I can’t see Indy moving out of there spot until they are on the clock. If 1 and 2 are QBs I don’t see how they could pass on Barkley.
If I am the Cleveland GM I roll the dice and take Barkley at 1 then at 4 you know there will still be 3 QB options there (or maybe even all of them).
For the Giants, I know (from reading posts in this thread) that they said Eli is their guy and they have many holes to fill but if I’m them, I still take a QB here. They have enough pieces (when healthy) that they shouldn’t be picking this high in the draft again. Rosen and Darnold are 21 this year and Eli is 37. That gives them 3 years to groom them and provides them with a backup. This is an opportunity and unless they don’t believe in any of the QBs I think it would be a wasted opportunity so solidify the most important position.
My prediction...
1 Cle Barkley, 2 NYG Darnold, 3 NYJ (trade with Indy) Allen, 4 Cle Rosen, 5 Denver Mayfield. Then the Bills trade up in front of AZ with GB and take Jackson.
*The Jets/Indy trade really works for both teams. The Jets get to jump Cle and Den but Indy sees they can gain extra picks without having to sacrifice any player options because of the likely QB run and Barkley is gone.