What's new
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Every NFL Franchise's Best and Worst QBs? (1 Viewer)

Ravens

Best: Flacco's the most accomplished, but Jackson's already better than Joe ever was. Vinnie put up some good numbers in the early days.

Worst: The Kyle Boller mistake set them back years, but they also trotted out some truly horrific QBs like Stoney Case.

 
Quint said:
San Francisco:

Best - Montana (but i like Young more personally)

Worst - Druckenmiller
Click to expand...
That was my first thought (minus the Young part), but I guess Druckenmiller was undefeated as a starter, right?  Has to be someone worse. Alex Smith’s rookie year was the worst QB play I’ve ever seen, though he obviously got better (eventually). Maybe Cody Pickett?

 
Last edited by a moderator:
The Jets heads came up with some real doozies last time this question was asked. They had some from the vault that were truly terrible. Zamboni, NYRAGE, and Matthias* might chime in here with some truly awful ones before my time. 

Our best? Namath or Ken O'Brien. It's been bad. 

 
Hov34 said:
Minnesota Vikings:

Best:  Brett Favre

Worst:  Sean Salisbury
Click to expand...
Wrong. We can’t count any of our 1-2 year rentals. Sad that we haven’t developed a QB (best case was Culpepper) in 30 years. 
 

Tarkenton 

Ponder (just sheer bust compared to draft position)

I mean we had McNabb tossing bounce passes and the Josh Johnson MNF debacle but those were 1 game wonders. 

 
Last edited by a moderator:
bentley said:
You’re saying that he’s worse than Chad Hutchinson?
Click to expand...
He wasn't. Pelleur (sp?) got another team (KC) to give him a starting job where he nearly got killed by a vicious hit that wiykd be outlawed today.  Nobody ever wanted to see Chad Hutchinson again.  Or Drew Henson for that matter. 

 
Chemical X said:
Richard Todd was awful.  I’m talking full time starter too cause Glenn Foley, Brooks Bollinger and Rick Mirer loom large.  Also, Namath won a SB, but his numbers are downright atrocious.
Click to expand...
Agree on Namath being overrated, but wasn’t sure who would be best QB instead. Ken O’Brien? Chad Pennington?

 
wlwiles said:
Saints - Brees best obv, worst was Heath Shuler IMO but there’s lots of room for debate
Click to expand...
On the money. Mike Ditka was a terrible judge of QB ability, and compounded that problem by implementing 1970s offensive philosophies. 1997 Shuler was our worst, but 1998 Kerry Collins and 1999 Billy Joe Tolliver gave Shuler a run.

Danny Wuerffel and Billy Joe Hobert got some starts during those years, too — and were actually slight steps up.

 
Jaguars

Best - Really no competition for Mark Brunell. I guess second would be David Garrard. After 7 starts Minshew might slot in 4th after Leftwich.

Worst - I guess you go with Gabbert over such storied QB like Chad Henne, Blake Bortles, Trent Edwards and Todd Boumann. I almost forgot Quinn Gray, not to be confused with Jonathan Quinn

 
Uruk-Hai said:
Ravens

Best: Flacco's the most accomplished, but Jackson's already better than Joe ever was. Vinnie put up some good numbers in the early days.

Worst: The Kyle Boller mistake set them back years, but they also trotted out some truly horrific QBs like Stoney Case.
Click to expand...
That Boller - Anthony Wright combo was certainly something 

 
JaxBill said:
That Boller - Anthony Wright combo was certainly something 
Click to expand...
:shudder:

Boller was a great athlete and had ZERO clue how to play QB in the NFL. The Ravens wasted years of a really good team trying to make him one. Even if they had someone like Jake Delhomme, they may have added another SB title.

No one expected much from Wright, so he did much less damage.

 
mr roboto said:
Hov34 said:
Minnesota Vikings:

Best:  Brett Favre

Worst:  Sean Salisbury
Click to expand...
Wrong. We can’t count any of our 1-2 year rentals. Sad that we haven’t developed a QB (best case was Culpepper) in 30 years. 
 

