Dynasty Keeper League QB... Tebow or Mallett ? (1 Viewer)

[dmb3535]

Got to drop one. In a Non PPR keeper league and have to keep one. R.Mallett or Tebow, which has a better NFL future?

 

[Seekay]

Is this a serious question?

 

[dmb3535]

Unfortunately it is. We keep all our players from year to year and have rookie drafts each year. You have to pick a rookie at every position and drop one from the year before. Well since I have won the last 2 years, I get last pick of everything and have to keep one of these jokers til next year

 

[jonboltz]

Tebow by a mile.

 

[mr roboto]

Tebow by a mile.

Not necessarily if you are thinking long term at QB.Tebow is more valuable now. Trade him and get something. Keep Mallett and hope NE trades him after developing him, or he starts in a couple years. I think Mallett can be a more productive NFL QB.

 

[jonboltz]

Tebow by a mile.

Not necessarily if you are thinking long term at QB.Tebow is more valuable now. Trade him and get something. Keep Mallett and hope NE trades him after developing him, or he starts in a couple years. I think Mallett can be a more productive NFL QB.

This is not the same question I was answering.

 

[mr roboto]

Tebow by a mile.

Not necessarily if you are thinking long term at QB.Tebow is more valuable now. Trade him and get something. Keep Mallett and hope NE trades him after developing him, or he starts in a couple years. I think Mallett can be a more productive NFL QB.

This is not the same question I was answering.

From the OP...

which has a better NFL future?

 

[Sarnoff]

Tebow by a mile.

Not necessarily if you are thinking long term at QB.Tebow is more valuable now. Trade him and get something. Keep Mallett and hope NE trades him after developing him, or he starts in a couple years. I think Mallett can be a more productive NFL QB.

This is not the same question I was answering.

From the OP...

which has a better NFL future?

From above the OP...

IMPORTANT NOTE ABOUT THE SHARK POOL

Threads that are asking for advice on how you should draft or manage your team belong in The Assistant Coach forum.

 

[jonboltz]

Tebow by a mile.

Not necessarily if you are thinking long term at QB.Tebow is more valuable now. Trade him and get something. Keep Mallett and hope NE trades him after developing him, or he starts in a couple years. I think Mallett can be a more productive NFL QB.

This is not the same question I was answering.

From the OP...

which has a better NFL future?

And from the title and rest of the OP "In a Non PPR keeper league and have to keep one" he is clearly speaking about fantasy value.

 

[Hipple Long Ware & Peete]

epends do you want the air apparent to Brady in NE , or the air apparent to Jesse Palmer on TV

 

[Hipple Long Ware & Peete]

Tebow by a mile.

X

 

[Hipple Long Ware & Peete]

Tebow by a mile.

Not necessarily if you are thinking long term at QB.Tebow is more valuable now. Trade him and get something. Keep Mallett and hope NE trades him after developing him, or he starts in a couple years. I think Mallett can be a more productive NFL QB.

This is not the same question I was answering.

Depends I guess if you play in a league that allows a roster spot for wildcat QB

 

[mr roboto]

Tebow by a mile.

Not necessarily if you are thinking long term at QB.Tebow is more valuable now. Trade him and get something. Keep Mallett and hope NE trades him after developing him, or he starts in a couple years. I think Mallett can be a more productive NFL QB.

This is not the same question I was answering.

From the OP...

which has a better NFL future?

And from the title and rest of the OP "In a Non PPR keeper league and have to keep one" he is clearly speaking about fantasy value.

And my answer to that is the same. He will outscore, for his career, Tebow.

 

[jonboltz]

And my answer to that is the same. He will outscore, for his career, Tebow.

He might, but nobody knows that at this point. His upside is nowhere near Tebow's upside, and that is what you are looking for when picking up a flyer at QB in a Dynasty--if you don't like Tebow, then try for Josh Johnson instead. You can essentially have 1-2 years to find out how good Tebow is, and if he is awful, you can trade a 3rd round draft pick for Mallett (or grab him off the WW), who will still be on the bench.

 

[EBF]

Mallett. I think his game more closely resembles successful NFL QBs. He's mistake-prone, but a prolific passer with all of the tools to be productive in that role.

 

[EBF]

He might, but nobody knows that at this point. His upside is nowhere near Tebow's upside, and that is what you are looking for when picking up a flyer at QB in a Dynasty--

I would disagree with this. A QB's upside is not determined by his running ability or athletic skills. Guys like Manning and Brady have had some of the greatest QB FF seasons in history and neither is a threat to run the ball. They make a living with their arms.

 

[jurb26]

Tebow has more value now. Here's my feeling though. I can envision Mallett as a starting QB in the NFL with a successful career. I can't envision that with Tebow. I think Mallett has starter potential and Tebow is more in line with a career back up or gadget QB. I'd prefer to have Mallett on my team. I would try to trade Tebow though because I think he has enough value right now to at least get something. Certainly more than you would get for Mallett.

