What's new
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Bloomberg Decision Maker (1 Viewer)

GoBears84

Footballguy
Bloomberg Analysts are offering a product called Decision Maker.

http://www.bloombergsports.com/fanofferings/

It looks like an interesting product - maybe not a replacement for Lineup Dominator but an interesting use as a Trade Analyzer or a "Who do I Start?"

Has anybody had a chance to test it out? Is it worth the $8 price tag?

 
Bloomberg Analysts are offering a product called Decision Maker.

http://www.bloombergsports.com/fanofferings/

It looks like an interesting product - maybe not a replacement for Lineup Dominator but an interesting use as a Trade Analyzer or a "Who do I Start?"

Has anybody had a chance to test it out? Is it worth the $8 price tag?
You made me curious so I just signed up. It seems interesting. But they seem to baseline projections at per total game stats instead of per played game stats or any other adjustments. For every game starters this will be fine, but if you look at Vick, for instance, their base projection for him is 85 passing yards. Pretty ridiculous. They do say that he has a lot of 'upside' but their baseline projection is not that high. They could certainly use improvement. Depends on what you play and how good you are without it, I guess, but if you play reasonable stakes at all, basically any reasonable info source is worth $8, IMO...
 
Bloomberg Analysts are offering a product called Decision Maker.

http://www.bloombergsports.com/fanofferings/

It looks like an interesting product - maybe not a replacement for Lineup Dominator but an interesting use as a Trade Analyzer or a "Who do I Start?"

Has anybody had a chance to test it out? Is it worth the $8 price tag?
You made me curious so I just signed up. It seems interesting. But they seem to baseline projections at per total game stats instead of per played game stats or any other adjustments. For every game starters this will be fine, but if you look at Vick, for instance, their base projection for him is 85 passing yards. Pretty ridiculous. They do say that he has a lot of 'upside' but their baseline projection is not that high. They could certainly use improvement. Depends on what you play and how good you are without it, I guess, but if you play reasonable stakes at all, basically any reasonable info source is worth $8, IMO...
I guess that's the question - is it going to be reasonable? Please keep us posted....
 
Bloomberg Analysts are offering a product called Decision Maker.

http://www.bloombergsports.com/fanofferings/

It looks like an interesting product - maybe not a replacement for Lineup Dominator but an interesting use as a Trade Analyzer or a "Who do I Start?"

Has anybody had a chance to test it out? Is it worth the $8 price tag?
You made me curious so I just signed up. It seems interesting. But they seem to baseline projections at per total game stats instead of per played game stats or any other adjustments. For every game starters this will be fine, but if you look at Vick, for instance, their base projection for him is 85 passing yards. Pretty ridiculous. They do say that he has a lot of 'upside' but their baseline projection is not that high. They could certainly use improvement. Depends on what you play and how good you are without it, I guess, but if you play reasonable stakes at all, basically any reasonable info source is worth $8, IMO...
I guess that's the question - is it going to be reasonable? Please keep us posted....
Been playing around with it a bit more: bottom line, don't think it's worth much at this point. Instead of building forward looking projections into account, taking views on specific players and their changing circumstances, they seem to be more historically data-mining to find predictive factors. In and of itself, that sounds fine and should provide a useful complementary view to a site like FBG. However, they need someone from FBG (or similar) as a consultant because their analysis doesn't seem to be sophisiticated enough (as in my Vick example above where they didnt differentiate between games he started and games he didnt even play in developing his baseline). There also are major issues with their GUI since they only allow you to filter based on position and team or to select two individuals to compare. Much more useful would be something similar to the MyFBG team projections, where you can select (and save) a set of players and then view the projections for all of those players (baseline, upside, and downside) all together in one table. Without that it's too frustrating to sit there comparing individual players or creating pseudo-cheatsheets by filtering by position. Finally, in the consumer version they don't allow custom scoring mechanisms. That is only available in the co-branded professional version that they apparently offer jointly with some other commercial providers. Basically, if they hired me to be a consultant for them, or they tried more closely to emulate the FBG cheatsheet/MyFBG offerings, it would be a good counter-viewpoint well worth $8. For now, though, not worth it.

 
Bloomberg Analysts are offering a product called Decision Maker.

http://www.bloombergsports.com/fanofferings/

It looks like an interesting product - maybe not a replacement for Lineup Dominator but an interesting use as a Trade Analyzer or a "Who do I Start?"

Has anybody had a chance to test it out? Is it worth the $8 price tag?
You made me curious so I just signed up. It seems interesting. But they seem to baseline projections at per total game stats instead of per played game stats or any other adjustments. For every game starters this will be fine, but if you look at Vick, for instance, their base projection for him is 85 passing yards. Pretty ridiculous. They do say that he has a lot of 'upside' but their baseline projection is not that high. They could certainly use improvement. Depends on what you play and how good you are without it, I guess, but if you play reasonable stakes at all, basically any reasonable info source is worth $8, IMO...
I guess that's the question - is it going to be reasonable? Please keep us posted....
Been playing around with it a bit more: bottom line, don't think it's worth much at this point. Instead of building forward looking projections into account, taking views on specific players and their changing circumstances, they seem to be more historically data-mining to find predictive factors. In and of itself, that sounds fine and should provide a useful complementary view to a site like FBG. However, they need someone from FBG (or similar) as a consultant because their analysis doesn't seem to be sophisiticated enough (as in my Vick example above where they didnt differentiate between games he started and games he didnt even play in developing his baseline). There also are major issues with their GUI since they only allow you to filter based on position and team or to select two individuals to compare. Much more useful would be something similar to the MyFBG team projections, where you can select (and save) a set of players and then view the projections for all of those players (baseline, upside, and downside) all together in one table. Without that it's too frustrating to sit there comparing individual players or creating pseudo-cheatsheets by filtering by position. Finally, in the consumer version they don't allow custom scoring mechanisms. That is only available in the co-branded professional version that they apparently offer jointly with some other commercial providers. Basically, if they hired me to be a consultant for them, or they tried more closely to emulate the FBG cheatsheet/MyFBG offerings, it would be a good counter-viewpoint well worth $8. For now, though, not worth it.
Thanks! I realize it's just a starting point for them, but I had the same gripe: To be worth using it needed to be able to compare sets of players - not just two. Maybe next year...Thank you again for the effort.

 
This has been out for 2 seasons now...has anyone tried this out and found it useful? I am sure its useful to someone who is very new to fantasy football but I am wondering if its useful for people that have been playing for a while now that need lineup help with tough decisions.

 
It appears to be a plug-in with Yahoo leagues--curious if it'll be there all year or just free for a week or two. Didn't really tell me much, but I like the graphs.

 
Thought you guys might be interested in checking out Fantasy Brain (http://www.fantasybrain.com, which is (sort of) competitive with Decision Maker.

We also built custom algorithms, but rather than just making projections about players like Bloomberg, Fantasy Brain runs analytics on YOUR fantasy rosters, measuring every draft pick, start/sit decision and transaction for efficiency. We like to think of this like an XBox Live Gamerscore or a Klout score (for those of you who know what that company does). So you get a detailed Fantasy expertise score while identifying strengths and weaknesses in your roster. There's a bunch more social Fantasy Football features, but I'll leave those for another time.

Even though the products are notably different, I'd love to hear what you think about Fantasy Brain vs Decision Maker. Fantasy Brain is completely free and it takes 30 seconds to sign up. Thanks for indulging!

 
If it's anything like the Michael Bloomberg calorie police in NYC then I don't want to touch it or have it make any decisions for me

 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top