2012 Offseason Dynasty Trades (2 Viewers)

[Instinctive]

12 Team PPR 1 QB, must start 2 RB with capability of up to 4.Team A Got: Cam Newton, Marshawn Lynch, Shonn Greene, and some end of the bench guysTeam B Got: RGIII, Ingram, FJax, 3 future 2nds, and some end of the bench guysI ain't involved but I know one team is a clear winner

Newton/Lynch?

AND Greene...I feel like this isn't even close. And I rarely feel that way. One team got the three best players. Wow.

 

[lbouchard]

12 Team PPR 1 QB, must start 2 RB with capability of up to 4.Team A Got: Cam Newton, Marshawn Lynch, Shonn Greene, and some end of the bench guysTeam B Got: RGIII, Ingram, FJax, 3 future 2nds, and some end of the bench guysI ain't involved but I know one team is a clear winner

Newton/Lynch?

AND Greene...I feel like this isn't even close. And I rarely feel that way. One team got the three best players. Wow.

I agree. Several league members and I think that this upsets the integrity of the league. The commish, who is Team A in this deal, refuses to allow a league vote. Regrettably, as a first year dynasty, we don't have anything in the rules about vetoes. It's threatening to split the league apart

 

[Sebowski]

12 Team PPR 1 QB, must start 2 RB with capability of up to 4.Team A Got: Cam Newton, Marshawn Lynch, Shonn Greene, and some end of the bench guysTeam B Got: RGIII, Ingram, FJax, 3 future 2nds, and some end of the bench guysI ain't involved but I know one team is a clear winner

Newton/Lynch?

AND Greene...I feel like this isn't even close. And I rarely feel that way. One team got the three best players. Wow.

I agree. Several league members and I think that this upsets the integrity of the league. The commish, who is Team A in this deal, refuses to allow a league vote. Regrettably, as a first year dynasty, we don't have anything in the rules about vetoes. It's threatening to split the league apart

 

[mozzy84]

12 Team PPR 1 QB, must start 2 RB with capability of up to 4.Team A Got: Cam Newton, Marshawn Lynch, Shonn Greene, and some end of the bench guysTeam B Got: RGIII, Ingram, FJax, 3 future 2nds, and some end of the bench guysI ain't involved but I know one team is a clear winner

Newton/Lynch?

AND Greene...I feel like this isn't even close. And I rarely feel that way. One team got the three best players. Wow.

I agree. Several league members and I think that this upsets the integrity of the league. The commish, who is Team A in this deal, refuses to allow a league vote. Regrettably, as a first year dynasty, we don't have anything in the rules about vetoes. It's threatening to split the league apart

that trade is perfectly fine imo

 

[lbouchard]

12 Team PPR 1 QB, must start 2 RB with capability of up to 4.Team A Got: Cam Newton, Marshawn Lynch, Shonn Greene, and some end of the bench guysTeam B Got: RGIII, Ingram, FJax, 3 future 2nds, and some end of the bench guysI ain't involved but I know one team is a clear winner

Newton/Lynch?

AND Greene...I feel like this isn't even close. And I rarely feel that way. One team got the three best players. Wow.

I agree. Several league members and I think that this upsets the integrity of the league. The commish, who is Team A in this deal, refuses to allow a league vote. Regrettably, as a first year dynasty, we don't have anything in the rules about vetoes. It's threatening to split the league apart

I don't get it.

 

[Gottabesweet]

Winslow and 51 for Pierre Thomas

Fitpatrick, 4th next year for Weeden and 3rd this year

just a couple trades made during our draft. Nothing big.

 

[squistion]

12 Team PPR 1 QB, must start 2 RB with capability of up to 4.

Team A Got: Cam Newton, Marshawn Lynch, Shonn Greene, and some end of the bench guys

Team B Got: RGIII, Ingram, FJax, 3 future 2nds, and some end of the bench guys

I ain't involved but I know one team is a clear winner

Newton/Lynch?

AND Greene...I feel like this isn't even close. And I rarely feel that way. One team got the three best players. Wow.

I agree. Several league members and I think that this upsets the integrity of the league. The commish, who is Team A in this deal, refuses to allow a league vote. Regrettably, as a first year dynasty, we don't have anything in the rules about vetoes. It's threatening to split the league apart

that trade is perfectly fine imo

I think so too...

