Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums
This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!
FBG Mock Draft '25 Completed with all 101 picks inside (3 Viewers)
- Thread starter Ministry of Pain
- Start date
Long Ball Larry
Footballguy
Out of curiosity, would you have taken Cameron Williams instead if still available? I was considering trapilo also.
A big kid that modelled his game after Derrick Henry. They've spoken many times and spent some time together working out. (Who has the nerve to want to workout with Henry?) Henry has promised to spend some time with him after the draft as well. I know it's a stretch but Titans fans may like him.
Early on, he can be the thunder to Pollard and see how things go. They really need a powerful runner and he checks a lot of boxes including falling to a comfy spot in the draft.
It IS possible there can be some games during which the Titans seem to run fifty times and play good D and not seem to be all about the QB.
********
Cam Ward and Kyle Williams played together as ya know. Williams is obviously a good WR, but the comfort they will both get from being in the NFL together could prove to be so valuable here.
********
I have another WR and an Edge in mind for the fourth and I think I could add a quality C later.
I think I could move Chig, Spears, and Levis and get fourth or fifths and fill more holes. I like enough whereas some are projects to avoid...still think I could finish this strong if we went 7
RC94
Footballguy
Trapilo was my 1st choice but I would have taken Williams if Trapilo was gone.
Ministry of Pain
Footballguy
I bet you do
Streetduck
Footballguy
Pick #70 Jaguars select TE Elijah Arroyo Miami
Athletic 6’4” 251lbs In-line Multi role TE with big play ability. Natural Hands catcher.
Athletic 6’4” 251lbs In-line Multi role TE with big play ability. Natural Hands catcher.
I would like it if the Titans would draft him also irl.
If it's gonna be Ward, I want that guy as comfy as reasonable
farfromforgotten
Footballguy
With the 71st selection, the New Orleans Saints select Jordan Burch, EDGE Oregon
Finally filling one of the bigger needs that I had for the Saints coming into this draft, with OL and CB being others. Measuring in at 6’4 280lbs, Burch is a bigger EDGE with speed to burn having run a 4.67 40 at the combine.
Finally filling one of the bigger needs that I had for the Saints coming into this draft, with OL and CB being others. Measuring in at 6’4 280lbs, Burch is a bigger EDGE with speed to burn having run a 4.67 40 at the combine.
Last edited:
farfromforgotten
Footballguy
And you’re up!
-OZ-
Footballguy
It’s crazy how deep Edge seems to be this year.
An embarrassment of riches here at #72 in my opinion. There are several guys I would have considered at #41. To me, there are 3 top contenders, and while I don't wanna do the "hey how has nobody taken this guy" thing, I do wanna discuss my thought process.
RB is probably the Bears biggest need, and I love how this draft has fallen. Personally, I find the Big Ten guys all to be a little overrated. I like Cam Skattebo a ton here. I think Skattebo's speed is a very minor issue, and think he is arguably the best pass game RB in the class. There's some Mark Ingram/Arian Foster to his game. However, I also love Dylan Sampson (James Cook clone) and I like guys like RJ Harvey and DJ Giddens, who could be there in round 4, so I don't feel desperate to take a RB here. I also think guys like Nick Chubb or JK Dobbins could be solid signings as complements to Swift.
WR is not a huge need, especially with the Hunter pick who I would have moonlight there, but I'm really tempted by Jack Bech, who I think has a lot of Puka Nacua qualities to his game and just needs to stay healthy. He could be a very good big slot, and I like him more than probably 4-5 WRs who have already gone. Bech outproduced Malik Nabers and Brian Thomas when they were together at LSU a few years ago, before his injuries and eventual transfer.
But alas, I think the best combo of player/need at the 72nd pick is: Darius Alexander DT Toledo.
I think Alexander is a borderline 1st round talent, who is likely only available this late because he's 24 years old. I would have taken him at #41. 6-4 305 and one of the strongest players in the draft. He's a solid athlete but wins more with strength and technique. He holds up against double teams in the run game and has an excellent 1st step in the pass game. You see a lot of interior OL stumbling backward upon contact with him.
I'm not too concerned with the small school factor, as he tore up the Senior Bowl. I think there is a very high ceiling here, as an excellent run stopper with above average pass rush chops. I wouldn't be shocked if he ended up a top 3 DT in this class. I expect him to be a week 1 starter and start for a long time.
