What's new
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

FBG'S TOP 81 LED ZEPPELIN SONGS: #1 - When The Levee Breaks from Led Zeppelin IV (1971) (2 Viewers)

SPOILER ALERT: You have 13 of the Top 14.


I believe you are one of 3 people to have 3 of your Top 5 songs appear so far. That's something to be cherished and applauded. Good job avoiding the group think mentality.
Interesting comment.

I didn't and still haven't looked at any internet list. Had no idea how they would be ranked. Just listened to all the songs and compared how I like one versus another.

I had only six LZ on my Spotify play list before this.   Had Fool in The Rain #10. 

My Top 14 list is for sale.  :lmao:

 
I like shuke's format - my top 16 still in tact.

1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.
11.
12.
13.
14.
15.
16.
17. Dancing Days (41)
18.
19.
20. Houses Of the Holy (37)
21.
22. Trampled Under Foot (31)
23. Four Sticks (53)
24. Gallows Pole (36)
25.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Interesting comment.

I didn't and still haven't looked at any internet list. Had no idea how they would be ranked. Just listened to all the songs and compared how I like one versus another.

I had only six LZ on my Spotify play list before this.   Had Fool in The Rain #10. 

My Top 14 list is for sale.  :lmao:
Truth be told, I have no issue with however anybody ranks the songs. People like what they like. But differences of opinion create conflict, and conflict sparks more discussion and name calling. Which gets more posts and people in the thread. So there’s that. 

 
Truth be told, I have no issue with however anybody ranks the songs. People like what they like. But differences of opinion create conflict, and conflict sparks more discussion and name calling. Which gets more posts and people in the thread. So there’s that. 
A group think response if I ever saw one.  :D

 
1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13 Nobobdy's Fault But Mine (32)

14

15

16

17 The Lemon Song (40)

18

19 Out On the Tiles (56)

20

21 Celebration Day (52)

22

23 Gallows Pole (36)

24 Achilles Last Stand (33)

25

 
Truth be told, I have no issue with however anybody ranks the songs. People like what they like. But differences of opinion create conflict, and conflict sparks more discussion and name calling. Which gets more posts and people in the thread. So there’s that. 
You selling a NFT of this thread or something?

 
suck it, conformist sheep


I believe you are one of 3 people to have 3 of your Top 5 songs appear so far. That's something to be cherished and applauded. Good job avoiding the group think mentality.


i think the real test of groupthink and conformity will lie with one song: Stairway to Heaven - but not for the reasons ya might think. 

i think the conformist/groupthink cabal will be in the "oh, it's too played out/i'm tired of it/way over rated" camp, which seems to be the conventional wisdom surrounding it for at least the past couple decades.  

and i get all that. 

so i could see it being left outta the top 10 by the great majority of that group. 

conversely, i think the non-chalk eaters will rank it higher, simply because it is an incredible piece of work, warts and all, and because it is now de rigueur, if not conformist, to slag it and lessen it in the rankings. 

gonna be the most polarizing of the remaining lot, imo. 

 
I believe you are one of 3 people to have 3 of your Top 5 songs appear so far. That's something to be cherished and applauded. Good job avoiding the group think mentality.
I had 3 of my top 5 selected

3- In the Evening

4 - The Wanton Song

5- Celebration Day

 
I don't understand what this means.  I'm not trying to "win" anything.
I wasn't suggesting that anyone is trying to win anything. All we are doing is giving thoughts on songs. Some people are really into how many songs they have left, others not so much.

My point was that you have multiple songs that you ranked highly that are coming up soon.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10. In The Evening (34)
11
12. All My Love (44)
13. Gallows Pole (36)
14
15
16
17
18. Fool in the Rain (35)
19

20
21
22
23. Nobody's Fault But Mine (32)
24. Achilles Last Stand (33)
25
 

 
I have 20 tunes left on my top 25 not mentioned yet with 30 to go. 

Nobody’s Fault But Mine was the last tune on my list ranked.....we had that gem ranked 22.

We are getting to the nitty gritty here!

1. 

2. 

3. 

4. 

5. Achilles Last Stand

6. 

7. 

8. 

9. 

10. 

11.

12. Bring It On Home

13. 

14. 

15. 

16. 

17. 

18. 

19. 

20. 

21. 

22. Nobody’s Fault But Mine

23. Gallows Pole

24.  

25. Night Flight 

 
Last edited by a moderator:
1. 

2. 

3. 

4. 

5.

6. 

7. Gallows Pole (36)

8. 

