Terminalxylem
Footballguy
Well, if it's any consolation, pretty sure my low protein muscle can match you in pull ups, even with a bum leg.I agree lifting weights and maintaining muscle is great. While I’m sure you imagine me as some frail egghead, I’ve spent plenty of time in the gym. Though I’ve transitioned away from lifting, by no means have I given up on maintaining strength.If your goal is to ensure you maintain as much muscle, for as long as possible, maybe. I’d still argue anything over 1.6 g/kg is gratuitous, but whatever.American protein consumption per capita is among the highest in the world, about 114 grams/day, over 20% daily caloric intake. That’s well above what is recommended. So why does everyone seem to believe we need more?
I don't think it's wise to compare the average American who lives a sedentary lifestyle to those of us who are actively lifting weights, playing sport and exercising almost daily. As you age, protein becomes even more important for muscle growth, maintenance and recovery. All of our bodies respond differently though and most of have varying goals. The little guy down the street who preaches a vegan diet and does daily transcendental meditation, doesn't need to worry about consuming as much protein as a beast like me who's working on throwing a football over them mountains like I did back in 82![]()
OTOH, if you want to maximize healthspan, not so much.
I guess we differ theoretically. I think lifting weights and carrying muscle has so many more benefits for my mind and body than purely aesthetics.
We differ in opinion about how much muscle/strength is enough. More importantly, what level of protein intake is necessary to achieve that goal, in the context of living a long, healthy life?
While the first statement is pretty subjective, there’s an objective answer to the second question, or enough data to generate a ballpark estimate, at least.
Haha, I don't think that. I do enjoy the banter because you seem to take on this anti protein approach that categorizes it as a bro science while I think there is a lot of evidence that increased protein helps aging men maintain their health and muscle.
And I'm not anti-protein. I'm anti-pop nutrition, especially when it interferes with optimizing overall health.