3-way QB Comparison (1 Viewer)

[lawyer]

Ok, here I ask you to rank three QB's by how you think they'll perform in terms of fantasy numbers this season. The three guys are:

Drew Brees

Steve McNair

Jake Plummer

Here are some numbers to give perspective:

Brees:

323/500, 64.6% Comp., 3576 yds, 24 TD, 15 INT, 89.2 QB Rat.

McNair (14 games):

292/476, 61.3% Comp., 3161 yds, 16 TD, 11 INT, 82.4 QB Rat.

Plummer:

277/456, 60.7% Comp., 3366 yds, 18 TD, 7 INT, 90.2 QB Rat.

Fire Away!

 

[pigskinliquors]

As to how I'd draft them:

Plummer (safest pick by far)

Brees (good weapons; offense provided Brooks w/ numbers, why not Drew?)

McNair (too many question marks)

 

[perry147]

As to how I'd draft them:

Plummer (safest pick by far)

Brees (good weapons; offense provided Brooks w/ numbers, why not Drew?)

McNair (too many question marks)

I would rank them as followslummer - Solid pick with little risk and has Javon and Rod Smith to play catch with.

McNair and Brees are about even in my opinion; both are with new teams and have aging WR's. The deciding factor IMHO would be health because McNair is a much larger injury risk.