What's new
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

2019 College football thread - It's 2020, yo. Go to the new thread. (4 Viewers)

Last edited by a moderator:
facook said:
This is the right answer.  That way the Capellas of the world get their "eye test" Alabama in every year and the rest of us get our "results on the field" champs and small school dreamers in every year.  Also, quarters should be on campus of the top 4 conference champs.
Click to expand...
Cmon...the only ‘eye test’ selection of Bama was ‘17, when they won.  By far the least worthy selections have been based on Conf Champs. 

 
Oh come on.....can we get one competitive semifinal game ever? Having so many blowouts routinely in the final four shows 4 teams is plenty. Most years only two teams deserve the title shot and now at least we get the semifinals to show people that's the case.

 
Jayded said:
Oh come on.....can we get one competitive semifinal game ever? Having so many blowouts routinely in the final four shows 4 teams is plenty. Most years only two teams deserve the title shot and now at least we get the semifinals to show people that's the case.
Click to expand...
nope.  8 teams is the future.   Maybe more once the NCAA and sponsors see how much more money playoff games will generate. 

 
Jayded said:
Oh come on.....can we get one competitive semifinal game ever? Having so many blowouts routinely in the final four shows 4 teams is plenty. Most years only two teams deserve the title shot and now at least we get the semifinals to show people that's the case.
Click to expand...
Again, the 4th seed has won the title 40% of the time. It's not #1 and #2 always blowing out #3 and #4. 

 
SHIZNITTTT said:
nope.  8 teams is the future.   Maybe more once the NCAA and sponsors see how much more money playoff games will generate. 
Click to expand...
The only real argument anymore is the G5 argument from the anti-trust position. Given what we just saw with OU/LSU and so far what we've seen in this second game, adding four more teams to this won't increase the "good football" we would all get to see. We'd get even more poundings.

 
With 141 rush yards tonight, J.K. Dobbins (1,970) has now passed Eddie George (1,927) for the most rush yards in a single-season for an Ohio State player.  

Wow!

 
Jayded said:
The only real argument anymore is the G5 argument from the anti-trust position. Given what we just saw with OU/LSU and so far what we've seen in this second game, adding four more teams to this won't increase the "good football" we would all get to see. We'd get even more poundings.
Click to expand...
Are we going to base the future on tonights games?   again no one wants to see ND and ISU playing in whatever bowl they were in today.    But for arguments sake ...

LSU vs Wisconsin

Ohio State vs Baylor

Clemson vs Oregon

Oklahoma vs Georgia  

All of those games would be fun to watch.

 
gump said:
Cmon...the only ‘eye test’ selection of Bama was ‘17, when they won.  By far the least worthy selections have been based on Conf Champs. 
Click to expand...
Capella represents a very legit opinion in this thread: put in the best "other" team every year.  

Conference champs should have a shot.  So should the G5.  And add in 2 wild cards, it's the best option we have.  The top 4 conference champs should host the quarters each year.  Better than the tripe bowls we get now.

 
SHIZNITTTT said:
Are we going to base the future on tonights games?   again no one wants to see ND and ISU playing in whatever bowl they were in today.    But for arguments sake ...

LSU vs Wisconsin

Ohio State vs Baylor

Clemson vs Oregon

Oklahoma vs Georgia  

All of those games would be fun to watch.
Click to expand...
You’d need to exclude Wisconsin for Memphis though as a G5. My biggest gripe would be Baylor, Georgia, and Oregon all lost twice. I like 4 teams because it keeps the regular season meaningful and think including those teams would cheapen the seasons had by LSU, OSU, and Clemson. 

 
ILUVBEER99 said:
no way.  A lot of conferences are garbage.  They don't deserve to make playoffs because they won their trash conference.
Click to expand...
Conferences are going to be realigned in a few years, but it still seems the right way. Let the committee argue over the seeding.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
facook said:
Capella represents a very legit opinion in this thread: put in the best "other" team every year.  

Conference champs should have a shot.  So should the G5.  And add in 2 wild cards, it's the best option we have.  The top 4 conference champs should host the quarters each year.  Better than the tripe bowls we get now.
Click to expand...
Sounds good...with true wild card slots regardless of conference (meaning they could both come from the same one). The eye test has proven to be a legit selection process.

 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

Joey Wright
2025-2026 NCAA College Basketball Thread
Replies
17
Views
428
gump
gump
Sigmund Bloom
Visiting New Orleans Thread
Replies
29
Views
788
Sigmund Bloom
Sigmund Bloom
Todem
Official Rush “Fifty Something Tour” Thread
2
Replies
81
Views
1K
Todem
Todem

Users who are viewing this thread

Total: 3 (members: 0, guests: 3)
Back
Top