Not even average. The dude got his stats chasing people down field. He was horrible in GB and can’t believe he got paid that much. Fans in GB were screaming for a replacement of him. Giants will be disappointed in this signing.
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums
This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!
2021 New York football Giants (2 Viewers)
- Thread starter Yenrub
- Start date
fruity pebbles
Footballguy
Yeah, I was trying to be kind. I focused on him in several games I watched cause I was planning on moving him in a fantasy league. Dude is perpetually out of position in the run game and a downright liability in pass defense.
Last edited by a moderator:
Yenrub
Footballguy
The Frankman
Footballguy
Giants sign RB Dion Lewis to a 1-year deal. Obvioiusly this is the compete with Wayne Gallman Jr., but Lewis is a Judge/Patriots connection. Would not suprise me to see him win the job as the coaching staff soured on WGJr. last year.
Yenrub
Footballguy
It was a totally different coaching staff that soured on Gallman so he still might have a fighting chance
Giants Depth Chart ...
https://forums.footballguys.com/forum/topic/753841-infinite-new-york-football-giants-thread/page/33/?tab=comments#comment-22597975
This is crazy .... this is a much worse team than last year on paper.
Much weaker O'line and TE's on offense ...Less depth and inexperience at Safety and SCB and weaker at DE/OLB
https://forums.footballguys.com/forum/topic/753841-infinite-new-york-football-giants-thread/page/33/?tab=comments#comment-22597975
This is crazy .... this is a much worse team than last year on paper.
Much weaker O'line and TE's on offense ...Less depth and inexperience at Safety and SCB and weaker at DE/OLB
The Big Donkey
Footballguy
Dan Duggan
@DDuggan21
The Giants are signing DT Austin Johnson, per source. A second-round pick in 2016, Johnson spent the past four seasons with the Titans (13 starts). NJ native's position coach at Penn State: New Giants DL coach Sean Spencer.
@DDuggan21
The Giants are signing DT Austin Johnson, per source. A second-round pick in 2016, Johnson spent the past four seasons with the Titans (13 starts). NJ native's position coach at Penn State: New Giants DL coach Sean Spencer.
This could mean the Giants are about to rescind Leonard Williams Franchise tag to persue Clowney which would make this their best free agent move .
I still want Williams but would love to to see them negotiate ~4 year $40-48 milion for him and a 4 year $60-$70m for Clowney
They have to fix this mess that they have created
Last edited by a moderator:
JetMaxx
Footballguy
Williams and Clowney are highly drafted turds from elsewhere and yet you advocate signing them to big contracts to fix the mess?
Last edited by a moderator:
Clowney is a top 10 edge player in the NFL ... top 3-5 against the run and he is only 27 with potential to get better - $16m a year is reasonable ... It fills a huge need and allows the Giants to fill other holes in the draft. It's is weak Edge draft with no depth so the Giants, who neglected Oline in Free Agency, will have to fill RT, Center cover LBer through the draft.JetMaxx said:Williams and Clowney are highly drafted turds from elsewhere and yet you advocate signing them to big contracts to fix the mess?
Williams is also very good against the run ... Giants run D Improved significantly after his arrival .... still only 25 with tons of potential ... $11m a year is a steal for what should be his prime years
People put to much emphasis on Sacks which are somewhat fluky and unpredictable. QB pressures are more consistent year to year and a better measurement of pass rush ability. Clowney and Williams both put a lot of pressure on QBs and are stellar against the run which most sack leaders are not.
Had the Giants signed Conklin as a FA they could have drafted an edge rusher in the 1st 3 rounds ... they cant afford to do that now unless Chase Young falls to them. Their holes at RT C and MLB are far bigger than Edge
Last edited by a moderator:
Guy from Locked on Packers was on Patricia Traina Locked on Giants talking about Fackrell. He said Fackrell's pressures to sacks ratio in 2018 was fluky and unsustainable. In fact he had more pressures in 2019 when he only 1 sack than he did in 2018 when he had 10.5 sacks.
Also said Fackrell was not good at all vs the run.
You get what pay for
Also said Fackrell was not good at all vs the run.
You get what pay for
Last edited by a moderator:
It's sounding like the Giants are going to be drafting Oline with the first pick in less they are able to trade out of the spot. I'm fine with that as long as it is Jedrick Wills who is clearly the best OT in the class. I've seen some mocks taking Andrew Thomas which would be a huge mistake ...Thomas is not strong enough and athletic enough to be a top OT in the NFL. Wirfs has that incredibly strong and athletic build but does not have the incredible quickness and natural instincts that Wills has
Take a look at the links below ... Andrew Thomas unimpressive highlights where he is consistently almost beat one on one at the collegiate level. Most of his highlights are double teams. Look at his quickness and footwork compare to Wills in the next link. Them look at Wills vs Wirfs and notice how much better his footwork and technique are then either Wirfs or Thomas. Look at the way he use his hands and punch to keep the defenders at a distance and off balance.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uie24vz5btk
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6K-OL21I2xE
Take a look at the links below ... Andrew Thomas unimpressive highlights where he is consistently almost beat one on one at the collegiate level. Most of his highlights are double teams. Look at his quickness and footwork compare to Wills in the next link. Them look at Wills vs Wirfs and notice how much better his footwork and technique are then either Wirfs or Thomas. Look at the way he use his hands and punch to keep the defenders at a distance and off balance.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uie24vz5btk
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6K-OL21I2xE
Yenrub
Footballguy
Thanks for the videos. If the Giants are going to OL, I sure hope they can trade down a bit then pick one.