9. 

10. 

11. 

12. 

13. 

14. Houses of the Holy (37)

15. Boogie With Stu (63)

16. 

17. D'yer Mak'er (46)

18. Fool in the Rain (35)

19. Your Time Is Gonna Come (39)

20. Down by The Seaside (57)

21. 

22. 

23. That's The Way (55)

24. 

25. Nobody's Fault But Mine (32)

 
1. 
2. 
3. 
4. 
5. 
6.  
7. Houses Of the Holy (37)
8. All My Love (44)
9. 
10. Gallows Pole (36)
11. I Can't Quit You Baby (50)
12. 
13. 
14. 
15. 
16. 
17. 
18. 
19. 
20. 
21. 
22. 
23. Nobody's Fault But Mine (32)
24. Achilles Last Stand (33)
25. Your Time Is Gonna Come (39)

I guess I'm not surprised so far.  My LZ experience was listening to Cleveland's WWMS (The Buzzard) and Youngstown's WSRD (The Wizard) back in the late 70s-early 80s.  I'm old enough to remember (but too young to go to) the World Series of Rock  at old Cleveland Stadium.  While LZ never played it, a lot of other big names did. Plus, what Cleveland mega show is going to leave out Michael Stanley?

 
Last edited by a moderator:
5 of my top 25 have already been listed.

#5  - Your Time is Gonna Come

#10  - Down By The Seaside

#18 - In the Evening

#22 - All My Love

#25  - The Lemon Song

 
#31 - Trampled Under Foot from Physical Graffiti (1975)

Appeared On: 25 ballots (out of 62 . . . 40.3%)
Total Points: 275 points (out of 1,550 possible points . . .  17.7%)
#1 Rankers: @Long Ball Larry@BrutalPenguin
Top 10 Rankers: @2Young2BBald@drunken slob@ConstruxBoy
Highest Ranking: 1

Live Performances:
LZ: 77 (London - 1975-5-24Cleveland - 1977-04-27Knebworth - 1979-08-04, Frankfurt - 1980-06-30, London - 2007-12-10)
Page & Plant: 6 (London - 1988-04-17)
Plant: 101 (Stockholm 2015-07-14, Unknown)
JPJ: 21 (Milan - 1999-11-13)

Ultimate Classic Rock Ranking (out of 92 songs): 21
Vulture Ranking (out of 74 songs): 19
Rolling Stone Ranking (out of 40 songs): 26
Louder Ranking (out of 50 songs): 40
Uproxx Ranking (out of 50 songs): 22
WMGK Ranking (out of 92 songs): 15
SPIN Ranking (out of 87 songs):42
Ranker Ranking (out of 87 songs): 28
Anachronarchy Ranking (out of 80 songs): 57

Our first song to garner two first place votes. The early origins of TUF stem back to the Houses Of The Holy recordings sessions in 1972. Like many other Led Zep songs, the band was rehearsing in the studio and started jamming. John Paul Jones and Jimmy Page mimicked each other on the main riff and things developed from there. The song was revisited, reworked, and expanded on in early 1974.

How they ended up on that song title is a bit of a mystery, but Robert Plant once introduced the song by saying, "If you like the motor cars and the parts of the human body, then sometimes... you can get trrrrrampled under foot!" The song started out called Brandy & CokeRehearsal Part IRehearsal Part 2Rehearsal Part 3

The song was inspired by Terraplane Blues by Robert Johnson, , a song about a car with lyrics with multiple double entendres. John Paul Jones would later describe that his keyboard playing was loosely based on, and in the style of, Superstition by Stevie Wonder, with additional flares and homages to Outa Space by Billy Preston and Machine Gun by The Commodores. Page drew from his days in The Yardbirds, using effects (a backwards echo and wah-wah) similar to his work on Ten Little Indians from 1967.

The entire band loved the song and loved to perform it. Bonham broke down why he loved tackling Trampled Under Foot in concert. “It’s great for me. Great rhythm for a drummer. It’s just at the right pace, and you can do a lot of frills.” Though the band sped up the tempo in live performances, Bonham still had plenty of room to improvise within every few bars.

John Paul Jones recalled creating the song in the studio. “I just started playing it on the clavinet, and Bonzo came in with this glorious stomp that had this great feel. He could play in front of the beat, and he could play behind it, depending on what was needed. Trampled Under Foot had this swagger.” Robert Plant has said it’s one of his favorites from the Zeppelin catalog.

