2007 Rookie Draft / QUARTERBACKS (1 Viewer)

[aposulli]

Updated list (tiered)

Disclosure: These rankings are tiered based on NFL fantasy potential, not necessarily predicted NFL Draft order

1. JaMarcus Russell, LSU*

2. Brady Quinn, Notre Dame

3. Drew Stanton, Michigan State

4. Troy Smith, Ohio State

5. Kevin Kolb, Houston

6. Jordan Palmer, UTEP

7. Trent Edwards, Stanford

8. Jeff Rowe, Nevada

9. Zac Taylor, Nebraska

10. Tyler Palko, Pittsburgh

11. John Beck, BYU

12. Chris Leak, Florida

13. Matt Gutierrez, Idaho State

14. Justin Rascati, James Madison

15. Matt Moore, Oregon State

16. Jared Zabransky, Boise State

17. Luke Getsy, Akron

18. Brett Ratliff, Utah

19. Sam Hollenbach, Maryland

20. Toby Korrodi, Central Missouri

*Underclassmen

 

[Ron_Mexico]

Updated list (tiered)Disclosure: These rankings are tiered based on NFL fantasy potential, not necessarily predicted NFL Draft order1. JaMarcus Russell, LSU*2. Brady Quinn, Notre Dame3. Drew Stanton, Michigan State4. Troy Smith, Ohio State5. Kevin Kolb, Houston6. Jordan Palmer, UTEP7. Trent Edwards, Stanford8. Jeff Rowe, Nevada9. Zac Taylor, Nebraska10. Tyler Palko, Pittsburgh11. John Beck, BYU12. Chris Leak, Florida13. Matt Gutierrez, Idaho State14. Justin Rascati, James Madison15. Matt Moore, Oregon State16. Jared Zabransky, Boise State17. Luke Getsy, Akron18. Brett Ratliff, Utah19. Sam Hollenbach, Maryland20. Toby Korrodi, Central Missouri *Underclassmen

I agree with most of this.I will take a chance and bumpKevin Kolb up to #3.

 

[aposulli]

Updated list (tiered)Disclosure: These rankings are tiered based on NFL fantasy potential, not necessarily predicted NFL Draft order1. JaMarcus Russell, LSU*2. Brady Quinn, Notre Dame3. Drew Stanton, Michigan State4. Troy Smith, Ohio State5. Kevin Kolb, Houston6. Jordan Palmer, UTEP7. Trent Edwards, Stanford8. Jeff Rowe, Nevada9. Zac Taylor, Nebraska10. Tyler Palko, Pittsburgh11. John Beck, BYU12. Chris Leak, Florida13. Matt Gutierrez, Idaho State14. Justin Rascati, James Madison15. Matt Moore, Oregon State16. Jared Zabransky, Boise State17. Luke Getsy, Akron18. Brett Ratliff, Utah19. Sam Hollenbach, Maryland20. Toby Korrodi, Central Missouri *Underclassmen

I agree with most of this.I will take a chance and bumpKevin Kolb up to #3.

I had him at 4 at some point, but Stanton and Smith have both impressed in the Senior Bowl

 

[Ron_Mexico]

Updated list (tiered)Disclosure: These rankings are tiered based on NFL fantasy potential, not necessarily predicted NFL Draft order1. JaMarcus Russell, LSU*2. Brady Quinn, Notre Dame3. Drew Stanton, Michigan State4. Troy Smith, Ohio State5. Kevin Kolb, Houston6. Jordan Palmer, UTEP7. Trent Edwards, Stanford8. Jeff Rowe, Nevada9. Zac Taylor, Nebraska10. Tyler Palko, Pittsburgh11. John Beck, BYU12. Chris Leak, Florida13. Matt Gutierrez, Idaho State14. Justin Rascati, James Madison15. Matt Moore, Oregon State16. Jared Zabransky, Boise State17. Luke Getsy, Akron18. Brett Ratliff, Utah19. Sam Hollenbach, Maryland20. Toby Korrodi, Central Missouri *Underclassmen

I agree with most of this.I will take a chance and bumpKevin Kolb up to #3.

I had him at 4 at some point, but Stanton and Smith have both impressed in the Senior Bowl

Truth is that Troy Smith failed on the biggest stage of all against Florida.This will hurt his value more than the Senior Bowl will help it, imo.