Obviously it takes two to tango
This may sound crazy but I might go as far drafting Tua if MIA or some other team refuses to trade up. Once he's off the board someone will be willing to trade for him or to a lesser extent Jones. I think jones is clearly worth a 1st rounder plus after what he did his rookie season.
There are too many highly rate QBs for teams not to trade up ... It wouldnt be out of the question to see 3 QBS go in the 5 picks (Burrow , Tua and the Herbert are as good a top 3 QBs propects as we've seen in years )
Tua is a better prospect than almost any QB is recent years ... if he doesnt go in the top 3 he'd be hard to pass uo
Last edited by a moderator:
Yenrub
Footballguy
Jones was pretty impressive last year
I read that Pats are looking to use a premium pick on a QB and they have a lot of draft picks (3 x 3rd rounders ) ... Jones looks the part for the Pats
So maybe Jone to the Pats for their 1st #23 overall and 2 of their 3rd rounders ... Then trade the 23rd and one of the 3s to move back up in the first round to grab a T
End up with Tua , OT and an extra 3rd rd pick
10-20 after the big two...And possibly 3. I’m guessing giants go ol 1st round and trade back a few spots to get additional picks. The giants desperately need someone who can pressure qb but they will likely go def heavy after 1st round.
We drafted a qb last year so we cant draft a more valuable qb this year seems like a mistake waiting to happen.
What round draft pick do you have to add with Jones to get Tua?
I think this is a stupid strategy that is only going to bite them in the ###. How would "offers eventually come"?
If NYG and DET took QBs, then Miami is ON THE CLOCK. They could reach for a different QB or trade back, or take some Oline player (one maybe the Giants didn't want) and that screws everything up for both teams. Also they likely will have made their other first round picks too, so any trade DET or NYG got, would likely involve FUTURE picks rather than getting more picks in this draft. Would be dumb on all fronts.
Yenrub
Footballguy
Here is link to Jimmy's videoDeamon said:
https://twitter.com/NFLonFOX/status/1252447970735292417?s=20
Just watched it. I absolutely can't get behind that. You're not only missing out on a stud defensive player that you want, but any picks you acquire for this QB will be 2021 picks or later. How does that help? That's a massive risk and I wouldn't do it but Jimmy is entitled to his opinion.
Angry Beavers
Footballguy
Based on the amount of HW the NYG are doing on Herbert - maybe they are thinking of taking him and trading Jones. 
Smoke screen dude.Based on the amount of HW the NYG are doing on Herbert - maybe they are thinking of taking him and trading Jones.
Jimmy Drafted a Supplimental QB Steve Walsh giving up his 1st Rd pick in 1990 after Drafting Aikman with the #1 Pick in 1989
He turned around and traded Walsh for Saints' No. 1 and No. 3 choices in 1991 and a No. 2 pick in 1992 which could have been upgraded to a No. 1 if Walsh had peformed
Tua would have likely been the #1 pick in this years draft had he not gotten injured. The guy is worth a ton if he is avaiable and you have to take him whether it's for trade or for the future QB.
The Giants are terrible at playing their hand and the Phins and Chargers know it. The only way they will give up picks is if you draft Tua or Herbert ahead of them. They will immediately propose a trade before the next pick if that happens and you have them right where you want them ... bidding against each other
He turned around and traded Walsh for Saints' No. 1 and No. 3 choices in 1991 and a No. 2 pick in 1992 which could have been upgraded to a No. 1 if Walsh had peformed
Tua would have likely been the #1 pick in this years draft had he not gotten injured. The guy is worth a ton if he is avaiable and you have to take him whether it's for trade or for the future QB.
The Giants are terrible at playing their hand and the Phins and Chargers know it. The only way they will give up picks is if you draft Tua or Herbert ahead of them. They will immediately propose a trade before the next pick if that happens and you have them right where you want them ... bidding against each other
Gettleman has done so many unbelievably bad things ... passing on Darnold was not one of them. In fact passing on Darnold and Rosen, for that matter, may be the only sensible things that he has done since coming to the Giants.Faust said:
- While drafting Daniel Jones was not a bad thing ... Drafting Daniel Jones with the 6th pick, ahead of Josh Allen (LB). with a historically strong QB draft class coming up in 2020. and while you are desperate for an Edge Rusher ...is really really, really really bad.