 

[JohnW1970]

14 team PPR

Gave: Mike Wallace and Doug Martin

Got: Arian Foster and Jerome Simpson

 

[Sabertooth]

Just traded

Gabbert for Starks and then Starks for Harvin.

over the course of a few weeks.

I'm ok with that.

 

[bmsarvis]

12 Team PPR 1 QB, must start 2 RB with capability of up to 4.Team A Got: Cam Newton, Marshawn Lynch, Shonn Greene, and some end of the bench guysTeam B Got: RGIII, Ingram, FJax, 3 future 2nds, and some end of the bench guysI ain't involved but I know one team is a clear winner

Newton/Lynch?

AND Greene...I feel like this isn't even close. And I rarely feel that way. One team got the three best players. Wow.

I agree. Several league members and I think that this upsets the integrity of the league. The commish, who is Team A in this deal, refuses to allow a league vote. Regrettably, as a first year dynasty, we don't have anything in the rules about vetoes. It's threatening to split the league apart

that trade is perfectly fine imo

Actually has a small chance of workin out in team b favor. Slight chance albeit

 

[bmsarvis]

Just traded Gabbert for Starks and then Starks for Harvin.over the course of a few weeks. I'm ok with that.

Thats flat out stealin harvin! Good moves

 

[lbouchard]

12 Team PPR 1 QB, must start 2 RB with capability of up to 4.Team A Got: Cam Newton, Marshawn Lynch, Shonn Greene, and some end of the bench guysTeam B Got: RGIII, Ingram, FJax, 3 future 2nds, and some end of the bench guysI ain't involved but I know one team is a clear winner

Newton/Lynch?

AND Greene...I feel like this isn't even close. And I rarely feel that way. One team got the three best players. Wow.

I agree. Several league members and I think that this upsets the integrity of the league. The commish, who is Team A in this deal, refuses to allow a league vote. Regrettably, as a first year dynasty, we don't have anything in the rules about vetoes. It's threatening to split the league apart

that trade is perfectly fine imo

Actually has a small chance of workin out in team b favor. Slight chance albeit

if cam and lynch end up dead in a ditch

 

[Couch Potato]

12 team PPR. Cutler was my backup behind Brees. Team X also has Roethlisberger.

Fighting Couch Potatoes 2 gave up:

Cutler, Jay CHI QB

Team X gave up:

Fitzpatrick, Ryan BUF QB

Year 2013 Round 1 Draft Pick from Team X

 

[dickey moe]

Just traded Gabbert for Starks and then Starks for Harvin.over the course of a few weeks. I'm ok with that.

Congrats for playing with morons.

 

[joey]

12 team PPR. Cutler was my backup behind Brees. Team X also has Roethlisberger.Fighting Couch Potatoes 2 gave up:Cutler, Jay CHI QBTeam X gave up:Fitzpatrick, Ryan BUF QBYear 2013 Round 1 Draft Pick from Team X

Wow. Surprised you were able to get a 1st rounder out of Team X. A 2nd I could understand but I wouldn't have expected a 1st.

 

[joey]

A couple just went down in my league:Team A Gets: Demaryius ThomasTeam B Gets: Denarius Moore

Get Danario Alexander and Demarco Murray into that trade and it would be an epic collection of first names. .

 

[Couch Potato]

12 team PPR. Cutler was my backup behind Brees. Team X also has Roethlisberger.Fighting Couch Potatoes 2 gave up:Cutler, Jay CHI QBTeam X gave up:Fitzpatrick, Ryan BUF QBYear 2013 Round 1 Draft Pick from Team X

Wow. Surprised you were able to get a 1st rounder out of Team X. A 2nd I could understand but I wouldn't have expected a 1st.

I was surprised too, but he posted a wanted list on our MB where he was willing to part with a 1st and Cutler was on it. I think Jay is a fine QB and now has Marshall, but he's still a borderline Q1 or more likely a Q2, and not someone who is going to make a notable difference in winning a championship IMO (QBs in this league get 4 pts per TD by the way).So I was happy to get the 1st. Team X is a solid competitor but the roster is not dominant, so the pick s/b in the 1.7-1.10 range I'd guess, or better if injuries and bad breaks drop the record a bit.Hey Joey, I was meaning to write you. Look for a PM from me.

