PLEASE tell me how that is a fumbling problem ???
I never said he had a fumbling problem, I just asked the question how prevalent were the reports of Ricky Williams having small hands prior to his retirement.
Edited - As a huge fan of the Vikings and Culpepper, I am well aware of the importance of small hands. Culpepper (aka, 'nubbs') has very small hands and his fumbling is a known issue.
Yeah - I also remember hearing that Ricky had small hands, and was EXPECTED to have a fumbling problem, but he never actually had one.Here's my 2 cents on this, and it reflects a lot of what was said. (Disclaimer - I am a Brown owner, and a Williams hater for walking out on the team last year).
#1 - I expect BOTH backs to be used with Ricky in the traditional halfback role, and Brown to be used as a FB/H-back role. In that role, Miami could come out with Brown lined up as a TE and snap; line him up as a TE and shift him into a FB position playing play action or run; line him up as a FB and shift him out to a receiver position, short hand-off to the FB and so on. The presence of both Brown & Williams in the backfield AT THE SAME TIME would really create mis-matches on defense. Note that this would move Brown out of a traditoinal 20 carry game and put him more in line with 5-10 rushes but also 10 receiving targets. It would also mean Williams would be in the backfield more to block as opposed to running routs.
This makes sense to me especially because Brown is well known as a good blocker (best rookie blocker in this year's class iirr) and is reputed to have excellent hands.
#2 - Brown has been solid in his first 4 weeks. Not the first 2 really, but the last 2 he has been solid. Projecting his season out so far, he is on pace for about 300 carries for 1300 yards plus 44 receptions for 170 yards. Touchdowns will PROBABLY come. Compare that to Williams 2 years ago who got about 100 yards more on 25% more carries and had about the same number of receptions for about double the yards. I don't think the OL is that differnet this year from 2003.
Why is Brown not scoring TDs? Well, one thing is that Saban knows his team is weak, so is relying on "trickery" (like passing on 1st and goal from the 1) to win games. In Ricky's time with the Dolphins with Wandstat as coach, they would have run AT LEAST 3 times. I think Miami's been in a couple of those situations so far this year, so that's (potentially) a couple of TDs that Brown could have got. That would make the numbers for Brown and Williams very similar.
#3 - Williams may have been training, but he hasn't been in live NFL action for quite a while. I'd expect his role to start smaller (like maybe 5-10 carries vs. Tampa) and expanding by about 5 carries a week up to around 15-20 in 3 weeks. This is as he gets out of "in shape" and into "game shape", getting up to speed with the pro game again. Yes, players that get injured and take a year to come back often end up doing fine, but Williams has been out of football and NOT training or playing for a year... it will probably take him at least as long. I'd also go as far as to say that he's probably got a higher chance of becoming injured because of it.
But the bottom line for all of this - I do not think the return of williams will do anything but (a) lower Ronnie Brown's fantasy value and (b) increase Williams' fantasy value. My guess - Brown will average 60 yards and 0.3 TDs while Williams will average 70 yards and 0.4 TDs (yards & TDs are both rushing & receiving). Browns yards will come as much from the air as the ground while Williams' will be 80% ground.
One more thing (I forgot) - Fumbles will kill players value as long as the Dolphins are competitve (chasing the playoffs). IMO one fumble = 20% less carries the next game