- Trading a 3rd and 4th rd pick for DT Leonard Williams, who was going to be a free agent, in a lost season, when your only postion of strength on Defense is DT ... is incredibly bad.
- Not signing Conklin or Clowney when you are loaded with Cap $$$ and desperate for an OT and an Edge rusher is inexcusable.
- Using high draft picks and High priced free agents to stockpile questionable to OK CBs is pretty freakin bad
I fully expect him to do at least a few of the following ####ups torrow ...
- Fail to leverage the 4th pick in a QB loaded draft with multiple QB needy teams loaded with draft stock (MIA, LAC, CAR, JAC and NE)
- Draft another DT Derrick Brown or Corner Okudah with the 4th Pick in the draft
- Take an OT but it's Mekhi Becton (Flowers II), Andrew Thomas or Josh Jones
- Fail to land Chase Young, Isaiah Simmons or Jedrick Wills even if they land in his lap
Last edited by a moderator:
Yenrub
Footballguy
Draft day is here.
I want the Giants to trade down but I do not think it will happen.
If they stay at 4, I want Simmons but I don’t think it will happen. (I just like defense more than offense as a fan) I expect them to take one of the OL which is fine by me because they definitely need to upgrade the tackle spot.
I want the Giants to trade down but I do not think it will happen.
If they stay at 4, I want Simmons but I don’t think it will happen. (I just like defense more than offense as a fan) I expect them to take one of the OL which is fine by me because they definitely need to upgrade the tackle spot.
Yeah I'm with you on this ... Also Simmons is clearly the Top Defender after Chase Young and a unique talent. Taking a tackle at this position is kind of a waste of a 4th rd pick because you could get a similar and possibly better OT 5-10 picks later.
If Gettleman had played his cards right in Free Agency they could have done no wrong
- Sign Conklin draft Simmons ... No brainer
- Sign Clowny draft OT ... No Brainer
- Sign Both ...opportunities are endless
Yenrub
Footballguy
BTW Leonard Williams signed his franchise tag yesterday
https://www.nj.com/giants/2020/04/nfl-rumors-giants-leonard-williams-signs-expensive-franchise-tag-why-thats-not-exactly-a-good-thing.html
https://www.nj.com/giants/2020/04/nfl-rumors-giants-leonard-williams-signs-expensive-franchise-tag-why-thats-not-exactly-a-good-thing.html
ConstruxBoy
Kate's Daddy
Living in Charlotte and having followed the Panthers, 0.05% chance that Gettleman doesn't #### this up.
ConstruxBoy
Kate's Daddy
You might be better off with Lloyd Christmas as your GM. At least he doesn't try to pretend he's smarter than everyone else.
The Big Donkey
Footballguy
Hoping for a deal with the Jags #4 for #9 and #20.
#9 - Wirfs or Wills
#20 - Kenneth Murray (LB, OU)
#35 - Cesar Ruiz (C, Michigan)
Not Bad ... might be a little early for Murray (K'Lavon Chaisson/ Patrick Queen) I might go with another D player at #35 (Epenesa or Baun) and hope to get a C at 99 (Biadasz or Hennessy)
az_prof
Footballguy
I'm actually OK with this pick ... I was pissed at first but the more I read the more I like.
Of the Top 4 OT - Thomas is the least risk and the Most NFL / LT Ready ... It's possible they move Soldier to RT
- Thomas - Is a Pure Left Tackle that could play Right Tackle
- Wills - As good as he is and as much as I like his footwork and hands ...He's never played LT
- Wirfs - has played mostly RT and said that he is more comfortable at RT ... some say he may move inside
- Beckton - Huge risk ... I would hate to take a project in the first half of the draft
The Frankman
Footballguy
Yeah, this is actually a very pre-Jerry Reese Giants pick... doesn't have the highest upside but has the highest floor and is versatile. It's a good, safe pick.
The Big Donkey
Footballguy
Matos, Epenesa, Baun
Delpit, McKinney, Winfield
What you gonna do Gettleman?
Hoping they wait on C til later, sure could of used that early 3rd round pick.
Delpit, McKinney, Winfield
What you gonna do Gettleman?
Hoping they wait on C til later, sure could of used that early 3rd round pick.
Last edited by a moderator:
I dont want Winfield ...to small at 5'9"... Id be fine with Matos or Baun ...Maybe Epenesa but he looked really terrible in the combine drills
I'm hoping they move up in the 3rd ... package a 6 or 7th rder with pick 99 to move up 10-15 slots ... what ever it take to get a Center. I'd be thrilled with Biadasz ... I think his value dropped to much because of the hip injury.
I'd like a big Receiver like Pittman or Higgins but cant see anyway they could squeeze in LB, C and WR
Yenrub
Footballguy
To move up in the 3rd they will likely have to move down in the 2nd. I don't think those 7th rounders are worth much
Similar threads
