What's new
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Aaron Rodgers suffers concussion (1 Viewer)

Greg Bedard, GB beat writer:I'm starting to believe Packers QB Aaron Rodgers was concussed much earlier in the game and probably no one knew it.Before the second-quarter sneak (play where it could have happened): 11 of 14 for 130, 1 TD. After: 14 of 30 for 144, 0 TDs, 1 INT.
I don't know that I like this kind of thing. Were there any signs at all to indicate he'd suffered a concussion after the sneak? Seems like the writer is making excuses a bit. At best, it's pretty convenient.I'd hope he has something tangible to back up his theory there other than poor stats.J
This was something he said on Twitter, and had a series of follow-up comments. Here is the complete blog post on the same topic, in which I think he makes clear he is just speculating:
Did Rodgers suffer a concussion early in the game?By Greg A. Bedard of the Journal SentinelOct. 11, 2010 9:47 a.m. |(79) CommentsSomething about Sunday's loss to the Redskins and the passing game just did not add up for me. Something was off but I was having a hard time putting my finger on it.I'm not saying I have all the answers -- or any -- but I just wanted to point out Aaron Rodgers' stats before and after the early second-quarter sneak in which he took a hard hit to the head: C A Y TD INT RatingBefore sneak 13 16 149 1 0 126.03After sneak 14 30 144 0 1 47.1The drops obviously factor into that, but the Packers always have a few drops a game.I'd be willing to bet that Rodgers has never had a stretch like that in his young career.Something's not right.Guess we'll have to see what coach Mike McCarthy has to say at 11:30 a.m.Obviously I'm not insinuating the Packers knew this and allowed him to play -- that'd be criminal. But Rodgers may have played with a concussion and not even known it himself. Could the head shots he took later keep him out longer than if he just simply suffered a concussion and was removed on the spot? Only a doctor can answer that.
Bedard is known as a bit of a rumor monger - loves to stir the pot with his speculating in his reports. He's been in Green Bay three years now and has never been quite accepted by the old-timers. He announced last week that he took a promotion to be the lead NFL writer for the Boston Globe and is leaving after the Packers-Viking game in two weeks.
 
I don't know that I like this kind of thing. Were there any signs at all to indicate he'd suffered a concussion after the sneak? Seems like the writer is making excuses a bit. At best, it's pretty convenient.I'd hope he has something tangible to back up his theory there other than poor stats.
Actually I remember after the sneak that Rodgers came off the field and looked a little dazed. The commentators even mentioned that he seemed sluggish coming out of the pile. He could be right on in his pegging of when the concussion happened.
 
He must have had a concussion in Detriot when he stunk in the 2nd half.
:no: With Cutler and how he started to walk toward the wrong sideline, it was pretty obvious he had his bell rung. Rodgers is not so good he couldn't just have several off-series without being concussed. It may have been what happened, but I wouldn't go there just yet.
 
Laconfora confirms that Rodgers will miss practice time. As usual with this, no word on game status til later.

 
hate to say it butthe skins are gona punch you in the mouth this yearexpect more injuries on our opponents to come.
I suppose one could argue that the injury to Rodgers was the result of rough play. Not so th einjury to Lee, Finley, Picket, or Mathews which were just happenstance of the game or freak injuries related to conditioning.
 
hate to say it butthe skins are gona punch you in the mouth this yearexpect more injuries on our opponents to come.
I suppose one could argue that the injury to Rodgers was the result of rough play. Not so th einjury to Lee, Finley, Picket, or Mathews which were just happenstance of the game or freak injuries related to conditioning.
How was Pickett's a conditioning issue?I think he was hurt on the bottom of the pile.Same with Finley...he was hurt on the 2nd play of the game...not sure how much conditioning he could do for that not to happen.
 
