gianmarco
Footballguy
1 pprStart 1 RB, 2 WR, 1 TE, and 2 flex.
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums
This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!
2010 Offseason Dynasty Trades (1 Viewer)
- Thread starter jeter23
- Start date
GreatLakesMike
Footballguy
You'd have to start 40 and have a 60 man roster for that trade to be fair. Team A stole Fitz.
Hoot&HoLLer
Footballguy
You took him to the cleaners.
Is it me, or does this thread just seem to be mostly examples of people ripping other people off. Not to pick on Coltswin, most of the trades in this thread seem to be this way. Funny thing is, the guy posting is usually the one doing the ripping off.
BTW this was offered to me.
identikit
Footballguy
Not just you.A lot of 'LOOK AT ME' going on in here....
No worries, like i said, no offense to you, thats a great trade for you. Its just that most of the trades in this thread are not really examples of players true trade value.
ItsOnlytheRiver
Footballguy
Agreed and the most recent VJax trades have been ridiculous. Who are these people that treat their dynasty team like a redraft?
jwb
Footballguy
I agree that this is a bad one, but I think a lot of the trades have to be taken within the context of the league/teams. Maybe sometimes an explaination w/ the trade would be better.For example, the recent Fitz trade I posted - I traded Fitz in that one (for bowe/garcon/2012 #1, other stuff). My rationale was I had Fitz and Stewy as my only players. I was going to be starting both Avery and Aroma as wr's w/ fitz, and still needed another guy, plus have nobody to back Stew - the team is a mess (I took it over earlier this year). In other words, I need more quality players, even if they aren't the top elite. Personally, I feel Bowe/Garcon will be a nice WR tandem for me (I was already offered a player and a 2011 #1 for Garcon - a lot of people like him). It's a gamble, but one I feel is worth it, because I truly think Bowe is a solid WR, and will have a nice year. Is he Fitz? No. Is he capable of 85/10? Yea, he is, and I think we'll see that. I feel strongly enough about this that it makes this trade (to me) nowhere near the slam dunk for the other guy that some might think it is. Bowe will make losing Fitz at least somewhat bearable, and Garcon has a good chance to be a very viable FF WR. I can move that 2012 #1 in another deal to get better elsewhere, etc. I'm cool w/ it, even though some will think the other team "stole" Fitz.
ItsOnlytheRiver
Footballguy
That's an OK trade in a start 2 QB league, but it's not a start 2 QB league.
mozzy84
Footballguy
if it was a start 2 qb league I dont think the guy with brady and brees would have ever done it
thriftyrocker
Footballguy
12 team PPR league
Aaron Rodgers
Greg Jennings
for
Brandon Marshall
Devery Henderson
David Garrard
Matt Moore
2011 3rd
Aaron Rodgers
Greg Jennings
for
Brandon Marshall
Devery Henderson
David Garrard
Matt Moore
2011 3rd
The Real Hipster Doofus
Footballguy
Fitting considering the previous discussion about terrible trades.
Instinctive
Footballguy
I agree 100%. I had sent an offer for Rodgers in this league, but then a deal for Rivers worked out for me and I withdrew it...and then the guy said "I wish I'd seen this sooner I may have accepted..." He's a new guy, not sure if he's the greatest owner, but I was at that place 5 years ago too, and you gotta learn somehow.Of course, I'm high on Moore, QBs only get 4 per TD, and it's PPR for Marshall......but Hendersona nd a 2011 3rd are both useless, and I wouldn't even take that for just Rodgers, let alone adding in Jennings.
Ketamine Dreams
Footballguy
PPR, 12 teamer, all picks are 2010 rookie/free agent picks
Team A gives up: 1.12, Owen Daniels, and 2.12
Team B gives up: Randy Moss, 3.01, and 4.08
Team A gives up: 1.12, Owen Daniels, and 2.12
Team B gives up: Randy Moss, 3.01, and 4.08
The Captain
Footballguy
12 Team PPR
Team A gives Malcom Floyd
Team B gives Braylon Edwards.