RB is probably the Bears biggest need, and I love how this draft has fallen. Personally, I find the Big Ten guys all to be a little overrated. I like Cam Skattebo a ton here. I think Skattebo's speed is a very minor issue, and think he is arguably the best pass game RB in the class. There's some Mark Ingram/Arian Foster to his game. However, I also love Dylan Sampson (James Cook clone) and I like guys like RJ Harvey and DJ Giddens, who could be there in round 4, so I don't feel desperate to take a RB here. I also think guys like Nick Chubb or JK Dobbins could be solid signings as complements to Swift.
WR is not a huge need, especially with the Hunter pick who I would have moonlight there, but I'm really tempted by Jack Bech, who I think has a lot of Puka Nacua qualities to his game and just needs to stay healthy. He could be a very good big slot, and I like him more than probably 4-5 WRs who have already gone. Bech outproduced Malik Nabers and Brian Thomas when they were together at LSU a few years ago, before his injuries and eventual transfer.
But alas, I think the best combo of player/need at the 72nd pick is: Darius Alexander DT Toledo.
I think Alexander is a borderline 1st round talent, who is likely only available this late because he's 24 years old. I would have taken him at #41. 6-4 305 and one of the strongest players in the draft. He's a solid athlete but wins more with strength and technique. He holds up against double teams in the run game and has an excellent 1st step in the pass game. You see a lot of interior OL stumbling backward upon contact with him.
I'm not too concerned with the small school factor, as he tore up the Senior Bowl. I think there is a very high ceiling here, as an excellent run stopper with above average pass rush chops. I wouldn't be shocked if he ended up a top 3 DT in this class. I expect him to be a week 1 starter and start for a long time.
farfromforgotten
Footballguy
Agreed. After missing out on Walker by 1 spot in the first, not wanting to spend the #9 overall pick on the other top Edges available, and Pearce (amongst others) going before pick #40 in the 2nd, I’m actually pretty pumped to be able to land a prospect like Burch here.
Ministry of Pain
Footballguy
farfromforgotten
Footballguy
I was actually yo-yo’ing between Alexander and Burch the pick before you, and I know another team coming up shortly also had great interest in Darius as well.
Instinctive
Footballguy
I will be absolutely mind blown in real life if he lasts this long. Been trying to trade up for 20 picks but got multiple "who cares about future picks or later round picks, we are only doing 3" to trade offers LOL. Debated hard between him and AZ at 57 too.
Same here and same results. Nobody wants to do deals involving 4th and 5th rounders since we are only going 3 rounds.
But yeah, being 25 for his rookie season and playing in the MAC could push him down in the real draft. Will be one of the more interesting players to watch where he is picked.
Instinctive
Footballguy
Would be cool if we actually got a group that wanted to do this as if they were a GM (that's what I thought was happening) but this turned out to be more of a fun way to engage with some big boards and some guys to live out a fantasy for their favorite team. Nothing wrong with that, but a different exercise for sure.
rockaction
Footballguy
Pick #73 - Jalen Royals - WR - Utah State
This was a tough pick. Jack Bech, Tre Harris, and Jaylen Noel are all still on the board. I went with Royals over Bech due to speed concerns, over Harris because Harris's Reception Perception chart didn't look very good, and Jaylen Noel hasn't met a tackler that can't crumple him.
Royals was Utah State's number one guy. He's 6'0, 205 lbs. and played as an outside receiver because even though he lacked a bit of length, he was their best and most determined receiver. His junior year, which was his breakout year, saw him catch over 70 balls for over 1000 yards and 15 touchdowns. His senior year was cruising along towards similar numbers, but erratic QB play and then a season-ending injured foot seven games into the year cut his year short and his statistics down significantly.
He was good for Utah State. But it was he combine that set him apart a bit from his peers. On a foot that he estimated was around 90 percent, he went out a ran a 4.42 with a 1.49 10-yard split, which I think was the best 10-yard split in the rookie WR class. His vertical jump at his pro day was 36" and his broad jump was 10'1". In addition, his shuttle was a 4.25 and his three-cone was a 6.95, which is good. Those jumps and times, combined with his forty time and splits, gave him a 9.00 out of 10.00 RAS.
So we know he's athletic. One of the knocks on him was explosiveness and he puts those criticisms to bed with his shuttle and his 1.49 ten-yard split. He has a reputation for great hands and high pointing the ball, and that came through in his highlights. The only thing puzzling scouts is that he's a bit of a tweener. He is comfortable playing outside, but height might dictate (I don't think this is necessarily the case) that he plays the slot. So we'll see what happens in the pros, but he was available, he was my favorite out of the remaining top receiver, the Jets had a need at WR, and therefore, I picked him.
