Also, I think it's now fair to start to ask questions about this year's draft class. This team had very few starting spots open in camp, so it's not surprising that we didn't see much from the rookies early on, but it's kind of wild at how none of these guys has done much of anything.
Elam -- Can't beat out a guy who other teams are intentionally targeting (Dane Jackson).
Cook -- How long does it really take for a RB to transition into the NFL? He's still a liability in pass protection.
Bernard -- Whole lot of nothing.
Shakir -- Whole lot of nothing.
Araiza -- Well, you know . . .
Benford -- A nice find in the sixth round, but he's should be quality depth, not a starter.
Tenuta -- Gone.
Spector -- Nothing.
Obviously I'm not worried about whiffing on somebody like Luke Tenuta, but we've gotten next to nothing out of our draft class so far. I was very pleased with this group back in May.
I’m not as worried about the rookie thing as I am frustrated with the staff for not playing them more. This team’s insistence that they bring rookies along slowly no matter what is mind boggling when the team clearly needs more from them. Their hand was forced with the two rookie CBs and ultimately that will be a good thing IMO. Elam has been a disappointment considering his draft position (though he’s being asked to do way more off coverage when his strength in college was press man) but Benford has actually been pretty good. He could very well end up the #2 CB to White.
The guys on offense just simply aren’t being given opportunities. Shakir is being given no playing time. And they have no trust in Cook. His pass blocking hasn’t been tremendous, and I get that’s a problem, but if the O-line wasn’t so garbage that it forces the RB to straight up take on blockers so often it wouldn’t be as big of a deal that Cook isn’t a great pass blocker.
The question is, where are the plays/schemes to get guys open and use their strengths? Shakir was a great possession receiver in college. Where are the slants and comeback routes to get him open/touches? Where are the formations to use Cook and Hines out wide to stress defenses? Or start them both in the backfield and run actual routes with them and/or motion them out wide to run routes? Where are the combo routes that work together to confuse and stress defenses? Where are the routes to the TE over the middle of the field? Nothing this offense does confuses or stresses defense.
How is it that other teams can run screens that break off for huge plays, but every time Buffalo runs a screen it gets blown up at the point of the catch? How can other teams have slot receivers and TEs run over the middle of the field and have nobody there to cut them off but Buffalo always has 2-3 defenders clogging that up? Diggs is the only guy on the team that can be expected to be good enough to just beat his coverage all the time. These other guys need some help to scheme up ways to get guys open. Guys like Davis, McKenzie, Knox, Shakir, Cook, and Hines have some elite skills, but Dorsey has done nothing to scheme ways to utilize those skills. As much as people complained about Dabol, he knew how to game plan for a defense and utilize the skills of his players to beat a defense. Dorsey seems like he just has a set playbook and each week goes out and just calls plays from the playbook with no rhyme or reason for why he is doing it against that defense other than he has plays for certain downs and distances and that’s that. So defenses shutdown screens before they start. They drop back into passing lanes at the goal line when they see an RPO. There’s no misdirection, there’s no double moves, there’s no WR stacking, there are no RPOs unless they’re in the red zone, etc. This team made a mistake in making Dorsey the OC. The guy is super smart, Allen loves him, he’s been with the team and all that, but this is a team that needed an experienced play caller that understands how to scheme against specific defenses each week.