2025 Team Defense & Defense by Committee Thread (14 Viewers)

[JohnnyU]

San Fran all day long vs Sanders on a rainy windy day , i see INTs and fumbles in this game .

That SF defense hasn’t been good. Whether real life or fantasy.

True but they just were good on Monday

Haven’t scored double digits all year. Had 5 games of 0 or 2 pts and 1 with -4. No thanks. That’s half their games from -4 to 2 points. Let that sink in for a while.

 

[BroncoFreak_2K3]

Picked up JAX after they were dropped along with ATL. Thinking JAX is the better play this week. Will hold ATL so no one else has them also...

 

[kyoun1e]

Debating Miami at home against NO with no Kamara and a banged up Olave or SF at Cleveland where the weather looks nasty.

Miami the better D I think but SF with the better matchup. I'm sure I'll pick wrong.

 

[JohnnyU]

Debating Miami at home against NO with no Kamara and a banged up Olave or SF at Cleveland where the weather looks nasty.

Miami the better D I think but SF with the better matchup. I'm sure I'll pick wrong.

Miami

 

[OnTheReg]

I love Sig but I cannot for the life of me ever make sense of his Rent a Defense column. Denver is a candidate this week? Not a single person dropped them on their bye.

The column often slightly confuses me.

Ok I’m glad I’m not the only one. Like I said love him but I haven’t gotten any real value out of it. The candidates are almost always 90% of the time on rosters.

 

[FarFromHome]

San Fran all day long vs Sanders on a rainy windy day , i see INTs and fumbles in this game .

That SF defense hasn’t been good. Whether real life or fantasy.

True but they just were good on Monday

Haven’t scored double digits all year. Had 5 games of 0 or 2 pts and 1 with -4. No thanks. That’s half their games from -4 to 2 points. Let that sink in for a while.

I'll add in they are dead last in sacks this year with 13. Like historically bad. We can research fantasy defenses for countless hours and the one thing I know for sure is my fantasy defense needs to get sacks. They don't. Hard pass no matter the matchup.

 

[Faust]

2025 NFL defensive line rankings ahead of Week 13: The Cleveland Browns continue to dominate

 

[Peak]

I have CLE in one of and BALT in the other. I considered dropping either for a better matchup this week, but after reading the thread, I think I'll stay out and roll the dice with both.

 

[Schmeabs]

San Fran all day long vs Sanders on a rainy windy day , i see INTs and fumbles in this game .

Huge day coming for SF D

 

[Doubles]

Should I drop the chargers vs LV to try and get Houston for ROS? Houston vs Daniel Jones I don’t mind as much especially after seeing what they did to Josh Allen. The claim goes through Sunday.

 

[Harjiran]

Should I drop the chargers vs LV to try and get Houston for ROS? Houston vs Daniel Jones I don’t mind as much especially after seeing what they did to Josh Allen. The claim goes through Sunday.

Run don't walk.

 

[urbanhack]

Anything to see with Philly at home against the Bears? Have Baltimore, but Burrow is back. Hmmmmmmmmm

 

[JohnnyU]

Anything to see with Philly at home against the Bears? Have Baltimore, but Burrow is back. Hmmmmmmmmm

I think Baltimore defense is playing well.

 

[Doubles]

Should I drop the chargers vs LV to try and get Houston for ROS? Houston vs Daniel Jones I don’t mind as much especially after seeing what they did to Josh Allen. The claim goes through Sunday.

Run don't walk.

Claim is in. This is the second league that I’m in that Houston got dropped after that Thursday night game. I don’t get it. How did anyone watch that game and not think that the Houston dst is not droppable? Maybe because it was on Amazon prime?

 

[Harjiran]

Should I drop the chargers vs LV to try and get Houston for ROS? Houston vs Daniel Jones I don’t mind as much especially after seeing what they did to Josh Allen. The claim goes through Sunday.

Run don't walk.

Claim is in. This is the second league that I’m in that Houston got dropped after that Thursday night game. I don’t get it. How did anyone watch that game and not think that the Houston dst is not droppable? Maybe because it was on Amazon prime?

They looked like the best D in the NFL - if people somehow missed that, you're wise to take advantage.