 

[jurb26]

He might, but nobody knows that at this point. His upside is nowhere near Tebow's upside, and that is what you are looking for when picking up a flyer at QB in a Dynasty--

I would disagree with this. A QB's upside is not determined by his running ability or athletic skills. Guys like Manning and Brady have had some of the greatest QB FF seasons in history and neither is a threat to run the ball. They make a living with their arms.

Agreed, I don't know what upside Tebow has over Mallett. Mallett has the upside of being an elite QB IMO. Sure, it's a long shot. The physical tools are there though and he just needs to get his head on right or be developed. Physically, Mallett may have been the best QB in this years class. He easily has the best arm.

 

[jonboltz]

He might, but nobody knows that at this point. His upside is nowhere near Tebow's upside, and that is what you are looking for when picking up a flyer at QB in a Dynasty--

I would disagree with this. A QB's upside is not determined by his running ability or athletic skills. Guys like Manning and Brady have had some of the greatest QB FF seasons in history and neither is a threat to run the ball. They make a living with their arms.

But his fantasy upside is determined by his running ability. Do I ever envision Tebow being an elite NFL QB? No, I think that is doubtful. But all he has to be is a mediocre starting NFL QB and he will produce QB1 fantasy stats with his legs.Certainly Manning, Brady, and other elite QBs will put together great FF seasons. If you want to project Mallett to be a elite QB at this point, be my guest, but I think there are a lot better options that won't have you waiting 2-4 years to find out.

 

[jonboltz]

He might, but nobody knows that at this point. His upside is nowhere near Tebow's upside, and that is what you are looking for when picking up a flyer at QB in a Dynasty--

I would disagree with this. A QB's upside is not determined by his running ability or athletic skills. Guys like Manning and Brady have had some of the greatest QB FF seasons in history and neither is a threat to run the ball. They make a living with their arms.

Agreed, I don't know what upside Tebow has over Mallett. Mallett has the upside of being an elite QB IMO. Sure, it's a long shot. The physical tools are there though and he just needs to get his head on right or be developed. Physically, Mallett may have been the best QB in this years class. He easily has the best arm.

I think the chances of Mallett being an elite QB that puts up QB1 fantasty stats is significantly less likely than Tebow becoming a mediocre QB putting up QB1 numbers with his ability to add fantasy stats with his legs. The margin for error is significantly in Tebow's favor.

 

[eakfootball]

You could probably get something for Tebow. Trade him for a 3rd or 4th round rookie pick and keep Mallett.

 

[jurb26]

He might, but nobody knows that at this point. His upside is nowhere near Tebow's upside, and that is what you are looking for when picking up a flyer at QB in a Dynasty--

I would disagree with this. A QB's upside is not determined by his running ability or athletic skills. Guys like Manning and Brady have had some of the greatest QB FF seasons in history and neither is a threat to run the ball. They make a living with their arms.

Agreed, I don't know what upside Tebow has over Mallett. Mallett has the upside of being an elite QB IMO. Sure, it's a long shot. The physical tools are there though and he just needs to get his head on right or be developed. Physically, Mallett may have been the best QB in this years class. He easily has the best arm.

I think the chances of Mallett being an elite QB that puts up QB1 fantasty stats is significantly less likely than Tebow becoming a mediocre QB putting up QB1 numbers with his ability to add fantasy stats with his legs. The margin for error is significantly in Tebow's favor.

I disagree. Tebow looks like a career backup to me. Mallett looks like a much more likely possible starter.

 

[jonboltz]

He might, but nobody knows that at this point. His upside is nowhere near Tebow's upside, and that is what you are looking for when picking up a flyer at QB in a Dynasty--

I would disagree with this. A QB's upside is not determined by his running ability or athletic skills. Guys like Manning and Brady have had some of the greatest QB FF seasons in history and neither is a threat to run the ball. They make a living with their arms.

Agreed, I don't know what upside Tebow has over Mallett. Mallett has the upside of being an elite QB IMO. Sure, it's a long shot. The physical tools are there though and he just needs to get his head on right or be developed. Physically, Mallett may have been the best QB in this years class. He easily has the best arm.

I think the chances of Mallett being an elite QB that puts up QB1 fantasty stats is significantly less likely than Tebow becoming a mediocre QB putting up QB1 numbers with his ability to add fantasy stats with his legs. The margin for error is significantly in Tebow's favor.

I disagree. Tebow looks like a career backup to me. Mallett looks like a much more likely possible starter.

That's certainly up to you to decide, but I wouldn't discount the fact that Tebow outplayed Mallett's preseson in the preseason last year, in the regular season last year, and in the preseason this year...

 

[moderated]

Mallett. I think his game more closely resembles successful NFL QBs. He's mistake-prone, but a prolific passer with all of the tools to be productive in that role.

Is leftwich considered a successful NFL qb? That's who Ryan "slow long delivery" mallet resembles.