Cirton, the firm that loves to trash DDD, has moved onto PLUG, saying fair value is 50 cents.
Down 20-25% today.
I'm back in it
-QG
Let's say that at some point in time Share Price and True Value Meet. If there was a continuum of Price:Value it might look something like this:
Crashing Bear Market= Extremely Undervalued
Bear Market= Undervalued
Minor Bear= Undervalued to Slightly Undervalued
Minor Bull= Slightly undervalued to Fairly Valued
Bull= Fairly Valued to Slightly Overvalued
Bubble= Extremely Overvalued
$PLUG was a $.50 stock in November.. Let's agree it was undervalued at $.50. But at the nearly $12 it was trading at early today that's an increase of more than 20x in share value in 4 months. Does it seem likely that somehow investors in the midst of a 4+ year bull market completely "missed" the value of $PLUG and are just catching up?
Does:
1) growth rate;
2) Sales;
3) PROFITS in the past 4 months validate such an extreme move?
Or has the exuberance of the crowd pushed the stock into bubble territory?
Earlier today this was a $billion market cap company with a lot of negative fundamentals and revenues of just under $25m. Perhaps the earnings report in a couple of days will show dramatic improvement. I did try to place a trade in the early part of the year for $PLUG at $1.60ish that never got filled- and I typically don't chase (which has hurt me considerably this year)
Technically $PLUG is wildly bullish even with the decline today. Though this bar will be concerning.
I'd love to hear thoughts on why it should be "honestly" valued at more than $3-$4 which was the high end of my expectation for the entire 2014 back when I tried to make the trade in Jan.
Edit: All things being equal: I would also expect that even with today's decline $PLUG will work it's way back towards the old highs and probably even exceed them. It's that kind of market. (The one caveat is the earning report)