 

[Faust]

Eatman: A 'Super' last 4 days for THIS defense

Slater and Brooks discuss Cowboys' defense resurgence since Quinnen Williams trade | 'The Insiders'



Chiefs-Cowboys on Thanksgiving: What We Learned from Dallas' 31-28 win

Excerpt:

1. Dallas' defense continues to improve. The trade-deadline moves continue to pay off for Jerry Jones’ club. Defensive tackle Quinnen Williams generated a team-high six QB pressures and tied for the lead with two run stuffs. Williams’ presence completely changes how Dallas can play defense -- he took on 10 double teams on 29 pass rush snaps, most among Cowboys players. The back end getting healthier has also been massive for Brian Schottenheimer’s club, not as easily giving up free releases as they did early in the season. Things got a little wobbly early, with the Chiefs gashing Dallas on the opening drives, but the Cowboys defense settled in and made the stops that mattered. They held Patrick Mahomes & Co. to 5-of-13 on third downs for the game. The biggest stop was a quick three-and-out in the fourth quarter after Dallas retook the lead -- a spot where Mahomes usually answers.

 

[urbanhack]

I didn’t like the BAL play but stuck with it. Ugggg.

 

[Steelerhead]

Both starting tackles out for Bills, I’m thinking Steelers weekly ranking should be higher.

 

[Faust]

2025 NFL Defensive Tiers Week 13: Texans on Top; Eagles Drop; Browns Hold Firm

 

[VikingFrog]

Cleveland weather

24 mph wind, gusts up to 45 mph

64% chance of precipitation, 44% chance of 2-4 inches of snow.

If this weather pattern holds, I will have a rough time picking between Miami and Cleveland.

 

[kyoun1e]

Cleveland weather

24 mph wind, gusts up to 45 mph

64% chance of precipitation, 44% chance of 2-4 inches of snow.

If this weather pattern holds, I will have a rough time picking between Miami and Cleveland.

I'd have a hard time not going with CLE.

SF travelling east. Lousy weather. Burdy hasn't looked great anyway. Could see CLE offense just running it all day as well against that SF D.

 

[VikingFrog]

Been holding Tampa for a few weeks, but that playoff run not looking as juicy and I think there’s other options. Anyone dropping them.

Trying to make room for McClaurin to come off IR and they are likely my first droppable candidate.

 

[the moops]

Have DEN for next 2 weeks. I am in the playoffs and debating picking up either New Orleans or Pittsburgh or maybe even both (both would be hard with roster spots). Don't want to use DEN week 15 against GB or week 17 @ KC. Pitt has a bad week 16 matchup @ DET so don't wanna just roll with them.

Hmm. Parentheses has average points DST has scored against that team

Week 15 PIT vs MIA (9.5) or NO vs CAR (10.3)
Week 16 DEN vs JAX (8.3) or NO vs NYJ (10.2)
Week 17 PIT @ CLE (12.1) or NO @ TEN (13.0)

 

[ZADO]

San Fran all day long vs Sanders on a rainy windy day , i see INTs and fumbles in this game .

That SF defense hasn’t been good. Whether real life or fantasy.

True but they just were good on Monday

Haven’t scored double digits all year. Had 5 games of 0 or 2 pts and 1 with -4. No thanks. That’s half their games from -4 to 2 points. Let that sink in for a while.

I'll add in they are dead last in sacks this year with 13. Like historically bad. We can research fantasy defenses for countless hours and the one thing I know for sure is my fantasy defense needs to get sacks. They don't. Hard pass no matter the matchup.

well i got 15 points from SF D , im very happy .

 

[jobarules]

San Fran all day long vs Sanders on a rainy windy day , i see INTs and fumbles in this game .

That SF defense hasn’t been good. Whether real life or fantasy.

True but they just were good on Monday

Haven’t scored double digits all year. Had 5 games of 0 or 2 pts and 1 with -4. No thanks. That’s half their games from -4 to 2 points. Let that sink in for a while.

Scored 19 in my league

 

[ZADO]

San Fran all day long vs Sanders on a rainy windy day , i see INTs and fumbles in this game .

That SF defense hasn’t been good. Whether real life or fantasy.

True but they just were good on Monday

Haven’t scored double digits all year. Had 5 games of 0 or 2 pts and 1 with -4. No thanks. That’s half their games from -4 to 2 points. Let that sink in for a while.