Tarkenton 

Ponder (just sheer bust compared to draft position)

I mean we had McNabb tossing bounce passes and the Josh Johnson MNF debacle but those were 1 game wonders. 
Click to expand...
You guys know I was just ####### with Packer fans, right?

Btw, Favre had the highest QB rating in a season of any Viking ever in 2009.  And the highest QB rating of his career.

Real:

Best - Tark

Worst - Tarvaris Jackson (or Ponder)

 
dutch said:
Bills- Kelly best, honorable mention- kemp

Worst tie: Rob Johnson, jp losman, Trent Edwards, Alex van pelt, ej Manuel, Nathan peterman
Click to expand...
I realize you're being a bit facetious here, but there's no way Johnson, Losman, Edwards, AVP, and Manuel are anywhere near as bad as Peterman was.  Peterman was a historically bad QB, statistically one of the worst QBs in NFL history.  The Chargers game is a "where were you when this happened?" moment for Buffalo natives.  I was having dinner at my sister in law's apartment, watching the game with my FIL.  You literally remember where you were when you watched "The Peterman Game".

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Steve Tasker said:
I realize you're being a bit facetious here, but there's no way Johnson, Losman, Edwards, AVP, and Manuel are anywhere near as bad as Peterman was.  Peterman was a historically bad QB, statistically one of the worst QBs in NFL history.  The Chargers game is a "where were you when this happened?" moment for Buffalo natives.  I was having dinner at my sister in law's apartment, watching the game with my FIL.  You literally remember where you were when you watched "The Peterman Game".
Click to expand...
And surprisingly it actually helped his catalog sales.

 
Ilov80s said:
Ouch, tough to argue that. Ware was 0.500 as a starter despite completing 52% passes, 6.9 y/a, 5 TD, 8 Int, 64 QBR as the 7th overall pick. 
Click to expand...
I had a Chuck Long mesh half jersey.  :bag:  

11 tds vs 20 ints  in 12 games in 1987.  4-17 as a starter.

 
Don Quixote said:
Agree on Namath being overrated, but wasn’t sure who would be best QB instead. Ken O’Brien? Chad Pennington?
Click to expand...
amazing, 60 years of football and i wonder why this franchise reeks.  look at these names.  i think pennington and his noodle arm was better than o’brien.  i felt confidant in pennington in tight spots and end of game stuff, he was so smart.  kicking him out for favre still irks me.

 
JaxBill said:
Jaguars

Best - Really no competition for Mark Brunell. I guess second would be David Garrard. After 7 starts Minshew might slot in 4th after Leftwich.

Worst - I guess you go with Gabbert over such storied QB like Chad Henne, Blake Bortles, Trent Edwards and Todd Boumann. I almost forgot Quinn Gray, not to be confused with Jonathan Quinn
Click to expand...
I had no idea Henne was still in the league. According to overthecap he has made 34 mil in his career. Sweet gig.

@FieldYates: Non-Patrick Mahomes Chiefs QB news: the team has activated Chad Henne from IR and waived Kyle Shurmur. Mahomes, Henne and Matt Moore are now all on the active roster.

 
dgreen said:
Redskins

Best: Either Baugh or Jurgensen. I’d go Baugh. 

Worst: Maybe Shuler. Looking at a list of Redskins QBs, there are some old-timers with some bad stats who I’m not familiar with so I will go with Heath Shuler. 
Click to expand...
I think every team might have trouble selecting a "worst" QB.  There should be some minimum number of starts so that you're not trying to figure out if Josh Johnson was better than John Friesz.  

 
Ramsay Hunt Experience said:
I think every team might have trouble selecting a "worst" QB.  There should be some minimum number of starts so that you're not trying to figure out if Josh Johnson was better than John Friesz.  
Click to expand...
Yep. I glanced at the QBs with more than 200 attempts as an arbitrary cutoff. 

I think someone like Druckenmiller is fair game for the 49ers, though, since he was a 1st round pick. A high draft pick should be able to throw more than 52 passes. 