 

[joey]

12 team PPR. Cutler was my backup behind Brees. Team X also has Roethlisberger.Fighting Couch Potatoes 2 gave up:Cutler, Jay CHI QBTeam X gave up:Fitzpatrick, Ryan BUF QBYear 2013 Round 1 Draft Pick from Team X

Wow. Surprised you were able to get a 1st rounder out of Team X. A 2nd I could understand but I wouldn't have expected a 1st.

I was surprised too, but he posted a wanted list on our MB where he was willing to part with a 1st and Cutler was on it. I think Jay is a fine QB and now has Marshall, but he's still a borderline Q1 or more likely a Q2, and not someone who is going to make a notable difference in winning a championship IMO (QBs in this league get 4 pts per TD by the way).So I was happy to get the 1st. Team X is a solid competitor but the roster is not domant, so the pick s/b in the 1.7-1.10 range I'd guess, or better if injuries and bad breaks drop the record a bit.Hey Joey, I was meaning to write you. Look for a PM from me.

I'll keep an eye out.I actually traded for Cutler a month or two ago and I agree he is a pretty solid backup QB but not a difference maker. I have Stafford as my starter and had Ryan as my backup, so I traded Ryan for Cutler and the 1.07. I don't think there is that much of a difference between Ryan and Culter to be honest but I knew someone would bite on Ryan as the Next Top 5 QB of the future with his wr weapons.

 

[Dragon1952]

12 team, 1 PPR, start 2-4RB, 2-4WR

Team A gave Brandon Lloyd

Team B gave Steve Smith (CAR)

 

[SproutDaddy]

12 Team PPR 1 QB, must start 2 RB with capability of up to 4.Team A Got: Cam Newton, Marshawn Lynch, Shonn Greene, and some end of the bench guysTeam B Got: RGIII, Ingram, FJax, 3 future 2nds, and some end of the bench guysI ain't involved but I know one team is a clear winner

Newton/Lynch?

AND Greene...I feel like this isn't even close. And I rarely feel that way. One team got the three best players. Wow.

I agree. Several league members and I think that this upsets the integrity of the league. The commish, who is Team A in this deal, refuses to allow a league vote. Regrettably, as a first year dynasty, we don't have anything in the rules about vetoes. It's threatening to split the league apart

that trade is perfectly fine imo

Actually has a small chance of workin out in team b favor. Slight chance albeit

if cam and lynch end up dead in a ditch

I will easily take Ingram, Jackson, and the picks over Lynch and Greene. Not a believer that Newton will repeat, but could be wrong. Always 2 sides to a coin. You got a crystal ball?

 

[bmsarvis]

12 Team PPR 1 QB, must start 2 RB with capability of up to 4.Team A Got: Cam Newton, Marshawn Lynch, Shonn Greene, and some end of the bench guysTeam B Got: RGIII, Ingram, FJax, 3 future 2nds, and some end of the bench guysI ain't involved but I know one team is a clear winner

Newton/Lynch?

AND Greene...I feel like this isn't even close. And I rarely feel that way. One team got the three best players. Wow.

I agree. Several league members and I think that this upsets the integrity of the league. The commish, who is Team A in this deal, refuses to allow a league vote. Regrettably, as a first year dynasty, we don't have anything in the rules about vetoes. It's threatening to split the league apart

that trade is perfectly fine imo

Actually has a small chance of workin out in team b favor. Slight chance albeit

if cam and lynch end up dead in a ditch

I will easily take Ingram, Jackson, and the picks over Lynch and Greene. Not a believer that Newton will repeat, but could be wrong. Always 2 sides to a coin. You got a crystal ball?

W the injuries ingram suffered he can def bounce back.this.year and rg3 is pretty high on my qb list. 3 second rd picks can solidify a roster if the right guys fall and are taken. Id rather have Newton side but i won't say it was a bad trade

 

[JPeso]

14 team PPRGave: Mike Wallace and Doug MartinGot: Arian Foster and Jerome Simpson

I'll take Wallace and Martin here.

