Blick
Footballguy
Thanks. I think we're somewhat on the same page.This will likely be very league dependent and league manager dependent. Most dynasty rankings have ARSB around 4-5 and Puka maybe a couple spots lower but not far. If I owned Puka I would likely just hold rather that pay up to get ARSB. I like them both and both have different "positives" on why you would want one over the other.What would you need on top of Puka to tier down from Amon Ra?
Now though to answer your question, again very league dependent but I would think a mid 3rd is maybe all the Puka owner would pay up? If you found someone who really loved ARSB maybe they would give a mid to late 2nd but again I probably wouldn't if I had Puka. I'd just hold. Not sure you can get much added on but maybe you have a league manager willing to pay up?
I'd be really curious to see what others have to say with this one and what the "perceived" difference is. The actual production for me probably isn't worth moving up from Puka, I would likely hold pat.
I do feel like there's a bigger gap between them than the rankings say. I guess I'm probably still a little hung up on Puka coming out of nowhere (oddly, so did ARSB). ARSB feels much safer though. He's got more track record and I assume will have long term stability at QB soon. I'm thinking a mid 2 in a 1 QB league would be needed to make me think hard about it.