Trampled Under Foot as the only single from Physical Graffiti. Backed with Black Country Woman, it cracked the Top 40 singles chart in the U.S., peaking at #38.

The song was performed on probably the least known Led Zeppelin performance . . . at the Hen & Chickens public house in Oldbury, West Midlands to celebrate Carmen Plant’s 21st birthday in 1989. Jason Bonham again took over the drum kit and the group cranked out Trampled Under Foot, Misty Mountain Hop, and Rock and Roll. Plant soaked in every minute of it: “Pagey was playing so good. I had a big lump in my throat. When he plays in those circumstances, it’s unbelievable. That little time of playing with him gave me something I haven’t had for a long time.” The lyrics “Now I'm singing all my songs to the girl who won my heart / She is only three years old and it's a real fine way to start” from The Ocean is a direct reference to Carmen.

Ultimate Classic Rock (21 of 92 songs): Inspired by Stevie Wonder's Superstitious, Led Zeppelin's funkiest song was the only single released from the two-LP Physical Graffiti. One of the band's most radio-ready tracks spotlights Jones' relentless clavinet, the album's not-so-secret weapon.

Vulture (19 of 74 songs): This stomping, brittle rocker should have been the lead off track of Graffiti instead of the inferior Custard Pie. Page has at this point moved far on from the slow and sometimes labored riffs of the first few albums. (Compare this song to Heartbreaker, for example.) Here, he’s utterly frenetic. To my ears the song has a dry shrillness, a high-pitched trebly patina, that I associate with heroin. You can take or leave Plant’s jokey lyrics about car mechanics or such, but there’s no gainsaying the ferocity of the band’s attack. Historical footnote: A reviewer in Rolling Stone said the song, a rock-radio staple now for almost 40 years, reminded him of Kool and the Gang — a novelty funk amalgamation known at the time for songs like Hollywood Swinging and Jungle Boogie.

Rolling Stone (26 of 40 songs): Possibly the funkiest Zep track: Jones (inspired by Stevie Wonder's Superstition) rocks a clavinet and Page a wah-wah, and they ride Bonzo's proto-disco beat. Plant works a sexual metaphor with automobile imagery echoing Robert Johnson's Terraplane Blues.

Louder (40 of 50 songs): Physical Graffiti produced not only the Led Zeppelin anthems Kashmir and Houses Of The Holy, but it also the delightfully upbeat, out-of-character Trampled Underfoot. The keyboard-orientated theme provided a whole new groove for the band, which stunned fans who heard it being played at the 1975 Earls Court concerts. It had the kind of relentlessly driving rhythm that no one wanted to stop. John Paul Jones set up the electric piano riff and Bonham supplied the surging back beat. Although Stevie Wonder may have provided the inspiration, the attack was certainly all Zeppelin. Trampled Underfoot emerged from an informal jam session, and rapidly became one of Plant’s favorite tracks. The lyrics are said to be based on Robert Johnson’s 1936 vintage Terraplane Blues. The song uses motor cars as a sexual metaphor – 'Mama, let me pump your gas'. Trampled was released as another US single and reached number 38 in the Billboard chart in May 1975.

Uproxx (22 of 50 songs): A tremendous Stevie Wonder homage, just as Pastime Paradise is a tremendous Led Zeppelin homage.

WMGK (15 of 92 songs): The clavinet is more closely associated with the funk music of the ‘70s (notably Stevie Wonder) than Led Zeppelin, but John Paul Jones’ playing of that electric keyboard is what makes this track so damn catchy and memorable. It’s perhaps the most toe-tapping hook in Zeppelin’s entire catalog.

SPIN (42 of 87 songs):One of the band’s thickest, tightest stomps, largely thanks to the superlative work of John Paul Jones on the clavinet and a melody generously pinched from the Doobie Brothers’ Long Train Running. As fun as it is, though, it goes on a minute or two too long after the groove starts to feel repetitive and Plant’s cars-as-sex (sex-as-cars?) exhortations get considerably tiresome, keeping it comfortably out of the group’s top tier of hits.

I thank you for all the likes and gratitude . . . but we move on to a love song Plant wrote about his wife.
My rank: 12

My friend’s rank: None

As I said before, I love songs with momentum and groove, and this song has a ton of both. It landed in my inviolable top 15 and there are days where I feel it should be higher than that. 

It’s another rare tune that rocks AND swings supremely. Every time it comes on I can’t help but move or fidget to it. I never thought of JPJ channeling Stevie Wonder on the clavinet, but it makes perfect sense. And I love how the vocal and guitar seem to be having a conversation.