 

[the turnip]

16 team / $1000 Salary cap / contract length Dynasty league (NON ppr)

Team A gave

Roddy White $75

Mike Crabtree $66

Jemicheal Finley $31

2012 25th rookie draft pick

Team B gave

Rob Gronkowski $13

 

[lbouchard]

16 team / $1000 Salary cap / contract length Dynasty league (NON ppr)Team A gave Roddy White $75Mike Crabtree $66Jemicheal Finley $312012 25th rookie draft pickTeam B gaveRob Gronkowski $13

wow. Gronk side by a mile

 

[the turnip]

You would prefer to be team B?

16 team / $1000 Salary cap / contract length Dynasty league (NON ppr)

Team A gave

Roddy White $75

Mike Crabtree $66

Jemicheal Finley $31

2012 25th rookie draft pick

Team B gave

Rob Gronkowski $13

wow. Gronk side by a mile

 

[Andy Dufresne]

Zealots, non-PPR, IDP

Minnesota Vikings gives up Floyd, Malcom SDC WRMcClain, Rolando OAK LB Year 2013 Round 1 Draft Pick from Minnesota VikingsYear 2013 Round 3 Draft Pick from Minnesota VikingsNew Orleans Saints gives up Romo, Tony DAL QBCarlson, John MIN TEBailey, Dan DAL PKBarnett, Nick BUF LB Year 2013 Round 5 Draft Pick from Minnesota VikingsYear 2013 Round 6 Draft Pick from New Orleans Saints

Needed a #2 QB. I think the 1st I gave up was worth Romo & Barnett. Got rid of junk (McClain) and am okay losing Floyd - he's a tease.What's funny is that I traded Romo to the same guy earlier in the year:

New Orleans Saints will giveJackson, Tarvaris SEA QBCruz, Victor NYG WRYear 2013 Round 2 Draft Pick from New Orleans SaintsTo Minnesota Vikings forRomo, Tony DAL QBYear 2013 Round 5 Draft Pick from Minnesota Vikings

So really it's like a 1st for Cruz and Barnett.

 

[Dr. Octopus]

12 Team PPR 1 QB, must start 2 RB with capability of up to 4.Team A Got: Cam Newton, Marshawn Lynch, Shonn Greene, and some end of the bench guysTeam B Got: RGIII, Ingram, FJax, 3 future 2nds, and some end of the bench guysI ain't involved but I know one team is a clear winner

Newton/Lynch?

AND Greene...I feel like this isn't even close. And I rarely feel that way. One team got the three best players. Wow.

I agree. Several league members and I think that this upsets the integrity of the league. The commish, who is Team A in this deal, refuses to allow a league vote. Regrettably, as a first year dynasty, we don't have anything in the rules about vetoes. It's threatening to split the league apart

That's going a little too far. It's a bad trade for sure, but it's not Earth shattering. If Ingram lives up to his potential, it will balance out a little.

 

[Dr. Octopus]

12 Team PPR 1 QB, must start 2 RB with capability of up to 4.

Team A Got: Cam Newton, Marshawn Lynch, Shonn Greene, and some end of the bench guys

Team B Got: RGIII, Ingram, FJax, 3 future 2nds, and some end of the bench guys

I ain't involved but I know one team is a clear winner

Newton/Lynch?

AND Greene...I feel like this isn't even close. And I rarely feel that way. One team got the three best players. Wow.

I agree. Several league members and I think that this upsets the integrity of the league. The commish, who is Team A in this deal, refuses to allow a league vote. Regrettably, as a first year dynasty, we don't have anything in the rules about vetoes. It's threatening to split the league apart

that trade is perfectly fine imo

Actually has a small chance of workin out in team b favor. Slight chance albeit

if cam and lynch end up dead in a ditch

I don't mean this as an insult, but is this your first dynasty league? You seem to be way over-reacting to a bad, but not terrible trade. I've seen much worse trades go down, and sometimes these things have a way of working out in a way we don't expect.If Griffin has an outstanding rookie season, his value will creep up much closer to Newton's and Ingram had a disappointing rookie season, but so did Rashard Mendenhall, Beanie Wells, Ray Rice, and Lesean McCoy just to name a few recent examples.

Don't get yourself and the league all worked up over nothing. The commish is right not to veto it, especially if you have no veto rule in place (and you really shouldn't unless you think there is some cheating going on).