Greg Bedard, GB beat writer:I'm starting to believe Packers QB Aaron Rodgers was concussed much earlier in the game and probably no one knew it.Before the second-quarter sneak (play where it could have happened): 11 of 14 for 130, 1 TD. After: 14 of 30 for 144, 0 TDs, 1 INT.
I don't know that I like this kind of thing. Were there any signs at all to indicate he'd suffered a concussion after the sneak? Seems like the writer is making excuses a bit. At best, it's pretty convenient.I'd hope he has something tangible to back up his theory there other than poor stats.J
This was something he said on Twitter, and had a series of follow-up comments. Here is the complete blog post on the same topic, in which I think he makes clear he is just speculating:
Did Rodgers suffer a concussion early in the game?By Greg A. Bedard of the Journal SentinelOct. 11, 2010 9:47 a.m. |(79) CommentsSomething about Sunday's loss to the Redskins and the passing game just did not add up for me. Something was off but I was having a hard time putting my finger on it.I'm not saying I have all the answers -- or any -- but I just wanted to point out Aaron Rodgers' stats before and after the early second-quarter sneak in which he took a hard hit to the head: C A Y TD INT RatingBefore sneak 13 16 149 1 0 126.03After sneak 14 30 144 0 1 47.1The drops obviously factor into that, but the Packers always have a few drops a game.I'd be willing to bet that Rodgers has never had a stretch like that in his young career.Something's not right.Guess we'll have to see what coach Mike McCarthy has to say at 11:30 a.m.Obviously I'm not insinuating the Packers knew this and allowed him to play -- that'd be criminal. But Rodgers may have played with a concussion and not even known it himself. Could the head shots he took later keep him out longer than if he just simply suffered a concussion and was removed on the spot? Only a doctor can answer that.
Bedard is known as a bit of a rumor monger - loves to stir the pot with his speculating in his reports. He's been in Green Bay three years now and has never been quite accepted by the old-timers. He announced last week that he took a promotion to be the lead NFL writer for the Boston Globe and is leaving after the Packers-Viking game in two weeks.
Thanks. That makes more sense.J
 
Rodgers has concussion, Pack hit hard by injuriesBy CHRIS JENKINS AP Sports Writer © 2010 The Associated PressOct. 11, 2010, 4:22PMGREEN BAY, Wis. — Quarterback Aaron Rodgers has a concussion and might have to sit out Sunday's game against Miami, the latest blow in a wave of injuries that has hit the Green Bay Packers in a season they hoped would end in the Super Bowl.Packers coach Mike McCarthy said Rodgers got the concussion during a helmet-to-helmet hit late in Sunday's overtime loss at Washington and he could miss the Dolphins game."It's definitely possible," McCarthy said Monday. "I know at a minimum he'll miss some practice time."The backup quarterback is Matt Flynn, a third-year player out of LSU who has thrown 17 passes in his career. Flynn said he's ready to play if needed, but hopes Rodgers is healthy."I saw him this morning," Flynn said. "He looked fine. We sat down, talked, just waited around and everything was kind of normal."The Packers likely will need much of the week to evaluate Rodgers, who hasn't missed a game since taking over as the starter in 2008.Under stricter return-to-play guidelines for head injuries the NFL adopted late last year, Rodgers must be free of concussion symptoms, even after rigorous exercise, and cleared by the team doctor and an approved independent neurologist before he plays again.Chicago Bears quarterback Jay Cutler did not play in a win at Carolina on Sunday after sustaining a concussion a week ago."There's a protocol, and he'll go through it just like we've always done," McCarthy said. "And we'll definitely take the proper time and make sure he's fully recovered."That's just the beginning of the bad news for the Packers.Two players are scheduled for surgery this week: tight end Jermichael Finley on his knee and linebacker Nick Barnett on his wrist.McCarthy said he "would be surprised" if Finley's surgery ended his season but was less definitive on Barnett, saying he was "holding out hope" that the linebacker would be back."When you're dealing with his particular injury, they really won't know until they get in there," McCarthy said.Outside linebacker Clay Matthews has a left hamstring strain, defensive lineman Ryan Pickett has an ankle sprain, tight end Donald Lee has a chest sprain and safety Derrick Martin has a knee sprain.Matthews' injury was not as severe as the one that caused him to miss most of training camp and the preseason, the coach said, though there isn't a clear timeline for his return. Lee and Martin might be out a few weeks.Meanwhile, veteran right tackle Mark Tauscher has a shoulder injury and was inactive against Washington. McCarthy did have one piece of good injury news: linebacker Brandon Chillar, who has been out with a shoulder injury, will begin "trial" practice this week.Green Bay has already lost starting running back Ryan Grant to a season-ending ankle injury, starting safety Morgan Burnett to a torn ACL and backup defensive lineman Justin Harrell to a knee injury. And cornerback Al Harris (knee) and safety Atari Bigby (ankle) might return to practice for the first time next week, although it's not clear whether either will be able to play right away.Going into the Miami game, that's a lot of potential absences for a team that now has lost two of its last three games — and didn't look particularly good in its win over Detroit.Still, McCarthy said this week would be business as usual. And if Rodgers can't go?Quarterbacks coach Tom Clements said Flynn does a good job running the scout team in practice and is capable of taking over the offense."During the regular season with the opponent squad, he's going against our defense," Clements said. "Now, obviously, playing in the regular season is different and things go a little faster. But we're confident that Matt will do a good job if needed."
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top