Team A gives Malcom Floyd
Team B gives Braylon Edwards.
Last edited by a moderator:
HenryMuto
Footballguy
I don't think it matters what the starting requirments are or roster limits.I will take Fitz every day in a deal like this. I am always going for the best player in a draft when I make a trade and Bowe is the only player even decent though Garcon is a nice player.
HenryMuto
Footballguy
Who the heck are playing in these leagues this is a just a redonkulous trade.I would not give up Vincent Jackson straight up for those 3 players.
I post all my trades. For the most part. Few said I got robbed on some. Guess if you trade enough you get some good and some bad.
thriftyrocker
Footballguy
I also thought it would be a lot closer to fair if Jennings wasn't included.
Off topic a bit, but i almost always do the opposite. I usually try to trade a guy whose value has peaked for two or more younger, up and coming players.
I dont like Brandon Marshall, and i love Rodgers, but no way i would trade Marshall for Rodgers in a 4 pt. TD pass and PPR league.
Mighty Mice
Footballguy
Team A gets: Robert Meachem
Team B gets: Malcolm Floyd, Legadu Naanee, Mark Sanchez
Team B owns Vince Jackson.
Team B gets: Malcolm Floyd, Legadu Naanee, Mark Sanchez
Team B owns Vince Jackson.
Donsmith753
Footballguy
Well done Team B
thriftyrocker
Footballguy
I am really high on Floyd as a replacement player, but I wouldn't give up Meachem that easily. Maybe if Sanchez was replaced by a QB I liked more.
mikel2014
Footballguy
In my main league Meachem was just traded straight up for Josh Cribbs
ChuckLiddell
Footballguy
Return yards count?In my main league Meachem was just traded straight up for Josh Cribbs
I would take the package myself.
Ketamine Dreams
Footballguy
12 team, PPR, (2010 rookie/free agent picks)
Team A gives up: Matthew Stafford, Kenny Britt, 3.01
Team B gives up: 1.04 (picked Dez Bryant), 3.04, 4.04
Team A gives up: Matthew Stafford, Kenny Britt, 3.01
Team B gives up: 1.04 (picked Dez Bryant), 3.04, 4.04
Last edited by a moderator:
thriftyrocker
Footballguy
Yeah you're right, in most cases. I am only saying it is closer to fair.If I had 3 elite WRs and could sell one to go from Garrard and Moore to Rodgers, I would do the deal. Even if I had to give up Moore and Garrard on top.Of course, I bilked this same guy once last year so I probably shouldn't talk.
Last edited by a moderator:
No Way Jose
Footballguy
Team A gets: Calvin Johnson, Ryan Matthews, Darren Sproles
Team B gets: Frank Gore, Miles Austin, Glen Coffee
Team B gets: Frank Gore, Miles Austin, Glen Coffee
The Real Hipster Doofus
Footballguy
Pretty even trade, but I would take team A's side myself.Team A gets: Calvin Johnson, Ryan Matthews, Darren SprolesTeam B gets: Frank Gore, Miles Austin, Glen Coffee
No Way Jose
Footballguy
I am team B here, and this was a tough one for me. Team A is in more of a rebuild mode as I feel like I'm a contender. This makes my starting RB's Chris Johnson, Gore and D. Williams with D Jackson, Ausitin and R. White as WR. I might lose a little bit in youth but I feel like I am getting a bump in scoring. But I feel this is a very good trade for both teams.Pretty even trade, but I would take team A's side myself.Team A gets: Calvin Johnson, Ryan Matthews, Darren SprolesTeam B gets: Frank Gore, Miles Austin, Glen Coffee
Dreamer
Footballguy
No way Jose.I am team B here, and this was a tough one for me. Team A is in more of a rebuild mode as I feel like I'm a contender. This makes my starting RB's Chris Johnson, Gore and D. Williams with D Jackson, Ausitin and R. White as WR. I might lose a little bit in youth but I feel like I am getting a bump in scoring. But I feel this is a very good trade for both teams.Pretty even trade, but I would take team A's side myself.Team A gets: Calvin Johnson, Ryan Matthews, Darren SprolesTeam B gets: Frank Gore, Miles Austin, Glen Coffee
According to my trade calculator, i feel the same. 5 point(or 2%) advantage to team A.Pretty even trade, but I would take team A's side myself.Team A gets: Calvin Johnson, Ryan Matthews, Darren SprolesTeam B gets: Frank Gore, Miles Austin, Glen Coffee
HenryMuto
Footballguy
A serious head scratcher here especially since the guy giving up 2 picks is probably the worst team in the league so those picks are likely in the 11-12 range.