 

[aposulli]

Updated list (tiered)Disclosure: These rankings are tiered based on NFL fantasy potential, not necessarily predicted NFL Draft order1. JaMarcus Russell, LSU*2. Brady Quinn, Notre Dame3. Drew Stanton, Michigan State4. Troy Smith, Ohio State5. Kevin Kolb, Houston6. Jordan Palmer, UTEP7. Trent Edwards, Stanford8. Jeff Rowe, Nevada9. Zac Taylor, Nebraska10. Tyler Palko, Pittsburgh11. John Beck, BYU12. Chris Leak, Florida13. Matt Gutierrez, Idaho State14. Justin Rascati, James Madison15. Matt Moore, Oregon State16. Jared Zabransky, Boise State17. Luke Getsy, Akron18. Brett Ratliff, Utah19. Sam Hollenbach, Maryland20. Toby Korrodi, Central Missouri *Underclassmen

I agree with most of this.I will take a chance and bumpKevin Kolb up to #3.

I had him at 4 at some point, but Stanton and Smith have both impressed in the Senior Bowl

Truth is that Troy Smith failed on the biggest stage of all against Florida.This will hurt his value more than the Senior Bowl will help it, imo.

True but people were talking about him as a 1st Rounder to begin with.I never thought he was really worth that, but the thing that actually surprised me was that he measured out at 6' even.He should go in the 2nd Round while Kolb won't go higher than the 3rd. Even still, it's definitly possible I move Kolb up to that tier as I don't necessarily think he and Palko are on the same level right now.

 

[FTRWRTR]

Truth is that Troy Smith failed on the biggest stage of all against Florida.This will hurt his value more than the Senior Bowl will help it, imo.

Ppl have short memories, what will matter the most is what he does at the combine since that'll be the last thing they see of him. Case in point he's a late first/early 2nd rounder at the end of the year, he has a bad game in the nat'l championship and falls to like the 4th round, he has a strong senior bowl performance and goes back up to the 3rd maybe even 2nd round.

 

[aposulli]

Truth is that Troy Smith failed on the biggest stage of all against Florida.This will hurt his value more than the Senior Bowl will help it, imo.

Ppl have short memories, what will matter the most is what he does at the combine since that'll be the last thing they see of him. Case in point he's a late first/early 2nd rounder at the end of the year, he has a bad game in the nat'l championship and falls to like the 4th round, he has a strong senior bowl performance and goes back up to the 3rd maybe even 2nd round.

True, but I do not expect his value to change much.His windup delivery will be critizized, but other than that, I think everyone pretty much understands what kind of QB he is.His athleticism will be on display, but it won't surprise anyone I don't think.2nd-3rd Round, I don't think he ever was knocked out of the 1st day considering the lack of top QBs in this draft.

 

[JayMan]

My DayOne picks - QBs/RBs/WRs/TEs:

Round 1 talent:

QB: J. Russell / B. Quinn

RB: A. Peterson / M. Lynch

WR: C. Johnson / D. Jarrett / T. Ginn / S. Rice / D. Bowe

TE: none

Round 2 talent:

QB: T. Smith / D. Stanton

RB: M. Bush / K. Irons / T. Hunt / B. Leonard

WR: R. Meachem / C. Davis / JL. Higgins / A. Gonzalez

TE: Z. Miller / G. Olsen

Round 3 talent:

QB: K. Kolb / T. Edwards

RB: A. Pittman / L. Booker

WR: S. Smith / J. Hill / D. Clowney / A. Allison / P. Williams

TE: S. Chandler

 

[aposulli]

Pre Combine update

Disclosure: These rankings are tiered based on NFL fantasy potential, not necessarily predicted NFL Draft order

1. JaMarcus Russell, Louisiana State*

2. Brady Quinn, Notre Dame

3. Drew Stanton, Michigan State

4. Troy Smith, Ohio State

5. Kevin Kolb, Houston

6. Trent Edwards, Stanford

7. Jeff Rowe, Nevada

8. Jordan Palmer, UTEP

9. Zac Taylor, Nebraska

10. Tyler Palko, Pittsburgh

11. John Beck, BYU

12. Matt Gutierrez, Idaho State

13. Jared Zabransky, Boise State

14. Chris Leak, Florida

15. Matt Moore, Oregon State

*Underclassmen

 

[Sigmund Bloom]

Pre Combine update

Disclosure: These rankings are tiered based on NFL fantasy potential, not necessarily predicted NFL Draft order

1. JaMarcus Russell, Louisiana State*

2. Brady Quinn, Notre Dame

3. Drew Stanton, Michigan State

4. Troy Smith, Ohio State

5. Kevin Kolb, Houston

6. Trent Edwards, Stanford

7. Jeff Rowe, Nevada

8. Jordan Palmer, UTEP

9. Zac Taylor, Nebraska

10. Tyler Palko, Pittsburgh

11. John Beck, BYU

12. Matt Gutierrez, Idaho State

13. Jared Zabransky, Boise State

14. Chris Leak, Florida

15. Matt Moore, Oregon State

*Underclassmen

Any particular reason Stanback isnt on your list?

