Do you downgrade UP and coming WRs with shaky QB situations? (1 Viewer)

[bigreese82]

I find myself downgrading these guys when I am uncertain about their QB situations in the immediate future. Do you do this? Should it be done? Feel free to add to the list of wrs

Baltimore-Clayton(What happens when McNair retires in the next year or so

GB-Jennings(Farve)

Clev-B.Edwards(rookie qb)

Any studies been done on the effect of a new qb on young wrs?

 

[Weiner Dog]

Edwards:

Rookie QB > current QB

*** UPGRADE ***

 

[JuSt CuZ]

How do you say a guy who's qb is with in reach of all time records is in a shaky situation, Farve is going to have a hella year, who is gonna run the ball, and at the early part of the season WATCH OUT!!! He does play the Vikes and Leos twice. But maybe thats just me Farve #14 on my preseason rankings for QB's.

 

[JuSt CuZ]

Any KC WR though!!!!!

 

[BigTex]

Yes, even running backs..........see Caddy.

 

[Pipes]

How do you say a guy who's qb is with in reach of all time records is in a shaky situation, Farve is going to have a hella year, who is gonna run the ball, and at the early part of the season WATCH OUT!!! He does play the Vikes and Leos twice. But maybe thats just me Farve #14 on my preseason rankings for QB's.

Yeah I wonder what kind of numbers Driver would've put up the past couple of years if he had a decent quarterback throwing him the rock.

 

[flooredyas]

Fitz and Bouldin didn't seem too affected.

 

[mlball77]

I think you have to. Talent and skill set don't totally dictate production. Obviously things like offensive scheme, offensive line, and the talent level of the QB impact the production of WRs and RBs.

Jennings should be okay with Favre this year and we haven't seen enough of Rodgers to call him shakey at this point, imho.

I agree with a previous poster that Quinn actually is an upgrade for CLE at QB, even in year one.

And Clayton has McNair for now. McNair isn't great at this point, but solid.

But back to your specific point, the situation a WR is in should factor into your valuation of them.

 

[Da Guru]

I find myself downgrading these guys when I am uncertain about their QB situations in the immediate future. Do you do this? Should it be done? Feel free to add to the list of wrsBaltimore-Clayton(What happens when McNair retires in the next year or soGB-Jennings(Farve)Clev-B.Edwards(rookie qb)Any studies been done on the effect of a new qb on young wrs?

McNair has never been a big passing TD guy. And the Frye-Quinn combo will hur Edwards as well.So downgrade.