Best of all, Bonzo is just ridiculous here. This is way more funky than anything from a “rock” band has a right to be. 

 
My rank: 12

My friend’s rank: None

As I said before, I love songs with momentum and groove, and this song has a ton of both. It landed in my inviolable top 15 and there are days where I feel it should be higher than that. 

It’s another rare tune that rocks AND swings supremely. Every time it comes on I can’t help but move or fidget to it. I never thought of JPJ channeling Stevie Wonder on the clavinet, but it makes perfect sense. And I love how the vocal and guitar seem to be having a conversation.

Best of all, Bonzo is just ridiculous here. This is way more funky than anything from a “rock” band has a right to be. 


also one of Plant's most versatile vocal exercises ... i'm not a huge fan of the "cat's tail stepped on" schtick he loved to deploy, so this vox was most welcome - ballsy and beefy, if not downright savage. 

 
i think the real test of groupthink and conformity will lie with one song: Stairway to Heaven - but not for the reasons ya might think. 

i think the conformist/groupthink cabal will be in the "oh, it's too played out/i'm tired of it/way over rated" camp, which seems to be the conventional wisdom surrounding it for at least the past couple decades.  

and i get all that. 

so i could see it being left outta the top 10 by the great majority of that group. 

conversely, i think the non-chalk eaters will rank it higher, simply because it is an incredible piece of work, warts and all, and because it is now de rigueur, if not conformist, to slag it and lessen it in the rankings. 

gonna be the most polarizing of the remaining lot, imo.


Possibly, but we discussed this before and I don't think so.  One, because lots of people who submitted lists have talked about how great it is while very few have called it overrated or overplayed.  Also, you can see that the vast majority of the folks who submitted lists are really in to LZ - both threads have been fantastic and most folks seems to be very knowledgeable.  I'm mostly confident it will get a good ranking.

 
i think the real test of groupthink and conformity will lie with one song: Stairway to Heaven - but not for the reasons ya might think. 

i think the conformist/groupthink cabal will be in the "oh, it's too played out/i'm tired of it/way over rated" camp, which seems to be the conventional wisdom surrounding it for at least the past couple decades.  


I actually feel this way about Kashmir, which I left off my list completely.  I've thought maybe I was trying to be too contrarian, but I honestly wouldn't want to bump anything from my list to add it.  

Stairway, on the other hand, will never get old.  I could listen to it every day.

 
On an unrelated note, I add Achilles Last Stand to my workout mix.  It may be my new go to when I need that extra push.

 
I actually feel this way about Kashmir, which I left off my list completely.  I've thought maybe I was trying to be too contrarian, but I honestly wouldn't want to bump anything from my list to add it.  

Stairway, on the other hand, will never get old.  I could listen to it every day.


crazy, I am at a complete opposite on those two songs

don't hate Stairway, but don't want to hear it anymore and is not on my list

Kashmir on the other hand is super high for me.  

 
I actually feel this way about Kashmir, which I left off my list completely.  I've thought maybe I was trying to be too contrarian, but I honestly wouldn't want to bump anything from my list to add it.  

Stairway, on the other hand, will never get old.  I could listen to it every day.


great point on Kashmir - i can see the parallel, no doubt. 

the reason i cited Stairway was because it was ALWAYS (not 90% of the time, or 95% of the time, or 99.9% of the time - but ALWAYS) the #1 tune whenever the big countdowns took place here in the City. 

the "Firecracker 500" was usually the big one, done over 4th of July, on the nation's premier FM channel, WNEW. 

ya had a group of a dozen or so that would always usually populate in any iteration behind it (Layla, Baba O'Reilly, Bohemian Rhapsody, Freebird, Born to Run, All Along the Watchtower, Roundabout, Hey Jude, Satisfaction, Hotel Cali, Smoke on the Water, etcetcetc) - but Stairway was KING.  never a doubt. 

undisputed Heavyweight Champeen, each n' every time ... so, yeah, i draw mostly from that unequaled run of positivity, which i last paid attention to some 40 years ago. 

it's their sig, for better or worse - though your points are very well taken with Kashmir. 

 
Zoso playing here locally tomorrow in Detroit. Standing Room tickets available for $25.  Thinking about checking it out.

Anybody ever seen this band live? Just wondering it=f it's worth my time.  Their Youtube videos look pretty sweet TBH.

 
Heading into the Top 30, individual Top 10 selections still remaining and yet to be revealed:

10 - 12
9 - 16
8 - 17
7 - 6
6 - 7
5 - 3
4 - 1

 
With 30 to go, still 21 left.