J-E-T-S JETS JETS JETS!!!!!! LFG!
This was a tough pick. Jack Bech, Tre Harris, and Jaylen Noel are all still on the board. I went with Royals over Bech due to speed concerns, over Harris because Harris's Reception Perception chart didn't look very good, and Jaylen Noel hasn't met a tackler that can't crumple him.
Royals was Utah State's number one guy. He's 6'0, 205 lbs. and played as an outside receiver because even though he lacked a bit of length, he was their best and most determined receiver. His junior year, which was his breakout year, saw him catch over 70 balls for over 1000 yards and 15 touchdowns. His senior year was cruising along towards similar numbers, but erratic QB play and then a season-ending injured foot seven games into the year cut his year short and his statistics down significantly.
He was good for Utah State. But it was he combine that set him apart a bit from his peers. On a foot that he estimated was around 90 percent, he went out a ran a 4.42 with a 1.49 10-yard split, which I think was the best 10-yard split in the rookie WR class. His vertical jump at his pro day was 36" and his broad jump was 10'1". In addition, his shuttle was a 4.25 and his three-cone was a 6.95, which is good. Those jumps and times, combined with his forty time and splits, gave him a 9.00 out of 10.00 RAS.
So we know he's athletic. One of the knocks on him was explosiveness and he puts those criticisms to bed with his shuttle and his 1.49 ten-yard split. He has a reputation for great hands and high pointing the ball, and that came through in his highlights. The only thing puzzling scouts is that he's a bit of a tweener. He is comfortable playing outside, but height might dictate (I don't think this is necessarily the case) that he plays the slot. So we'll see what happens in the pros, but he was available, he was my favorite out of the remaining top receiver, the Jets had a need at WR, and therefore, I picked him.
J-E-T-S JETS JETS JETS!!!!!! LFG!
Last edited:
rockaction
Footballguy
@Instinctive you're up
Almost took him at 58 for the Texans but DT is pretty deep, feel like the mock really slept on him and some other less sexy positions (not surprising considering this is a fantasy football forum.)
Instinctive
Footballguy
CAR 3.74 will settle for Deone Walker, IDL Kentucky
If I were running a team with as many needs as Carolina, I'd be trying to build on the strengths I did have. That's a good Dlineman and a good corner. So we add in this draft the #2 EDGE, a 2nd round grade IDL, and a late first/early second corner. With such a deep class on defense at these key positions, and underwhelming options on the OL and at WR, I think hitting the defense hard and snagging a RB to go with a recovering Brooks sometime on Day 3 is the best way to set up a core of future success.
If someone on the OL slipped to Carolina in the 2nd, probably need to consider it, but I have always been a build-a-strength philosophy holder on team building.
If I were running a team with as many needs as Carolina, I'd be trying to build on the strengths I did have. That's a good Dlineman and a good corner. So we add in this draft the #2 EDGE, a 2nd round grade IDL, and a late first/early second corner. With such a deep class on defense at these key positions, and underwhelming options on the OL and at WR, I think hitting the defense hard and snagging a RB to go with a recovering Brooks sometime on Day 3 is the best way to set up a core of future success.
If someone on the OL slipped to Carolina in the 2nd, probably need to consider it, but I have always been a build-a-strength philosophy holder on team building.
Instinctive
Footballguy
Gatorade
Footballguy
Damn you
Ben & Jerry's
Footballguy
I like him.
He's one of those questionable guys. During the draft cycle everyone praise with "he's a football guy. He can do it all...some explaining" but a lot of times not fast enough and not quick enough and not tall enough trump the "he just knows how to play ball" stuff.
Hunter Leupke is one that bugs me. Bruiser like Alstott, can play TE in spots and carry the load at RB if needed too. How desperate have the Cowboys been at times and he doesn't even get much of a shot at RB?
Zeirlein has him as a UDFA. https://www.nfl.com/prospects/xavier-restrepo/32005245-5356-4972-bc22-d183ed3e5893
I'm thinking if he falls to the 6th? Maybe fifth...I am definitely taking him. He won't make it to be a UDFA if I'm drafting.