 

[prymetyme25]

Pre Combine update

Disclosure: These rankings are tiered based on NFL fantasy potential, not necessarily predicted NFL Draft order

1. JaMarcus Russell, Louisiana State*

2. Brady Quinn, Notre Dame

3. Drew Stanton, Michigan State

4. Troy Smith, Ohio State

5. Kevin Kolb, Houston

6. Trent Edwards, Stanford

7. Jeff Rowe, Nevada

8. Jordan Palmer, UTEP

9. Zac Taylor, Nebraska

10. Tyler Palko, Pittsburgh

11. John Beck, BYU

12. Matt Gutierrez, Idaho State

13. Jared Zabransky, Boise State

14. Chris Leak, Florida

15. Matt Moore, Oregon State

*Underclassmen

that Trent Edwards is starting to intrigue me but I dont know much about him. any insight?

 

[aposulli]

Pre Combine update

Disclosure: These rankings are tiered based on NFL fantasy potential, not necessarily predicted NFL Draft order

1. JaMarcus Russell, Louisiana State*

2. Brady Quinn, Notre Dame

3. Drew Stanton, Michigan State

4. Troy Smith, Ohio State

5. Kevin Kolb, Houston

6. Trent Edwards, Stanford

7. Jeff Rowe, Nevada

8. Jordan Palmer, UTEP

9. Zac Taylor, Nebraska

10. Tyler Palko, Pittsburgh

11. John Beck, BYU

12. Matt Gutierrez, Idaho State

13. Jared Zabransky, Boise State

14. Chris Leak, Florida

15. Matt Moore, Oregon State

*Underclassmen

Any particular reason Stanback isnt on your list?

Don't think he'll be a QB. Had some doubts about Zabransky as well but it's not a very deep class of QBs this year.

 

[EBF]

Pre Combine update

Disclosure: These rankings are tiered based on NFL fantasy potential, not necessarily predicted NFL Draft order

1. JaMarcus Russell, Louisiana State*

2. Brady Quinn, Notre Dame

3. Drew Stanton, Michigan State

4. Troy Smith, Ohio State

5. Kevin Kolb, Houston

6. Trent Edwards, Stanford

7. Jeff Rowe, Nevada

8. Jordan Palmer, UTEP

9. Zac Taylor, Nebraska

10. Tyler Palko, Pittsburgh

11. John Beck, BYU

12. Matt Gutierrez, Idaho State

13. Jared Zabransky, Boise State

14. Chris Leak, Florida

15. Matt Moore, Oregon State

*Underclassmen

that Trent Edwards is starting to intrigue me but I dont know much about him. any insight?

5 star recruit in high school. Ranked as the top QB in the country by some recruiting services. Played with bad coaches and terrible offensive lines in college, which greatly limited his production. He really got killed behind that line. Also, his best two WRs both suffered serious injuries last season. A lot of people compare him to Cutler because he has a lot of talent, but was held back by a weak team. He could definitely end up as the best QB from this class.

 

[aposulli]

FINAL update

Disclosure: These rankings are tiered based on NFL fantasy potential, not necessarily predicted NFL Draft order

1. JaMarcus Russell, Louisiana State*

2. Brady Quinn, Notre Dame

3. Drew Stanton, Michigan State

4. Trent Edwards, Stanford

5. Kevin Kolb, Houston

6. Troy Smith, Ohio State

7. John Beck, BYU

8. Jeff Rowe, Nevada

9. Jordan Palmer, UTEP

10. Jared Zabransky, Boise State

11. Zac Taylor, Nebraska

12. Tyler Palko, Pittsburgh

13. Matt Gutierrez, Idaho State

14. Chris Leak, Florida

15. Toby Korrodi, Central Missouri State

16. Luke Getsy, Akron

17. Lester Ricard, Tulane

18. Matt Moore, Oregon State

19. James Pinkney, East Carolina

20. Isaiah Stanbeck, Washington

*Underclassmen

 

[ConstruxBoy]

Final Pre-Draft List:

1) B Quinn

2) J Russell

3) T Edwards

4) D Stanton

5) K Kolb

6) J Beck

7) T Smith

8) J Rowe

9) T Korrodi

10) T Palko