week 1. I also have some picks stockpiled, which may be swaying my opinion.