Harlem gave up
Year 2011 Round 2 Draft Pick from Harlem
Year 2012 Round 2 Draft Pick from Harlem
Tasmania gave up
Williams, Carnell TBB RB
Harlem gave up
Year 2011 Round 2 Draft Pick from Harlem
Year 2012 Round 2 Draft Pick from Harlem
Tasmania gave up
Williams, Carnell TBB RB
GreatLakesMike
Footballguy
I agree. I love Calvin, so it's just a matter of personal preference. San Fran did bump up their line through the draft, and they have plenty of weapons on the outside to keep defenses honest. I look for Gore to be extremely productive the next 2 seasons. Like you said though, even trade.Pretty even trade, but I would take team A's side myself.Team A gets: Calvin Johnson, Ryan Matthews, Darren SprolesTeam B gets: Frank Gore, Miles Austin, Glen Coffee
GreatLakesMike
Footballguy
I agree. Hell, I just moved R Brown/R Williams for Devin Hester in a PPR league.
GreatLakesMike
Footballguy
That trade makes 0 sense.
FunkyPlutos
Footballguy
I disagree. I think it is a HUGE buy low for Ronnie. He is a beast and will come back healthy. Now is the time to get him.
Well, youre kind of right. Now is the time to get him, because this is likely the last year he has any FF value left. As far as him being a huge buy low, thats way off. At best he is a RB2 for someone trying to make a run this year. Other than that, he is worthless.
fsufan
Footballguy
i would rather have Mathews and CJTeam A gets: Calvin Johnson, Ryan Matthews, Darren SprolesTeam B gets: Frank Gore, Miles Austin, Glen Coffee
No Way Jose
Footballguy
I guess we will see Fsu...here is to Mathews having a Morenoesque first year.i would rather have Mathews and CJTeam A gets: Calvin Johnson, Ryan Matthews, Darren SprolesTeam B gets: Frank Gore, Miles Austin, Glen Coffee
fsufan
Footballguy
like the trade for both of you. i am sure you are looking at winning now and mud is looking down the roadI guess we will see Fsu...here is to Mathews having a Morenoesque first year.i would rather have Mathews and CJTeam A gets: Calvin Johnson, Ryan Matthews, Darren SprolesTeam B gets: Frank Gore, Miles Austin, Glen Coffee
the_sig
Footballguy
14 Team league with a super-flex allowing a 2nd QB to start each week. .5/1/1.5 RB/WR/TE PPR scoring.
Team A gave:
Mendenhall
Josh Morgan
Jacoby Jones
2010 1.13
Team B gave:
Ahmad Bradshaw
Kevin Kolb
Mark Sanchez
2010 2.14
I was team A. Needed to restock the QB's as Cutler was my only one. The ability to start 2 QB's makes starters fairly scarce in this league imo. Kolb & Sanchez need some time to develop, but should be given plenty of time to do so and have the weapons to target. I'm not sold on Mendenhall long term, and had the depth at RB to deal him.
Team A gave:
Mendenhall
Josh Morgan
Jacoby Jones
2010 1.13
Team B gave:
Ahmad Bradshaw
Kevin Kolb
Mark Sanchez
2010 2.14
I was team A. Needed to restock the QB's as Cutler was my only one. The ability to start 2 QB's makes starters fairly scarce in this league imo. Kolb & Sanchez need some time to develop, but should be given plenty of time to do so and have the weapons to target. I'm not sold on Mendenhall long term, and had the depth at RB to deal him.
Similar threads
