My comment wasn't that you made money from braces. Just that you're in the profession peripherally so you're close to it. Notice I haven't said that dental procedures like bridges, crowns, etc are overpriced even though these are very expensive.
And you don't think elective procedures geared to children can be overprices? The emotional aspect when it comes to kids is huge and drives much of the decision. I gave you a very good comparison for a completely elective procedure, one done by a more educated and skilled medical professional, but not geared toward kids.
Plastic surgeons have at the minimum 5 years of residency once they've finished medical school (that's 13 years), then most have a 2 year fellowship before they're ready to practice. That's 15 years.
Plus, we're talking about medical doctors who deal with human lives, not teeth.
I respect the dental profession completely, it's just this segment of it that gets under my skin. Mind you I've had a wife who's had braces twice (once as a teen), a daughter who's had them twice, and a son who's had them once. So I'm about $20k deep into this.
I don't think anything elective can be over-priced. That would be like me complaining about the prices of homes being too high in my area or the prices of new cars being too high. I can biologically survive with a crappy apartment or an older used car just like Suzie can biologically survive with crooked teeth.
The market drives the price. If collectively everyone took a stand against the price of braces and stopped buying, the price would come down most likely.
Same with the breast implants you speak of. That's the market price in your area, most likely driven by supply/demand. If the doctor in question could get away with charging 10-12K for those same implants he would do so.
I just don't agree with the premise from a market driven cost perspective. It wouldn't matter if we were talking about braces or hip replacement. If the hip replacement is too high, opt for the wheelchair/scooter.
That's cool, I get where you're coming from. I think though the example I have given you shows very clearly that the market is not driven by cost near as much when children are involved. Orthodontists taking advantage of this = jackasses imho. Plus you have the whole, "well it looks like braces are needed again" angle.
But I get that you don't agree. As I said, it's only my opinion.
I'll give you a story. My daughter had braces from roughly 10 until 13. Less than a year later, she was going for a post-braces follow up and the orthodontist was like "her teeth have shifted, she needs braces again." The wife was there and says, ok, since you took the braces off just recently, we don't have to pay for the new set do we? The orthodontist, says of course we do. Wife is hysterical at home, I suggest she talk to our dentist whom my wife has a good relationship with. The dentist is appalled, calls the orthodontist, and lo and behold, the orthodontist calls and agrees to put the braces back on for free. What would have cost us $6k plus (mind you I've noted how much I've spent with the orthodontist earlier) is now being done free so the orthodontist doesn't jeopardize a referral source.
Greedy greedy jackasses.