Pick 3.75 49ers select Alfred Collins, DT, Texas
SF interior run defense was abysmal last year and Collins can plug right in and help fix that. Big body with decent agility who hasn't done much as a pass rusher, but has the physical traits to be effective as one. An interesting comment in his draft profile
"He's a legit specimen. With the right coaching, he could end up taking off and becoming the best interior player in this class.” NFL personnel director
49ers D-line coach Kris Kocurek is a good motivator so do your thing Kris
SF interior run defense was abysmal last year and Collins can plug right in and help fix that. Big body with decent agility who hasn't done much as a pass rusher, but has the physical traits to be effective as one. An interesting comment in his draft profile
"He's a legit specimen. With the right coaching, he could end up taking off and becoming the best interior player in this class.” NFL personnel director
49ers D-line coach Kris Kocurek is a good motivator so do your thing Kris
Last edited:
Grahamburn
Footballguy
Cruising right along. Sure we can’t do the 4th round? Seems like the interest is there.
Grahamburn
Footballguy
Royals is gas. Underrated. Love him.Damn you
Tau837
Footballguy
I'm in for the full 7 rounds if others are.
Uruk-Hai
Footballguy
I'm out after 3, but someone is welcome to grab Baltimore for the later rounds.
Instinctive
Footballguy
Was also in consideration for me with the Alexander and walker tier
rockaction
Footballguy
Same here, friend. Three is enough for me. Seven is deeper than I can go right now.
rockaction
Footballguy
I had them Royals, Bech, Noel, Harris. I think if Bech has enough speed, then he’s the guy, but he didn’t test at all and had a serious injury his junior (?) year. So you wonder if that will be an issue in the pros. But I saw some stuff where he was my #2 after Royals (with what I know now, which is subject to change).
RC94
Footballguy
Pick #77 the NY Giants select DT. Omarr Norman-Lott, Tennessee
Besides QB, this is tied with o-line for the biggest need and based on rankings that I've seen, this is good value for this player. Just like with the o-line, the d-line is one great player surrounded by 30+ year old low level vets. Like with o-line, they have neglected the d-line in the draft for years so it's now a huge need for a team filled with needs all over the place.
Besides QB, this is tied with o-line for the biggest need and based on rankings that I've seen, this is good value for this player. Just like with the o-line, the d-line is one great player surrounded by 30+ year old low level vets. Like with o-line, they have neglected the d-line in the draft for years so it's now a huge need for a team filled with needs all over the place.
Ministry of Pain
Footballguy
I was looking at him, good time to pull the trigger, has a chance to carve out a role in the WR2/3 slots
Instinctive
Footballguy
How did you think about the lack of playtime? He's got good traits and such but played less than half as much as all the surrounding guys. Made me drop him a bit.
A lot of WRs on the board.
Ministry of Pain
Footballguy
MAC_32
Footballguy
Rotational players are the expectation at this point and looking at what these complimentary players get on the open market, a good complimentary DT on a rookie contract is EV+. If he can ball, it don't matter if he's a 50%er or 65%er at this point- get them.
ZWK
Footballguy
UCLA LB Carson Schwesinger is generally seen as a round 2 pick, and was the top player available on a few different draft boards that I looked at. He was very productive in his 1 year as a starter (his 4th season, after doing very little in his first 3), had great athletic testing according to reports his private workout (though he didn't run the 40), and scouting reports praise his instincts and movement skills (but don't think he has amazing speed). Looked fluid in the highlights I watched. Was undersized when he started at UCLA, but has bulked up by now (242 pounds at the combine).
In 2024, Arizona had a hybrid ILB (Mack Wilson) who often lined up on the LOS and rushed the passer rather than dropping into coverage on 1/3 of passing snaps, and a more traditional off-ball linebacker (Kyzir White). Schwesinger is headed for the Kyzir White role. Schwesinger did play with some physicality and was very effective when he did blitz, but he generally blitzed from depth with a running start and did not look like someone who would thrive on the LOS (though I guess that it's possible that he'll develop that aspect of his game). He'll compete primarily with Akeem Davis-Gaither, who the Cardinals signed as an upgrade over Kyzir White. Davis-Gaither is a below average starter and is on a 2-year contract where the second year is a team option.
I was thinking I'd target the lines on this pick (IDL, EDGE, OG, or OT), because those are more important positions and somewhat higher priorities than LB for the Cardinals, but you guys picked those positions pretty clean. First OL, then DL.