1.

2.

3.

4.

5.

6.

7.

8: Traveling Riverside Blues (#43)

9.

10.

11.

12.

13.

14.

15.

16.

17.

18.

19.

20.

21.

22: Houses of the Holy (#37)

23.

24: I Can't Quit You Baby (Coda version preferred) (#50)

25: Your Time is Gonna Come (#39)

#8 was probably too high. 

 
With 30 to go, still 21 left.

1.

2.

3.

4.

5.

6.

7.

8: Traveling Riverside Blues (#43)

9.

10.

11.

12.

13.

14.

15.

16.

17.

18.

19.

20.

21.

22: Houses of the Holy (#37)

23.

24: I Can't Quit You Baby (Coda version preferred) (#50)

25: Your Time is Gonna Come (#39)

#8 was probably too high. 
Disagree . Great Song

 
6 of my top 25 have already been listed.

#5  - Your Time is Gonna Come

#10  - Down By The Seaside

#18 - In the Evening

#22 - All My Love

#24 - Trampled Under Foot

#25  - The Lemon Song
I forgot Trampled Under Foot. So it is 6 songs.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
6-Celebration Day-52

7-Friends-47 

8-Bring It On Home-42

13-Out On The Tiles-56

17-I Can't Quit You Baby-50

18-Achilles Last Stand-33

19-Trampled Under Foot-31

20-Bron-Y-Aur Stomp-49

21-You Shook Me-54

22-That's The Way-55

25-The Wanton Song-48 

The next song looks to be my #15

 
6-Celebration Day-52

7-Friends-47 

8-Bring It On Home-42

13-Out On The Tiles-56

17-I Can't Quit You Baby-50

18-Achilles Last Stand-33

19-Trampled Under Foot-31

20-Bron-Y-Aur Stomp-49

21-You Shook Me-54

22-That's The Way-55

25-The Wanton Song-48 

The next song looks to be my #15
10 - Fool In The Rain (35)
17 - All My Love (44)
19- Houses of the Holy (37)
22 - In The Evening (34)
25 - Achilles Last Stand (33) 

One Tinder match  :lmao:
 

 
1. 

2. 

3.

4. 

5. 

6.

7. 

8. 

9.

10.

11. Your Time is Gonna Come

12. 

13. 

14.

15.

16. 

17. 

18.

19. 

20. 

21. Nobody’s Fault But Mine

22. 

23. 

24. Achilles Last Stand

25. In the Evening

 
25. 
24.
23. 
22. 
21. "Black Mountain Side," Led Zeppelin #65
20. "Bron-Y-Aur Stomp," Led Zeppelin III #49
19. "In the Evening," In Through the Out Door #34
18.
17. 
16. "Four Sticks," Led Zeppelin IV #53
15. "Moby ****," Led Zeppelin II  #51
14. 
13. 
12. 
11. "Dancing Days," Houses of the Holy  #41
10. "Travelling Riverside Blues," Led Zeppelin #43
9. 
8. 
7. 
6. 
5.
4. 
3. 
2. 
1. 

 
Last edited by a moderator:
1. Achilles Last Stand (33)
2. Ten Years Gone (22)
3. No Quarter (19)
4. In the Evening (34)
5. 
6.
7.
8. In the Light (29)
9. The Song Remains the Same (23)
10.
11.
12. Trampled Under Foot (31)
13.
14. The Rover (38)
15. For Your Life (59)
16. Gallows Pole (36)
17. What Is And What Should Never Be (16)
18.
19. Rock and Roll (14)
20. Custard Pie (45)
21. Houses of the Holy (37)
22. 
23. Dancing Days (41)
24. Communication Breakdown (18)
25. Fool in the Rain (35)

I just got walloped in the 30s. Six straight between 38 and 33, and then 31. 

If the #1 song is on my list, I would guess it's my 5 or my 11. Outside shot for 3, 6, 18 or 22. (Anarchy -- no need to tell us.) I suspect the others are either too popular (ie, all the contrarians omitted them) or not popular enough for the top spot. 