 

[mozzy84]

12 Team PPR 1 QB, must start 2 RB with capability of up to 4.Team A Got: Cam Newton, Marshawn Lynch, Shonn Greene, and some end of the bench guysTeam B Got: RGIII, Ingram, FJax, 3 future 2nds, and some end of the bench guysI ain't involved but I know one team is a clear winner

Newton/Lynch?

AND Greene...I feel like this isn't even close. And I rarely feel that way. One team got the three best players. Wow.

I agree. Several league members and I think that this upsets the integrity of the league. The commish, who is Team A in this deal, refuses to allow a league vote. Regrettably, as a first year dynasty, we don't have anything in the rules about vetoes. It's threatening to split the league apart

that trade is perfectly fine imo

Actually has a small chance of workin out in team b favor. Slight chance albeit

its not a "upset the leagues integrity" type trade by any means or a vetoable trade. I hate whiny owners like that...

 

[lbouchard]

12 Team PPR 1 QB, must start 2 RB with capability of up to 4.

Team A Got: Cam Newton, Marshawn Lynch, Shonn Greene, and some end of the bench guys

Team B Got: RGIII, Ingram, FJax, 3 future 2nds, and some end of the bench guys

I ain't involved but I know one team is a clear winner

Newton/Lynch?

AND Greene...I feel like this isn't even close. And I rarely feel that way. One team got the three best players. Wow.

I agree. Several league members and I think that this upsets the integrity of the league. The commish, who is Team A in this deal, refuses to allow a league vote. Regrettably, as a first year dynasty, we don't have anything in the rules about vetoes. It's threatening to split the league apart

that trade is perfectly fine imo

Actually has a small chance of workin out in team b favor. Slight chance albeit

if cam and lynch end up dead in a ditch

I don't mean this as an insult, but is this your first dynasty league? You seem to be way over-reacting to a bad, but not terrible trade. I've seen much worse trades go down, and sometimes these things have a way of working out in a way we don't expect.If Griffin has an outstanding rookie season, his value will creep up much closer to Newton's and Ingram had a disappointing rookie season, but so did Rashard Mendenhall, Beanie Wells, Ray Rice, and Lesean McCoy just to name a few recent examples.

Don't get yourself and the league all worked up over nothing. The commish is right not to veto it, especially if you have no veto rule in place (and you really shouldn't unless you think there is some cheating going on).

No it's not, I've been playing for several years. I too have seen worse deals go down. I'll explain further. Team A and Team B are the only people in the league who know each other personally. Team B had a major weakness at WR, but was set at QB and RB. He gave away his best two players ( one of who is a top 10 dynasty asset) and didn't upgrade his team in any manner, actually weakened it. Meanwhile Team A obviously strengthened his team. I'm actually not that upset, but I know that at least the half thinks it upsets the league integrity.

 

[Coeur de Lion]

The fact that it's a brand new startup makes it worse, IMO. Cam and Lynch were likely that guy's top 2 picks and he dumped them for guys likely taken 2/3+ rounds later. I'm generally a big proponent of quality > quantity in a dynasty format, and a guy like Cam should be fetching a proven young stud in return. Still nowhere near vetoable though.

 

[Sebowski]

I'm curious about who these "end of the bench guys" are

 

[Couch Potato]

I'm curious about who these "end of the bench guys" are

Found one of 'emAnd another one

 

[Sebowski]

Two just went down. I think both have clear winners. One especially lopsided.

Donald Brown

Wes Welker

2.4

For

Nicks

1.3

-------

ShEli Manning

4.3

For

Ponder

'13 First Rounder (historically top 3)

 

[ctrlaltdefeat]

The 1.03 is on the wrong side of the deal. Stole nicks and the 1.03 highway robbery

 

[Buck Stop]

Just made this trade in my 12 team PPR dynasty. Banking on winning it now, as I normally don't like getting almost 12 years older in trades.

I gave: Ashlon Jeffery

I get: Steve Smith Panthers

Starters:

Stafford

Richardson, Stewart

Calvin, Marshall, Smitty

Gates, Cook

 

[xtreme11]

16 Team PPR

Team A

AJ Green

Team B

Victor Cruz

2013 1st (most likely back half)

 

[I was in the pool]

I gave: Decker, S.Rice, 13 1st

Received: Julio

Post trade 12 team, PPR roster highlights:

Cam

TRich, Spiller, Quizz, Hunter, Ry.Will

Green, Julio, Nicks, Dez, Demaryius, T.Smith, Cobb, Little, Hankerson.