 
Steve Tasker said:
I realize you're being a bit facetious here, but there's no way Johnson, Losman, Edwards, AVP, and Manuel are anywhere near as bad as Peterman was.  Peterman was a historically bad QB, statistically one of the worst QBs in NFL history.  The Chargers game is a "where were you when this happened?" moment for Buffalo natives.  I was having dinner at my sister in law's apartment, watching the game with my FIL.  You literally remember where you were when you watched "The Peterman Game".
Click to expand...
Yeah, none of those guys deserve to be mentioned in the same breath as Peterman.  

 
Steelers best.....tie between Bradshaw and big Ben. I think Ben is the better QB but Bradshaw was the better big game QB, as evidenced by 4 Superbowls.

Worst.......mark Malone and kordell Stewart give headaches thinking of them ......goota go with Stewart as the steelers wasted some good teams with Stewart

 
OrtonToOlsen said:
I came across a list on a lesser-known sports site.  I'll post the link and their list later.   

Who would you say are the best and worst QBs of all time for each franchise?  Keep in mind that they went all the way back to the 1930s for some of these.  So a team like the Cardinals could include players from the Saint Louis Cardinals or even the Chicago Cardinals.

1. ARIZONA CARDINALS

2. ATLANTA FALCONS

3. BALTIMORE RAVENS

4. BUFFALO BILLS

5. CAROLINA PANTHERS

7. CINCINNATI BENGALS

6. CHICAGO BEARS

8. CLEVELAND BROWNS (old and new but not Ravens)

9. DALLAS COWBOYS

10. DENVER BRONCOS

11. DETROIT LIONS

12. GREEN BAY PACKERS

13. HOUSTON TEXANS

14. INDIANAPOLIS COLTS

15. JACKSONVILLE JAGUARS

16. KANSAS CITY CHIEFS

17. LOS ANGELES CHARGERS

18. LOS ANGELES RAMS

19. MIAMI DOLPHINS

20. MINNESOTA VIKINGS

21. NEW ENGLAND PATRIOTS

22. NEW ORLEANS SAINTS

23. NEW YORK GIANTS

24. NEW YORK JETS

25. OAKLAND RAIDERS

26. PHILADELPHIA EAGLES

27. PITTSBURGH STEELERS

28. SAN FRANCISCO 49ERS

29. SEATTLE SEAHAWKS

30. TAMPA BAY BUCCANEERS

31. TENNESSEE TITANS (Includes Houston Oilers)

32. WASHINGTON REDSKINS
Click to expand...
Career or single season?

 
Texans

Best: Watson

Worst: Osweiler (regular season), Hoyer (playoffs)

*Still bugs me to consider Moon as a Titan rather than a Houston player

 
pfalvey said:
Steelers best.....tie between Bradshaw and big Ben. I think Ben is the better QB but Bradshaw was the better big game QB, as evidenced by 4 Superbowls.

Worst.......mark Malone and kordell Stewart give headaches thinking of them ......goota go with Stewart as the steelers wasted some good teams with Stewart
Click to expand...
:goodposting:

 
Broncos: 

Best: Elway.  I know some might say Manning but different eras and all that.  Don't saddle Elway with Dan Reeves and he wins at least two more SBs (No way Broncos were beating 49ers).

Worst: Paxton Lynch.  He never developed, I never even saw a spark.  Brandon Allen has shown more in 2 games than Lynch ever did.  If you were grading on QB talent alone, it's Tebow but man, that season was solo much fun.

 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

Yogibear
5 Professional Sports Franchises that need to be relocated. . . and 5 that must stay put!!
2
Replies
97
Views
3K
Herb
Herb
Joe Bryant
NFL Strength of Schedule
Replies
25
Views
3K
Uruk-Hai
Uruk-Hai
Scoresman
2024 SoS Analysis - Why this metric is not very useful
Replies
1
Views
542
TheWinz
TheWinz

Users who are viewing this thread

Total: 1 (members: 0, guests: 1)
Back
Top