 
Last edited by a moderator:
My friend's list:

1. In the Light (29)
2. Celebration Day (52)
3. Good Times Bad Times (11)
4. 
5.
6. Tangerine (28)
7.
8. 
9. Houses of the Holy (37)
10. Hey, Hey, What Can I Do? (24)
11. Out on the Tiles (56)
12. 
13.
14. Friends (47)
15. The Rain Song (17)
16. That's the Way (55)
17. Thank You (30)
18. The Ocean (20)
19. Heartbreaker / Livin' Lovin' Maid (11)
20.
21. 
22. Misty Mountain Hop (25)
23. What Is And What Should Never Be (16)
24. The Battle of Evermore (21)
25. The Song Remains the Same (25)

There are 10 songs in the top 30 that appear on both of our lists. 

 
Last edited by a moderator:
#30 - Thank You from Led Zeppelin II (1969)

Appeared On: 26 ballots (out of 62 . . . 41.9%)
Total Points: 296 points (out of 1,550 possible points . . .  19.1%)
Top 5 Rankers:  @UncleZen@Long Ball Larry@raidergil@Cowboysfan8
Top 10 Rankers:  @simey@Zeppelin@Dr. Octopus
Highest Ranking: 2

Live Performances:
LZ: 101 (Montreux - 1970-03-07London - 1971-01-04Southampton - 1973-01-22New York - 1973-07-29)
Page & Plant: 136 (Unledded - 1994Detroit - 1995-04-01Irvine - 1995-10-02)
Plant: 95 (Freddie Mercury Tribute – 1992Brooklyn - 2014-09-28)
Page: 1 (Page with Fred Durst (Limp Bizkit) and Wes Scantlin (Puddle Of Mudd) - 2001)

Covers: (TeslaChris CornellTori AmosDuran DuranFlaming LipsGreat WhiteTrainRandy Jackson (Zebra))

Ultimate Classic Rock Ranking (out of 92 songs): 39
Vulture Ranking (out of 74 songs): 64
Rolling Stone Ranking (out of 40 songs): 29
Louder Ranking (out of 50 songs): 19
Uproxx Ranking (out of 50 songs): 30
WMGK Ranking (out of 92 songs): 34
SPIN Ranking (out of 87 songs): 58
Ranker Ranking (out of 87 songs): 26
Anachronarchy Ranking (out of 80 songs): 50

Our first entry in the Top 30 did not land any #1 votes, but it did fetch three #2's. It’s one of nine remaining songs that failed to receive a single first-place vote. We still haven’t seen a song that was named on at least half the ballots. The band showcases its kinder, gentler, sensitive side on this one. Another song the external rankers couldn’t agree on . . . the range was 45 spots from high to low.

Thank You is the first song singer Robert Plant wrote lyrics for and was credited with. It is a tribute to his wife Maureen Plant. Jimmy Page once described, “It took a lot of ribbing and teasing to actually get him into writing, which was funny. And then on the second LP, he wrote the words to Thank You. He said, ‘I’d like to have a crack at this and write it for my wife’” (who Plant had married a few months earlier). The song loses some of its luster when we stop and consider that the couples eternal bliss was short lived, their marriage ended in divorce, and Plant would father a child with his ex-wife’s sister.

The song was recorded all in one day and was a favorite of both Page and Plant. Plant borrowed the lyrics "If the sun refuse to shine" and "mountains crumble to the sea" from If 6 Was 9 from Jimi Hendrix. It’s been speculated that the band included the false ending to the song to specifically mess with radio DJs. It’s one of the most covered songs in the Led Zeppelin catalog.

As far as live performances go, Zeppelin played the song 101 times but never beyond 1973 . . . not even at any of their various reunion gigs. It was a regular number for Page & Plant with 136 performances. Plant brought the song back after almost a 20-year hiatus for the Freddie Mercury Tribute and played it on his 93/94 tour (and every now and again since for a total of 95 times).

Speaking of live performances, only 7 musicians joined the band on stage over their 520 appearances . . .

- Steven Tyler & Joe Perry (Aerosmith) on 4 songs at LZ’s HOF Induction in 1995
- Keith Moon (The Who) at a show in L.A. in 1977 (on Moby ****, Whole Lotta Love, and Rock And Roll)
- Simon Kirke (Free and Bad Company) in Munich in 1980 (for Whole Lotta Love)
- Mick Ralphs (Mott the Hoople and Bad Company) in Fort Worth in 1977 (for an encore of It’ll Be Me)
- Ron Wood (Rolling Stones) for an encore of Communication Breakdown in Long Island in 1975.
- Neil Young at the HOF Induction show in 1995 on When the Levee Breaks

Ultimate Classic Rock (39 of 92 songs): Proving they weren't just a rock 'n' roll riff machine, Led Zeppelin busted out this love song, which Plant wrote for his wife, on their second album. It was the first time he penned lyrics all by himself.