In 2024, Arizona had a hybrid ILB (Mack Wilson) who often lined up on the LOS and rushed the passer rather than dropping into coverage on 1/3 of passing snaps, and a more traditional off-ball linebacker (Kyzir White). Schwesinger is headed for the Kyzir White role. Schwesinger did play with some physicality and was very effective when he did blitz, but he generally blitzed from depth with a running start and did not look like someone who would thrive on the LOS (though I guess that it's possible that he'll develop that aspect of his game). He'll compete primarily with Akeem Davis-Gaither, who the Cardinals signed as an upgrade over Kyzir White. Davis-Gaither is a below average starter and is on a 2-year contract where the second year is a team option.
I was thinking I'd target the lines on this pick (IDL, EDGE, OG, or OT), because those are more important positions and somewhat higher priorities than LB for the Cardinals, but you guys picked those positions pretty clean. First OL, then DL.
At 79, the HOU Texans select WR Tre Harris Ole Miss
WR is obviously a need with Tank rehabbing, Diggs signed elsewhere and Nico a good bet to miss at least a game or two every year. Kirk is in the last year of his deal and couldn't stay healthy the last two years either. I've seen him linked to the Texans in quite a few mocks/articles even at their 2nd round pick so seems good value here despite his less than stellar Reception Perception chart. While not a #1 guy, he should make a good complement as the Z to Nico in the X and Kirk in the slot (and/or Tank if he's back healthy at some point.) Harris was blowing up this past season until he got injured and was on his way to a huge season if not cut short. Think he's in play for a lot of teams in this range of the draft.
WR is obviously a need with Tank rehabbing, Diggs signed elsewhere and Nico a good bet to miss at least a game or two every year. Kirk is in the last year of his deal and couldn't stay healthy the last two years either. I've seen him linked to the Texans in quite a few mocks/articles even at their 2nd round pick so seems good value here despite his less than stellar Reception Perception chart. While not a #1 guy, he should make a good complement as the Z to Nico in the X and Kirk in the slot (and/or Tank if he's back healthy at some point.) Harris was blowing up this past season until he got injured and was on his way to a huge season if not cut short. Think he's in play for a lot of teams in this range of the draft.
popeye
Footballguy
With pick #80, the Colts select LB Demetrius Knight, South Carolina.
Demetrius Knight Jr.'s path to the NFL draft spans six years across three programs. A former dual-threat high-school quarterback, his family ties include former NFL Pro Bowler DeAngelo Hall and music legends Gladys Knight and Aretha Franklin. #CouldHaveBeenAPip
After four years at Georgia Tech, Knight transferred to Charlotte where he had 96 tackles and earned First-Team All-AAC honors. His final season at South Carolina showcased his development, earning team captain honors while recording 82 tackles (57 solo) with 8.0 tackles for loss and 2.0 sacks.
The 6'2", 245-pound linebacker collected multiple accolades in 2024, including the Rex Enright Team Captain award, Most Outstanding Senior recognition, and Joe Morrison MVP Defense honors. His academic achievements include three appearances on the ACC Academic Honor Roll (2019-2021).
Demetruis is an impactful defensive signal-caller who can both coordinate the defense and create havoc himself. His proven special-teams results provide day one value while he develops as a rotational linebacker. The tackling technique needs refinement, but his appetite for contact and closing burst project him as a future three-down MIKE.
By drafting TE, RG and LB, we’ve addressed the Colt’s most immediate needs. In later rounds, I’d look at the secondary along with OT depth.
Demetrius Knight Jr.'s path to the NFL draft spans six years across three programs. A former dual-threat high-school quarterback, his family ties include former NFL Pro Bowler DeAngelo Hall and music legends Gladys Knight and Aretha Franklin. #CouldHaveBeenAPip
After four years at Georgia Tech, Knight transferred to Charlotte where he had 96 tackles and earned First-Team All-AAC honors. His final season at South Carolina showcased his development, earning team captain honors while recording 82 tackles (57 solo) with 8.0 tackles for loss and 2.0 sacks.
The 6'2", 245-pound linebacker collected multiple accolades in 2024, including the Rex Enright Team Captain award, Most Outstanding Senior recognition, and Joe Morrison MVP Defense honors. His academic achievements include three appearances on the ACC Academic Honor Roll (2019-2021).
Demetruis is an impactful defensive signal-caller who can both coordinate the defense and create havoc himself. His proven special-teams results provide day one value while he develops as a rotational linebacker. The tackling technique needs refinement, but his appetite for contact and closing burst project him as a future three-down MIKE.
By drafting TE, RG and LB, we’ve addressed the Colt’s most immediate needs. In later rounds, I’d look at the secondary along with OT depth.