Graham, Gresham

 

[Buck Stop]

I gave: Decker, S.Rice, 13 1stReceived: JulioPost trade 12 team, PPR roster highlights:CamTRich, Spiller, Quizz, Hunter, Ry.WillGreen, Julio, Nicks, Dez, Demaryius, T.Smith, Cobb, Little, Hankerson.Graham, Gresham

What a steal for you. LOVE it.

 

[Skeletore Eh]

I gave: Decker, S.Rice, 13 1stReceived: JulioPost trade 12 team, PPR roster highlights:CamTRich, Spiller, Quizz, Hunter, Ry.WillGreen, Julio, Nicks, Dez, Demaryius, T.Smith, Cobb, Little, Hankerson.Graham, Gresham

What a steal for you. LOVE it.

julio side easily

 

[Skeletore Eh]

16 Team PPRTeam AAJ GreenTeam BVictor Cruz2013 1st (most likely back half)

green side easily.

 

[Skeletore Eh]

Just made this trade in my 12 team PPR dynasty. Banking on winning it now, as I normally don't like getting almost 12 years older in trades.I gave: Ashlon JefferyI get: Steve Smith PanthersStarters:StaffordRichardson, StewartCalvin, Marshall, SmittyGates, Cook

assuming i'm not in complete rebuild mode, i love the steve smith side

 

[Buck Stop]

Just made this trade in my 12 team PPR dynasty. Banking on winning it now, as I normally don't like getting almost 12 years older in trades.I gave: Ashlon JefferyI get: Steve Smith PanthersStarters:StaffordRichardson, StewartCalvin, Marshall, SmittyGates, Cook

assuming i'm not in complete rebuild mode, i love the steve smith side

Thanks. I won this league last year using smoke and mirrors, and definitely did a mini rebuild. Last year's starting lineup in the championship game was-VickSproles, Kahil Bell, Sammy Morris (no I'm not kidding)AJG, Marshall, SmittyGatesI actually traded away Smitty but got him back after this trade. I got younger at QB and at RB, and upgraded from AJG to Calvin at WR. Hoping for a repeat!

 

[Winning IS Everything]

Team A gets:

Shonn Greene

Team B gets:

Rashard Mendenhall

 

[ExaltedOne]

Team a gives

Kenny Britt WR

Andre Caldwell WR

2013 1st

Team b gives

Brandon Marshall WR

Jerome Simpson WR

2013 3rd

 

[Sabertooth]

Team A receives:

Josh Gordon

Delone Carter

Ryan Mallet

Round 1 2013

Team B receives:

Ben Tate

Robert Turbin

Michael Crabtree

Round 2 2013

 

[ExaltedOne]

Team A receives: Josh GordonDelone CarterRyan MalletRound 1 2013Team B receives:Ben TateRobert TurbinMichael CrabtreeRound 2 2013

I like the Tate side by a lot.

 

[lbouchard]

Took advantage of the Dez arrest in my 12 team PPR

Gave: Antonio Brown, 2013 first (my team is strong contender, should be 1.09-1.12)

Got: Dez Bryant

 

[Sabertooth]

Team A receives: Josh GordonDelone CarterRyan MalletRound 1 2013Team B receives:Ben TateRobert TurbinMichael CrabtreeRound 2 2013

I like the Tate side by a lot.

That was my side. Initial offer from him had me giving a 1st and receiving a 3rd. Then I countered with me receiving a 2nd and him getting a 3rd. We settle on him getting a 1st and me a 2nd. Funny thing is, we had our initial startup draft only 3 weeks ago, I picked Mallet and Gordon off the waiver wire (I got a little too hammered at the draft and had to make some moves...I think I had 8 quarterbacks..lol).

 

[Sabertooth]

Took advantage of the Dez arrest in my 12 team PPRGave: Antonio Brown, 2013 first (my team is strong contender, should be 1.09-1.12)Got: Dez Bryant

Not sure on this one to be honest. Brown is a real player. He's shown more so far in two seasons than Dez has.