Vulture (64 of 74 songs): A purty little paean to ‘60s flower-children. I’m not buying it, though, in the end; it seems a bit forced, and not really in keeping with the band’s overall approach. There’s more than a little Spinal Tap in it, and the production is muddy, even on the remasters. Despite the sonic dominance of tracks like Whole Lotta Love and Immigrant Song, Zeppelin was trying to broaden their palette on the second and third albums, to mixed results. It would be the fourth album before they made their claim to greatness.

Rolling Stone (29 of 40 songs): "Sometimes Zeppelin was gross and very indecent, and sometimes it was delicate and beautiful," Plant said. Thank You presents a rare happily married side of the band. Plant sings a grateful declaration to his wife, Maureen Wilson, and Jones' organ part is like a regal processional.

Louder (19 of 50 songs): Marking the point where Plant grew into himself as a lyricist (Page: “I always knew he would”), and delivering a cracked, heartfelt paean to his wife – even if it was part motivated by guilt – there’s also some highly effective pop nous on the chorus here, curiously bolstered by Page’s relatively weak backing vocals. Widely covered, versions range from the surprisingly great (Duran Duran), the idiosyncratic (Tori Amos), to the quick-call-the-police (Fred Durst, Wes Scantlin).

Uproxx (30 of 50 songs): Zeppelin has dozens of songs about sex — I think every song at least has sex in the subtext of Bonzo’s drums. But there aren’t all that many romantic love songs in their catalog. This is one of them. “My love is strong / With you there is no wrong / Together we shall go until we die.”

WMGK (34 of 92 songs): Led Zeppelin wasn’t all about lust, and they proved that with Thank You, which is an unbelievably sweet love song. With lyrics like, “When mountains crumble to the sea/There will still be you and me,” it’s hard not to swoon, regardless of your gender… or your dating status. 

SPIN (58 of 87 songs): The only Zep song to rival All My Love in sappiness, Thank You lays it on plenty thick (“If the sun refused to shine / I would still be loving you”), but it’s resonated enough with audiences that it was even used to soundtrack the (similarly sentimental) end of the True Blood series finale earlier this year. It’s not our Zep of choice, but some long-haired couple’s probably getting married to it somewhere this weekend, so fair enough.

I'm starting to feel like I can't go on (I actually don't feel well), but the countdown must continue.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
#30 - Thank You from Led Zeppelin II (1969)

Appeared On: 26 ballots (out of 62 . . . 41.9%)
Total Points: 296 points (out of 1,550 possible points . . .  19.1%)
Top 5 Rankers:  @UncleZen@Long Ball Larry@raidergil@Cowboysfan8
Top 10 Rankers:  @simey@Zeppelin@Dr. Octopus
Highest Ranking: 2

Live Performances:
LZ: 101 (Montreux - 1970-03-07London - 1971-01-04Southampton - 1973-01-22New York - 1973-07-29)
Page & Plant: 136 (Unledded - 1994Detroit - 1995-04-01Irvine - 1995-10-02)
Plant: 95 (Freddie Mercury Tribute – 1992Brooklyn - 2014-09-28)
Page: 1 (Page with Fred Durst (Limp Bizkit) and Wes Scantlin (Puddle Of Mudd) - 2001)

Covers: (TeslaChris CornellTori AmosDuran DuranFlaming LipsGreat WhiteTrainRandy Jackson (Zebra))

Ultimate Classic Rock Ranking (out of 92 songs): 39
Vulture Ranking (out of 74 songs): 64
Rolling Stone Ranking (out of 40 songs): 29
Louder Ranking (out of 50 songs): 19
Uproxx Ranking (out of 50 songs): 30
WMGK Ranking (out of 92 songs): 34
SPIN Ranking (out of 87 songs): 58
Ranker Ranking (out of 87 songs): 26
Anachronarchy Ranking (out of 80 songs): 50

Our first entry in the Top 30 did not land any #1 votes, but it did fetch three #2's. It’s one of nine remaining songs that failed to receive a single first-place vote. We still haven’t seen a song that was named on at least half the ballots. The band showcases its kinder, gentler, sensitive side on this one. Another song the external rankers couldn’t agree on . . . the range was 45 spots from high to low.

Thank You is the first song singer Robert Plant wrote lyrics for and was credited with. It is a tribute to his wife Maureen Plant. Jimmy Page once described, “It took a lot of ribbing and teasing to actually get him into writing, which was funny. And then on the second LP, he wrote the words to Thank You. He said, ‘I’d like to have a crack at this and write it for my wife’” (who Plant had married a few months earlier). The song loses some of its luster when we stop and consider that the couples eternal bliss was short lived, their marriage ended in divorce, and Plant would father a child with his ex-wife’s sister.