Scored 19 in my league

I pcked SF because of Sanders and i heard the weather was going to be very windy and cold with snow likely . The weather wasnt a factor after all

 

[jobarules]

San Fran all day long vs Sanders on a rainy windy day , i see INTs and fumbles in this game .

That SF defense hasn’t been good. Whether real life or fantasy.

True but they just were good on Monday

Haven’t scored double digits all year. Had 5 games of 0 or 2 pts and 1 with -4. No thanks. That’s half their games from -4 to 2 points. Let that sink in for a while.

Scored 19 in my league

I pcked SF because of Sanders and i heard the weather was going to be very windy and cold with snow likely . The weather wasnt a factor after all

I played rams over SF after steaming Raiders F over rams last week. Im not good at this.

 

[VikingFrog]

All hail Seattle Defense.

 

[Pietaster2]

All hail Seattle Defense.

Won me my week and clinched first seed.

Question to Seattle owners:

What are you doing week 16 against the Rams? Is anyone in here crazy enough to start them?

 

[VikingFrog]

If you have a playoff Bye

Grab Bills and Steelers and play the Browns twice in the playoffs.

 

[bcat01]

Looking ahead to the first week of playoffs
Week 15 -
San Fran vs Tenn
Chicago vs Cleveland

 

[Hurl Bruce]

https://x.com/Ihartitz/status/1993385365311537585?s=20

 

[FairWarning]

Have DEN for next 2 weeks. I am in the playoffs and debating picking up either New Orleans or Pittsburgh or maybe even both (both would be hard with roster spots). Don't want to use DEN week 15 against GB or week 17 @ KC. Pitt has a bad week 16 matchup @ DET so don't wanna just roll with them.

Hmm. Parentheses has average points DST has scored against that team

Week 15 PIT vs MIA (9.5) or NO vs CAR (10.3)
Week 16 DEN vs JAX (8.3) or NO vs NYJ (10.2)
Week 17 PIT @ CLE (12.1) or NO @ TEN (13.0)

Are the Giants available? They would fit both weeks as they play Minnesota at home and at the Raiders. They have a pretty good DL.

 

[amnesiac]

Have DEN for next 2 weeks. I am in the playoffs and debating picking up either New Orleans or Pittsburgh or maybe even both (both would be hard with roster spots). Don't want to use DEN week 15 against GB or week 17 @ KC. Pitt has a bad week 16 matchup @ DET so don't wanna just roll with them.

Hmm. Parentheses has average points DST has scored against that team

Week 15 PIT vs MIA (9.5) or NO vs CAR (10.3)
Week 16 DEN vs JAX (8.3) or NO vs NYJ (10.2)
Week 17 PIT @ CLE (12.1) or NO @ TEN (13.0)

Are the Giants available? They would fit both weeks as they play Minnesota at home and at the Raiders. They have a pretty good DL.

i looked at the Giants but in my league they've only scored over 4 points twice this year.

the Saints have nice matchups the last three weeks, but i haven't pulled the trigger yet.

 

[FairWarning]

Have DEN for next 2 weeks. I am in the playoffs and debating picking up either New Orleans or Pittsburgh or maybe even both (both would be hard with roster spots). Don't want to use DEN week 15 against GB or week 17 @ KC. Pitt has a bad week 16 matchup @ DET so don't wanna just roll with them.

Hmm. Parentheses has average points DST has scored against that team

Week 15 PIT vs MIA (9.5) or NO vs CAR (10.3)
Week 16 DEN vs JAX (8.3) or NO vs NYJ (10.2)
Week 17 PIT @ CLE (12.1) or NO @ TEN (13.0)

Are the Giants available? They would fit both weeks as they play Minnesota at home and at the Raiders. They have a pretty good DL.

i looked at the Giants but in my league they've only scored over 4 points twice this year.

the Saints have nice matchups the last three weeks, but i haven't pulled the trigger yet.

This time of year I look for teams trying hard vs teams that are quitting. Minn has the look in week 16 - disappointed season, bad/young qb, star player checking out, and a dome team outside in the cold.

 

[Runkle]

Is Commanders vs. Minny a thing this week or fools gold?

 

[FairWarning]

Is Commanders vs. Minny a thing this week or fools gold?