The song was recorded all in one day and was a favorite of both Page and Plant. Plant borrowed the lyrics "If the sun refuse to shine" and "mountains crumble to the sea" from If 6 Was 9 from Jimi Hendrix. It’s been speculated that the band included the false ending to the song to specifically mess with radio DJs. It’s one of the most covered songs in the Led Zeppelin catalog.

As far as live performances go, Zeppelin played the song 101 times but never beyond 1973 . . . not even at any of their various reunion gigs. It was a regular number for Page & Plant with 136 performances. Plant brought the song back after almost a 20-year hiatus for the Freddie Mercury Tribute and played it on his 93/94 tour (and every now and again since for a total of 95 times).

Speaking of live performances, only 7 musicians joined the band on stage over their 520 appearances . . .

- Steven Tyler & Joe Perry (Aerosmith) on 4 songs at LZ’s HOF Induction in 1995
- Keith Moon (The Who) at a show in L.A. in 1977 (on Moby ****, Whole Lotta Love, and Rock And Roll)
- Simon Kirke (Free and Bad Company) in Munich in 1980 (for Whole Lotta Love)
- Mick Ralphs (Mott the Hoople and Bad Company) in Fort Worth in 1977 (for an encore of It’ll Be Me)
- Ron Wood (Rolling Stones) for an encore of Communication Breakdown in Long Island in 1975.
- Neil Young at the HOF Induction show in 1995 on When the Levee Breaks

Ultimate Classic Rock (39 of 92 songs): Proving they weren't just a rock 'n' roll riff machine, Led Zeppelin busted out this love song, which Plant wrote for his wife, on their second album. It was the first time he penned lyrics all by himself.

Vulture (64 of 74 songs): A purty little paean to ‘60s flower-children. I’m not buying it, though, in the end; it seems a bit forced, and not really in keeping with the band’s overall approach. There’s more than a little Spinal Tap in it, and the production is muddy, even on the remasters. Despite the sonic dominance of tracks like Whole Lotta Love and Immigrant Song, Zeppelin was trying to broaden their palette on the second and third albums, to mixed results. It would be the fourth album before they made their claim to greatness.

Rolling Stone (29 of 40 songs): "Sometimes Zeppelin was gross and very indecent, and sometimes it was delicate and beautiful," Plant said. Thank You presents a rare happily married side of the band. Plant sings a grateful declaration to his wife, Maureen Wilson, and Jones' organ part is like a regal processional.

Louder (19 of 50 songs): Marking the point where Plant grew into himself as a lyricist (Page: “I always knew he would”), and delivering a cracked, heartfelt paean to his wife – even if it was part motivated by guilt – there’s also some highly effective pop nous on the chorus here, curiously bolstered by Page’s relatively weak backing vocals. Widely covered, versions range from the surprisingly great (Duran Duran), the idiosyncratic (Tori Amos), to the quick-call-the-police (Fred Durst, Wes Scantlin).

Uproxx (30 of 50 songs): Zeppelin has dozens of songs about sex — I think every song at least has sex in the subtext of Bonzo’s drums. But there aren’t all that many romantic love songs in their catalog. This is one of them. “My love is strong / With you there is no wrong / Together we shall go until we die.”

WMGK (34 of 92 songs): Led Zeppelin wasn’t all about lust, and they proved that with Thank You, which is an unbelievably sweet love song. With lyrics like, “When mountains crumble to the sea/There will still be you and me,” it’s hard not to swoon, regardless of your gender… or your dating status. 

SPIN (58 of 87 songs): The only Zep song to rival All My Love in sappiness, Thank You lays it on plenty thick (“If the sun refused to shine / I would still be loving you”), but it’s resonated enough with audiences that it was even used to soundtrack the (similarly sentimental) end of the True Blood series finale earlier this year. It’s not our Zep of choice, but some long-haired couple’s probably getting married to it somewhere this weekend, so fair enough.

I'm starting to feel like I can't go on (I actually don't feel well), but the countdown must continue.
My rank: None

My friend's rank: 17

Definitely the sonic outlier on II. I like it well enough but it's not really the kind of thing I turn to Zep for. My friend likes deeply-felt love songs -- and I suspect this was another one he employed in his "macking on hippie chicks" phase. 

 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top