I think it can be a thing. Depends on what is out there. Another long shot that could surprise is the Jets. Remember how much Tua struggles in cold weather.

 

[urbanhack]

I think I might be leaning Saints.

 

[Pietaster2]

Have DEN for next 2 weeks. I am in the playoffs and debating picking up either New Orleans or Pittsburgh or maybe even both (both would be hard with roster spots). Don't want to use DEN week 15 against GB or week 17 @ KC. Pitt has a bad week 16 matchup @ DET so don't wanna just roll with them.

Hmm. Parentheses has average points DST has scored against that team

Week 15 PIT vs MIA (9.5) or NO vs CAR (10.3)
Week 16 DEN vs JAX (8.3) or NO vs NYJ (10.2)
Week 17 PIT @ CLE (12.1) or NO @ TEN (13.0)

Are the Giants available? They would fit both weeks as they play Minnesota at home and at the Raiders. They have a pretty good DL.

i looked at the Giants but in my league they've only scored over 4 points twice this year.

the Saints have nice matchups the last three weeks, but i haven't pulled the trigger yet.

No way do I start the Giants, for that reason. When are people going to learn? Don’t start bad defenses; even in good matchups.

In my scoring system the Giants DST is dead last in points on the year at #32. Are you going to trust that in the fantasy playoffs?

 

[GoBirds]

Are Cowboys week 15 vs MIN worth grabbing now VS rolling TB?

 

[VikingFrog]

Are Cowboys week 15 vs MIN worth grabbing now VS rolling TB?

I think so. Especially if they show something vs Detroit on Thursday.

 

[GoBirds]

Is Colts D worth picking up for playoffs? Thought I was in good shape with TB but FBG has them lower than Colts week 15 and 17 at least.

 

[Gottabesweet]

Looking ahead to the first week of playoffs
Week 15 -
San Fran vs Tenn
Chicago vs Cleveland

I don’t hate Pittsburgh at home MNF vs Miami

 

[Faust]

Bears' Ben Johnson: Packers 'might be the best defense we've seen all year'

 

[VikingFrog]

Can the Bills be trusted week 16 against Cleveland?

Seems every time I’ve started the bills over my lifetime they’ve failed me.

They actually looked decent against Pitt last week.

 

[ignatiusjreilly]

Last week was a bad one for us "prioritize good defenses over good matchups" truthers. Actually, Houston's D played well against Indy but didn't put up a lot of fantasy points. Cleveland's D didn't play terribly, either, but that game script was the exact reason you worry about teams like that. The offense/special teams kept screwing up and giving the SF offense great field position, and eventually the game got out of hand. That's going to happen sometimes with an offense that bad.

I'm still sticking with both. Obviously Cleveland has a dream matchup vs Tenn this week. Houston has a much tougher one with KC, but I've ridden them this far, plus with the uncertainty on the rest of my roster I don't really have the spots for a second defense. We'll see if that changes for the playoffs

 

[urbanhack]

You have to consider the offenses of these Ds as well. Last week Baltimore was completely hung out to dry as the offense turned it over 5 times. Yes, Burrow looked good, but part of that was giving him the ball in great field position. Cleveland D has to be in that camp as well, no? I guess they will get the sacks. But a big part of scoring system is points allowed.

 

[JohnnyU]

I wouldn't trust the Washington defense just because the matchup looks good. You've been warned.

 

[Pietaster2]

Can the Bills be trusted week 16 against Cleveland?

Seems every time I’ve started the bills over my lifetime they’ve failed me.

They actually looked decent against Pitt last week.

I’m riding with the Bills week 16, and only week 16. Browns O is very generous to DSTs and Bills D is improving. Deshaun Watson’s practice window opened today, so the Bills might even be able to tee off on his shakey self.

For whatever reason there aren’t a lot of great matchups in week 16 compared to the other playoff weeks, so the Bills are toward the top of the options you can reasonably still pick up off the WW.

 

[stillfeelme]

Is Colts D worth picking up for playoffs? Thought I was in good shape with TB but FBG has them lower than Colts week 15 and 17 at least.

Not sure how confident you are in your lineup or your scoring rules. Maybe your league scoring rules favors Colts over TB.

TB has one of the most favorable matchups ROS.